Bitcoin Forum

Local => Mining (India) => Topic started by: bitcoinkerala on July 31, 2014, 08:03:18 PM



Title: Why cant we build our own miners ? may be an Indian Company ?
Post by: bitcoinkerala on July 31, 2014, 08:03:18 PM
We all know that mining companies release the products once they got all the profit and the customers wont get their

We can get chips here - https://zeusminer.com/product-category/zeuschips/

and Schematics & PCB here - https://mega.co.nz/#!UwY0hbrK!xwLhgHgP0YgjfO8hxSxmLvjS4k_2lXLIlfHSK8AKnpw

So I assume if you are a electronics engineer its easy to make miners.

Or am i wrong ?


Zeus scrypt chip’s software implementation
https://onedrive.live.com/view.aspx?resid=7B9890399DE89575!603&ithint=file%2c.docx&app=Word&authkey=!ABXOuckyMb5Cu2w


Title: Re: Why cant we build our own miners ? may be an Indian Company ?
Post by: escrow.ms on July 31, 2014, 08:09:22 PM
We all know that mining companies release the products once they got all the profit and the customers wont get their

We can get chips here - https://zeusminer.com/product-category/zeuschips/

and Schematics & PCB here - https://mega.co.nz/#!UwY0hbrK!xwLhgHgP0YgjfO8hxSxmLvjS4k_2lXLIlfHSK8AKnpw

So I assume if you are a electronics engineer its easy to make miners.

Or am i wrong ?

One of my friend is an electronic engineer, I'll ask him if he can do something.


Title: Re: Why cant we build our own miners ? may be an Indian Company ?
Post by: Benson Samuel on August 01, 2014, 04:12:44 AM
We all know that mining companies release the products once they got all the profit and the customers wont get their

We can get chips here - https://zeusminer.com/product-category/zeuschips/

and Schematics & PCB here - https://mega.co.nz/#!UwY0hbrK!xwLhgHgP0YgjfO8hxSxmLvjS4k_2lXLIlfHSK8AKnpw

So I assume if you are a electronics engineer its easy to make miners.

Or am i wrong ?

One of my friend is an electronic engineer, I'll ask him if he can do something.

We have an Electronics Engineer with Coinsecure as well, the problem is that it is far easier to import from China, hence noone is taking big steps in this direction.


Title: Re: Why cant we build our own miners ? may be an Indian Company ?
Post by: subvolatil on August 01, 2014, 04:16:35 AM
We all know that mining companies release the products once they got all the profit and the customers wont get their

We can get chips here - https://zeusminer.com/product-category/zeuschips/

and Schematics & PCB here - https://mega.co.nz/#!UwY0hbrK!xwLhgHgP0YgjfO8hxSxmLvjS4k_2lXLIlfHSK8AKnpw

So I assume if you are a electronics engineer its easy to make miners.

Or am i wrong ?

One of my friend is an electronic engineer, I'll ask him if he can do something.

We have an Electronics Engineer with Coinsecure as well, the problem is that it is far easier to import from China, hence noone is taking big steps in this direction.

Our country does not have any commercial chip fabrication plants, there are alot in china, USA and Israel. So becomes cheaper to manufacture in China. 


Title: Re: Why cant we build our own miners ? may be an Indian Company ?
Post by: bitcoinkerala on August 01, 2014, 04:24:12 AM
We all know that mining companies release the products once they got all the profit and the customers wont get their

We can get chips here - https://zeusminer.com/product-category/zeuschips/

and Schematics & PCB here - https://mega.co.nz/#!UwY0hbrK!xwLhgHgP0YgjfO8hxSxmLvjS4k_2lXLIlfHSK8AKnpw

So I assume if you are a electronics engineer its easy to make miners.

Or am i wrong ?

One of my friend is an electronic engineer, I'll ask him if he can do something.

We have an Electronics Engineer with Coinsecure as well, the problem is that it is far easier to import from China, hence noone is taking big steps in this direction.

I work near China , so I can make a initial step visiting. but among thousands of cheap companies in China it is difficult to find which of them is the real deal. Those who found a good company , are not making millions selling miners .. but before approaching  chip fabrication plants in China we should develop the schematics and the design , ( but most of the established companies  starts pre order even before the design phase  ;D )

Esrow.ms - please ask your friend to take a look at the Schematics & PCB , is it difficult to assemble such miners


Title: Re: Why cant we build our own miners ? may be an Indian Company ?
Post by: bitcoinkerala on August 01, 2014, 04:30:17 AM
Professional asic miner pcb board manufacture service  -- http://www.alibaba.com/product-detail/Professional-asic-miner-pcb-board-manufacture_1664093222.html?s=p

28nm ASIC chip --- http://www.alibaba.com/product-detail/fast-speed-enough-stock-bitcoin-asic_1786099575.html


Asic manufacturers in China -- https://bitcointalk.org/index.php?topic=594728.0


https://bitcointalk.org/index.php?topic=294197.0


Title: Re: Why cant we build our own miners ? may be an Indian Company ?
Post by: Equate on August 01, 2014, 05:36:40 PM
I think a bangalore based company was manufacturing Scrypt miners for Alpha-T, but nothing has been delivered by them on ground so far.


Title: Re: Why cant we build our own miners ? may be an Indian Company ?
Post by: bitcoinkerala on August 01, 2014, 05:47:18 PM
I think a bangalore based company was manufacturing Scrypt miners for Alpha-T, but nothing has been delivered by them on ground so far.

It was based on UK and with all India works .. looks fake .
No communication from them other than lot of Photoshop ed miners


Title: Re: Why cant we build our own miners ? may be an Indian Company ?
Post by: Equate on August 01, 2014, 05:52:07 PM
I think a bangalore based company was manufacturing Scrypt miners for Alpha-T, but nothing has been delivered by them on ground so far.

It was based on UK and with all India works .. looks fake .
No communication from them other than lot of Photoshop ed miners

Alpha-T is UK based but Dexcel designs from bangalore are making miners for them and I agree , with so many Scrypt miners out there , all the delay by Alpha-t screams of scam.


Title: Re: Why cant we build our own miners ? may be an Indian Company ?
Post by: bitcoinkerala on August 01, 2014, 06:16:24 PM
I think a bangalore based company was manufacturing Scrypt miners for Alpha-T, but nothing has been delivered by them on ground so far.

It was based on UK and with all India works .. looks fake .
No communication from them other than lot of Photoshop ed miners

Alpha-T is UK based but Dexcel designs from bangalore are making miners for them and I agree , with so many Scrypt miners out there , all the delay by Alpha-t screams of scam.

https://alpha-t.net/shop/


Title: Re: Why cant we build our own miners ? may be an Indian Company ?
Post by: Equate on August 01, 2014, 06:38:21 PM
I think a bangalore based company was manufacturing Scrypt miners for Alpha-T, but nothing has been delivered by them on ground so far.

It was based on UK and with all India works .. looks fake .
No communication from them other than lot of Photoshop ed miners

Alpha-T is UK based but Dexcel designs from bangalore are making miners for them and I agree , with so many Scrypt miners out there , all the delay by Alpha-t screams of scam.

https://alpha-t.net/shop/

They released working prototypes of miners long time back and after that only excuses. I feel good that I avoided that pre-order :P


Title: Re: Why cant we build our own miners ? may be an Indian Company ?
Post by: allcoinminer on August 01, 2014, 09:38:47 PM
I think a bangalore based company was manufacturing Scrypt miners for Alpha-T, but nothing has been delivered by them on ground so far.

It was based on UK and with all India works .. looks fake .
No communication from them other than lot of Photoshop ed miners

Alpha-T is UK based but Dexcel designs from bangalore are making miners for them and I agree , with so many Scrypt miners out there , all the delay by Alpha-t screams of scam.

https://alpha-t.net/shop/

They released working prototypes of miners long time back and after that only excuses. I feel good that I avoided that pre-order :P

They released nothing than photoshop images.
Those released are LCD board & Viper Interface board. No use for them.
https://alpha-t.net/news/development-update-14042014/


Title: Re: Why cant we build our own miners ? may be an Indian Company ?
Post by: Equate on August 02, 2014, 02:48:24 PM
I think a bangalore based company was manufacturing Scrypt miners for Alpha-T, but nothing has been delivered by them on ground so far.

It was based on UK and with all India works .. looks fake .
No communication from them other than lot of Photoshop ed miners

Alpha-T is UK based but Dexcel designs from bangalore are making miners for them and I agree , with so many Scrypt miners out there , all the delay by Alpha-t screams of scam.

https://alpha-t.net/shop/

They released working prototypes of miners long time back and after that only excuses. I feel good that I avoided that pre-order :P

They released nothing than photoshop images.
Those released are LCD board & Viper Interface board. No use for them.
https://alpha-t.net/news/development-update-14042014/

I saw the video of their prototype on youtube and it was in very early stages but that was months ago and now everything seems shady.


Title: Re: Why cant we build our own miners ? may be an Indian Company ?
Post by: ravin on August 03, 2014, 06:47:33 AM
Alpha-T is under scam radar. So until we see something substantial, it's better to wait. They keep sending mails once in a while though.

Probably, the easiest way is to buy chips from ASICMINER, Blackarrow, Bitmine or Bitfury(if available) and make pcbs and assemble the miners. However, if you are not going to do that at a massive scale and very quick, you are going to get into losses for sure because the chips themselves cost $/GH very close to the actual full ready made miner.  SO more than the money, time is the villain. How much time do you want to prepare everything, components, PCB, workflow to build a miner if you have chips in hand right now?? I think a lot of time.

Second: You do a FPGA based design and do a chip fab (which is difficult here like everyone mentioned). But this is a multi million dollar operation if I understand it correctly.

UPDATE: Also, as it looks, everything has to be imported in a massive scale. The customs delay (if not the duty) will kill you. Unlless you get IEC and do everything to make the movements of goods faster, you are in losses. These folks will never understand that your ROI matters within a week or so.


Title: Re: Why cant we build our own miners ? may be an Indian Company ?
Post by: Fernandez on August 04, 2014, 09:47:21 AM
I don't think there is a big enough market to warrant this effort. There is also a very short life span with quick upgrade cycles. Unless the market gets stabilized don't bank on something like this to happen.


Title: Re: Why cant we build our own miners ? may be an Indian Company ?
Post by: BitCoinDream on August 04, 2014, 02:00:24 PM
I think a bangalore based company was manufacturing Scrypt miners for Alpha-T, but nothing has been delivered by them on ground so far.

This is the Alpha-T thread => https://bitcointalk.org/index.php?topic=314402.0 ..in case someone is interested.


Title: Re: Why cant we build our own miners ? may be an Indian Company ?
Post by: ravin on August 04, 2014, 02:05:13 PM
I don't think there is a big enough market to warrant this effort. There is also a very short life span with quick upgrade cycles. Unless the market gets stabilized don't bank on something like this to happen.
'
This is also a point that I want to validate. How many miners are getting sold here monthly? May be highkart, bitling etc can put some light. But I am sure many others will be ordering directly from bitmain or likes.


Title: Re: Why cant we build our own miners ? may be an Indian Company ?
Post by: BitLing on August 05, 2014, 06:36:37 AM
Well obviously the market is not that big compared to other countries. However, why limit yourself to the Indian population. If you actually end up making a miner, why not market it to the world and export it in large numbers. If its ROI is better than others, everyone will buy it.


Title: Re: Why cant we build our own miners ? may be an Indian Company ?
Post by: highkart on August 06, 2014, 05:22:58 AM
I don't think there is a big enough market to warrant this effort. There is also a very short life span with quick upgrade cycles. Unless the market gets stabilized don't bank on something like this to happen.
'
This is also a point that I want to validate. How many miners are getting sold here monthly? May be highkart, bitling etc can put some light. But I am sure many others will be ordering directly from bitmain or likes.

Just to put some light, we have enough miners in India to support the initial purchases of any new miner built in India. Most of the miner are not very active on forum. We r doing enough business in miners just to say.

However the difficult part is to keep up with the pace of hardware development at the current stage. A hardware team should be trying and apply new innovation rather than copying the existing designs to be ahead of the curve and keep costs reasonable.

If somebody want to really take an effort we will be more than glad to help them with our sales channel. You can PM us for more discussions.


Title: Re: Why cant we build our own miners ? may be an Indian Company ?
Post by: PewDiePie on August 06, 2014, 06:19:20 AM
I think a bangalore based company was manufacturing Scrypt miners for Alpha-T, but nothing has been delivered by them on ground so far.

i think no one will interest to do thats . thats really sick.. lick just give money without profit  .


Title: Re: Why cant we build our own miners ? may be an Indian Company ?
Post by: allcoinminer on August 06, 2014, 06:49:06 AM
From where can I get low cost server power supplies (used or new) of IBM/Dell/HP.
Is there any place in India selling them offline/online?
I can see it on ebay but are overpriced and most are rejecting orders some days after payment.


Title: Re: Why cant we build our own miners ? may be an Indian Company ?
Post by: ravin on August 06, 2014, 07:08:37 AM
From where can I get low cost server power supplies (used or new) of IBM/Dell/HP.
Is there any place in India selling them offline/online?
I can see it on ebay but are overpriced and most are rejecting orders some days after payment.

There are a few people selling them in Bangalore - but last time I checked they will charge you 6-7k for Dell 750w. May not really worth it compared to a PSU unless you have formfactor limitations. Have a look in OLX and talk to them.


Title: Re: Why cant we build our own miners ? may be an Indian Company ?
Post by: allcoinminer on August 06, 2014, 07:15:40 AM
If I get a co-buyer there we can order 2 from ebay.com and split 1 for me and one for the other.
For a single one the price is high. If any one ready to buy let me know. I will offer free PCI power supply cable setup in this server psu for you.


Title: Re: Why cant we build our own miners ? may be an Indian Company ?
Post by: ravin on August 06, 2014, 07:16:11 AM
Well obviously the market is not that big compared to other countries. However, why limit yourself to the Indian population. If you actually end up making a miner, why not market it to the world and export it in large numbers. If its ROI is better than others, everyone will buy it.
Agree. This makes sense when you can produce chips in india and build miners - which I think is very unlikely. On the other hand if you are importing components and assembling, we will have price constraints others like BTCGarden, Rockminers does not have. Having said that there can be a startups like Technobit that has very same business model we are talking about.

I don't think there is a big enough market to warrant this effort. There is also a very short life span with quick upgrade cycles. Unless the market gets stabilized don't bank on something like this to happen.
'
This is also a point that I want to validate. How many miners are getting sold here monthly? May be highkart, bitling etc can put some light. But I am sure many others will be ordering directly from bitmain or likes.

Just to put some light, we have enough miners in India to support the initial purchases of any new miner built in India. Most of the miner are not very active on forum. We r doing enough business in miners just to say.

However the difficult part is to keep up with the pace of hardware development at the current stage. A hardware team should be trying and apply new innovation rather than copying the existing designs to be ahead of the curve and keep costs reasonable.

If somebody want to really take an effort we will be more than glad to help them with our sales channel. You can PM us for more discussions.

Thanks for chipping in and appreciate the information sharing.


Title: Re: Why cant we build our own miners ? may be an Indian Company ?
Post by: luckyindia on August 29, 2014, 05:36:27 AM
Miners can b built in India. Globally several SUPERCOMPUTERS have been built on computer Junk-waste. Hundereds of 286 / 386 / 486 Systems are connected in PARALLEL to create a SUPER-COMPUTER. India has tons of computer Junk waste which can b used by school / college students to build an Educational Project- A SUPERCOMPUTER, A BTC MINER


Title: Re: Why cant we build our own miners ? may be an Indian Company ?
Post by: ravin on August 29, 2014, 08:15:06 AM
Miners can b built in India. Globally several SUPERCOMPUTERS have been built on computer Junk-waste. Hundereds of 286 / 386 / 486 Systems are connected in PARALLEL to create a SUPER-COMPUTER. India has tons of computer Junk waste which can b used by school / college students to build an Educational Project- A SUPERCOMPUTER, A BTC MINER

It may be a nice college project. But the issue with 486 machines is that their computational and power efficiency is nowhere near the current ASICs. So even if you get them for free, you will be running in loss from day 1 if your objective is Bitcoin mining.