Bitcoin Forum

Bitcoin => Mining software (miners) => Topic started by: Nyaaan on April 15, 2012, 07:07:41 AM



Title: What are the best CPU and GPU miners? ▲▼
Post by: Nyaaan on April 15, 2012, 07:07:41 AM
I'm not very knowledgeable about miners, I have a question.

What is the best miner for GPUs, and what is the best miner for CPUs?

Is it true that cgminer is best for GPU mining and Ufasoft is best for CPU mining?

Please help recommend some miners, thank you!


Title: Re: What are the best CPU and GPU miners? ▲▼
Post by: P4man on April 15, 2012, 08:18:01 AM
I guess it depends on your definition of best. There are differences in features and performance and usability, and the performance also depends on the hardware. Different people have different opinions, depending on their hardware and preferences.

For features, go cgminer. For usability and arguably speed, depending on your hardware, you could try bitminter.

For cpuminers, if you mean for bitcoin mining, save yourself the trouble. Even the best miner wouldnt come close to being worth it.


Title: Re: What are the best CPU and GPU miners? ▲▼
Post by: Brunic on April 16, 2012, 04:04:29 AM
Cgminer for GPU is probably the best option at this time of the year.

For CPU, well, I can't say for Bitcoins, I don't see the point of mining BTC with a CPU. But from my experience with Litecoin, I've tried both Ufasoft and Cpuminer from pooler, and I think cpuminer is a LOT better. It gave me a lot less stales shares and better khash/s than ufasoft.



Title: Re: What are the best CPU and GPU miners? ▲▼
Post by: pooler on April 17, 2012, 10:22:37 PM
I would like to mention that since version 2.2 my fork of cpuminer supports both Bitcoin and Litecoin mining.
It defaults to Litecoin because at present it's the best option for CPUs in terms of profitability, but you can mine bitcoins by specifying --algo=sha256d as a command-line parameter.
I've worked hard to make the miner as fast as possible on both Intel and AMD processors; moreover, the program can detect your CPU's capabilities so that you don't have to play with settings to get optimal performance.

Source code and binaries (https://github.com/pooler/cpuminer/downloads) are available at GitHub.


Title: Re: What are the best CPU and GPU miners? ▲▼
Post by: GernMiester on April 27, 2012, 07:45:38 PM
Go with CGminer. The ability to dynamically manage clock and fan speeds is really handy in the summer here in NJ with 80's and 90's with high humidity.


Title: Re: What are the best CPU and GPU miners? ▲▼
Post by: Gabi on April 28, 2012, 04:28:51 PM
You can mine Litecoin with GPU now, so cpu mining is useless


Title: Re: What are the best CPU and GPU miners? ▲▼
Post by: os2sam on April 29, 2012, 06:39:00 PM
Is it true that cgminer is best for GPU mining and Ufasoft is best for CPU mining?

Yes and yes, that is true on both counts.
Sam


Title: Re: What are the best CPU and GPU miners? ▲▼
Post by: pooler on April 29, 2012, 06:52:34 PM
Is it true that cgminer is best for GPU mining and Ufasoft is best for CPU mining?

Yes and yes, that is true on both counts.
Sam

I suppose you haven't tried my fork of cpuminer.
It should be significantly faster than Ufasoft on most (if not all) processors, and is the only miner to provide optimizations for AVX-enabled systems.
A brief introduction to the fork is available here (https://bitcointalk.org/index.php?topic=1925.msg834141#msg834141).


Title: Re: What are the best CPU and GPU miners? ▲▼
Post by: grue on April 29, 2012, 06:52:41 PM
Go with CGminer. The ability to dynamically manage clock and fan speeds is really handy in the summer here in NJ with 80's and 90's with high humidity.
humidity shouldn't be a factor when it comes to computer cooling.


Title: Re: What are the best CPU and GPU miners? ▲▼
Post by: os2sam on April 29, 2012, 07:49:51 PM
Is it true that cgminer is best for GPU mining and Ufasoft is best for CPU mining?

Yes and yes, that is true on both counts.
Sam

I suppose you haven't tried my fork of cpuminer.

You have supposed correctly.
Sam


Title: Re: What are the best CPU and GPU miners? ▲▼
Post by: Tittiez on April 29, 2012, 11:53:14 PM

Yes and yes, that is true on both counts.
Sam

I suppose you haven't tried my fork of cpuminer.

You have supposed correctly.
Sam

I get an extra ~.33MH/s per thread on a phenom with his fork over Ufasoft.