|
Title: Can next bitcoin client limit hash/sec? Post by: Groc on May 15, 2011, 02:30:14 PM With the next version of bitcoin client I would like to limit the hash/sec to a trickle or what ever limit I want.
Please help me gain support for this feature. Thanks. Groc Title: Re: Can next bitcoin client limit hash/sec? Post by: Matt Corallo on May 15, 2011, 02:51:18 PM Thats up to the miner, the in-built miner is moving towards miner removal (its already gone in GUI), though I kind of doubt it will be fully removed for a long time (if at all), no one will be adding more features to the miner in the client.
Title: Re: Can next bitcoin client limit hash/sec? Post by: Matt Corallo on May 15, 2011, 03:41:17 PM Quite the opposite, not having a Generate coins option keeps noobs from constantly complaining that they haven't gotten any coins and have been "mining" for a month. Limiting khash is absolutely possible, but it should be done on the miner side.
Title: Re: Can next bitcoin client limit hash/sec? Post by: wumpus on May 15, 2011, 03:52:03 PM I have a pending pull request for m0mchil's miner to do exactly this, it adds a "-s <value>" option to reduce load on GPU/CPU when running the miner while doing other stuff:
https://github.com/m0mchil/poclbm/pull/10 It sleeps a fixed amount per frame, so you have to play with the sleep value a bit if you want to approximate a fixed nr of mhash/sec. The built-in miner will never support this because it is already too slow to be of any use anyway, so it was removed. Title: Re: Can next bitcoin client limit hash/sec? Post by: just_someguy on May 15, 2011, 04:46:28 PM Isn't the whole point of bitcoin to get a lot of computers to verify the transactions? Having your CPU hash with the goal of generating a block doesn't confirm the transactions or help the network confirm them at this point. (Unless you get reaaaalllly lucky.) Your machine will still do all the hashes necessary to confirm a transaction/block whether or not you have the generate option turned on. Title: Re: Can next bitcoin client limit hash/sec? Post by: Pieter Wuille on May 15, 2011, 04:58:35 PM All nodes in the network - even those who are not lookin to generate new blocks - are verifying all transactions and blocks generated by others. This on itself is beneficial for the network (especially if you have a lot of connections).
Generating blocks is only as good as the (average) number of blocks generated. If a node would try one 1 khash per second, it will generate 1/2144027 of a block per year. Sorry, that's pointless. The current network hashing speed is estimated around 1.8 Thash/s. It requires around 50000 normal desktop systems (4 Mhash/s each) to get a 10% share of this number. The same can be accomplished with 300 high-end graphic cards. Doing it with anything else, is just a waste of electricity. |