Bitcoin Forum

Economy => Economics => Topic started by: Elwar on November 01, 2014, 06:23:06 PM



Title: When money dies
Post by: Elwar on November 01, 2014, 06:23:06 PM
Quote
In 1914 there was a minor increase in the wholesale price index. That index, with a base of one in 1913, had increased to 2.45 by the end of 1918. Beginning in 1919, the speed of the inflation increased, advancing to 12. 6 in January 1920; 14.4 in January 1921 and 36. 7 in January 1922. By the second half of 1922, that index stood at 101 in July; it was 74,787 in July 1923 and 750 billion on 15 November 1923.

A good read:
http://mises.org/daily/6945/When-Money-Dies-Germany-and-Paper-Money-After-1910


Title: Re: When money dies
Post by: segvec on November 01, 2014, 06:52:08 PM
Quote
In 1914 there was a minor increase in the wholesale price index. That index, with a base of one in 1913, had increased to 2.45 by the end of 1918. Beginning in 1919, the speed of the inflation increased, advancing to 12. 6 in January 1920; 14.4 in January 1921 and 36. 7 in January 1922. By the second half of 1922, that index stood at 101 in July; it was 74,787 in July 1923 and 750 billion on 15 November 1923.

A good read:
http://mises.org/daily/6945/When-Money-Dies-Germany-and-Paper-Money-After-1910

Thanks for sharing.
I have been loving your posts lately.

Impressive.


Title: Re: When money dies
Post by: evok3d on November 01, 2014, 07:29:05 PM
Quote
"In a few years time, most of the world will be as sick of managed paper currencies as it was twelve years ago. The main trouble will be that popular ignorance and lethargy, coupled with selfish special interests, forces politics into the management of economics and the management of economics into politics. Politically speaking, the world is yet far from being ready for managed paper currency standards."


Great article, thank you for sharing :)


Title: Re: When money dies
Post by: BlindMayorBitcorn on November 01, 2014, 07:31:00 PM
I thought this was going to be about Beanz LOL


Title: Re: When money dies
Post by: Q7 on November 02, 2014, 02:09:57 AM
And that is why we have bitcoin coming into the picture now


Title: Re: When money dies
Post by: efiin on November 02, 2014, 02:12:48 AM
Thanks for sharing I'll add that to my reading list and will weigh in on anything which I think needs to be discussed later.


Title: Re: When money dies
Post by: cbeast on November 02, 2014, 02:28:50 AM
Thanks. This might be the cure for the insomnia caused by the price crash.  ;D


Title: Re: When money dies
Post by: Jamie_Boulder on November 02, 2014, 03:01:26 AM
Good article however my lack of history economics knowledge made some things harder to understand


Title: Re: When money dies
Post by: bitnanigans on November 02, 2014, 03:51:44 AM
Still don't get why people are losing sleep over the price crash. We should all be used to this by now.


Title: Re: When money dies
Post by: bornil267645 on November 02, 2014, 05:23:42 AM
Simple, when money dies, Bitcoin prevails. It's as simple as that. Bitcoin was invented for that very moment.


Title: Re: When money dies
Post by: worle1bm on November 02, 2014, 06:44:38 AM
No no no no. First, Mises is not a good reference. There is a reason the vast majority of econ professionals look at the Austrian school like an embarrassing little brother.

Second, Bitcoin holds no inherent value, none. There is no transactional benefit in using Bitcoin versus a currency. An internet fad =/= superior system.


Title: Re: When money dies
Post by: Elwar on November 02, 2014, 08:58:07 AM
No no no no. First, Mises is not a good reference. There is a reason the vast majority of econ professionals look at the Austrian school like an embarrassing little brother.

Second, Bitcoin holds no inherent value, none. There is no transactional benefit in using Bitcoin versus a currency. An internet fad =/= superior system.

Austrian school that is annoying because it is right all the time and the big brother with the power hates being reminded about it all the time.

And thank you for making your view on Bitcoin clear instead of just trolling. My ignore list welcomes you. If I wanted to discuss the dollar I would go to bankrate.com.


Title: Re: When money dies
Post by: worle1bm on November 02, 2014, 05:19:12 PM
No no no no. First, Mises is not a good reference. There is a reason the vast majority of econ professionals look at the Austrian school like an embarrassing little brother.

Second, Bitcoin holds no inherent value, none. There is no transactional benefit in using Bitcoin versus a currency. An internet fad =/= superior system.

Austrian school that is annoying because it is right all the time and the big brother with the power hates being reminded about it all the time.

And thank you for making your view on Bitcoin clear instead of just trolling. My ignore list welcomes you. If I wanted to discuss the dollar I would go to bankrate.com.
This is a big part of why Bitcoin and Mises aren't taken seriously. Folks manage to, at the same time, be supremely sanctimonious and plug their ears of any different lines of thinking.


Title: Re: When money dies
Post by: manselr on November 02, 2014, 10:01:02 PM
No no no no. First, Mises is not a good reference. There is a reason the vast majority of econ professionals look at the Austrian school like an embarrassing little brother.

Second, Bitcoin holds no inherent value, none. There is no transactional benefit in using Bitcoin versus a currency. An internet fad =/= superior system.

Austrian school that is annoying because it is right all the time and the big brother with the power hates being reminded about it all the time.

And thank you for making your view on Bitcoin clear instead of just trolling. My ignore list welcomes you. If I wanted to discuss the dollar I would go to bankrate.com.
This is a big part of why Bitcoin and Mises aren't taken seriously. Folks manage to, at the same time, be supremely sanctimonious and plug their ears of any different lines of thinking.
Yes, but i have the fear the dollar supremacy can reinvent itself and keep growing forever.


Title: Re: When money dies
Post by: Robert Paulson on November 02, 2014, 10:24:09 PM
No no no no. First, Mises is not a good reference. There is a reason the vast majority of econ professionals look at the Austrian school like an embarrassing little brother.

Second, Bitcoin holds no inherent value, none. There is no transactional benefit in using Bitcoin versus a currency. An internet fad =/= superior system.

Austrian school that is annoying because it is right all the time and the big brother with the power hates being reminded about it all the time.

And thank you for making your view on Bitcoin clear instead of just trolling. My ignore list welcomes you. If I wanted to discuss the dollar I would go to bankrate.com.
This is a big part of why Bitcoin and Mises aren't taken seriously. Folks manage to, at the same time, be supremely sanctimonious and plug their ears of any different lines of thinking.

your right, we should take the monetarist/Keynesian scam that destroyed world markets twice (soon to be three) in the last 14 years seriously.

why do we even play games with money printing and interest rates, working so hard to prop prices up.
lets just skip right to a north korean command economy model and dictate what the price of everything should be and be done with it.


Title: Re: When money dies
Post by: worle1bm on November 02, 2014, 10:33:52 PM
your right, we should take the monetarist/Keynesian scam that destroyed world markets twice (soon to be three) in the last 14 years seriously.

why do we even play games with money printing and interest rates, working so hard to prop prices up.
lets just skip right to a north korean command economy model and dictate what the price of everything should be and be done with it.
Well, it makes sense to take the dominant model seriously, since it is at work every day. I don't think you can lay all these evils at the feet of an economic model, however, that's simply lazy thinking.


Title: Re: When money dies
Post by: TheMasterKey on November 03, 2014, 06:11:32 AM
Quote
In 1914 there was a minor increase in the wholesale price index. That index, with a base of one in 1913, had increased to 2.45 by the end of 1918. Beginning in 1919, the speed of the inflation increased, advancing to 12. 6 in January 1920; 14.4 in January 1921 and 36. 7 in January 1922. By the second half of 1922, that index stood at 101 in July; it was 74,787 in July 1923 and 750 billion on 15 November 1923.

A good read:
http://mises.org/daily/6945/When-Money-Dies-Germany-and-Paper-Money-After-1910

Were those the days were you had to carry money in the barrels just to buy a loaf of bread? The hyperinflation in the 20s Germany? It might happen anytime soon these days. Paper is just that - paper.


Title: Re: When money dies
Post by: Keyara on November 03, 2014, 08:03:17 AM
Kind of misleading.

Fiat might die, but money will not. Society always find a way to exchange good using a medium of exchange (aka money).


Title: Re: When money dies
Post by: pattu1 on November 04, 2014, 05:08:47 AM
http://www.bbc.co.uk/schools/gcsebitesize/history/mwh/germany/crisis1923rev_print.shtml

People collected their wages in suitcases. One person, who left their suitcase unattended, found that a thief had stolen the suitcase but not the money.


Title: Re: When money dies
Post by: Pente on November 04, 2014, 09:52:20 PM
After reading that book, be sure to read "Fiat Money Inflation in France" by Andrew Dickson White:

Read online:
https://archive.org/stream/fiatmoneyinflati00andrguat#page/2/mode/2up

or download here:
http://www.gutenberg.org/ebooks/6949?msg=welcome_stranger


Title: Re: When money dies
Post by: countryfree on November 05, 2014, 12:22:31 AM
Kind of misleading.

Fiat might die, but money will not. Society always find a way to exchange good using a medium of exchange (aka money).

Let's be more precise: one currency can die. This is what happened in Germany 90 years ago.
All currencies are not equal.


Title: Re: When money dies
Post by: DhaniBoy on November 05, 2014, 10:47:08 AM
many factors that can make a fiat currency can die, but not all factors may occur simultaneously and not necessarily those factors could apply in a country, a factor which makes the currency of the country may die, distrust of the currency markets that exist and exchange rates the very little impact on currency trading that are excellent as the dollar ...  :o


Title: Re: When money dies
Post by: pereira4 on November 05, 2014, 03:19:04 PM
The only talked about alternative to "no money" is RBU. Going back to gold standard is even more delusional than that.


Title: Re: When money dies
Post by: ARadzi on November 05, 2014, 11:40:09 PM
There are so many reasons that one currency could die. And if that happens, it would simply be replaced with another one. Paper currency is backed-up by an issuing countrys gold reserved, thats why they cant just print money. Over printing would lead to a lower value of that currency.


Title: Re: When money dies
Post by: nikkoy on November 06, 2014, 02:20:17 AM
when money dies we all get back to barter economy or other


Title: Re: When money dies
Post by: worle1bm on November 06, 2014, 03:34:47 AM
when money dies we all get back to barter economy or other
Man, it sure would be easier if we could barter using an efficient means of exchange that everyone recognized...


Title: Re: When money dies
Post by: TheMasterKey on November 06, 2014, 10:17:41 AM
Yeah btw, money as in paper money is dying a slow painful death, it will take decades but it will die, it's brain dead and on machines now kept alive by banksters and conmen in the governments.


Title: Re: When money dies
Post by: worle1bm on November 08, 2014, 04:02:05 AM
Yeah btw, money as in paper money is dying a slow painful death, it will take decades but it will die, it's brain dead and on machines now kept alive by banksters and conmen in the governments.
Thanks Nostradamus. Any other vague claims?


Title: Re: When money dies
Post by: pattu1 on November 09, 2014, 03:54:22 AM
Yeah btw, money as in paper money is dying a slow painful death, it will take decades but it will die, it's brain dead and on machines now kept alive by banksters and conmen in the governments.
Thanks Nostradamus. Any other vague claims?

Just look at the amount of physical money (notes and coins) versus the total money supply. If everybody tried to withdraw their money from banks, it just wouldn't be possible. Paper money has been replaced by 1's and 0's on a network.


Title: Re: When money dies
Post by: Seketsuna on November 09, 2014, 05:18:34 AM
money never dies  ;)


Title: Re: When money dies
Post by: JackRipper on November 21, 2014, 08:34:19 PM
Quote
In 1914 there was a minor increase in the wholesale price index. That index, with a base of one in 1913, had increased to 2.45 by the end of 1918. Beginning in 1919, the speed of the inflation increased, advancing to 12. 6 in January 1920; 14.4 in January 1921 and 36. 7 in January 1922. By the second half of 1922, that index stood at 101 in July; it was 74,787 in July 1923 and 750 billion on 15 November 1923.

A good read:
http://mises.org/daily/6945/When-Money-Dies-Germany-and-Paper-Money-After-1910

Very interesting article. Thanks for sharing.


Title: Re: When money dies
Post by: Useli Violent on November 22, 2014, 02:38:19 AM
why do we even play games with money printing and interest rates, working so hard to prop prices up.
lets just skip right to a north korean command economy model and dictate what the price of everything should be and be done with it.

Bingo!


Title: Re: When money dies
Post by: picolo on November 22, 2014, 03:48:22 AM
Quote
In 1914 there was a minor increase in the wholesale price index. That index, with a base of one in 1913, had increased to 2.45 by the end of 1918. Beginning in 1919, the speed of the inflation increased, advancing to 12. 6 in January 1920; 14.4 in January 1921 and 36. 7 in January 1922. By the second half of 1922, that index stood at 101 in July; it was 74,787 in July 1923 and 750 billion on 15 November 1923.

A good read:
http://mises.org/daily/6945/When-Money-Dies-Germany-and-Paper-Money-After-1910

I will read the article, thanks.

When USSR wanted money to disappear through inflation it went bad. When the USD, EURO and Yen  will implode, people will still be able to exchange Gold and Bitcoin ;)


Title: Re: When money dies
Post by: BAGOBO on November 22, 2014, 01:19:58 PM
Money can die,
maybe yes...

Money just made by wood

But we can use other medium transaction like gold or silver


Title: Re: When money dies
Post by: piike2323 on November 22, 2014, 09:45:25 PM
And that is why we have bitcoin coming into the picture now

Not so fast. The only thing most people do with the bitcoin is buy money. For as long as bitcoin is tied to fiat it will not become real money. To make bitcoin real money we need to create an economy around it. This means we need to trade bitcoins not just simply for goods at a store but also for property such as cars and land. In addition the bitcoin will need to enter the stock market. As of today the bitcoin cannot replace money.


Title: Re: When money dies
Post by: Justine on November 23, 2014, 03:21:25 PM
One one currency fails, another take over. Money will never die.


Title: Re: When money dies
Post by: neurotypical on November 23, 2014, 06:58:52 PM
One one currency fails, another take over. Money will never die.
Year 3000. Once automation has replaced 99% of human labour... where is the place for money there?


Title: Re: When money dies
Post by: Foxpup on November 24, 2014, 07:00:27 AM
One one currency fails, another take over. Money will never die.
Year 3000. Once automation has replaced 99% of human labour... where is the place for money there?
Human labour is only part of the production process. The process can be automated, but production itself still requires energy, raw materials, and real estate, all of which are in finite supply and must therefore be traded in some way (such as money).


Title: Re: When money dies
Post by: cbeast on November 24, 2014, 07:29:03 AM
One one currency fails, another take over. Money will never die.
Year 3000. Once automation has replaced 99% of human labour... where is the place for money there?
Human labour is only part of the production process. The process can be automated, but production itself still requires energy, raw materials, and real estate, all of which are in finite supply and must therefore be traded in some way (such as money).
Year 3000. Once all of the Earth's natural resources are mapped, quantified, and there is no need for labor, who decides what is traded and its price?


Title: Re: When money dies
Post by: Foxpup on November 24, 2014, 08:12:01 AM
Year 3000. Once all of the Earth's natural resources are mapped, quantified, and there is no need for labor, who decides what is traded and its price?
A subspecies of Roko's basilisk that charges obscene prices to people who opposed the automation of all labour?


Title: Re: When money dies
Post by: cbeast on November 24, 2014, 08:14:33 AM
Year 3000. Once all of the Earth's natural resources are mapped, quantified, and there is no need for labor, who decides what is traded and its price?
A subspecies of Roko's basilisk that charges obscene prices to people who opposed the automation of all labour?
Without labor, where will Roko's customer's with money come from?
edit: I'd not seen that argument. It's silly.


Title: Re: When money dies
Post by: sonofacoin on November 24, 2014, 08:18:14 PM
Kind of misleading.

Fiat might die, but money will not. Society always find a way to exchange good using a medium of exchange (aka money).

+1000


Title: Re: When money dies
Post by: vvv8 on November 24, 2014, 08:28:30 PM
always find
exchange good