Bitcoin Forum

Bitcoin => Mining speculation => Topic started by: dac_2020 on November 10, 2014, 03:52:23 AM



Title: I have LOTS of idle servers, should I mine?
Post by: dac_2020 on November 10, 2014, 03:52:23 AM
While looking for an answer to converting a batch of TP-Link devices back to standard OpenWrt, I came across bitcoins and have become a little curious. This is obviously something which will make more sense to the average person once you've started doing it, then learning things one step at a time. The basic information is one thing but the deeper understandings obviously take some hands on time.

That said... I have a bunch of IBM blade servers which for the most part sit idle all day long. They server up mysql, web sites, email, things which aren't all that resource intensive. The servers pretty much sit idle most of the time and could be used for something else.

One thing which has become confusing to me is that people talk about USB as if USB is the only way to mine. I'm sure I am wrong about this but that is the gist of how it sounds to be so far.

Anyhow, if that is not the case... here is what I have.

I have a number of 2xduo 3.0 blades with 16GB of RAM and 2xquad/4xquad servers each with 16GB to 32GB of RAM. I also have several older CUBIX 8 blade servers which are only 758Mhz/512MB ram which are used only as fail over backups for low usage stuff.

The server room is always on 24/7, the stuff is running no matter what, the A/C, the power, all of those costs are already there whether I do something more with the hardware or not.

Much of this stuff is pretty idle and could be used for?


Title: Re: I have LOTS of idle servers, should I mine?
Post by: -ck on November 10, 2014, 04:11:17 AM
Leave it idle. For every thousand dollars of energy extra used you will earn one cent worth of bitcoin and the denomination of bitcoin will be so small you wont be able to spend it. Regular computer mining bitcoin died a long time ago. Leave it alone.


Title: Re: I have LOTS of idle servers, should I mine?
Post by: cinnamon_carter on November 10, 2014, 04:14:57 AM
do as you please

if i had resources like that i would at least run nodes for coins i believe in and probably mine some cpu coins


Title: Re: I have LOTS of idle servers, should I mine?
Post by: chaosknight on November 10, 2014, 04:32:13 AM
you can rent out those server and buy bitcoin with that money
it will better then mining bitcoin on those servers


Title: Re: I have LOTS of idle servers, should I mine?
Post by: 1echo on November 10, 2014, 04:33:50 AM
i woul mine a bit with free servers


Title: Re: I have LOTS of idle servers, should I mine?
Post by: Blazed on November 10, 2014, 04:41:49 AM
Some CPU coins used to be pretty good profits (PTS) and a few others. Then trade them crap coins into BTC


Title: Re: I have LOTS of idle servers, should I mine?
Post by: BTCish on November 10, 2014, 05:04:22 AM
I would mine with those servers some cpu coins, they still can bring you some profit.


Title: Re: I have LOTS of idle servers, should I mine?
Post by: darkaire on November 10, 2014, 08:57:24 AM
You might fair ok with CPU coins, server processors perform pretty well it seems like, specially suited to intensive compute. These can be X11 coins like Darkcoin or others based on it, or something like Primecoin or a derivative. Though servers are also power hungry, you may not get back what goes in depending.

Though something much more useful would be hosting Bitcoin Core nodes, P2Pools, and other blockchain apps (though many are for testing only at the moment). There is more to the network than just mining itself, the more nodes the better. A core node and P2Pool can be set up in a few hours if you have any Linux experience.



Title: Re: I have LOTS of idle servers, should I mine?
Post by: seriouscoin on November 10, 2014, 10:22:17 AM
This is why i think BTC is FAR from being mainstream.... when we keep getting this kind of thread.

Someone always want to jump into btc thinking, its so easy to mine btc. If BTC can be mined with those CPUs do you really think its at the current price level right now? At least learn abit more about BTC economic b4 having this pipe dream of being rich.

Also for all "CPU coin" believers, the only ppl will be "rich" are bots operator. Good luck having that system as a viable currency.


Title: Re: I have LOTS of idle servers, should I mine?
Post by: zetaray on November 10, 2014, 10:27:28 AM
CPU mining is not profitable anymore, not even feasible in my view. You might earn more if you rent those servers  out.


Title: Re: I have LOTS of idle servers, should I mine?
Post by: dac_2020 on November 10, 2014, 01:59:21 PM
@seriouscoin, it is too bad you see such posts as being negative and what you imply about my interests is completely wrong :).

I said nothing about getting rich or having dreams. I only said I have a lot of hardware which for the most part sits idle and I would be interested in doing something fun with it, which perhaps makes me a few dollars. I doubt the return would be so large that it would pay for the costs but the network is always running 24/7 anyhow, with or without generating something.

Therefore, I thought I would ask in the forums because this is the best place to get real, up to date input and ideas. Reading about bitcoins for days would not teach me as much as getting a bunch of responses to a post would in hours.

Thanks to everyone for the input. I will look into hosting and some of the other things mentioned.


Title: Re: I have LOTS of idle servers, should I mine?
Post by: dac_2020 on November 10, 2014, 02:12:24 PM
You might fair ok with CPU coins, server processors perform pretty well it seems like, specially suited to intensive compute. These can be X11 coins like Darkcoin or others based on it, or something like Primecoin or a derivative. Though servers are also power hungry, you may not get back what goes in depending.

Though something much more useful would be hosting Bitcoin Core nodes, P2Pools, and other blockchain apps (though many are for testing only at the moment). There is more to the network than just mining itself, the more nodes the better. A core node and P2Pool can be set up in a few hours if you have any Linux experience.



I don't think I would want to host something where many people have to access my network but if it were something where my machines can process and it is mainly just data going in and out of my network, that might be suitable.

I am not too worried about the power costs because I already have to pay for it, whether I do something else with it or not, it still has to be up and running 24/7, year in and out. The connection to this particular network is pretty slow, maybe 2Mbs or so but other than a little down time now and then, it's very reliable, all on UPS, generator, etc.

And yes, I am technical enough to do most things and setting up new things with forums help until I learn it better as well, just like anyone else :).

I would not mind knowing more about what I could do with the idle resources. I like having purpose and making a few bucks to recover some of the costs would be nice.

Besides... I like the idea of a democratic currency.


Title: Re: I have LOTS of idle servers, should I mine?
Post by: tacotime on November 10, 2014, 07:20:34 PM
We could use the hash rate on the Monero network.


Title: Re: I have LOTS of idle servers, should I mine?
Post by: xstr8guy on November 10, 2014, 10:50:11 PM
You might fair ok with CPU coins, server processors perform pretty well it seems like, specially suited to intensive compute. These can be X11 coins like Darkcoin or others based on it, or something like Primecoin or a derivative. Though servers are also power hungry, you may not get back what goes in depending.

Though something much more useful would be hosting Bitcoin Core nodes, P2Pools, and other blockchain apps (though many are for testing only at the moment). There is more to the network than just mining itself, the more nodes the better. A core node and P2Pool can be set up in a few hours if you have any Linux experience.



I don't think I would want to host something where many people have to access my network but if it were something where my machines can process and it is mainly just data going in and out of my network, that might be suitable.

I am not too worried about the power costs because I already have to pay for it, whether I do something else with it or not, it still has to be up and running 24/7, year in and out. The connection to this particular network is pretty slow, maybe 2Mbs or so but other than a little down time now and then, it's very reliable, all on UPS, generator, etc.

And yes, I am technical enough to do most things and setting up new things with forums help until I learn it better as well, just like anyone else :).

I would not mind knowing more about what I could do with the idle resources. I like having purpose and making a few bucks to recover some of the costs would be nice.

Besides... I like the idea of a democratic currency.

There a huge difference in power usage between a server that is sitting idle and one that is hashing away at an algorithm. Your power bill would increase significantly.


Title: Re: I have LOTS of idle servers, should I mine?
Post by: west420 on November 10, 2014, 10:55:51 PM
Leave it idle. For every thousand dollars of energy extra used you will earn one cent worth of bitcoin and the denomination of bitcoin will be so small you wont be able to spend it. Regular computer mining bitcoin died a long time ago. Leave it alone.
This assumes that he needs to pay for his own electricity, which is not necessarily true. It is hypothetically possible that the OP works for some company when his job is to oversee a large number of servers that happen to be idle (although the ethics of mining with your company's equipment is questionable).

The OP could also potentially "mine" bitcoin via mining various altcoins via a multi pool that mines scrypt or x-11 coins that would be substantially more profitable on an electric basis


Title: Re: I have LOTS of idle servers, should I mine?
Post by: Rabinovitch on November 11, 2014, 01:12:27 AM
Leave it idle. For every thousand dollars of energy extra used you will earn one cent worth of bitcoin and the denomination of bitcoin will be so small you wont be able to spend it. Regular computer mining bitcoin died a long time ago. Leave it alone.
Why not use these computational power for computations of BOINC projects? Rosetta@home, Test4Theory@home etc...


Title: Re: I have LOTS of idle servers, should I mine?
Post by: dac_2020 on November 11, 2014, 01:14:13 AM
Leave it idle. For every thousand dollars of energy extra used you will earn one cent worth of bitcoin and the denomination of bitcoin will be so small you wont be able to spend it. Regular computer mining bitcoin died a long time ago. Leave it alone.
Why not use these computational power for computations of BOINC projects? Rosetta@home, Test4Theory@home etc...

I am hoping/wanting to put them to good use but also recover some costs. That said, I don't yet know what I will do, just looking for ideas which is why I thought I would post since everyone here is knowledgeable.

The point is that I am already paying for these costs so am looking for something interesting, profitable to some extent. I am not looking for a get rich quick scheme nor do I believe in overnight riches. Just makes sense to look.


Title: Re: I have LOTS of idle servers, should I mine?
Post by: bbxx on November 11, 2014, 10:51:41 AM
you can rent your rigs at betarigs and mine cpu coins when your power is not rented.


Title: Re: I have LOTS of idle servers, should I mine?
Post by: moiraine on November 11, 2014, 01:51:39 PM
You won't be able to cover power costs imo...renting them out and buying btc is your best bet


Title: Re: I have LOTS of idle servers, should I mine?
Post by: FlashCrash on November 11, 2014, 07:46:15 PM
You would make more money going into the hosting business and charging for website hosting than mining :) (or CPU coin mining)


Title: Re: I have LOTS of idle servers, should I mine?
Post by: guitarplinker on November 11, 2014, 11:00:41 PM
You would make more money going into the hosting business and charging for website hosting than mining :) (or CPU coin mining)
This sounds like a good idea.

I can't think of any CPU only coins off the top of my head right now, but if you could use these servers to offer people a service (ex. VPN) then you might be able to make some money off of them.


Title: Re: I have LOTS of idle servers, should I mine?
Post by: dac_2020 on November 11, 2014, 11:03:07 PM
I can't offer services where people have to log in, access etc, it's too much to maintain for what I have setup. The environment is not built for remote access, it is built only to offload/backup/fail over our hosting business.

We already do hosting, that's why I have the setup.


Title: Re: I have LOTS of idle servers, should I mine?
Post by: Seketsuna on November 12, 2014, 07:07:13 AM
mining? unless if you're prepared to lose money coz right now its a bad time to mine BTC the price keeps on gonig down


Title: Re: I have LOTS of idle servers, should I mine?
Post by: BitBear2 on November 12, 2014, 01:09:49 PM
You won't be able to cover power costs imo...renting them out and buying btc is your best bet

Def agree.


Title: Re: I have LOTS of idle servers, should I mine?
Post by: sumantso on November 13, 2014, 03:19:33 PM
Some CPU coins used to be pretty good profits (PTS) and a few others. Then trade them crap coins into BTC

PTS is almost dead now. I don't know what the CPU coin scene is now, I think FTC moved to an algo which is CPU optimized.


Title: Re: I have LOTS of idle servers, should I mine?
Post by: dac_2020 on November 15, 2014, 04:33:58 PM
Well, I appreciate everyone's input and I guess the answer is to find something else to do with the hardware so thanks for your input.

Good luck to all.