Bitcoin Forum

Alternate cryptocurrencies => Altcoin Discussion => Topic started by: Mr. Spread on November 23, 2014, 01:28:26 AM



Title: Vote for SpreadCoin logo
Post by: Mr. Spread on November 23, 2014, 01:28:26 AM
This is the official thread for SpreadCoin (https://bitcointalk.org/index.php?topic=715435.0) logo selection.
For those of you who didn't know SpreadCoin is a decentralized cryptocurrency without pools. Counter-measures against pools are described in its whitepaper (http://spreadcoin.net/files/SpreadCoin-WhitePaper.pdf).
This poll will last for 7 days.

Here are all the logos which were submitted to contest, please choose carefully:

http://spreadcoin.net/logo3/all.png

1 http://spreadcoin.net/logo3/01.original/16x16.png
Original Logo
http://spreadcoin.net/logo3/01.original/512x512.png

Splash screen:
http://spreadcoin.net/logo3/01.original/splash.png

2 http://spreadcoin.net/logo3/02.LitcoinCollector-1/16x16.png
Author - LitcoinCollector
http://spreadcoin.net/logo3/02.LitcoinCollector-1/512x512.png

Splash screen:
http://spreadcoin.net/logo3/02.LitcoinCollector-1/splash.png

3 http://spreadcoin.net/logo3/03.Susel-1/16x16.png
Author - Susel
http://spreadcoin.net/logo3/03.Susel-1/512x512.png

Splash screen:
http://spreadcoin.net/logo3/03.Susel-1/splash.png

4 http://spreadcoin.net/logo3/04.Susel-2/16x16.png
Author - Susel
http://spreadcoin.net/logo3/04.Susel-2/512x512.png

Splash screen:
http://spreadcoin.net/logo3/04.Susel-2/splash.png

5 http://spreadcoin.net/logo3/05.e1ghtSpace-1/16x16.png
Author - e1ghtSpace
http://spreadcoin.net/logo3/05.e1ghtSpace-1/512x512.png

Splash screen:
http://spreadcoin.net/logo3/05.e1ghtSpace-1/splash.png

6 http://spreadcoin.net/logo3/06.e1ghtSpace-2/16x16.png
Author - e1ghtSpace
http://spreadcoin.net/logo3/06.e1ghtSpace-2/512x512.png

Splash screen:
http://spreadcoin.net/logo3/06.e1ghtSpace-2/splash.png

7 http://spreadcoin.net/logo3/07.coolmancarl-1/16x16.png
Author - coolmancarl
http://spreadcoin.net/logo3/07.coolmancarl-1/512x512.png


8 http://spreadcoin.net/logo3/08.hardroad-1/16x16.png
Author - hardroad
http://spreadcoin.net/logo3/08.hardroad-1/512x512.png


9 http://spreadcoin.net/logo3/09.hardroad-2/16x16.png
Author - hardroad
http://spreadcoin.net/logo3/09.hardroad-2/512x512.png


10 http://spreadcoin.net/logo3/10.hardroad-3/16x16.png
Author - hardroad
http://spreadcoin.net/logo3/10.hardroad-3/512x512.png


11 http://spreadcoin.net/logo3/11.zeca-pagodinho-1/16x16.png
Author - zeca pagodinho
http://spreadcoin.net/logo3/11.zeca-pagodinho-1/512x512.png


12 http://spreadcoin.net/logo3/12.zeca-pagodinho-2/16x16.png
Author - zeca pagodinho
http://spreadcoin.net/logo3/12.zeca-pagodinho-2/512x512.png


13 http://spreadcoin.net/logo3/13.zeca-pagodinho-3/16x16.png
Author - zeca pagodinho
http://spreadcoin.net/logo3/13.zeca-pagodinho-3/512x512.png


14 http://spreadcoin.net/logo3/14.zeca-pagodinho-4/16x16.png
Author - zeca pagodinho
http://spreadcoin.net/logo3/14.zeca-pagodinho-4/512x512.png


15 http://spreadcoin.net/logo3/15.zeca-pagodinho-5/16x16.png
Author - zeca-pagodinho
http://spreadcoin.net/logo3/15.zeca-pagodinho-5/512x512.png


16 http://spreadcoin.net/logo3/16.zeca-pagodinho-6/16x16.png
Author - zeca-pagodinho
http://spreadcoin.net/logo3/16.zeca-pagodinho-6/512x512.png


17 http://spreadcoin.net/logo3/17.zeca-pagodinho-7/16x16.png
Author - zeca pagodinho
http://spreadcoin.net/logo3/17.zeca-pagodinho-7/512x512.png


18 http://spreadcoin.net/logo3/18.zeca-pagodinho-8/16x16.png
Author - zeca pagodinho
http://spreadcoin.net/logo3/18.zeca-pagodinho-8/512x512.png




Title: Re: Vote for SpreadCoin logo
Post by: sparkster on November 23, 2014, 08:51:06 AM
I like the motto of second one. We can use it somehow. But my vote goes for 1 and 4. It's strange that 10 still hasn't any votes, it's stylish, too aggresive though.


Title: Re: Vote for SpreadCoin logo
Post by: e1ghtSpace on November 23, 2014, 09:00:42 AM
Number 3 looks good.   As well as 5 and 6. ;)

I like the motto of second one. We can use it somehow. But my vote goes for 1 and 4. It's strange that 10 still hasn't any votes, it's stylish, too aggresive though.
When I saw 4 for the first time i didn't even realise it was an S. My vote goes to number 3, stylish and simplistic.

I would suggest limiting voting to only 1 vote, maybe 2 at most because then it is easy to see which logos are better.


Title: Re: Vote for SpreadCoin logo
Post by: Run Away Train on November 23, 2014, 09:13:09 AM
I can't vote in the poll but I will say 7 is the one I would choose.


Title: Re: Vote for SpreadCoin logo
Post by: Mr. Spread on November 23, 2014, 11:26:52 AM
I would suggest limiting voting to only 1 vote, maybe 2 at most because then it is easy to see which logos are better.
Voting with one vote per user can produce incorrect result.
Consider the following example:
1. 30% prefer logo A but also like logo B and hate logo C.
2. 30% prefer logo B but also like logo A and hate logo C.
3. 40% prefer logo C.
Obviously logo A will get 30%, logo B - 30% and logo C will win with 40%. Logo which is hated by 60% of voters will win, 60% would prefer either A or B instead. This is why two-round voting systems (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Two-round_system) are usually used to elect presidents (not the case for my country though where the same guy wins all elections).

I can't vote in the poll but I will say 7 is the one I would choose.
Why can't you vote?


Title: Re: Vote for SpreadCoin logo
Post by: nekkitt on November 23, 2014, 07:35:51 PM
Can't vote too (don't see any vote button in poll).
My vote is for 3 and 4.


Title: Re: Vote for SpreadCoin logo
Post by: e1ghtSpace on November 24, 2014, 11:16:51 PM
I would suggest limiting voting to only 1 vote, maybe 2 at most because then it is easy to see which logos are better.
Voting with one vote per user can produce incorrect result.
Consider the following example:
1. 30% prefer logo A but also like logo B and hate logo C.
2. 30% prefer logo B but also like logo A and hate logo C.
3. 40% prefer logo C.
Obviously logo A will get 30%, logo B - 30% and logo C will win with 40%. Logo which is hated by 60% of voters will win, 60% would prefer either A or B instead. This is why two-round voting systems (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Two-round_system) are usually used to elect presidents (not the case for my country though where the same guy wins all elections).

I can't vote in the poll but I will say 7 is the one I would choose.
Why can't you vote?
Maybe it is limited to member level or something. ???


Title: Re: Vote for SpreadCoin logo
Post by: orsotheysaid on November 25, 2014, 12:39:30 AM
2 and 18 look the best for me, simple and slick design.


Title: Re: Vote for SpreadCoin logo
Post by: mymenace on November 25, 2014, 02:11:04 AM


http://s27.postimg.org/xvjrjw81f/s_coin.png


i like this one


Title: Re: Vote for SpreadCoin logo
Post by: Undermood on November 25, 2014, 08:59:53 AM
like 2 and 18, simple design is best for advertising and printing.


Title: Re: Vote for SpreadCoin logo
Post by: Miracal on November 25, 2014, 01:43:33 PM
Like the style of 10. The style looks good.


Title: Re: Vote for SpreadCoin logo
Post by: gnargnar on November 25, 2014, 02:04:03 PM
i voted 11.  it's the one that looks the most professional made, non-mspaint done.

good luck  ;)


Title: Re: Vote for SpreadCoin logo
Post by: Erkallys on November 26, 2014, 02:09:24 PM
I love the 4 but the 3 and the 2 are well too.


Title: Re: Vote for SpreadCoin logo
Post by: smalltimer on November 26, 2014, 02:44:32 PM
all of them look pretty gay

maybe 3 or 4 is ok but change that stupid colour.


Title: Re: Vote for SpreadCoin logo
Post by: sparkster on November 26, 2014, 08:17:36 PM
all of them look pretty gay
Elaborate.
change that stupid colour.
how a color can be 'stupid'? It's not even a color combination, just single color.


Title: Re: Vote for SpreadCoin logo
Post by: AT101ET on November 26, 2014, 08:21:33 PM
Number 3 is definitely the best. After that I like the original one.


Title: Re: Vote for SpreadCoin logo
Post by: edschroedinger on November 28, 2014, 05:53:15 AM
Number 3 is definitely the best. After that I like the original one.
3 is quite good, yet I'd prefer 4 as it's even more abstract, clean and resembles the 's' in spread likewise. what makes the 4 superior to 3 is the symbolism of the spreading waves that supports the 'spread'ing and distributed character. I'd go for another colour as well, that purple violet sheme sheds a bit too much of a naive esotheric flair which is certainly not the wanted outcome... and all that bevelish glowish 90ies effects are... well 90ies... :D
I'd go for a vivid green/black orange/black - flat shaded - version of logo 3 ... best practice: always use (as) basic (as can be) colours. see.: google colours ;)

bonus would be 4 or 5 versions of the logo, each with another basic colour plus black (or white) as contrast/contour that could be displayed on a random basis every startup... one time the yellow/black then red/black, blue/black, etc. every other start, u get the pic.

apart from the colour 4 is almost perfect... some lighter colour, this and combined with some partial black outline to contrast wouldn't hurt either


Title: Re: Vote for SpreadCoin logo
Post by: Mr. Spread on November 29, 2014, 08:23:39 PM
Only several hours are remaining until voting ends.


Title: Re: Vote for SpreadCoin logo
Post by: meowball on November 29, 2014, 09:33:23 PM
I like #3. I think it's unique and more memorable than the others.  ;)