Bitcoin Forum

.

better put this in meta section , because this matter is related with forum rule.
and for me , meme is ok as long that was related with topic.

Yes, they should be banned. They're immature and unfunny attempts at humor. They distract from the conversation at hand (if any exists) and they do not provide anything of value.

I think they're fine as long as it's occasional and doesn't turn into a spam fest like you see in some off-topic threads.

Not sure how to vote on this, I don't mind one or two here or there but when there are multiples in a row (or even just one that takes up the whole screen) then it's obnoxious. But then it seems like if you introduce a rule like memes are ok only under certain circumstances, enforcement will become an issue.

I wonder if it may just be better to have two general bitcoin discussion pages, one as it is today and one with much tighter rules on spam, memes, nonsense, personal attacks, no-content/low-content posts, thread topics repeated for the umpteenth time, etc... That's probably my preference.

Can you give examples of that threads?

This is a good idea imo. For example there's a meme speculation thread (https://bitcointalk.org/index.php?topic=158739.0) to contain meme images from spreading to the rest of the forum.

Yes, indeed, these topics are too many memes.

I voted for 'No' as I agree with b!z. If there is a few memes, there isn't any problem but if one is posted, many others come along.

   -MZ

I think they should be allowed only if they are on-topic and valuable. I see a lot of memes in Wall Observer, that's okay. But we don't need memes in serious discussion threads.

Then you should have voted 'Yes'


Example?

I voted no , anyone can post a meme  ( not off topic & spam ).

I think we should ban all forms of freedom of speech. Make it so no one can say anything unless everyone else agrees. No one can express their dissent from the majority opinion either. Especially no use of satire.

/s

Ha. I agree. Why do people want to ban everything that just vaguely annoys them? Freedom of speech until somebody says something you don't like? I haven't even noticed much of the memes either, but as long as they're on topic it's good to inject a little humour into things instead of being so serious all the time.

Oops, you are right! I overlooked the poll!


This distracts but this has a value.

   -MZ

No. I think memes are fine, as they are part of freedom of speech, and sometimes they are funny. I personally don't find them annoying, as long as they are not spammed. However, I think there should be an option (in your profile) to disable images. (You would use this if you are on mobile or a slow connection, so the thread would load faster.

That's the problem, in a serious topic, memes cause some distraction but it won't be a spam.


If there is a mobile compatible site(maybe in new forum), showing the link embedded in [img] tag would be good rather than showing the image. An option in profile would also be fine!

   -MZ

Meme is an entertainment so with we don't get seriously anytime
and as long as they on topic


which user  ???

If all someone posts is meme pictures then that might be a different story. Who is the user in question?