Bitcoin Forum

Bitcoin => Bitcoin Discussion => Topic started by: OROBTC on February 05, 2015, 06:58:08 AM



Title: How long can a "Public Note" be?
Post by: OROBTC on February 05, 2015, 06:58:08 AM
...

I am curious to know how many alphanumerics can "ride along" a BTC transaction ("Public Note").

Here is an example (hash code for this transaction) of a small BTC transaction with a Public Note (perhaps best viewed at blockchain.info):

798b90badb81492b35ac2f98b1d6b742edd3da490a99f7b48588655f91ad6841

Here is the message (about 39 characters, went through OK):

HowManyCharactersCanRideAlongAsALabel?


EDIT:

Perhaps using hash codes as the Public Note is what factom.org (http://factom.org) has in mind for using the blockchain to store their large quantities of information without making the blockchain too bloated (?)

factom.org is an interesting little start-up.


Title: Re: How long can a "Public Note" be?
Post by: MineForeman.com on February 05, 2015, 07:01:55 AM
No idea, but remember, the "public note" feature is only available on blockchain.info and wont be seen anywhere else.  (I personally dislike it as I think it encourages blockchain spam)

It is not stored in the real blockchain.


Title: Re: How long can a "Public Note" be?
Post by: geforcelover on February 05, 2015, 07:02:40 AM
...

I am curious to know how many alphanumerics can "ride along" a BTC transaction ("Public Note").

Here is an example (hash code for this transaction) of a small BTC transaction with a Public Note:

798b90badb81492b35ac2f98b1d6b742edd3da490a99f7b48588655f91ad6841

Here is the message (about 39 characters, went through OK):

HowManyCharactersCanRideAlongAsALabel?


EDIT:

Perhaps using hash codes as the Public Note is what factom.org (http://factom.org) has in mind for using the blockchain to store their large quantities of information without making the blockchain too bloated (?)

well i think why not you try sending with a longish note ? i think it can fill the whole line alongwith transaction !


Title: Re: How long can a "Public Note" be?
Post by: OROBTC on February 05, 2015, 07:07:45 AM
...

@ MineForeman.com

It looks like MultiBit will allow a "Label" too, I tried to send something out from my 11-cent balance there at MultiBit, but forgot the password...

I do not know if any other blockchain watch programs will allow viewing a Label.


Title: Re: How long can a "Public Note" be?
Post by: shorena on February 05, 2015, 07:10:15 AM
...

@ MineForeman.com

It looks like MultiBit will allow a "Label" too, I tried to send something out from my 11-cent balance there at MultiBit, but forgot the password...

I do not know if any other blockchain watch programs will allow viewing a Label.

Most wallets allow a local label to help you remember which address is for what. That has nothing to do with the data stored on the actual blockchain.


Title: Re: How long can a "Public Note" be?
Post by: OROBTC on February 05, 2015, 07:17:05 AM
...

shorena & MineForeman.com

Thank you for the information!


Title: Re: How long can a "Public Note" be?
Post by: MineForeman.com on February 05, 2015, 07:17:40 AM
...

@ MineForeman.com

It looks like MultiBit will allow a "Label" too, I tried to send something out from my 11-cent balance there at MultiBit, but forgot the password...

I do not know if any other blockchain watch programs will allow viewing a Label.

Never used MultiBit so I would not know.

There is only one place you can put arbitrary data into a transaction and that is the OP_RETURN script that currently takes 40 bytes (soon to be 80).  So you will get 40 ASCII character into it if you really wanted.  (80 soon).

I have a feeling though that OP_RETURN is going to be abused and it might not be around for long.