Bitcoin Forum

Other => Politics & Society => Topic started by: jaysabi on February 06, 2015, 05:53:00 PM



Title: Can You Kidnap Your Own Kid?
Post by: jaysabi on February 06, 2015, 05:53:00 PM
The full article is below, but here's the TL;DR:

Kid's mother and grandmother agree to a plan by kid's aunt to "kidnap" him to teach him the concept of stranger danger because he was "too nice to people." Aunt asks a coworker to "kidnap" him. Guy does, in the process telling him some pretty horrible things and brandishing a gun, tying his hands and feet together, and leaving him in a basement for four hours. Mother was charged with kidnapping and abuse/neglect of a child. Grandmother, aunt, and coworker were all charged with kidnapping, felonious restraint, and abuse/neglect of a child.

I fully agree with the charges of felonious restraint and abuse/neglect of a child. And all these people sound like wretched, horrible people. But the charge that I found interesting was kidnapping, since I guess I always assumed the definition of kidnapping was the taking of child from his parents without consent. There was consent here by the kid's guardians. Can you kidnap your own kid, or are the authorities just adding that charge because none of the other charges really capture the extent of this crime?


Police: Family plots to teach child a lesson with fake kidnapping

TROY, MO (KTVI) – Family members plotted to have a six-year-old boy kidnapped to teach him a lesson on stranger danger because he was “too nice” to people, the Lincoln County Sheriff’s Office said Thursday.

According to the sheriff’s office, deputies learned of a kidnapping in Troy on February 4.

Investigators learned that sometime before February 2, 38-year-old Denise Kroutil approached a co-worker, 23-year-old Nathan Firoved, and asked him to kidnap her nephew to “scare” him. The victim’s mother, 25-year-old Elizabeth Hupp, and grandmother, 58-year-old Rose Brewer, agreed with the plan to kidnap the young boy to teach him a lesson.

The boy’s mother and grandmother did not know Nathan’s last name, only Kroutil.

On Monday, February 2, authorities said Firoved parked his pickup truck by the boy’s bus stop and waited for him to be dropped off after school. Firoved lured the six-year-old into his truck and drove off.

Firoved told the frightened young boy he would never see his mother again and that he would be “nailed to the wall of a shed.”

The young boy began crying, at which point Firoved pulled out a handgun and threatened to harm the child if he didn’t stop crying.

Investigators said Firovfed bound the boy’s hands and feet with plastic bags, then covered the child’s face with a jacket. Firoved drove the boy to his own home, carried the child into the basement, and left him there.

Kroutil, the boy’s aunt, walked down into the basement, pulled the victim’s pants down, and began shouting that he could be sold into sex slavery. She also allegedly chastised the child for not trying to resist her or Firoved.

The boy was kept in the basement for some time longer before he was finally unbound and allowed to go upstairs, at which time his family lectured him about stranger danger.

Family members and Firoved kept in contact via cell phone during the whole ordeal, which lasted about four hours.

The victim told school authorities on Wednesday, who then contacted the Missouri Division of Family Services. The sheriff’s office was called to the home and the child placed into protective custody.

The family members told investigators their intent was to educate the child and felt they had done nothing wrong.

Firoved, Brewer, and Kroutil were charged with kidnapping, felonious restraint, and abuse/neglect of a child. They remain in custody at Lincoln County Jail on $250,000 bond. The boy’s mother, Hupp, was charged with kidnapping and abuse/neglect of a child. She remains jailed on a $250,000 cash-only bond.


Title: Re: Can You Kidnap Your Own Kid?
Post by: Lethn on February 06, 2015, 05:57:09 PM
Quote
The family members told investigators their intent was to educate the child and felt they had done nothing wrong.

*Sits back with popcorn and waits for the Christians*


Title: Re: Can You Kidnap Your Own Kid?
Post by: michaeladair on February 06, 2015, 06:01:33 PM
When you can't find enough bad in the world around you to show your son, you must take matters into your own hands.


Title: Re: Can You Kidnap Your Own Kid?
Post by: Lethn on February 06, 2015, 06:02:29 PM
Wow! That was fast!  ;D


Title: Re: Can You Kidnap Your Own Kid?
Post by: Bit_Happy on February 06, 2015, 06:08:20 PM
There must be a better way to teach him the same lesson.
Also, how about police abuse videos? Are they also 'educating' him to stay away from police?


Title: Re: Can You Kidnap Your Own Kid?
Post by: Nemo1024 on February 06, 2015, 06:12:15 PM
Apparently you can, if the state (CPS) take your kids from you first and you try to take them back:
https://bitcointalk.org/index.php?topic=828129.msg10369459#msg10369459

But the scenario in the OP is pretty... twisted.


Title: Re: Can You Kidnap Your Own Kid?
Post by: pedrog on February 06, 2015, 06:33:48 PM
That's how George Bluth Sr. teach important lessons to his kids in Arrested Development. :D


Title: Re: Can You Kidnap Your Own Kid?
Post by: rosh on February 06, 2015, 07:52:13 PM
Answer to the question - yes.
If custody is given to one parent, who is separated from the other, and the other parent takes away the kid - it can be construed as kidnapping.

However, the incident given above is truly crazy.  :P


Title: Re: Can You Kidnap Your Own Kid?
Post by: (oYo) on February 06, 2015, 09:25:15 PM
When you can't find enough bad in the world around you to show your son, you must take matters into your own hands.
This comment made me laugh.

I find this story quite appalling. Although I don't consider this case to be an actual kidnapping, there's plenty enough wrong with it. The only thing this kid learned for certain, is that (some of) his family are real disgusting assholes.


Title: Re: Can You Kidnap Your Own Kid?
Post by: Lethn on February 07, 2015, 07:11:03 AM
yeah it wasn't 'actual' kidnapping, I don't dispute that, but it was child abuse enough, what kind of shit heads do that to a perfectly nice kid? Especially when you consider how on this very forum people were bitching about what assholes children are.

I really don't see how anyone unless they are total lunatics can justify that kind of treatment.


Title: Re: Can You Kidnap Your Own Kid?
Post by: rosh on February 07, 2015, 09:46:33 AM
yeah it wasn't 'actual' kidnapping, I don't dispute that, but it was child abuse enough, what kind of shit heads do that to a perfectly nice kid? Especially when you consider how on this very forum people were bitching about what assholes children are.

I really don't see how anyone unless they are total lunatics can justify that kind of treatment.

There are all sorts of lunatics out there.
And some of them go on to become parents as well.  :(


Title: Re: Can You Kidnap Your Own Kid?
Post by: TrianglePythagoras on February 07, 2015, 09:50:48 AM
That's straight up child abuse to me. Leaving the kid tied up in the basement for FOUR hours is way too far.


Title: Re: Can You Kidnap Your Own Kid?
Post by: Lethn on February 07, 2015, 09:54:47 AM
That's straight up child abuse to me. Leaving the kid tied up in the basement for FOUR hours is way too far.

Seriously, you're going to argue the semantics of how long they were tied up their rather than the actual act itself?


Title: Re: Can You Kidnap Your Own Kid?
Post by: enryk on February 07, 2015, 09:56:13 AM
There was actually a movie, where someone did for Insurance movie.
Man of Fire I think.


Title: Re: Can You Kidnap Your Own Kid?
Post by: Lethn on February 07, 2015, 09:57:57 AM
There was actually a movie, where someone did for Insurance movie.
Man of Fire I think.

There was actually a recent case here in the UK where there was a kidnapping of a child and it turned out that the child's own mother was in on it, I should probably dig that one up.

Got it! Knew I remembered right!

http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/uk/7733586.stm

basic summary of what happened:

Quote
The court heard the pair plotted to claim the £50,000 reward money put up by the press for the youngster's return. 


Title: Re: Can You Kidnap Your Own Kid?
Post by: enryk on February 07, 2015, 10:00:37 AM
There was actually a movie, where someone did for Insurance movie.
Man of Fire I think.

There was actually a recent case here in the UK where there was a kidnapping of a child and it turned out that the child's own mother was in on it, I should probably dig that one up.

Got it! Knew I remembered right!

http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/uk/7733586.stm

Hmm..Thats bad.
Seems people don't do it for harming anyone , but only for the money.


Title: Re: Can You Kidnap Your Own Kid?
Post by: Lethn on February 07, 2015, 10:02:23 AM
Money or Obedience, that's all people who attack their own children care about.


Title: Re: Can You Kidnap Your Own Kid?
Post by: Elwar on February 07, 2015, 10:51:36 AM
I would say it was unlawful restraint as opposed to kidnapping.

Here is a definition (Texas) of kidnapping:
KIDNAPPING. (a) A person commits an offense if he intentionally or knowingly abducts another person.

(b) It is an affirmative defense to prosecution under this section that:

(1) the abduction was not coupled with intent to use or to threaten to use deadly force;

(2) the actor was a relative of the person abducted; and

(3) the actor's sole intent was to assume lawful control of the victim.



When I was in high school there was a knock on the door, my mom said it was for me so I go to the door. Two big guys from my high school grab me and drag me to a van and throw me in. All while my mom and sisters watched. I get in the van and see another girl from our church. It was a kidnapping church retreat for the day. They told her in advance so she knew what was coming and made sure I was home at that time. That was an abduction by someone who was not a family member. But their sole intent was not to assume lawful control over me. And I didn't really fight back since I knew the guys from church and my mom was just watching like everything was ok.

I also remember seeing an old episode of Gidget where her friends kidnapped her and took her to a kidnapping party.


Title: Re: Can You Kidnap Your Own Kid?
Post by: Lethn on February 07, 2015, 10:55:24 AM
Quote
the actor's sole intent was to assume lawful control of the victim.

Well going by this definition I would say that was kidnapping because they were not going to let the child get away and they certainly wouldn't let him fight back.


Title: Re: Can You Kidnap Your Own Kid?
Post by: Nikolai the Barber on February 07, 2015, 11:25:23 AM
Wow, this is a terrible way to teach your child a lesson. I don't think psychologically scaring him for life is the right way to go. As for the whether this is kidnapping or not doesn't really matter. It's still fucked up and abuse.


Title: Re: Can You Kidnap Your Own Kid?
Post by: Streetview on February 07, 2015, 11:52:10 AM
Haha. I think its possible

Posted From bitcointalk.org Android App


Title: Re: Can You Kidnap Your Own Kid?
Post by: Agestorzrxx on February 07, 2015, 01:04:09 PM
what they did was psychological abuse, possibly bordering on sexual abuse but I don't really know about that. It is inexcusable and that kid will no longer feel safe in his own home. I feel really bad for him having been thru that trauma and I am not a 'kid person'. I hope he can be moved somewhere safer, possibly with another relative who can better protect him. 


Title: Re: Can You Kidnap Your Own Kid?
Post by: BitMos on February 07, 2015, 02:41:37 PM
possibly bordering on sexual abuse ...

I always have pleasure to read your post, and of course I wasn't disappointed. I thought the same thing...


Title: Re: Can You Kidnap Your Own Kid?
Post by: (oYo) on February 08, 2015, 09:50:51 PM
Especially when you consider how on this very forum people were bitching about what assholes children are.

No-one said ALL kids are assholes, yet there seems to be more and more of them each day because parents either refuse to or feel unable to maintain control over them. Some kids are a delight because they are considerate. Which is no different from how I feel about adults who share the same qualities.


Title: Re: Can You Kidnap Your Own Kid?
Post by: Lethn on February 08, 2015, 10:48:24 PM
Especially when you consider how on this very forum people were bitching about what assholes children are.

No-one said ALL kids are assholes, yet there seems to be more and more of them each day because parents either refuse to or feel unable to maintain control over them. Some kids are a delight because they are considerate. Which is no different from how I feel about adults who share the same qualities.


That's my point, you guys act as if all kids who question their orders deserve to be hit for it, I'm going to stop repeating myself now because this isn't really going anywhere, you may think your justified with one or two kids who are acting like total cunts for no reason but what about all the children out there ( Again with parents that tend to be religious ) who see through their own parents' bullshit and hypocrisy and when they point it out they end up getting hit for it?

These laws are designed to protect kids like that, children are have to be one of the worst abused and opressed groups in history among all others purely because of how defenceless they are most of the time and it's about time people started owning up to the kind of bullshit they make them deal with.


Title: Re: Can You Kidnap Your Own Kid?
Post by: grendel25 on February 08, 2015, 11:12:25 PM
Yeah, it's not a matter of if the parents condoned it or not.  It's a matter of a sentient human being taken against their will and that's abduction or kidnapping.


Title: Re: Can You Kidnap Your Own Kid?
Post by: (oYo) on February 08, 2015, 11:51:27 PM
Especially when you consider how on this very forum people were bitching about what assholes children are.

No-one said ALL kids are assholes, yet there seems to be more and more of them each day because parents either refuse to or feel unable to maintain control over them. Some kids are a delight because they are considerate. Which is no different from how I feel about adults who share the same qualities.


That's my point, you guys act as if all kids who question their orders deserve to be hit for it, I'm going to stop repeating myself now because this isn't really going anywhere, you may think your justified with one or two kids who are acting like total cunts for no reason but what about all the children out there ( Again with parents that tend to be religious ) who see through their own parents' bullshit and hypocrisy and when they point it out they end up getting hit for it?

These laws are designed to protect kids like that, children are have to be one of the worst abused and opressed groups in history among all others purely because of how defenceless they are most of the time and it's about time people started owning up to the kind of bullshit they make them deal with.

I absolutely do not agree with parents being assholes towards children and hitting them for no good reason either. That's child abuse.

BTW, there's no reason to bring up religion in nearly every comment you make. This thread has nothing to do with religion. There's people who are religious that would never hit their kids, as well as there being people who aren't religious which do hit their kids. You're like the forum's opposing force to BADecker, who unashamedly promotes his dogma.

Yeah, it's not a matter of if the parents condoned it or not.  It's a matter of a sentient human being taken against their will and that's abduction or kidnapping.

I disagree. Parents often take their kids to school, or to visit relatives, etc. against the will of their kids. This is not a crime, much less a kidnapping by any stretch of the imagination. The parents condoning it is absolutely what makes all the difference here. The real crime here is the manner in which it is done. In this case specifically, the appalling treatment the child received during his ordeal is nothing less than (child) abuse and everyone involved is despicable, but I still wouldn't consider it kidnapping.


Title: Re: Can You Kidnap Your Own Kid?
Post by: ajareselde on February 09, 2015, 01:17:59 AM
Especially when you consider how on this very forum people were bitching about what assholes children are.

No-one said ALL kids are assholes, yet there seems to be more and more of them each day because parents either refuse to or feel unable to maintain control over them. Some kids are a delight because they are considerate. Which is no different from how I feel about adults who share the same qualities.


Most kids just lack parenting, and its easier for some to on the line with less resistance and let their child run wild.
That kid in question definetly got kidnaped, held in restrain against his will, and that was a big step over the line,
and the thing about situations like theese is that court needs to make an example out of theese parents to minimise risk of some genious repeating this scene.

cheers


Title: Re: Can You Kidnap Your Own Kid?
Post by: (oYo) on February 09, 2015, 02:21:22 AM
Especially when you consider how on this very forum people were bitching about what assholes children are.

No-one said ALL kids are assholes, yet there seems to be more and more of them each day because parents either refuse to or feel unable to maintain control over them. Some kids are a delight because they are considerate. Which is no different from how I feel about adults who share the same qualities.


Most kids just lack parenting, and its easier for some to on the line with less resistance and let their child run wild.
That kid in question definetly got kidnaped, held in restrain against his will, and that was a big step over the line,
and the thing about situations like theese is that court needs to make an example out of theese parents to minimise risk of some genious repeating this scene.

cheers

Apologies. The subject of some kids acting like assholes has nothing to do with this incident whatsoever, but is a sentiment carried over from a different thread.
https://bitcointalk.org/index.php?topic=947171.0

Getting back on topic. Whether or not the term 'kidnapping' is accurately being used to describe what happened in this story, I certainly feel we can all agree that everyone involved is definitely guilty of child abuse. To think that some parents might copy this in some pathetic attempt to teach their own children about 'stranger danger' never even crossed my mind, since I would hope that anyone else hearing about it would find it as equally absurd and disturbing as I do.


Title: Re: Can You Kidnap Your Own Kid?
Post by: jeffhuys on February 09, 2015, 02:29:38 AM
Well, I've read about it a lot, and I think it's very possible to kidnap your own kid.
For instance, what if the mother and father get into a fight and the dad takes the kid "hostage" as to make the mother "change her mind".
Or the mother kidnaps the kid, whatever feels better to you.
I'd call that kidnapping, what else would you call it? A field trip?  :P


Title: Re: Can You Kidnap Your Own Kid?
Post by: Lethn on February 09, 2015, 09:18:24 AM
Quote

BTW, there's no reason to bring up religion in nearly every comment you make. This thread has nothing to do with religion. There's people who are religious that would never hit their kids, as well as there being people who aren't religious which do hit their kids. You're like the forum's opposing force to BADecker, who unashamedly promotes his dogma.

Thanks! I take that as a compliment! Because I AM the opposing force to people like BADecker, that said, it was disturbing how much we all agreed on the issue of freedom of speech but things are getting back to normal now. Sure, I can accept that there will be non-religious people who think hitting their kids does something, they're assholes too, but at least they don't use an invisible god to try and justify their violence, I am of course against it all though but the thing is people actually draw inspiration from the fucking bible a lot of the time that going around hitting their own kids is totally fine which is why religion is always an issue with this kind of crap.

I'm also being fairly polite here, I really do consider it just beating the shit out of them most of the time, because for how 'uncontrollable' they are they don't put up much of a fight when they're hit do they? Kind of invalidates the whole idea that it does something in the first place and that it's necessary.

Quote
I'd call that kidnapping, what else would you call it? A field trip?

They're just trying to sugar coat this kind of bullshit to make themselves feel better because they know it reflects horribly on their mantra about children needing discipline.


Title: Re: Can You Kidnap Your Own Kid?
Post by: erikalui on February 09, 2015, 10:18:39 AM
IT's not the right way to teach your child and the child may instead start hating the person for doing it. For me the answer would be an obvious no.


Title: Re: Can You Kidnap Your Own Kid?
Post by: TrianglePythagoras on February 09, 2015, 01:36:36 PM
That's straight up child abuse to me. Leaving the kid tied up in the basement for FOUR hours is way too far.

Seriously, you're going to argue the semantics of how long they were tied up their rather than the actual act itself?

I did make it seem as if I was talking about that last part. I'm sorry about that, Talking about the incident as a whole and giving that side information at the same time.


Title: Re: Can You Kidnap Your Own Kid?
Post by: jaysabi on February 09, 2015, 03:35:31 PM
That's straight up child abuse to me. Leaving the kid tied up in the basement for FOUR hours is way too far.

Seriously, you're going to argue the semantics of how long they were tied up their rather than the actual act itself?

I did make it seem as if I was talking about that last part. I'm sorry about that, Talking about the incident as a whole and giving that side information at the same time.

Haha, it did seem like you were saying tying him up for four hours is what made this wrong, like if they had only tied him up for an hour, everything would have been fine. Perhaps you just enunciated it poorly, but I think maybe you brought up that bit about him being tied up for four hours as evidence as to how out of control and unreasonable these people were, not the singular point of what made it wrong.


Title: Re: Can You Kidnap Your Own Kid?
Post by: dsly on February 09, 2015, 03:47:35 PM
IT's not the right way to teach your child and the child may instead start hating the person for doing it. For me the answer would be an obvious no.

If you just take them to a different house or something, they might never know. Untill they are back


Title: Re: Can You Kidnap Your Own Kid?
Post by: Lethn on February 09, 2015, 09:28:17 PM
That's straight up child abuse to me. Leaving the kid tied up in the basement for FOUR hours is way too far.

Seriously, you're going to argue the semantics of how long they were tied up their rather than the actual act itself?

I did make it seem as if I was talking about that last part. I'm sorry about that, Talking about the incident as a whole and giving that side information at the same time.

Haha, it did seem like you were saying tying him up for four hours is what made this wrong, like if they had only tied him up for an hour, everything would have been fine. Perhaps you just enunciated it poorly, but I think maybe you brought up that bit about him being tied up for four hours as evidence as to how out of control and unreasonable these people were, not the singular point of what made it wrong.

lol if you didn't mean that then it's fine, I tend to always get pretty hostile with this sort of thing because there are people out there as you can see who genuinely think treating children in this kind of way is their moral prerogative.


Title: Re: Can You Kidnap Your Own Kid?
Post by: ObscureBean on February 10, 2015, 05:56:59 AM
The problem with cases like these is that holistic solutions are never really possible. People will almost invariably side with the child but what they fail to appreciate is that what's acceptable and what's not is a purely relative thing (here assuming that the parents only had the best interest in mind and that this stunt is not is direct contradiction with the rest of the child's upbringing).
For example, there are tribal practices, involving children, in places like Africa that westerners would immediately condemn. 


Title: Re: Can You Kidnap Your Own Kid?
Post by: jaysabi on February 11, 2015, 04:51:12 PM
The problem with cases like these is that holistic solutions are never really possible. People will almost invariably side with the child but what they fail to appreciate is that what's acceptable and what's not is a purely relative thing (here assuming that the parents only had the best interest in mind and that this stunt is not is direct contradiction with the rest of the child's upbringing).
For example, there are tribal practices, involving children, in places like Africa that westerners would immediately condemn. 

Parents may vary wildly in their habits of bringing up their children, but child abuse is a little bit like porn or art, in that most of the time, you know it when you see it. In this case, I believe these actions had a good intention (the long term safety of the kid by not trusting strangers), but there's no question in my mind that this was child abuse.


Title: Re: Can You Kidnap Your Own Kid?
Post by: RodeoX on February 11, 2015, 05:01:03 PM
Lesson learned... By Mom.  :)


Title: Re: Can You Kidnap Your Own Kid?
Post by: Armis on February 11, 2015, 05:42:07 PM
This matter is sad on so many levels:

1) clearly the kid was traumatized, but that was obviously the intent of the exercise,
2) the "scaring for life" is shared by the whole family as well as the coworker,
3) the state (via police and DA) is clearly trying to inflict their own brand of trauma and terror on the whole family, and their damages are not just physiological, but financial, and will very likely impact them socially for a very long time.

All of the responsible actors (family and state) went overboard and everyone did so in what they felt was the best interest of the kid, but obviously NONE of it is serving any short term good and the likelihood is that the "kidnapping" in all of its idiocy will likely serve as a far better lesson for the kid then the mass arrest, persecution, and prosecution of his family in an attempt to correct their internal injustice.

Depending how the narrative is written the story is either bad or worse, but the underlined fact is the child was not in any real or meaningful danger.  The intent of the family is clear they were trying to protect their family member.  As more rational and logical minds try to judge the family's foolish they should also hear of all of the child abduction stories to get a better understanding of how their fears provoked such irrational behavior.  

It should not take a police officer, a DA, much less a criminal court judge to see this was just a case of magnificent stupidity.  Unless the family has a history of child abuse this should not have risen above a civil matter (family services).

The wicked irony is through all of this the kid is now truly taken from his family, traumatize for substantially longer than 4 hours, and placed with real "strangers" who actually care less than his family about his actual welfare.  

The bail provisions were additionally wicked, I'd really like to hear the whole story including the back story (family history).




Title: Re: Can You Kidnap Your Own Kid?
Post by: jaysabi on February 12, 2015, 06:48:18 PM
This matter is sad on so many levels:

1) clearly the kid was traumatized, but that was obviously the intent of the exercise,
2) the "scaring for life" is shared by the whole family as well as the coworker,
3) the state (via police and DA) is clearly trying to inflict their own brand of trauma and terror on the whole family, and their damages are not just physiological, but financial, and will very likely impact them socially for a very long time.

All of the responsible actors (family and state) went overboard and everyone did so in what they felt was the best interest of the kid, but obviously NONE of it is serving any short term good and the likelihood is that the "kidnapping" in all of its idiocy will likely serve as a far better lesson for the kid then the mass arrest, persecution, and prosecution of his family in an attempt to correct their internal injustice.

Depending how the narrative is written the story is either bad or worse, but the underlined fact is the child was not in any real or meaningful danger.  The intent of the family is clear they were trying to protect their family member.  As more rational and logical minds try to judge the family's foolish they should also hear of all of the child abduction stories to get a better understanding of how their fears provoked such irrational behavior.  

It should not take a police officer, a DA, much less a criminal court judge to see this was just a case of magnificent stupidity.  Unless the family has a history of child abuse this should not have risen above a civil matter (family services).

The wicked irony is through all of this the kid is now truly taken from his family, traumatize for substantially longer than 4 hours, and placed with real "strangers" who actually care less than his family about his actual welfare.  

The bail provisions were additionally wicked, I'd really like to hear the whole story including the back story (family history).

Well, in the least, the coworker assaulted the kid with a gun by threatening to shoot him if he didn't stop crying. And also threatening to nail him to the wall of a shed is assault, and tying him up is felonious restraint. The fact the family asked this guy to "kidnap" him makes them culpable for these actions as well. I think the charges against all four actors are justified on those counts.


Title: Re: Can You Kidnap Your Own Kid?
Post by: erikalui on February 12, 2015, 06:52:30 PM
IT's not the right way to teach your child and the child may instead start hating the person for doing it. For me the answer would be an obvious no.

If you just take them to a different house or something, they might never know. Untill they are back

They won't know but it is not the right thing to do. Kids are innocent and you tell them just anything, they will believe you but creating fear in them is wrong.