Bitcoin Forum

Bitcoin => Bitcoin Discussion => Topic started by: i_rape_bitcoins on July 26, 2012, 06:01:43 AM



Title: Generosity of recent Bitcoin thefts
Post by: i_rape_bitcoins on July 26, 2012, 06:01:43 AM
As we all know with the recent plausible evidence of Zhou Tong being the Bitcoinica hacker, we should recall the generosity of this theft compared to MyBitcoin.

Zhou Tong offered a 5,000 BTC refund of the 100,000+ BTC stolen. If we use 100,000 as optimistic estimate of the stolen coins, 5,000 easily amounts to 5%.

Looking back on MyBitcoin, they offered 49% of the total 154,406 stolen.

Whats the verdict? MyBitcoin was more generous than Zhou Tong.


Title: Re: Generosity of recent Bitcoin thefts
Post by: Phinnaeus Gage on July 26, 2012, 06:06:09 AM
As we all know with the recent plausible evidence of Zhou Tong being the Bitcoinica hacker, we should recall the generosity of this theft compared to MyBitcoin.

Zhou Tong offered a 5,000 BTC refund of the 100,000+ BTC stolen. If we use 100,000 as optimistic estimate of the stolen coins, 5,000 easily amounts to 5%.

Looking back on MyBitcoin, they offered 49% of the total 154,406 stolen.

Whats the verdict? MyBitcoin was more generous than Zhou Tong.

Only if Zhou Tong promised to pay back 5%. He didn't just promise, he performed. Whereas Tom Williams only promised, paying back nothing except to Bruce Wagner his 25,000 BTC. Big difference. (somebody please correct me if I'm in error)

~Bruno~


Title: Re: Generosity of recent Bitcoin thefts
Post by: zhoutong on July 26, 2012, 06:12:01 AM
No. The evidence was not plausible. See: https://bitcointalk.org/index.php?topic=95738.msg1055046#msg1055046


Title: Re: Generosity of recent Bitcoin thefts
Post by: FreeMoney on July 26, 2012, 07:11:15 AM
As we all know with the recent plausible evidence of Zhou Tong being the Bitcoinica hacker, we should recall the generosity of this theft compared to MyBitcoin.

Zhou Tong offered a 5,000 BTC refund of the 100,000+ BTC stolen. If we use 100,000 as optimistic estimate of the stolen coins, 5,000 easily amounts to 5%.

Looking back on MyBitcoin, they offered 49% of the total 154,406 stolen.

Whats the verdict? MyBitcoin was more generous than Zhou Tong.

Only if Zhou Tong promised to pay back 5%. He didn't just promise, he performed. Whereas Tom Williams only promised, paying back nothing except to Bruce Wagner his 25,000 BTC. Big difference. (somebody please correct me if I'm in error)

~Bruno~


You are in error, 49% was returned.