Bitcoin Forum

Bitcoin => Bitcoin Technical Support => Topic started by: jmintuck on February 28, 2015, 07:34:36 PM



Title: 12 hours unconfirmed transaction - help
Post by: jmintuck on February 28, 2015, 07:34:36 PM
I sent a bitcoin transaction 12 hours ago, I think without paying the fee
now it is still unconfirmed, is this normal?
please help I don't know what to do except to wait for it to be confirmed but I think it will take forever?


Title: Re: 12 hours unconfirmed transaction - help
Post by: redsn0w on February 28, 2015, 07:37:07 PM
I sent a bitcoin transaction 12 hours ago, I think without paying the fee
now it is still unconfirmed, is this normal?
please help I don't know what to do except to wait for it to be confirmed but I think it will take forever?

Can you post the transaction id ? Have you paid the correct fee ?


Title: Re: 12 hours unconfirmed transaction - help
Post by: jmintuck on February 28, 2015, 07:38:55 PM
I sent a bitcoin transaction 12 hours ago, I think without paying the fee
now it is still unconfirmed, is this normal?
please help I don't know what to do except to wait for it to be confirmed but I think it will take forever?

Can you post the transaction id ? Have you paid the correct fee ?
https://blockchain.info/address/1JhjPXadXnkq47zrh4Ue7cY8K3dejgw4gC

I don't think I paid the fee


Title: Re: 12 hours unconfirmed transaction - help
Post by: redsn0w on February 28, 2015, 07:40:40 PM
I sent a bitcoin transaction 12 hours ago, I think without paying the fee
now it is still unconfirmed, is this normal?
please help I don't know what to do except to wait for it to be confirmed but I think it will take forever?

Can you post the transaction id ? Have you paid the correct fee ?
https://blockchain.info/address/1JhjPXadXnkq47zrh4Ue7cY8K3dejgw4gC

I don't think I paid the fee

So this is the transaction id : 2a2d12c4e1200d8200b116aa98763d6322aa2d2ef5475a400d731c6bf53d4387

I've seen you put 0 btc as fee, now you have only to wait that one "miner" will include your transaction in a block (but it will vey very difficult, because you didn't put the fee).

Most probably it will return back or confirmed in the next 24-48 hours, good luck.


Title: Re: 12 hours unconfirmed transaction - help
Post by: cr1776 on February 28, 2015, 07:42:06 PM
This has some info too:

https://bitcointalk.org/index.php?topic=232979.0

But it is relatively large with a high priority, so give it some time. :-)


Title: Re: 12 hours unconfirmed transaction - help
Post by: jmintuck on February 28, 2015, 07:42:15 PM
I sent a bitcoin transaction 12 hours ago, I think without paying the fee
now it is still unconfirmed, is this normal?
please help I don't know what to do except to wait for it to be confirmed but I think it will take forever?

Can you post the transaction id ? Have you paid the correct fee ?
https://blockchain.info/address/1JhjPXadXnkq47zrh4Ue7cY8K3dejgw4gC

I don't think I paid the fee

So this is the transaction id : 2a2d12c4e1200d8200b116aa98763d6322aa2d2ef5475a400d731c6bf53d4387

I've seen you put 0 btc as fee, now you have only to wait that one "miner" will include your transaction in a block (but it will vey very difficult, because you didn't put the fee).

Most probably it will return back or confirmed in the next 24-48 hours, good luck.

Thanks
How much fee should I put for it to be confirmed next time?


Title: Re: 12 hours unconfirmed transaction - help
Post by: shorena on February 28, 2015, 07:43:42 PM
-snip-

Thanks
How much fee should I put for it to be confirmed next time?

The fee your wallet suggests. If your wallet does not suggest a fee pay 10k satoshi.


Title: Re: 12 hours unconfirmed transaction - help
Post by: jmintuck on February 28, 2015, 07:45:17 PM
Thanks a lot, is there any chance the bitcoins will be lost forever?


Title: Re: 12 hours unconfirmed transaction - help
Post by: shorena on February 28, 2015, 07:46:17 PM
Thanks a lot, is there any chance the bitcoins will be lost forever?

No, the TX has a high priority it should confirm pretty soon even without fee.


Title: Re: 12 hours unconfirmed transaction - help
Post by: NiceSoft12 on February 28, 2015, 07:50:14 PM
So does every exchange that you send btc from pay a fee for you?  When I send from Bitstamp or BFX it goes through on time and never take this long.  Does that mean they've paid the fee for you?


Title: Re: 12 hours unconfirmed transaction - help
Post by: shorena on February 28, 2015, 07:51:21 PM
So does every exchange that you send btc from pay a fee for you?  When I send from Bitstamp or BFX it goes through on time and never take this long.  Does that mean they've paid the fee for you?

Yes, but usually you pay a it though. It gets substracted from the amount you withdraw. IIRC bitstamp pays a the fee for you... hm maybe exchanges usually pay for you, but services dont, not sure tbh. It depends on the site.


Title: Re: 12 hours unconfirmed transaction - help
Post by: redsn0w on February 28, 2015, 07:52:06 PM
So does every exchange that you send btc from pay a fee for you?  When I send from Bitstamp or BFX it goes through on time and never take this long.  Does that mean they've paid the fee for you?

Yes  "they" have removed the fee from your requested bitcoin plus their "internal fee".


Title: Re: 12 hours unconfirmed transaction - help
Post by: najzenmajsen on February 28, 2015, 08:10:26 PM
hi , because you didnt pay the fee your transaction will be delayed , nothing else. you just gotta wait it out man ;: )


Title: Re: 12 hours unconfirmed transaction - help
Post by: chaosknight on March 01, 2015, 01:37:24 PM
if you don't pay the tx fees then it can take a long time to confirm your transaction and possible it will never confirm who know
so always pay a small fee for your transactions


Title: Re: 12 hours unconfirmed transaction - help
Post by: philipma1957 on March 01, 2015, 02:03:53 PM
   if you pay 0.0005 it is about 12 cents.

   I try to pay 0.001 which is about 24 cents.

If btc jumps up to 500 a coin I would pay 0.0005 which would be about 25 cents


Title: Re: 12 hours unconfirmed transaction - help
Post by: kilminukas on March 01, 2015, 04:22:13 PM
   if you pay 0.0005 it is about 12 cents.

   I try to pay 0.001 which is about 24 cents.

If btc jumps up to 500 a coin I would pay 0.0005 which would be about 25 cents
whats the point of paying 0.001 when the deposit goes through easily with 0.0001 fee?


Title: Re: 12 hours unconfirmed transaction - help
Post by: redsn0w on March 01, 2015, 05:08:30 PM
   if you pay 0.0005 it is about 12 cents.

   I try to pay 0.001 which is about 24 cents.

If btc jumps up to 500 a coin I would pay 0.0005 which would be about 25 cents
whats the point of paying 0.001 when the deposit goes through easily with 0.0001 fee?

It is a free choice, if you want you can also put 0.005 btc but remember that the bitcoin's fee is always "lowest" compared to bank transfer's fee.


Title: Re: 12 hours unconfirmed transaction - help
Post by: philipma1957 on March 01, 2015, 07:09:29 PM
  if you pay 0.0005 it is about 12 cents.

   I try to pay 0.001 which is about 24 cents.

If btc jumps up to 500 a coin I would pay 0.0005 which would be about 25 cents
whats the point of paying 0.001 when the deposit goes through easily with 0.0001 fee?


I can afford to pay it. .

 I do  it  because helps pool operators and miners that choose to mine with pools that share fees.

For instance kano runs this pool

http://www.kano.is/  it charges only 0.9% fee to miners and he keeps the transaction fees. So if my 0.001 is in a block he hits I help him.

www.mmpool.org  gives all the transaction fees in a block to the miner on the pool that hits the block.  so if my transaction fee is in  a block hit by mmpool.org  I support that   pool.

Frankly 0.0001 is too low,but I do not make rules.    0.001 may be too high for some.


Title: Re: 12 hours unconfirmed transaction - help
Post by: Coctur1937 on March 01, 2015, 09:59:20 PM
12 hours is way too long. Perhaps you didn't pay enough fee, or maybe you weren't properly connected to the internet when you broadcasted it. Block confirm times have been slower recently.


Title: Re: 12 hours unconfirmed transaction - help
Post by: zvs on March 02, 2015, 03:21:30 AM
   if you pay 0.0005 it is about 12 cents.

   I try to pay 0.001 which is about 24 cents.

If btc jumps up to 500 a coin I would pay 0.0005 which would be about 25 cents
whats the point of paying 0.001 when the deposit goes through easily with 0.0001 fee?

i'm unsure with this new version, I think it adjusts fees based on tx volume, but not positive about that.

anyway, it doesn't (or didn't, maybe) ALWAYS go through easily with a 0.0001 fee, esp. if it was 900-999 bytes.  this is why you do something like 0.000101


Title: Re: 12 hours unconfirmed transaction - help
Post by: yenzae0215 on March 05, 2015, 06:02:20 AM
The OP is a scammer who defaulted on my 0.8 btc loan (and other 0.2 btc) and stole the account kalgecin
In this transaction https://blockchain.info/tx/e2e79809de7a6d1826dc470043e3571a2902c23385d6c8e50008c4277e9609c1
I sent the 0.8
Which was then forwarded to another wallet https://blockchain.info/tx/2a2d12c4e1200d8200b116aa98763d6322aa2d2ef5475a400d731c6bf53d4387

i see, hmm.. can you put link to where you have discussed the loan?


Title: Re: 12 hours unconfirmed transaction - help
Post by: redsn0w on March 05, 2015, 06:12:04 AM
The OP is a scammer who defaulted on my 0.8 btc loan (and other 0.2 btc) and stole the account kalgecin
In this transaction https://blockchain.info/tx/e2e79809de7a6d1826dc470043e3571a2902c23385d6c8e50008c4277e9609c1
I sent the 0.8
Which was then forwarded to another wallet https://blockchain.info/tx/2a2d12c4e1200d8200b116aa98763d6322aa2d2ef5475a400d731c6bf53d4387

If you didn't already do , I suggest you to open a scam accusation in the properly section with all the valid proofs. Good luck with your battle (here you are off topic).