Bitcoin Forum

Economy => Trading Discussion => Topic started by: SgtSpike on May 26, 2011, 12:03:50 AM



Title: Is MtGox the best way to withdraw BTC as USD?
Post by: SgtSpike on May 26, 2011, 12:03:50 AM
Well, it's easy to change it from BTC into USD via a trade, but is it the best route to go as far as withdrawing that USD into one's bank account?

Right now, I'm mining 50/50.  I keep 50%, and use 50% to help pay for the hardware I purchased.  It's working well so far withdrawing through Virwox/SL, but I'm all for an easier/cheaper solution.  Going the Virwox/SL route, I end up paying about 5% in fees on average.  Of course, it's not exact since I go through another exchange, which may be under or overvalued compared to MtGox, but it does the trick.

Going the MtGox route though, all I see are two fees:  The 0.65% fee for making a trade from BTC to USD, and the $0.25 fee from dwolla to receive money into my account.  Are there any other fees I am not considering?


Title: Re: Is MtGox the best way to withdraw BTC as USD?
Post by: FooDSt4mP on May 26, 2011, 12:10:05 AM
Well, it's easy to change it from BTC into USD via a trade, but is it the best route to go as far as withdrawing that USD into one's bank account?

Right now, I'm mining 50/50.  I keep 50%, and use 50% to help pay for the hardware I purchased.  It's working well so far withdrawing through Virwox/SL, but I'm all for an easier/cheaper solution.  Going the Virwox/SL route, I end up paying about 5% in fees on average.  Of course, it's not exact since I go through another exchange, which may be under or overvalued compared to MtGox, but it does the trick.

Going the MtGox route though, all I see are two fees:  The 0.65% fee for making a trade from BTC to USD, and the $0.25 fee from dwolla to receive money into my account.  Are there any other fees I am not considering?

Nope.. that's it.


Title: Re: Is MtGox the best way to withdraw BTC as USD?
Post by: Horkabork on May 26, 2011, 12:20:26 AM
Going the MtGox route though, all I see are two fees:  The 0.65% fee for making a trade from BTC to USD, and the $0.25 fee from dwolla to receive money into my account.  Are there any other fees I am not considering?

There's also the (semi-optional) 0.01 bitcoin transaction fee to factor into your calculations.

However, the real advantage of dwolla is that you get to talk to friends about bitcoins and dwolla and sound like you're a huge nerd with a speech impediment who can't pronounce "dollar."

Try saying "I changed my bitcoins into dwolla dwolla bills y'all" without sounding like you're a speech-impaired gangster nerd from Brooklyn.

It's all about the dwollas, yo.


Title: Re: Is MtGox the best way to withdraw BTC as USD?
Post by: nickwit on May 26, 2011, 12:51:40 AM
Well, that is the 64000$ question.

I'm in NZ... how do I get bitcoins into $NZD? Or any currency.

I'm in NZ, all my clients are in the EU - at the moment, I take cash out of an ATM using a UK card... and there are costs associated with that. Right now it costs 0 to transfer bitcoins around the world. It'd be worth a lot to know a fast, reliable way of getting them into local currencies without massive fees.


Title: Re: Is MtGox the best way to withdraw BTC as USD?
Post by: pancakes on May 26, 2011, 05:21:41 AM
Well, that is the 64000$ question.

I'm in NZ... how do I get bitcoins into $NZD? Or any currency.

I'm in NZ, all my clients are in the EU - at the moment, I take cash out of an ATM using a UK card... and there are costs associated with that. Right now it costs 0 to transfer bitcoins around the world. It'd be worth a lot to know a fast, reliable way of getting them into local currencies without massive fees.


I'm in NZ too. I sell them on MtGox then withdraw into Liberty Reserve, then exchange into NZD in my bank account with webmoney.co.nz which is an e-currency exchanger service.

There's probably a better/cheaper way to do it though.


Title: Re: Is MtGox the best way to withdraw BTC as USD?
Post by: eturnerx on May 26, 2011, 10:34:50 AM
I'm in NZ too. And yes, the chain is MTGOX -> Liberty Reserve -> Webmoney.co.nz

I think the webmoney minimum fee is quite step ($10NZD) since a domestic bank transfer only costs $0.35 cents.


Title: Re: Is MtGox the best way to withdraw BTC as USD?
Post by: jed on May 26, 2011, 12:42:11 PM
Mtgox has an AUD bank account now. Maybe that helps you NZ guys?


Title: Re: Is MtGox the best way to withdraw BTC as USD?
Post by: Gilboa on May 26, 2011, 07:34:10 PM
I remember reading that MT Gox was working on enabling direct deposits to and from US bank accounts. Is that still going to happen or was I mistaken?


Title: Re: Is MtGox the best way to withdraw BTC as USD?
Post by: Maged on May 27, 2011, 01:40:32 AM
I remember reading that MT Gox was working on enabling direct deposits to and from US bank accounts. Is that still going to happen or was I mistaken?
I suspect that Dwolla usurped the need for that. Once you set it up, it's no slower than MtGox would be able to do directly. Not to mention, $0.25 each way is pretty cheap.


Title: Re: Is MtGox the best way to withdraw BTC as USD?
Post by: FooDSt4mP on May 27, 2011, 03:04:26 AM
I remember reading that MT Gox was working on enabling direct deposits to and from US bank accounts. Is that still going to happen or was I mistaken?
I suspect that Dwolla usurped the need for that. Once you set it up, it's no slower than MtGox would be able to do directly. Not to mention, $0.25 each way is pretty cheap.

Yeah, if I were MagicalTux, I'd leave it at that.  Then Dwolla is there to arbitrate if there is a dispute.


Title: Re: Is MtGox the best way to withdraw BTC as USD?
Post by: Syke on May 27, 2011, 04:54:01 AM
Going the MtGox route though, all I see are two fees:  The 0.65% fee for making a trade from BTC to USD, and the $0.25 fee from dwolla to receive money into my account.  Are there any other fees I am not considering?

Nothing else. I'm quite pleased with the MtGox->Dwolla->Bank Account transfer. It take a few days to get Dwolla all setup, but once that's done, then the conversion from BTC all the way to USD is quite easy and quick.

Now that the Dwolla fee is only $.25, the .65% MtGox fee is looking enormous.


Title: Re: Is MtGox the best way to withdraw BTC as USD?
Post by: SgtSpike on May 27, 2011, 05:20:56 AM
Thanks for the feedback guys - looks like that's what I'll be doing from here on out then!


Title: Re: Is MtGox the best way to withdraw BTC as USD?
Post by: BitChaser on March 12, 2014, 01:26:11 AM
Thanks for the feedback guys - looks like that's what I'll be doing from here on out then!

DONT DO IT!


Title: Re: Is MtGox the best way to withdraw BTC as USD?
Post by: Kazimir on March 12, 2014, 02:22:45 PM
Thanks for the feedback guys - looks like that's what I'll be doing from here on out then!

DONT DO IT!
Congratis on bumping a 3 year old thread, about some exchange that doesn't even exist anymore  ;)


Title: Re: Is MtGox the best way to withdraw BTC as USD?
Post by: Simon8x on March 12, 2014, 02:48:34 PM
Thanks for the feedback guys - looks like that's what I'll be doing from here on out then!

DONT DO IT!

I bet you haven't noticed the thread creation time lol.


Title: Re: Is MtGox the best way to withdraw BTC as USD?
Post by: cooltoadfrommoon on March 12, 2014, 03:11:32 PM
lol , quite funny to see a thread with this title :P


Title: Re: Is MtGox the best way to withdraw BTC as USD?
Post by: b!z on March 13, 2014, 09:49:53 AM
Thanks for the feedback guys - looks like that's what I'll be doing from here on out then!

DONT DO IT!

too late ;)


Title: Re: Is MtGox the best way to withdraw BTC as USD?
Post by: ns12123 on March 15, 2014, 07:30:25 PM
Yes, it's late now ... i hated mt gox from the beginning


Title: Re: Is MtGox the best way to withdraw BTC as USD?
Post by: redwhitenblue on June 08, 2014, 02:43:41 AM
I would not recommend using MtGox for BTC trading.


Title: Re: Is MtGox the best way to withdraw BTC as USD?
Post by: smoothie on June 08, 2014, 02:46:29 AM
I would not recommend using MtGox for BTC trading.

Oh really?

You mean the non-existent exchange to trade BTC for nothing?

mtgox.com

lolz


Title: Re: Is MtGox the best way to withdraw BTC as USD?
Post by: jonsi on June 08, 2014, 10:44:40 AM
Buy at https://btc-e.com/ (current price 646$)
Sell at http://btcpromo.net/index.php?r=1HrhYoXdvyNPZMqyo3trxWNFTaXXPGiSxQ  (current price 678$)

thank you for using my referral link. cheers



btcpromo is a scam that steals your bitcoins:
https://bitcointalk.org/index.php?topic=640736.0
https://bitcointalk.org/index.php?topic=612476.0
https://bitcointalk.org/index.php?topic=636638.0



Title: Re: Is MtGox the best way to withdraw BTC as USD?
Post by: Harley997 on June 10, 2014, 04:11:44 AM
I would not recommend using MtGox for BTC trading.

This is probably good advise.

It was probably good advise for several months prior to when the imploded as they were taking a long time to process withdrawals.

It was probably good advise since they had their bank account seized by DHS


Title: Re: Is MtGox the best way to withdraw BTC as USD?
Post by: Ilsk on June 10, 2014, 10:57:12 AM
I would not recommend using MtGox for BTC trading.

Yeah, volumes are low and the price it's too stable, too much spread between buy and sell.