Bitcoin Forum

Other => CPU/GPU Bitcoin mining hardware => Topic started by: martinH on June 10, 2011, 01:40:56 PM



Title: Graphic Card Memory
Post by: martinH on June 10, 2011, 01:40:56 PM
Hi,

I've checked the graphic cards in the mining equipment wiki and found some candidates I would buy for my first mining rig. But I'm still wondering why there is no statement about required graphic card memory in the wiki. Is it not important for the performance? Can I go with some small graphic card memory like 1 Gb or is it better the have some bigger one?

Another question: I've read that it tends to be difficult to combine two entirely different graphic cards like 6970 and 5850 in the same mining rig. Would it also be a problem to combine two different models of the same series, like a 6970 with 1 Gb memory with another 6970 with 2 Gb memory?

Martin


Title: Re: Graphic Card Memory
Post by: happypal on June 10, 2011, 02:16:10 PM
Memory is totally irrelevant when it comes to mining, so less memory=cheaper card for same result. Furthermore, memory produces heat, so many miners under-clock their memory as much as possible.


Title: Re: Graphic Card Memory
Post by: martinH on June 12, 2011, 10:23:00 PM
Thanks, that's good to know.


Title: Re: Graphic Card Memory
Post by: stordoff on June 13, 2011, 02:00:23 AM
Purely for mining, I'd go for the card with the smaller memory. They tend to be a little cheaper, and I suspect that it will save some power consumption. Downclocking the memory also has no effect no hash-rate, but can give substantial heat and power savings.


Title: Re: Graphic Card Memory
Post by: Goldenmaw on June 13, 2011, 02:05:41 AM
I have noticed on my 5830's and my 6870's a reproducible increase in hash rates by 5-10 mh/s by as a result of downclocking to 200 mhz.  This is in addition to the decreased heat generation.  I have no idea why this happens.


Title: Re: Graphic Card Memory
Post by: Basiley on June 13, 2011, 02:05:55 AM
Purely for mining, I'd go for the card with the smaller memory. They tend to be a little cheaper, and I suspect that it will save some power consumption. Downclocking the memory also has no effect no hash-rate, but can give substantial heat and power savings.
actually, downclocking reduce memory latency in Radeons case and for mining context thats far more handy, than throughput[which is matter in case of gaming workload/appz]cuz tiny amounts of data need to be moved VERY quick.


Title: Re: Graphic Card Memory
Post by: stordoff on June 13, 2011, 03:17:26 AM
Purely for mining, I'd go for the card with the smaller memory. They tend to be a little cheaper, and I suspect that it will save some power consumption. Downclocking the memory also has no effect no hash-rate, but can give substantial heat and power savings.
actually, downclocking reduce memory latency in Radeons case and for mining context thats far more handy, than throughput[which is matter in case of gaming workload/appz]cuz tiny amounts of data need to be moved VERY quick.

Never noticed an increase, but I can see why it could happen. I'll have a play around with that later. Thanks.


Title: Re: Graphic Card Memory
Post by: Basiley on June 13, 2011, 03:55:48 AM
Purely for mining, I'd go for the card with the smaller memory. They tend to be a little cheaper, and I suspect that it will save some power consumption. Downclocking the memory also has no effect no hash-rate, but can give substantial heat and power savings.
actually, downclocking reduce memory latency in Radeons case and for mining context thats far more handy, than throughput[which is matter in case of gaming workload/appz]cuz tiny amounts of data need to be moved VERY quick.

Never noticed an increase, but I can see why it could happen. I'll have a play around with that later. Thanks.
some tweakers allow to modify timings directly, like [shipped-with-suspiciously-behaving-kernel-space-driver]Ati Tray Tools, but you can see how timings change with clocks, by looking into BIOS settings.