Bitcoin Forum

Bitcoin => Mining => Topic started by: Severian on March 31, 2013, 06:19:51 PM



Title: I just realized why I need to start mining, so a question for miners
Post by: Severian on March 31, 2013, 06:19:51 PM
“The system is secure as long as honest nodes collectively control more CPU power than any cooperating group of attacker nodes.”

The importance of the above quote struck me last night. So I want to throw in my .02 btc of being an honest node and add some hashing power. I'm not worried about spending a few more dollars on electricity than I make in bitcoins because Bitcoin has already treated me so well.

I mined on my laptop back in the day but stopped when it went to GPUs. Now, looking at mining has the same effect on me as the first time I encountered Bitcoin itself. It's confusing for us non-miners. So perhaps an expert or two could help clear up the confusion.

My question: What's the lowest impact, cheapest method of adding 1-2 gigahashes/s to the network? As said, this is just to be an honest node as I'm not worried about profit from mining.

Thanks!



Title: Re: I just realized why I need to start mining, so a question for miners
Post by: lassdas on March 31, 2013, 06:33:00 PM
The "being an honest node" argument with just 1-2GH/s is moot, because with such a low hashrate you're probably going to mine on a pool anyways.
In that case it's not you, but the pool-operator who has to be honest (and you don't really have any control about that).

But to answer your question: the cheapest way in terms of initial investment is probably to grab some used ATI GPUs on ebay, although the energy-cost is quite high for the long term. Another way would be to grab some used FPGA boards, higher initial investment, lower energy-costs. Or just wait a few more months and hope for ASICs to be available/affordable.
And that's about all methods around for everybody.  :D


Title: Re: I just realized why I need to start mining, so a question for miners
Post by: Severian on March 31, 2013, 06:39:53 PM
but the pool-operator who has to be honest (and you don't really have any control about that).

So it would serve my interests to do my research first into who's running the pool.

Quote
But to answer your question: the cheapest way in terms of initial investment is probably to grab some used ATI GPUs on ebay, although the energy-cost is quite high for the long term. Another way would be to grab some used FPGA boards, higher initial investment, lower energy-costs. Or just wait a few more months and hope for ASICs to be available/affordable.
And that's about all methods around for everybody.  :D

And that's what I wanted to know. Thanks for the quick answers.


Title: Re: I just realized why I need to start mining, so a question for miners
Post by: meowmeowbrowncow on April 01, 2013, 09:20:00 PM
“The system is secure as long as honest nodes collectively control more CPU power than any cooperating group of attacker nodes.”

The importance of the above quote struck me last night. So I want to throw in my .02 btc of being an honest node and add some hashing power. I'm not worried about spending a few more dollars on electricity than I make in bitcoins because Bitcoin has already treated me so well.

I mined on my laptop back in the day but stopped when it went to GPUs. Now, looking at mining has the same effect on me as the first time I encountered Bitcoin itself. It's confusing for us non-miners. So perhaps an expert or two could help clear up the confusion.

My question: What's the lowest impact, cheapest method of adding 1-2 gigahashes/s to the network? As said, this is just to be an honest node as I'm not worried about profit from mining.

Thanks!




Good for you for realizing the importance of why Bitcoin is so important.  Impartiality.


So, now, with the right philosophic point of view, go get yourself some ASIC's.




Title: Re: I just realized why I need to start mining, so a question for miners
Post by: icellan on April 01, 2013, 11:31:49 PM
“The system is secure as long as honest nodes collectively control more CPU power than any cooperating group of attacker nodes.”

The importance of the above quote struck me last night. So I want to throw in my .02 btc of being an honest node and add some hashing power. I'm not worried about spending a few more dollars on electricity than I make in bitcoins because Bitcoin has already treated me so well.

I mined on my laptop back in the day but stopped when it went to GPUs. Now, looking at mining has the same effect on me as the first time I encountered Bitcoin itself. It's confusing for us non-miners. So perhaps an expert or two could help clear up the confusion.

My question: What's the lowest impact, cheapest method of adding 1-2 gigahashes/s to the network? As said, this is just to be an honest node as I'm not worried about profit from mining.

Thanks!

Good for you for realizing the importance of why Bitcoin is so important.  Impartiality.

So, now, with the right philosophic point of view, go get yourself some ASIC's.

Where can we get some? Butterfly labs seems to be DOA and Avalon is sold out.


Title: Re: I just realized why I need to start mining, so a question for miners
Post by: amencon on April 02, 2013, 06:28:25 AM
I would wait for the ASIC boom to end and when there is an available product on the shelves which you can receive a tracking number for on the day of purchase, buy one, plug it in and forget about it.

Yeah this is what I'm waiting for.  It's OK if I miss the gold rush but will definitely want something simple hashing in the background at low cost once the technology matures a bit.  I'd bet plenty others are in the same boat.


Title: Re: I just realized why I need to start mining, so a question for miners
Post by: Dabs on April 07, 2013, 07:16:56 AM
I'd want a simple small device that I can plug into my computer's USB port and starting bitcoin mining at 10 GH/s or 20 GH/s. When there are about a few hundred of us little folks doing that, we'd help secure the network. Fees can also be lowered.


Title: Re: I just realized why I need to start mining, so a question for miners
Post by: gmaxwell on April 07, 2013, 11:39:30 AM
The "being an honest node" argument with just 1-2GH/s is moot, because with such a low hashrate you're probably going to mine on a pool anyways.
In that case it's not you, but the pool-operator who has to be honest (and you don't really have any control about that).
Use P2Pool, and then you're an honest to god honest node.

Or really, if your motivation is primarily to secure Bitcoin— feel free to solo mine. Your expected return is as good or better, and if you're not in it for the income the fact that its a bit of a lottery shouldn't turn you off.