|
Title: Growing Mh/s discrepancy on deepbit, showing about 1Gh/s less than actual? Post by: marvinmartian on August 03, 2011, 04:59:00 PM My miners typically run at around 7.5 Gh/s these days. For the past month, that's been pretty much in accord with what my account on the deepbit website reports. It's maybe off by 100-300 Mh/s.
For the last couple of days, however, my account on deepbit consistently shows about 1 Gh/s less than what my machines are reporting (output from DiabloMiner). Anyone else notice this? It's both odd and annoying. It's also affecting my daily BTC mining quota. Title: Re: Growing Mh/s discrepancy on deepbit, showing about 1Gh/s less than actual? Post by: [Tycho] on August 03, 2011, 08:14:58 PM PM me your login name, I'll check my logs.
Have you tried any other miners to see if this error will show up ? Title: Re: Growing Mh/s discrepancy on deepbit, showing about 1Gh/s less than actual? Post by: marvinmartian on August 03, 2011, 08:28:05 PM PM me your login name, I'll check my logs. Have you tried any other miners to see if this error will show up ? PM sent. Title: Re: Growing Mh/s discrepancy on deepbit, showing about 1Gh/s less than actual? Post by: Kermee on August 03, 2011, 08:32:07 PM My miners typically run at around 7.5 Gh/s these days. For the past month, that's been pretty much in accord with what my account on the deepbit website reports. It's maybe off by 100-300 Mh/s. For the last couple of days, however, my account on deepbit consistently shows about 1 Gh/s less than what my machines are reporting (output from DiabloMiner). Anyone else notice this? It's both odd and annoying. It's also affecting my daily BTC mining quota. Are you looking at the 'Average Speed' calculation where you can set the average calculations between 5 minutes and 60 minutes, or on the right-side of https://deepbit.net/account where it shows your calculated MH/s speed from the # of shares submitted for the last 7 blocks? Cheers, Kermee Title: Re: Growing Mh/s discrepancy on deepbit, showing about 1Gh/s less than actual? Post by: marvinmartian on August 03, 2011, 09:23:37 PM Are you looking at the 'Average Speed' calculation where you can set the average calculations between 5 minutes and 60 minutes, or on the right-side of https://deepbit.net/account where it shows your calculated MH/s speed from the # of shares submitted for the last 7 blocks? Cheers, Kermee Looking mainly at the average. It normally lines up with the logs from my miners. Right now, for example, my miners are reporting 7258 mh/s (and have been pretty much all afternoon). DB is showing my average over the last 15min at 5755.73 mh/s (about 21% difference). I've been mining with DB for a while now. This much discrepancy is new from my perspective. The difference between DB and my logs is more along 100 to 300 mh/s which I typically chalk up to stale shares, connection issues, etc... Right now, my logs show no connection issues. Similarly, a rough guesstimate from the DB website shows about 1-2% stale for my miners. I'm just trying to figure out why the discrepancy is so large. Title: Re: Growing Mh/s discrepancy on deepbit, showing about 1Gh/s less than actual? Post by: willphase on August 03, 2011, 10:02:58 PM have you tried switching to another pool for a few hours to see if it's specific to DB or whether it's something wrong with your local stats?
Will Title: Re: Growing Mh/s discrepancy on deepbit, showing about 1Gh/s less than actual? Post by: marvinmartian on August 03, 2011, 10:11:31 PM have you tried switching to another pool for a few hours to see if it's specific to DB or whether it's something wrong with your local stats? Will No, I never got around to setting up more than Slush, BTC Guild and DB. I didn't update my BTC Guild stuff (stopped using them during their weeks of DDoS). So yeah, I've been quite happy with DB. More stable than the others by far. So I'd rather keep it pointed there in the hopes that they sort it out relatively soon. Good (and obvious) suggestion for a test though. Call me a bit lazy, I deserve it. Title: Re: Growing Mh/s discrepancy on deepbit, showing about 1Gh/s less than actual? Post by: CanaryInTheMine on August 03, 2011, 10:56:46 PM I see similar wild swings on my numbers too.
Title: Re: Growing Mh/s discrepancy on deepbit, showing about 1Gh/s less than actual? Post by: Jack of Diamonds on August 03, 2011, 11:36:14 PM Same thing happening. My hashrate on DB is ~6 ghash (two 3gh clusters), give or take a few hundred based on stats
but currently it's been showing 4300-4500 for quite some time. Quote from: willphase have you tried switching to another pool for a few hours to see if it's specific to DB or whether it's something wrong with your local stats? No, I diversify to other pools all the time so it's not that. Eligius and some smaller pools like btcpool24 are showing correct hashrates so I narrowed it down to some bug on deepbit. Title: Re: Growing Mh/s discrepancy on deepbit, showing about 1Gh/s less than actual? Post by: Starlightbreaker on August 03, 2011, 11:56:50 PM i thought it's normal...apparently not.
it varies around 200-400mh/s for me, but the btc output seems correct. Title: Re: Growing Mh/s discrepancy on deepbit, showing about 1Gh/s less than actual? Post by: CanaryInTheMine on August 04, 2011, 12:00:34 AM i thought it's normal...apparently not. it varies around 200-400mh/s for me, but the btc output seems correct. It easily varies by 1G for me... Title: Re: Growing Mh/s discrepancy on deepbit, showing about 1Gh/s less than actual? Post by: kjj on August 04, 2011, 05:07:15 AM The hash rate reported by your client is the only place that the actual hash rate is measured. Pools don't know and don't care about that, they care how many candidate blocks you return. In the (very) long run, the measured hash rate and the rate estimated by the pool based on your shares should be fairly close, but that isn't a constraint on any particular interval of time. The difference is commonly known as "luck" in the community.
If you suspect a problem with a pool, what you need to do is remove your personal luck from consideration. Stop a few miners, clear the stats for those workers on the pool, then start the miners again. If the shares reported by your client don't match the shared reported by the pool, then there is a problem with the pool. Title: Re: Growing Mh/s discrepancy on deepbit, showing about 1Gh/s less than actual? Post by: Jack of Diamonds on August 04, 2011, 05:16:16 AM The hash rate reported by your client is the only place that the actual hash rate is measured. Pools don't know and don't care about that, they care how many candidate blocks you return. In the (very) long run, the measured hash rate and the rate estimated by the pool based on your shares should be fairly close, but that isn't a constraint on any particular interval of time. The difference is commonly known as "luck" in the community. If you suspect a problem with a pool, what you need to do is remove your personal luck from consideration. Stop a few miners, clear the stats for those workers on the pool, then start the miners again. If the shares reported by your client don't match the shared reported by the pool, then there is a problem with the pool. I mined on deepbit for ~6 months. It usually varies by a max. of 500-800mhash (calc. based on submitted shares) though. Swings of 2gh or more are rare if not inexistent & suggest temporary server issue. But you're right, easiest way is to reset the counter & compare submitted shares by client to those accepted by DB. The hashate is just an estimate. Title: Re: Growing Mh/s discrepancy on deepbit, showing about 1Gh/s less than actual? Post by: Clipse on August 05, 2011, 02:18:02 AM What everyone here forget, hashrate doesnt equal share submits.
If you process/submit shares slower than your hashrate, you can get reports of even half your actual hashrate on the poolsite. Pools only report hashrate based on submitted shares. Title: Re: Growing Mh/s discrepancy on deepbit, showing about 1Gh/s less than actual? Post by: [Tycho] on August 05, 2011, 02:16:10 PM Same thing happening. My hashrate on DB is ~6 ghash (two 3gh clusters), give or take a few hundred based on stats Are you also using DiabloMiner or not ?but currently it's been showing 4300-4500 for quite some time. Title: Re: Growing Mh/s discrepancy on deepbit, showing about 1Gh/s less than actual? Post by: marvinmartian on August 05, 2011, 08:24:10 PM What everyone here forget, hashrate doesnt equal share submits. If you process/submit shares slower than your hashrate, you can get reports of even half your actual hashrate on the poolsite. Pools only report hashrate based on submitted shares. Yes, but if I've been seeing my hashrate (as measured on my end) be roughly equal to what's reported on deepbit for the last month or so ... AND ONLY RECENTLY have the two figures started to diverge by a significant amount (and continue to diverge) ... then the above observation does not apply. Nothing on my end has changed. Title: Re: Growing Mh/s discrepancy on deepbit, showing about 1Gh/s less than actual? Post by: marvinmartian on August 05, 2011, 08:24:43 PM Same thing happening. My hashrate on DB is ~6 ghash (two 3gh clusters), give or take a few hundred based on stats Are you also using DiabloMiner or not ?but currently it's been showing 4300-4500 for quite some time. << - DiabloMiner here Title: Re: Growing Mh/s discrepancy on deepbit, showing about 1Gh/s less than actual? Post by: CanaryInTheMine on August 06, 2011, 08:19:40 PM What everyone here forget, hashrate doesnt equal share submits. If you process/submit shares slower than your hashrate, you can get reports of even half your actual hashrate on the poolsite. Pools only report hashrate based on submitted shares. Clipse, We're not forgetting anything here. What you are saying is trivial and obvious. What we are pointing out is the timing of this observation. What I'm saying is that recently I started noticing wild swings. I fully understand how the reported rate on the website is arrived at, but I have not seen such large swings before. I wonder if this is tied to the recent release of 2.1 phatk Title: Re: Growing Mh/s discrepancy on deepbit, showing about 1Gh/s less than actual? Post by: [Tycho] on August 07, 2011, 12:43:09 AM Are you also using DiabloMiner or not ? << - DiabloMiner hereJust to check if it's related to DiabloMiner or not. |