Bitcoin Forum

Bitcoin => Pools => Topic started by: GoodHosting on December 08, 2013, 02:41:34 AM



Title: Is this P2Pool working? [BTC]
Post by: GoodHosting on December 08, 2013, 02:41:34 AM
Been running this pool for about 3 days. Mining off and on. No pool shares yet. This is what console output looks like

Code:
2013-12-07 21:38:31.702000 P2Pool: 17386 shares in chain (17390 verified/17390 total) Peers: 13 (7 incoming)
2013-12-07 21:38:31.702000  Local: 121MH/s in last 10.0 minutes Local dead on arrival: ~11.8% (3-35%) Expected time to share: 184.7 days
2013-12-07 21:38:31.702000  Shares: 0 (0 orphan, 0 dead) Stale rate: ??? Efficiency: ??? Current payout: 0.0000 BTC
2013-12-07 21:38:31.702000  Pool: 130TH/s Stale rate: 14.9% Expected time to block: 6.5 hours
2013-12-07 21:38:40.702000 P2Pool: 17386 shares in chain (17390 verified/17390 total) Peers: 13 (7 incoming)
2013-12-07 21:38:40.702000  Local: 128MH/s in last 10.0 minutes Local dead on arrival: ~11.1% (3-33%) Expected time to share: 174.6 days
2013-12-07 21:38:40.702000  Shares: 0 (0 orphan, 0 dead) Stale rate: ??? Efficiency: ??? Current payout: 0.0000 BTC
2013-12-07 21:38:40.702000  Pool: 130TH/s Stale rate: 14.9% Expected time to block: 6.5 hours
2013-12-07 21:38:42.093000 Peer sent entire transaction 22ee36b2090fc3a2f31a84117501af2ef26c6be12216ff333468dcf903162a02 that was already received
2013-12-07 21:38:42.593000 Peer sent entire transaction 22ee36b2090fc3a2f31a84117501af2ef26c6be12216ff333468dcf903162a02 that was already received
2013-12-07 21:38:47.156000 New work for worker! Difficulty: 0.999985 Share difficulty: 459666.183611 Total block value: 25.177571 BTC including 630 transactions
2013-12-07 21:38:47.265000 New work for worker! Difficulty: 0.999985 Share difficulty: 459666.183611 Total block value: 25.177571 BTC including 630 transactions
2013-12-07 21:38:49.702000 P2Pool: 17387 shares in chain (17391 verified/17391 total) Peers: 13 (7 incoming)
2013-12-07 21:38:49.702000  Local: 128MH/s in last 10.0 minutes Local dead on arrival: ~11.1% (3-33%) Expected time to share: 174.6 days
2013-12-07 21:38:49.702000  Shares: 0 (0 orphan, 0 dead) Stale rate: ??? Efficiency: ??? Current payout: 0.0000 BTC
2013-12-07 21:38:49.702000  Pool: 132TH/s Stale rate: 14.9% Expected time to block: 6.4 hours
2013-12-07 21:38:51.312000 New work for worker! Difficulty: 0.999985 Share difficulty: 457218.134017 Total block value: 25.179561 BTC including 636 transactions
2013-12-07 21:38:51.421000 New work for worker! Difficulty: 0.999985 Share difficulty: 457218.134017 Total block value: 25.179561 BTC including 636 transactions
2013-12-07 21:38:52.702000 P2Pool: 17388 shares in chain (17392 verified/17392 total) Peers: 13 (7 incoming)
2013-12-07 21:38:52.702000  Local: 128MH/s in last 10.0 minutes Local dead on arrival: ~11.1% (3-33%) Expected time to share: 174.6 days
2013-12-07 21:38:52.702000  Shares: 0 (0 orphan, 0 dead) Stale rate: ??? Efficiency: ??? Current payout: 0.0000 BTC
2013-12-07 21:38:52.702000  Pool: 131TH/s Stale rate: 14.3% Expected time to block: 6.4 hours
2013-12-07 21:38:57.062000 Peer sent entire transaction fc3067d340a7083add1bbbf10fb7eaa219c90896e3cca94b98b082b3b4460748 that was already received
2013-12-07 21:38:57.406000 Skipping from block 556f2ba9b011069ce3d8545481e6be39d40b77123078a2e37 to block 12a2e6926aface65e43aeeca947ab42441320824aed7702a7!
2013-12-07 21:38:57.421000 New work for worker! Difficulty: 0.999985 Share difficulty: 457218.134017 Total block value: 25.000000 BTC including 0 transactions
2013-12-07 21:38:57.437000 New work for worker! Difficulty: 0.999985 Share difficulty: 457218.134017 Total block value: 25.000000 BTC including 0 transactions
2013-12-07 21:39:00.124000 Peer sent entire transaction afd48f16a6892984ab9f6a0abb7d3bb9358b0ca0dff1e9f64229ba71c1f23a2a that was already received
2013-12-07 21:39:01.734000 Peer sent entire transaction c07f1c54133af883f01d298c06ad4f08ef2b0abbf3b6862733940ebc1f550e4f that was already received
2013-12-07 21:39:02.656000 Punishing share for 'Block-stale detected! height(556f2ba9b011069ce3d8545481e6be39d40b77123078a2e37) < height(12a2e6926aface65e43aeeca947ab42441320824aed7702a7) or 19061242 != 19061242'!
Jumping from a17085d3 to 87db3d3c!
2013-12-07 21:39:02.687000 New work for worker! Difficulty: 0.999985 Share difficulty: 459666.183611 Total block value: 25.000000 BTC including 0 transactions
2013-12-07 21:39:02.687000 New work for worker! Difficulty: 0.999985 Share difficulty: 459666.183611 Total block value: 25.000000 BTC including 0 transactions
2013-12-07 21:39:02.859000 New work for worker! Difficulty: 0.999985 Share difficulty: 459666.183611 Total block value: 25.007643 BTC including 66 transactions
2013-12-07 21:39:03.359000 New work for worker! Difficulty: 0.999985 Share difficulty: 459666.183611 Total block value: 25.007643 BTC including 66 transactions
2013-12-07 21:39:04.093000 Punishing share for 'Block-stale detected! height(556f2ba9b011069ce3d8545481e6be39d40b77123078a2e37) < height(12a2e6926aface65e43aeeca947ab42441320824aed7702a7) or 19061242 != 19061242'!
Jumping from a17085d3 to 87db3d3c!
2013-12-07 21:39:04.093000 Punishing share for 'Block-stale detected! height(556f2ba9b011069ce3d8545481e6be39d40b77123078a2e37) < height(12a2e6926aface65e43aeeca947ab42441320824aed7702a7) or 19061242 != 19061242'!
Jumping from a17085d3 to 87db3d3c!
2013-12-07 21:39:04.702000 P2Pool: 17387 shares in chain (17392 verified/17392 total) Peers: 13 (7 incoming)
2013-12-07 21:39:04.702000  Local: 128MH/s in last 10.0 minutes Local dead on arrival: ~11.1% (3-33%) Expected time to share: 174.6 days
2013-12-07 21:39:04.702000  Shares: 0 (0 orphan, 0 dead) Stale rate: ??? Efficiency: ??? Current payout: 0.0000 BTC
2013-12-07 21:39:04.702000  Pool: 132TH/s Stale rate: 14.9% Expected time to block: 6.4 hours
2013-12-07 21:39:09.093000 Punishing share for 'Block-stale detected! height(556f2ba9b011069ce3d8545481e6be39d40b77123078a2e37) < height(12a2e6926aface65e43aeeca947ab42441320824aed7702a7) or 19061242 != 19061242'!
Jumping from a17085d3 to 87db3d3c!
2013-12-07 21:39:09.093000 Punishing share for 'Block-stale detected! height(556f2ba9b011069ce3d8545481e6be39d40b77123078a2e37) < height(12a2e6926aface65e43aeeca947ab42441320824aed7702a7) or 19061242 != 19061242'!
Jumping from a17085d3 to 87db3d3c!
2013-12-07 21:39:14.093000 Punishing share for 'Block-stale detected! height(556f2ba9b011069ce3d8545481e6be39d40b77123078a2e37) < height(12a2e6926aface65e43aeeca947ab42441320824aed7702a7) or 19061242 != 19061242'!
Jumping from a17085d3 to 87db3d3c!
2013-12-07 21:39:14.093000 Punishing share for 'Block-stale detected! height(556f2ba9b011069ce3d8545481e6be39d40b77123078a2e37) < height(12a2e6926aface65e43aeeca947ab42441320824aed7702a7) or 19061242 != 19061242'!
Jumping from a17085d3 to 87db3d3c!
2013-12-07 21:39:15.202000 Peer sent entire transaction 3005c2296f8fc00e53ed86fd9f3b11023ffbc6f77ebacb1b67d5245a1dfeccdb that was already received
2013-12-07 21:39:17.952000 Punishing share for 'Block-stale detected! height(556f2ba9b011069ce3d8545481e6be39d40b77123078a2e37) < height(12a2e6926aface65e43aeeca947ab42441320824aed7702a7) or 19061242 != 19061242'!
Jumping from a17085d3 to 87db3d3c!
2013-12-07 21:39:19.093000 Punishing share for 'Block-stale detected! height(556f2ba9b011069ce3d8545481e6be39d40b77123078a2e37) < height(12a2e6926aface65e43aeeca947ab42441320824aed7702a7) or 19061242 != 19061242'!
Jumping from a17085d3 to 87db3d3c!
2013-12-07 21:39:19.093000 Punishing share for 'Block-stale detected! height(556f2ba9b011069ce3d8545481e6be39d40b77123078a2e37) < height(12a2e6926aface65e43aeeca947ab42441320824aed7702a7) or 19061242 != 19061242'!
Jumping from a17085d3 to 87db3d3c!

Is this pool working correctly?

http://p2pool.goodhosting.info:9332/static/


Title: Re: Is this P2Pool working? [BTC]
Post by: GoodHosting on December 08, 2013, 02:46:04 AM
Also I've only tested it with CGMiner and Ufasoft CPU Miner.

If anyone wants to test it with other miners :)

-u BTC_ADDRESS -p any -o stratum+tcp://p2pool.goodhosting.info:9332


Title: Re: Is this P2Pool working? [BTC]
Post by: IYFTech on December 08, 2013, 04:01:53 AM
Yes, it's working - but with only 128mh/s you're wasting your electricity.......

"Expected time to share: 174.6 days"

That's almost half a year...........for a share.

11.1% DOA is too high also.


Title: Re: Is this P2Pool working? [BTC]
Post by: GoodHosting on December 08, 2013, 04:13:51 AM
It's only 128/Mhash because I haven't started throwing ASIC's at it or promoting it yet. Gotta make sure it works first :P


Title: Re: Is this P2Pool working? [BTC]
Post by: Rluner on December 08, 2013, 03:17:06 PM
I encountered similar issues with p2pool and my setup after the difficulty kept on rising.

I quote below the final post by me on this topic, which should summise my conclusions.

Taken from https://bitcointalk.org/index.php?topic=18313.msg3414073#msg3414073 page 342

After around 1 week of solid processing at 10 gh/s via p2pool network I received 0.00337845 BTC; after missing 16 block payouts in a row.
I'm sorry to say this can't be giving me my fair share for my work done on the p2pool network so I have moved off it.

You may have something wrong with your miner setup, or with the pool you're using - how many p2pool 'shares' did you submit ?

There is some element of 'randomness' - but a week of 15Gh/s has found 17 P2Pool-type 'shares' and apart from the 2 days when that miner had found no p2pool-shares, I've been paid on every block found.



Thanks for all the responses. It's good to get feed back.

My miner setup was working perfect before the difficulty rose to 268 m. I was running my own p2pool client, efficiently was near perfect, stall rate was virtually zero, DOA was zero. I was able to find a share in nearly every block and got paid out nearly every time. I think I missed two payouts in about twenty, but I hadn't found a share so I knew that was correct too.

As soon as the difficulty rose to 268 m without anything changing at my side (after three months working perfectly) I stopped receiving payouts. After a week I ended up with one pay out of a very low amount as previously wrote in a previous post, but p2pool has paid out about 17 times. I had noticed that I couldn't get a successful share before the pool solved a block and when I did manage to get two , one was orphaned. That's when I got my only payout in a week.

Summery....

After a week of running at 268 m I have to say p2pool did not work for my 10 gh processing.

It had worked perfectly below 268m difficulty, my payouts were nearly ever time and perfect amounts as I calculated from inputting numbers into online calculators.

The problem seems to me that my 10 gh can't get a share fast enough for the network, but although I was informed when I did get a share I would get my fair share I clearly didn't.

Also I have to add, at the same time I had another 10 gh in another pool, not p2pool, and this paid what I would have expected, over the same time period.

I end by saying I believe in the p2pool idea, and I thank the coders, but I also believe as the difficulty rises more low hashing users may have to leave p2pool network due to the issues I have mentioned.