Bitcoin Forum

Economy => Speculation => Topic started by: Elwar on February 20, 2014, 07:47:19 AM



Title: Official End of Mt Gox thread
Post by: Elwar on February 20, 2014, 07:47:19 AM
Mt Gox is currently trading at about $140/BTC and crashing.

What do you think the end of Mt Gox will look like?


Title: Re: Official End of Mt Gox thread
Post by: Krabby on February 20, 2014, 07:47:59 AM
What has happened?
Need to get my money in.


Title: Re: Official End of Mt Gox thread
Post by: Ibian on February 20, 2014, 07:48:21 AM
I think it will look like a fat guy in cuffs. No way can they be acting legally.


Title: Re: Official End of Mt Gox thread
Post by: hostmaster on February 20, 2014, 07:48:50 AM
Mt Gox is currently trading at about $140/BTC and crashing.

What do you think the end of Mt Gox will look like?
what is promised has to be delivered! MTGOx will be liar and crab after to day if no explanation comes.


Title: Re: Official End of Mt Gox thread
Post by: mvdheuvel1983 on February 20, 2014, 07:49:52 AM
This sudden big crash just hours before the Gox announcement must mean someone knows something we don't.


Title: Re: Official End of Mt Gox thread
Post by: Krabby on February 20, 2014, 07:51:51 AM
This sudden big crash just hours before the Gox announcement must mean someone knows something we don't.

Or they want some cheap ass coins.


Title: Re: Official End of Mt Gox thread
Post by: checkers6676 on February 20, 2014, 07:52:31 AM
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=vNoErHIfrGU (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=vNoErHIfrGU)


Title: Re: Official End of Mt Gox thread
Post by: F-bernanke on February 20, 2014, 07:53:02 AM
Will this be the BEST GOXXXING ever? Or will they continue?


Title: Re: Official End of Mt Gox thread
Post by: zedicus on February 20, 2014, 07:53:41 AM
This sudden big crash just hours before the Gox announcement must mean someone knows something we don't.

http://static.fjcdn.com/comments/DING+_e45172e6f172939d24f74fc882ac678a.jpg



Title: Re: Official End of Mt Gox thread
Post by: bitcon on February 20, 2014, 09:12:24 AM
has anyone successfully got any funds onto gox in the past few days?


Title: Re: Official End of Mt Gox thread
Post by: sgbett on February 20, 2014, 09:14:02 AM
has anyone successfully got any funds onto gox in the past few days?

yes. sepa took about 48 hours excluding weekends (and I think monday was a holiday in US? maybe elsewhere).


Title: Re: Official End of Mt Gox thread
Post by: Gulinborsti on February 20, 2014, 09:27:17 AM
has anyone successfully got any funds onto gox in the past few days?

yes. sepa took about 48 hours excluding weekends (and I think monday was a holiday in US? maybe elsewhere).
You are a lucky guy, my deposit from 14.2. is still not showing up on my account ...


Title: Re: Official End of Mt Gox thread
Post by: paulifa123 on February 20, 2014, 09:31:05 AM
Lucky guy, if Mark isn't in the midst of pulling a huge con job  :o Anyone sending money to gox is brave, that's for sure!


Title: Re: Official End of Mt Gox thread
Post by: rograz on February 20, 2014, 09:48:49 AM
This sudden big crash just hours before the Gox announcement must mean someone knows something we don't.

Or they want you to think they know something, one last attempt to cause panic just before the expected update from gox. This scenario is just as likely (if not more) as someone having insider information.


Title: Re: Official End of Mt Gox thread
Post by: wobber on February 20, 2014, 10:10:09 AM
eMpTyGox has no place in the bitcoin economy.

Mark my words: gox will fail.


Title: Re: Official End of Mt Gox thread
Post by: checkers6676 on February 20, 2014, 10:23:16 AM
https://www.mtgox.com/img/pdf/20140220-Announcement.pdf (https://www.mtgox.com/img/pdf/20140220-Announcement.pdf)


Title: Re: Official End of Mt Gox thread
Post by: bitcon on February 20, 2014, 10:25:31 AM
gox update:


!
"
FOR IMMEDIATE RELEASE
"
"
"
"
"
"
"
"
"
"
Tokyo, J
apan, February 20th, 201
4
!
"
"
Dear MtGox Customers,
"
"
Thank you for your patience this week while we are working on re-initiating bitcoin
withdrawals. In addition to the technical issue, this week we have experienced some
security problems, and as a result we had to relocate MtGox to our previous office building
in Shibuya (details can be found here
https://support.mtgox.com/home
). The move,
combined with some other security and technical challenges, pushed back our progress.
"
"
As much as we didn’t want to only provide an “update on an update”, this is the current
status. We are committed to solving this issue and will provide more information as soon
as
possible
to keep everyone in the loop.
"
"
We are very sorry for the delays and deeply appreciate your kind understanding and
continuous support.
"
"
Best regards,
"
"
"
MtGox Team


Title: Re: Official End of Mt Gox thread
Post by: GigaCoin on February 20, 2014, 10:27:32 AM
gox update:


!
"
FOR IMMEDIATE RELEASE
"
"
"
"
"
"
"
"
"
"
Tokyo, J
apan, February 20th, 201
4
!
"
"
Dear MtGox Customers,
"
"
Thank you for your patience this week while we are working on re-initiating bitcoin
withdrawals. In addition to the technical issue, this week we have experienced some
security problems, and as a result we had to relocate MtGox to our previous office building
in Shibuya (details can be found here
https://support.mtgox.com/home
). The move,
combined with some other security and technical challenges, pushed back our progress.
"
"
As much as we didn’t want to only provide an “update on an update”, this is the current
status. We are committed to solving this issue and will provide more information as soon
as
possible
to keep everyone in the loop.
"
"
We are very sorry for the delays and deeply appreciate your kind understanding and
continuous support.
"
"
Best regards,
"
"
"
MtGox Team


They had a 'security issue" which caused them to move offices ? hahahaha this is so hilarious  :D


Title: Re: Official End of Mt Gox thread
Post by: GigaCoin on February 20, 2014, 10:27:48 AM
eMpTyGox has no place in the bitcoin economy.

Mark my words: gox will fail.

it won't


Title: Re: Official End of Mt Gox thread
Post by: 404notfound on February 20, 2014, 10:30:16 AM
Mt gox is making bitcoin look like such a joke to any outside investors. Imagine being approached by a bitcoin business and then seeing this ridiculousness. It's sad really. We will recover, but the more times gox does this the longer it will take.


Title: Re: Official End of Mt Gox thread
Post by: spiderbrain on February 20, 2014, 10:34:25 AM
This is terrible. We need to end this quickly now. Surely we have the resources on this forum to hire Chuck Norris to finish this for us once and for all...?


Title: Re: Official End of Mt Gox thread
Post by: flower1024 on February 20, 2014, 10:38:56 AM
i dont think mtgox will die.
i've just heard and believed it to many times before.

this time again its a real joke: letting no money out, not freezing trading...


Title: Re: Official End of Mt Gox thread
Post by: WompRat on February 20, 2014, 10:42:17 AM
What is this security issue?  We used to have animal rights protestors outside our door every other week.  It never bothered me that much.  If it gets bad you call the police.  I have never heard of anyone running away because of a security issue.  Besides that an office move can be incredibly disruptive if it is not carefully planned. I am smelling that smell again...


Title: Re: Official End of Mt Gox thread
Post by: porcupine87 on February 20, 2014, 10:45:57 AM
Wow, the difference is 1 to 4 between Gox and others. Do you really think, the Mt-Gox guys have no temptation to buy on gox and sell somewhere else. I mean, they have the power to get out btc of Gox.

-> 300% Profit for sure in just a couple of hours. I think they could make at least a couple of 10 000$ per hour.


Title: Re: Official End of Mt Gox thread
Post by: Dragonkiller on February 20, 2014, 10:50:10 AM
Sooner gox goes to $0 and dies, the better. The best gift they can give the bitcoin economy right now is to just die.


Title: Re: Official End of Mt Gox thread
Post by: kwest on February 20, 2014, 10:51:50 AM
If I were to write an illustrated history of crypto currencies, I would have a picture of an active volcano on the timeline for this month, and the text "Goxpocalypse"


Title: Re: Official End of Mt Gox thread
Post by: smoothie on February 20, 2014, 10:52:25 AM
This last excuse about "security issue" is showing the world how full of crap they are.

Let the price crash to $0. Let them go out of business. Bitcoin doesn't need them.


Title: Re: Official End of Mt Gox thread
Post by: spiderbrain on February 20, 2014, 10:54:32 AM
The best gift they can give the bitcoin economy right now is to just die.
+1


Title: Re: Official End of Mt Gox thread
Post by: WompRat on February 20, 2014, 10:58:00 AM
Wow, the difference is 1 to 4 between Gox and others. Do you really think, the Mt-Gox guys have no temptation to buy on gox and sell somewhere else. I mean, they have the power to get out btc of Gox.

-> 300% Profit for sure in just a couple of hours. I think they could make at least a couple of 10 000$ per hour.

Tempting yes, illegal almost certainly.  It would be difficult to hide this if they were investigated,  so I guess it depends on just how big a hole they are in and whether they plan to move again - overseas maybe.  


Title: Re: Official End of Mt Gox thread
Post by: Mythul on February 20, 2014, 11:04:30 AM
Are they going to hit $2 ? You know guys...everything in life will come to an end eventually.


Title: Re: Official End of Mt Gox thread
Post by: UnDerDoG81 on February 20, 2014, 11:06:45 AM
Thats a shame I hope this is the end of Gox.


Title: Re: Official End of Mt Gox thread
Post by: WompRat on February 20, 2014, 11:08:34 AM
Are they going to hit $2 ? You know guys...everything in life will come to an end eventually.

Maybe it will hit $1 so Edward50 can finally buy back in.  


Title: Re: Official End of Mt Gox thread
Post by: phatsphere on February 20, 2014, 11:16:25 AM
I'm curious, has there been any info about mtgox trading on other exchanges? (e.g. to get lost coins back or to make up for their issues?)


Title: Re: Official End of Mt Gox thread
Post by: BlackHayate on February 20, 2014, 11:17:04 AM
http://s006.radikal.ru/i214/1402/9a/22148b6460bd.png
Dat gox.


Title: Re: Official End of Mt Gox thread
Post by: oda.krell on February 20, 2014, 11:19:43 AM
has anyone successfully got any funds onto gox in the past few days?

yes. sepa took about 48 hours excluding weekends (and I think monday was a holiday in US? maybe elsewhere).

just wondering... you wired money to gox to pick up coins cheap, which makes sense maybe economically, if the chance of total failure is outweighed by the chance of getting the coins out of gox and the possible profit you could make on that.

But you don't see any  problem at all that, by doing so, you're lending gox legitimacy that they very much don't deserve anymore? I mean, I know, it's a market, morality has no place in here but... really?


Title: Re: Official End of Mt Gox thread
Post by: DubFX on February 20, 2014, 11:21:01 AM
Wow, what if people will manage to get their coins out of the gox and the price on other markets will crash even more?


Title: Re: Official End of Mt Gox thread
Post by: Ibian on February 20, 2014, 11:21:45 AM
Wow, what if people will manage to get their coins out of the gox and the price on other markets will crash even more?
That would be wonderful. Payday is coming up soon.


Title: Re: Official End of Mt Gox thread
Post by: UnDerDoG81 on February 20, 2014, 11:25:22 AM
Bitstamp is holding up rather well, although we might see a sell off there too.

Imo Mark and gox are damaging bitcoin, either through incompetence or conspiracy. I can't decide.

Why is stamp holding up?


Title: Re: Official End of Mt Gox thread
Post by: Mythul on February 20, 2014, 11:26:20 AM
Bitstamp is holding up rather well, although we might see a sell off there too.

Imo Mark and gox are damaging bitcoin, either through incompetence or conspiracy. I can't decide.

Why is stamp holding up?

Because the dead of Gox has been partially priced in. Why sell when BTC ATMs are appearing in the USA which is really bullish news ?


Title: Re: Official End of Mt Gox thread
Post by: UnDerDoG81 on February 20, 2014, 11:29:30 AM
Bitstamp is holding up rather well, although we might see a sell off there too.

Imo Mark and gox are damaging bitcoin, either through incompetence or conspiracy. I can't decide.

Why is stamp holding up?

Because the dead of Gox has been partially priced in. Why sell when BTC ATMs are appearing in the USA which is really bullish news ?

Ok I missundestood, I thought he mean stamp has stoped withdrawals too.


Title: Re: Official End of Mt Gox thread
Post by: wobber on February 20, 2014, 11:41:12 AM
Bitstamp is holding up rather well, although we might see a sell off there too.

Imo Mark and gox are damaging bitcoin, either through incompetence or conspiracy. I can't decide.

Why is stamp holding up?

BitStamp is trading at $600, although dropping.

I'm surprised we haven't seen copycats on bitstamp panic selling and driving down the price.

Perhaps they will.......

Question is, why Bitstamp should go down?

Think of this: Me buys hillgox.com, do some design with Bootstrap, some PHP/MySQL and presto! New exchange. You cannot withdraw, cause no bank will work with me but you can put all the money you want.

Me also engineers the price to be low or just let the wolves kill each other will I get blown by Asian girls and drinking frappucino. Would your trades, your bitcoins and the bitcoin price be real? No. The only thing real is me getting rich.


Title: Re: Official End of Mt Gox thread
Post by: pietje on February 20, 2014, 11:49:32 AM
I hope they die today instead of dragging the same shit in the following weeks.
Gox can't do shit. They announched ltc 1 year ago still nothing. Will be same story for withdrawals.


Title: Re: Official End of Mt Gox thread
Post by: traderwin on February 20, 2014, 11:50:30 AM
So people - it's likely the gox price will go below $100 - that's a given. The question is what's the floor? $75? $50? $25? Even $10? Any thoughts?


Title: Re: Official End of Mt Gox thread
Post by: pietje on February 20, 2014, 11:51:11 AM
So people - it's likely the gox price will go below $100 - that's a given. The question is what's the floor? $75? $50? $25? Even $10? Any thoughts?

$0?

Still amazing how the other exchanges are holding up with all this gox crap.


Title: Re: Official End of Mt Gox thread
Post by: Rygon on February 20, 2014, 12:08:57 PM
It's about damn time. The red flags have been numerous here, and the evidence grows stronger everyday that MtGox is scamming folks. Reminds me of the Pirate scheme collapsing. Anyone wiring money to MtGox with the intent to buy coins cheap is taking a huge risk now. Not only is there a risk that they will never be allowed to withdraw those coins, but there's a class action suit forming and probably others on their way. I'd say there's at least a 50% chance that their operations are shut down, or at least their fiat bank accounts, within the next month.

It'll be ugly, and I feel bad for anyone who has funds trapped at Gox, but this will be best for bitcoin in the long run. Nearly every major exchange crisis in the last 3 years has been because of a Gox screwup. Looking forward to happier days with more reliable and professional exchanges.

On the plus side, prices on other exchanges should rise after Gox collapses, as soon as the market realizes the coins on Gox either a) don't exist or b) have been stolen. Then eventually customers will get some fiat out from the lawsuits and likely go to other exchanges to buy back into bitcoin.


Title: Re: Official End of Mt Gox thread
Post by: MakeBelieve on February 20, 2014, 12:13:08 PM
We should have a party that this scamming exchange is now gone from our community.


Title: Re: Official End of Mt Gox thread
Post by: Oblodo on February 20, 2014, 12:15:22 PM
Quote
By Takashi Mochizuki and Eleanor Warnock

TOKYO--Just six months ago, Mark Karpelès was sitting on top of the world. Mt. Gox, his Tokyo-based platform that had started as an exchange for Magic trading cards, had in a short time become the world's dominant platform for exchanging the new big thing--bitcoins.

Cut to a snowy February morning in Tokyo, and you find Mr. Karpelès trying to walk past a bitcoin trader holding a sign outside Mt. Gox's offices in the hip Shibuya neighborhood, asking: "MT. GOX--WHERE IS OUR MONEY?"

The trader, Kolin Burges, who had flown in from London, was only one of many customers of the company who have been pressing the trading platform to disclose more about its financial health after it froze customer withdrawals on Feb. 7.

The travails of Mt. Gox illustrate the convulsions of the bitcoin market as the first generation of companies trading the virtual currency face growing technical and security challenges.

Chris Larsen, chief executive of San Francisco-based Ripple Labs Inc., a startup associated with another virtual currency, ripples, likened the convulsions as the bitcoin market expands to the early days of the Internet, when it wasn't clear that the World Wide Web would really catch on.

Then, "it all just seemed like the craziest stuff--who would ever use this?--and now it's absolutely in the fabric of every enterprise on earth," he said.

Mr. Larsen developed Ripple with another bitcoin entrepreneur, Jed McCaleb, the founder of Mt. Gox, who sold it to Mr. Karpelès in 2011. The name Mt. Gox, which came from the Magic card game the company originally dealt in before Mr. McCaleb turned it onto bitcoins, is short for Magic: The Gathering Online Exchange.

Mt. Gox has been wrestling with problems since earlier this year, when it halted withdrawals in dollars.

Also in May, some of Mt. Gox's funds were seized by U.S. regulators, who said the exchange wasn't properly registered in the U.S. Mt. Gox said in a statement last month that it is has been properly registered as a money-services business in the U.S. since the end of June.

After Mt. Gox again abruptly halted customer withdrawals on Feb. 7, it blamed its issues on a glitch in the bitcoin software.

On Feb. 10, Mt. Gox said it had been hit by fraudulent requests for payment by users exploiting a feature in the core protocol known as "transaction malleability."

Initially, many in the bitcoin community argued that Mt. Gox had simply failed to use the correct internal procedures to protect its accounts. The next day, however, a hacking attack crippled other bitcoin-exchange platforms and raised questions about the security of the global network for trading the virtual currency.

Asked why the company hadn't addressed customers' concern sooner, Mr. Karpelès responded in an email interview with The Wall Street Journal on Monday: "I assume you refer to the malleability issue. We sincerely apologize for this incident; however, please understand that we are NOT the developers of Bitcoin." He added, "We are very surprised that anyone could fault MtGox instead of the bitcoin software."

However, he said, "We deeply apologize for any delays in our responses."

After Mr. Karpelès, who was running an IT company in Tokyo, bought Mt. Gox from Mr. McCaleb in 2011, Mt. Gox became the world's biggest bitcoin exchange by volume, with more than 80% of bitcoin trades, according to Bitcoinity.org, a service that tracks rates on various exchanges. During that time, the price of a single bitcoin rose from 92 cents to a peak of more than $1,147 last December, based on figures from CoinDesk, a bitcoin-data provider based in London.

Amid the turmoil surrounding Mt. Gox, CoinDesk removed Mt. Gox from its benchmark bitcoin index early last week. The index, which now includes just Slovenia-based Bitstamp and BTC-e of Bulgaria, stood at $624.63 in New York afternoon trading Monday, while Mt. Gox-traded bitcoin was valued at just $294.20. Its share of bitcoin trades had dropped to 25% on Monday, according to Bitcoinity.org.

But aside from the lower value of its bitcoins, investors are increasingly concerned about the status of their Mt. Gox accounts. The company's halt of bitcoin transfers to outside accounts led investors to speculate on online forums that the company had its bitcoins stolen by hackers or that it was out of cash and would default.

Tomoaki Ushida, who runs an IT consulting firm in Tokyo, has given up hope of recovering the two bitcoins he had in his Mt. Gox account. "I try to convince myself that I paid for a good lesson," he said. "If I ever get them returned, I'm lucky."

In the email interview, Mr. Karpelès responded to questions about the company's solvency or protection for customers' funds by saying that the matter is confidential. However, he said the company had discussed its business model with Japanese authorities "to ensure that we are operating within the law here."

At a weekly meeting Thursday of Mt. Gox investors and other members of Tokyo's small, tightknit bitcoin community at a bar about a 10-minute walk from Mt. Gox's headquarters, some 30 bitcoiners talked about bitcoins and exchanged the currency using cellphone-readable bar codes. Some members reminisced about tipping burlesque dancers in bitcoins at a bar called the Pink Cow in Tokyo's foreigner-rich Roppongi neighborhood that accepts bitcoins for payment.

But the conversation revolved mostly around Mt. Gox and whether the exchange would be able to honor deposits. Organizers had extended an invitation to Mr. Karpelès but said they didn't receive a response.

Ken Shishido, one of the group's organizers who works in the telecom industry, said, "Everyone's question is whether the company still has everyone's bitcoin and cash. That's a very critical thing we need to know."

Mr. Burges, the London investor, was among the bitcoiners Thursday night. The next morning, outside Mt. Gox's offices, he managed to get in a brief confrontation with Mr. Karpelès. "You still have everyone's bitcoin?" Mr. Burges asked while Mr. Karpelès tried to navigate around him holding a Starbucks cup and an umbrella.

In the wider Japanese business community, bitcoins aren't widely used or even well-known. Japanese officials are cautious about making any comments about bitcoins as they wait for the Bank of Japan to finish a study about the virtual currency. Still, some Japan-based lawyers say certain restrictions, especially on exchange platforms, should be considered in order to prevent criminal use of the currency, such as for money-laundering.

"I believe that regulating exchanges would be the best way to address these problems," said So Saito, a lawyer at the Tokyo law firm of Nishimura & Asahi.

Meanwhile, the turmoil at Mt. Gox has even touched the Pink Cow, home to the burlesque dancers, which has switched to another bitcoin payment process called BitPay.

Mt. Gox transactions are "taking an unacceptable length of time right now, so we are taking another route," said owner Traci Consoli. "Hopefully, a more stable system will evolve as it grows." [Suspicious link removed]j.com/article/BT-CO-20140217-704805.html


Title: Re: Official End of Mt Gox thread
Post by: igorr on February 20, 2014, 01:09:42 PM
I think it will look like a fat guy in cuffs. No way can they be acting legally.

Bitcoin has not legal currency anywhere in the world.


Title: Re: Official End of Mt Gox thread
Post by: WompRat on February 20, 2014, 01:21:02 PM
I think it will look like a fat guy in cuffs. No way can they be acting legally.

Bitcoin has not legal currency anywhere in the world.

It could still be fraud - doesn't matter what you are selling.  There could be dozens of charges you could bring, but fraud is probably the easiest to justify and is treated most harshly under Japanese law.


Title: Re: Official End of Mt Gox thread
Post by: segeln on February 20, 2014, 01:22:05 PM
why don`t we have any whistleblowers at Gox.which can "whistle" what is going on ?


Title: Re: Official End of Mt Gox thread
Post by: igorr on February 20, 2014, 01:25:46 PM
Mtgox is the same as the Edward Snouden, It is not possible in another country.


Title: Re: Official End of Mt Gox thread
Post by: iBug on February 20, 2014, 01:45:22 PM
"Official End of Mt Gox" ?
With "official" you must mean "unofficial". And with "End" you must mean "possible end".
I shouldn't spend so much time in the speculation forum ... nothing here makes any sense.  ::)


Title: Re: Official End of Mt Gox thread
Post by: NUFCrichard on February 20, 2014, 01:46:46 PM
Sorry if this is a dumb question, but if people buy bitcoins on Gox now at $100, they are actually buying bitcoins aren't they?
It is off blockchain so there is no way of knowing if Gox are naked shorting...


Title: Re: Official End of Mt Gox thread
Post by: eoJ on February 20, 2014, 01:53:28 PM
I think it will look like a fat guy in cuffs. No way can they be acting legally.

Bitcoin has not legal currency anywhere in the world.
Yes it is. Netherlands, Germany, Switzerland, USA, etc. I think you mean legal tender.


Title: Re: Official End of Mt Gox thread
Post by: Rygon on February 20, 2014, 01:54:34 PM
Sorry if this is a dumb question, but if people buy bitcoins on Gox now at $100, they are actually buying bitcoins aren't they?
It is off blockchain so there is no way of knowing if Gox are naked shorting...

Not bitcoin but IOU-Coins

I haven't seen this brought up yet, but has anyone done a blockchain analysis to venture a guess at how many bitcoins are under control of Gox? It probably won't be simple because they've been around a while, but bitcoins have been flowing in for a few months now, so I wouldn't be surprised if some of them have ended up in cold storage in a handful of large addresses.


Title: Re: Official End of Mt Gox thread
Post by: nopedope89 on February 20, 2014, 01:56:42 PM
Although MtGox is damaging bitcoin, I am not sure it is going to crash. It is still have a big chance to survive.


Title: Re: Official End of Mt Gox thread
Post by: wobber on February 20, 2014, 01:58:18 PM
Hey MtGox users,

Why panick? Bitcoin price is where it was 6 months ago.


Title: Re: Official End of Mt Gox thread
Post by: phatsphere on February 20, 2014, 02:21:44 PM
I don't get it, yet another drop to $130 ? how is this even possible given the current price on other markets?

I suspect, there are coins sold which only exist in their database. Does anybody have experience with a similar situation? Or knows of an example in history where we can look at? In my eyes it's completely insane, that trading hasn't been halted -- it should have been a few minutes prior to the first announcement, that bitcoin withdrawals are suspended!


Title: Re: Official End of Mt Gox thread
Post by: Tzupy on February 20, 2014, 02:30:06 PM
In my eyes it's completely insane, that trading hasn't been halted -- it should have been a few minutes prior to the first announcement, that bitcoin withdrawals are suspended!

A honest business would have done that (suspend trading), but MTGox chose to defraud its customers.
When the MtGox price is 75% lower than Bitstamp, I think defraud is the right verb describing the situation.


Title: Re: Official End of Mt Gox thread
Post by: Money Raccoon on February 20, 2014, 02:31:39 PM
Hey MtGox users,

Why panick? Bitcoin price is where it was 6 months ago.

It's not the price they're worried about.


Title: Re: Official End of Mt Gox thread
Post by: MANofthePEOPLE on February 20, 2014, 02:31:46 PM
Is there really only 20-25% chance gox pays out? I must say it's a bit tempting to wire money and buy $130 coins hoping for the best. Not going to though :p


Title: Re: Official End of Mt Gox thread
Post by: igorr on February 20, 2014, 02:32:25 PM
Game is over


Title: Re: Official End of Mt Gox thread
Post by: Dragonkiller on February 20, 2014, 02:32:58 PM
I am very impressed by Bitstamp (and the other exchanges). They've pretty much ran out of shits to give. I don't think we will go much below where we are now even if/when Gox goes to zero.


Title: Re: Official End of Mt Gox thread
Post by: igorr on February 20, 2014, 02:35:18 PM
I am very impressed by Bitstamp (and the other exchanges). They've pretty much ran out of shits to give. I don't think we will go much below where we are now even if/when Gox goes to zero.

Millions of Bitcoin will be sold from the MtGox on Bitstamp, and Bistamp  will collapse just like the MtGox !


Title: Re: Official End of Mt Gox thread
Post by: Dragonkiller on February 20, 2014, 02:36:12 PM
I am very impressed by Bitstamp (and the other exchanges). They've pretty much ran out of shits to give. I don't think we will go much below where we are now even if/when Gox goes to zero.

Millions of Bitcoin will be sold from the MtGox on Bitstamp, and Bistamp  will collapse just like the MtGox !

Those "bitcoins" from Gox are never getting out.


Title: Re: Official End of Mt Gox thread
Post by: Richard Branson on February 20, 2014, 02:39:48 PM

Those "bitcoins" from Gox are never getting out.


They don't have to get out.
Mark can easily just sell them.

Either way. Shorting bitcoin NOW is the way to go.

If Mt.Gox will completly default -> price will drop hard
If Mt.Gox will allow withdrawal of bitocoins -> price will drop hard

Either way, we will go down to 100-250$ per bitcoin and stay there till mass adoption really kicks in (2-5 years).


Title: Re: Official End of Mt Gox thread
Post by: Dragonkiller on February 20, 2014, 02:44:05 PM

Those "bitcoins" from Gox are never getting out.


They don't have to get out.
Mark can easily just sell them.

Either way. Shorting bitcoin NOW is the way to go.

If Mt.Gox will completly default -> price will drop hard
If Mt.Gox will allow withdrawal of bitocoins -> price will drop hard

Either way, we will go down to 100-250$ per bitcoin and stay there till mass adoption really kicks in (2-5 years).

Why do you assume Mark (and the people buying now if Gox does allow withdrawals) will suddenly want to sell? Mark already has a ton of coins of his own, by your logic he should be selling those.

If you think price is going to rise in the future, the rational thing is to hold regardless of the price you bought in at.


Title: Re: Official End of Mt Gox thread
Post by: dnaleor on February 20, 2014, 02:49:25 PM
https://i.imgur.com/1khaHUB.jpg


Title: Re: Official End of Mt Gox thread
Post by: DanielVG on February 20, 2014, 02:53:34 PM

That image will keep popping up the next couple of months.


Title: Re: Official End of Mt Gox thread
Post by: epetroel on February 20, 2014, 03:14:10 PM

If Mt.Gox will allow withdrawal of bitocoins -> price will drop hard


Why do you assume this?  From what I've seen the bid sum on Gox has dropped massively over the last few days.  This tells me people are reluctant to buy (obviously).  But where is that money going?  It certainly isn't being withdrawn (we all know about the huge fiat withdrawal delays).  So it's sitting in people's Gox accounts. 

So what happens when/if bitcoin withdrawals are restarted?  People who want to get their money out will buy bitcoin, send their coins elsewhere and sell them - just as they've been trying to do for the last few months.  People with low ask orders will cancel them now that they know they can send their coins elsewhere and get more money for them.  This causes the Gox price to skyrocket and prices elsewhere to (maybe) drop moderately.  And we end up right back where we were before this whole malleability mess - with a Gox price higher than everywhere else.


Title: Re: Official End of Mt Gox thread
Post by: sgbett on February 20, 2014, 03:21:18 PM
has anyone successfully got any funds onto gox in the past few days?

yes. sepa took about 48 hours excluding weekends (and I think monday was a holiday in US? maybe elsewhere).

just wondering... you wired money to gox to pick up coins cheap, which makes sense maybe economically, if the chance of total failure is outweighed by the chance of getting the coins out of gox and the possible profit you could make on that.

But you don't see any  problem at all that, by doing so, you're lending gox legitimacy that they very much don't deserve anymore? I mean, I know, it's a market, morality has no place in here but... really?

I'm not a moral arbiter. Especially not given that I don't actually *know* what is going on at gox.

I'm amazed how many people claim that they do.

Here's just one scenario out of a hat.

Gox knows that by allowing BTC withdrawals, they could potentially double pay (yes due to their own flawed algorithm - but still a risk all the same), and this would threaten solvency/customer deposits.

What needs to happen is that the free market will decide. If people are happy to tolerate gox's way of doing things they will carry on, if they don't gox will die.

If people want to make it a moral crusade that's their call. To me its just business.


Title: Re: Official End of Mt Gox thread
Post by: igorr on February 20, 2014, 03:28:11 PM
See MtGox,
how it is possible, big international robbery without any help and without any legal responsibility.
Who was behind this     ???


Title: Re: Official End of Mt Gox thread
Post by: Bobsurplus on February 20, 2014, 03:30:01 PM
130 and crashing!


Title: Re: Official End of Mt Gox thread
Post by: Bobsurplus on February 20, 2014, 03:30:38 PM
See MtGox,
how it is possible, big international robbery without any help and without any legal responsibility.
Who was behind this     ???


STOP FUCKING AROUND WITH YOUR COPY & PASTE.


Title: Re: Official End of Mt Gox thread
Post by: oda.krell on February 20, 2014, 03:32:06 PM
has anyone successfully got any funds onto gox in the past few days?

yes. sepa took about 48 hours excluding weekends (and I think monday was a holiday in US? maybe elsewhere).

just wondering... you wired money to gox to pick up coins cheap, which makes sense maybe economically, if the chance of total failure is outweighed by the chance of getting the coins out of gox and the possible profit you could make on that.

But you don't see any  problem at all that, by doing so, you're lending gox legitimacy that they very much don't deserve anymore? I mean, I know, it's a market, morality has no place in here but... really?

I'm not a moral arbiter. Especially not given that I don't actually *know* what is going on at gox.

I'm amazed how many people claim that they do.

Here's just one scenario out of a hat.

Gox knows that by allowing BTC withdrawals, they could potentially double pay (yes due to their own flawed algorithm - but still a risk all the same), and this would threaten solvency/customer deposits.

What needs to happen is that the free market will decide. If people are happy to tolerate gox's way of doing things they will carry on, if they don't gox will die.

If people want to make it a moral crusade that's their call. To me its just business.


I could say something about the paradox of the self-interested actor, something along the lines of the dominant strategy not necessarily leading to the optimal result for the individual that chose that strategy, but I would sound like a self-righteous, hypocritical dick. Carry on then.


Title: Re: Official End of Mt Gox thread
Post by: igorr on February 20, 2014, 03:32:44 PM
130 and crashing!

http://img40.imageshack.us/img40/7047/bncs.jpg (http://img40.imageshack.us/i/bncs.jpg/)View Screen Capture (http://img40.imageshack.us/i/bncs.jpg/)

Check volume last 14 days.  ;)


Title: Re: Official End of Mt Gox thread
Post by: igorr on February 20, 2014, 03:33:19 PM
See MtGox,
how it is possible, big international robbery without any help and without any legal responsibility.
Who was behind this     ???


STOP FUCKING AROUND WITH YOUR COPY & PASTE.

I just want answers to my questions !


Title: Re: Official End of Mt Gox thread
Post by: fonzie on February 20, 2014, 03:33:44 PM
Bitstamp withdrawl problems...

https://bitcointalk.org/index.php?topic=476614.0


Title: Re: Official End of Mt Gox thread
Post by: Bobsurplus on February 20, 2014, 03:33:57 PM
130 and crashing!

http://img40.imageshack.us/img40/7047/bncs.jpg (http://img40.imageshack.us/i/bncs.jpg/)View Screen Capture (http://img40.imageshack.us/i/bncs.jpg/)

Check volume last 14 days.  ;)

Its nuts.. I think by mid next week we'll see bitcoins at <$10 on gox.


Title: Re: Official End of Mt Gox thread
Post by: Bobsurplus on February 20, 2014, 03:34:40 PM
Only 8500 btc to go till $20


Title: Re: Official End of Mt Gox thread
Post by: igorr on February 20, 2014, 03:37:48 PM
Only 8500 btc to go till $20

Or 45000 btc to go till $70 on Bitstamp


Title: Re: Official End of Mt Gox thread
Post by: Bobsurplus on February 20, 2014, 03:41:28 PM
Only 8500 btc to go till $20

Or 45000 btc to go till $70 on Bitstamp


6665 to $20 bucks now...

I enjoy watching this chart on the 15 Minute more then any chart I've ever watched.


Title: Re: Official End of Mt Gox thread
Post by: derpinheimer on February 20, 2014, 03:42:48 PM
Only 8500 btc to go till $20

That's a lie; it's actually 42,000


Title: Re: Official End of Mt Gox thread
Post by: Bobsurplus on February 20, 2014, 03:44:00 PM
Only 8500 btc to go till $20

That's a lie; it's actually 42,000

It was no lie when I posted it, things have changed in the few minutes since.


Title: Re: Official End of Mt Gox thread
Post by: Bobsurplus on February 20, 2014, 03:44:27 PM
Only 8500 btc to go till $20

That's a lie; it's actually 42,000

It was no lie when I posted it, things have changed in the few minutes since.

and right now its 11800 to $20


Title: Re: Official End of Mt Gox thread
Post by: Manticore on February 20, 2014, 03:45:55 PM
I love that under any other circumstance they would've halted trading. They've done it countless time during mini BTC crashes.

I suppose holding their customer's coins hostage and letting the price go down to nothing is their best exit. At this point, they know their days are numbered even in a best case scenario.

So they bide time, let the price crash, buy cheap coins, potentially arb them to make money for themselves and possibly pay back the customers that haven't sold out of panic, and they also attract new money from clients with enormous appetites for risk, enabling them to buy even more coins. So, they enrich themselves and possibly manipulate their way out of liability (possibly returning coins after they've flipped everyone else's coins several times over), then close shop?


Title: Re: Official End of Mt Gox thread
Post by: derpinheimer on February 20, 2014, 03:46:30 PM
Whatever site you are using is crap

It's still 42k


Title: Re: Official End of Mt Gox thread
Post by: Bobsurplus on February 20, 2014, 03:49:44 PM
Whatever site you are using is crap

It's still 42k

Bitcoinwisdom and its the best site out there!


Title: Re: Official End of Mt Gox thread
Post by: pleiotropik on February 20, 2014, 03:50:38 PM
Helmets on? Karpeles is not done. That bull is on the lose in the china shop.  :D


Title: Re: Official End of Mt Gox thread
Post by: aminorex on February 20, 2014, 03:51:09 PM
I could say something about the paradox of the self-interested actor, something along the lines of the dominant strategy not necessarily leading to the optimal result for the individual that chose that strategy, but I would sound like a self-righteous, hypocritical dick. Carry on then.


No, you'd sound like a game theorist.


Title: Re: Official End of Mt Gox thread
Post by: Mythul on February 20, 2014, 03:51:35 PM
I feel sorry for anybody stuck there.


Title: Re: Official End of Mt Gox thread
Post by: pleiotropik on February 20, 2014, 03:51:39 PM
meant to say "loose" sorry for spelling spam.  :(


Title: Re: Official End of Mt Gox thread
Post by: DanielVG on February 20, 2014, 03:57:06 PM
MTgox is currently under 100$


Title: Re: Official End of Mt Gox thread
Post by: fonzie on February 20, 2014, 03:57:43 PM
Guess who´s next

http://i57.tinypic.com/2nn804.jpg


Title: Re: Official End of Mt Gox thread
Post by: ledmaniak on February 20, 2014, 03:58:13 PM
MTgox is currently under 100$
under 100$? My low shows $130...


Title: Re: Official End of Mt Gox thread
Post by: derpinheimer on February 20, 2014, 03:58:32 PM
Whatever site you are using is crap

It's still 42k

Bitcoinwisdom and its the best site out there!

Obviously not, considering its depth is terribly off.
MTgox is currently under 100$

Also a lie.


Title: Re: Official End of Mt Gox thread
Post by: jasonjm on February 20, 2014, 03:58:45 PM
GOX is a total and utter disaster.

There is no good part of it. The list of failures, scams, and setbacks continues.

Everything bitcoin ends up being a scam or con in some way or other. Instead of being a decentralized currency, bitcoin has turned into a shyster magnet.


Title: Re: Official End of Mt Gox thread
Post by: SolarSilver on February 20, 2014, 04:00:00 PM
MTgox is currently under 100$
under 100$? My low shows $130...

I think he means in EUR not USD

Quote
Low:95.80 €


Title: Re: Official End of Mt Gox thread
Post by: MOB on February 20, 2014, 04:01:53 PM

Because you have them all tied up, perhaps?


Title: Re: Official End of Mt Gox thread
Post by: igorr on February 20, 2014, 04:01:57 PM


+1
very logical


Title: Re: Official End of Mt Gox thread
Post by: Bobsurplus on February 20, 2014, 04:03:38 PM


Oh boy.


Title: Re: Official End of Mt Gox thread
Post by: Johnshpon3 on February 20, 2014, 04:30:59 PM
Don't lie and make panic!
I just log-on into my Bitstamp account and Bitcoin withdrawals are open.
I think you posted this print-screen about week or two old.


Title: Re: Official End of Mt Gox thread
Post by: igorr on February 20, 2014, 04:34:44 PM
Don't lie and make panic!
I just log-on into my Bitstamp account and Bitcoin withdrawals are open.
I think you posted this print-screen about week or two old.

It is today screenshot !

https://bitcointalk.org/index.php?topic=476614.0


Title: Re: Official End of Mt Gox thread
Post by: Tzupy on February 20, 2014, 04:38:24 PM
If you don't have 2FA enabled, that's what happens.


Title: Re: Official End of Mt Gox thread
Post by: ledmaniak on February 20, 2014, 04:39:50 PM
So, when is the next announcement?!  ???


Title: Re: Official End of Mt Gox thread
Post by: igorr on February 20, 2014, 04:40:37 PM
So, when is the next announcement?!  ???

The same as MtGox !


Title: Re: Official End of Mt Gox thread
Post by: kkaspar on February 20, 2014, 04:45:02 PM
I'm surprised to see the lack of discussion on the subject, on how the entire bitcoin market system will get a big hit in confidence, when MtGox turns out insolvent.
The bitcoin market system always had this halo of an open source community around it. That the community consists of idealistic and therefor trustworthy people. Those who have dealt with bitcoin in depth, know better, but to the outsiders, the market system has looked relatively honest. When MtGox turns out to be insolvent, and news will show things like how bitcoin.org linked MtGox as the main recommended exchange, then this halo will disappear. Bitcoin will be linked more as an tool of those "exchange" operators to scam people out of their money. It's funny to see how most seem to miss that threat.


Title: Re: Official End of Mt Gox thread
Post by: Johnshpon3 on February 20, 2014, 04:45:38 PM
I have Bitstamp open at this very moment (16:46 UTC). Bitcoin withdrawals are open.


Title: Re: Official End of Mt Gox thread
Post by: chesthing on February 20, 2014, 04:55:09 PM
So, when is the next announcement?!  ???
Maybe we'll get a postcard from Tahiti?


Title: Re: Official End of Mt Gox thread
Post by: jaybny on February 20, 2014, 05:00:21 PM
Sorry if this is a dumb question, but if people buy bitcoins on Gox now at $100, they are actually buying bitcoins aren't they?
It is off blockchain so there is no way of knowing if Gox are naked shorting...


no they are buying goxBTC which may or may not be thin air.


Title: Re: Official End of Mt Gox thread
Post by: sgbett on February 20, 2014, 05:04:05 PM
has anyone successfully got any funds onto gox in the past few days?

yes. sepa took about 48 hours excluding weekends (and I think monday was a holiday in US? maybe elsewhere).

just wondering... you wired money to gox to pick up coins cheap, which makes sense maybe economically, if the chance of total failure is outweighed by the chance of getting the coins out of gox and the possible profit you could make on that.

But you don't see any  problem at all that, by doing so, you're lending gox legitimacy that they very much don't deserve anymore? I mean, I know, it's a market, morality has no place in here but... really?

I'm not a moral arbiter. Especially not given that I don't actually *know* what is going on at gox.

I'm amazed how many people claim that they do.

Here's just one scenario out of a hat.

Gox knows that by allowing BTC withdrawals, they could potentially double pay (yes due to their own flawed algorithm - but still a risk all the same), and this would threaten solvency/customer deposits.

What needs to happen is that the free market will decide. If people are happy to tolerate gox's way of doing things they will carry on, if they don't gox will die.

If people want to make it a moral crusade that's their call. To me its just business.


I could say something about the paradox of the self-interested actor, something along the lines of the dominant strategy not necessarily leading to the optimal result for the individual that chose that strategy, but I would sound like a self-righteous, hypocritical dick. Carry on then.


Tragedy of the commons? true enough.

Sorry if i sound callous I'm just taking the 4-1 odds against mtgox crashing. I don't really share the seemingly common belief that what gox are doing/not doing is inherently good or bad for bitcoin. I think its just all 'stuff' like pirate wasn't good or bad for bitcoin, he was just bad for the people that fell for it. Like Madoff wasn't 'bad' for the dollar etc i dunno what i really think, just kind of riding the waves.


Title: Re: Official End of Mt Gox thread
Post by: proudhon on February 20, 2014, 05:06:16 PM
So, I do feel bad for everyone with any asset on MtGox right now.  Nevertheless, after so many goxxings and on the whole bitcoin community, plus the fact that Gox has held over 150 of my bitcoins (and tens of thousands of others') hostage since early 2012 related to the bitcoinica debacle, this is how I feel about the potential of the current situation...

https://i.imgur.com/VcxjU2M.gif


Title: Re: Official End of Mt Gox thread
Post by: chesthing on February 20, 2014, 05:06:35 PM
sgbett, how much did you just send to Gox?


Title: Re: Official End of Mt Gox thread
Post by: DeathAndTaxes on February 20, 2014, 05:08:50 PM
this time again its a real joke: letting no money out, not freezing trading...

They make money off of trades.  They don't make money off of fixing their withdraws. 

Perfect system for MtGox is that they never open withdraws and traders convert all their balances to trading fees and MtGox.

If the value of depositor funds is x and MtGox collects 0.5% (both sides) on each trade then after trades equal to 1000x ( 0.995^1000), 99% of depositor funds will have been converted into fees.  MtGox does a single one time withdraw for the remaining 1% and clears the books quasi legally.

Pretty much the same concept that results in poker sites ending up with 70% to 90% of the funds deposited.


Title: Re: Official End of Mt Gox thread
Post by: zeroday on February 20, 2014, 05:12:30 PM
From Gox announcement (https://www.mtgox.com/img/pdf/20140220-Announcement.pdf):
Quote
we had to relocate MtGox to our previous office building in Shibuya

Confirmed bad news. Gox is moving towards DOGE at Shiba headquarters.


Title: Re: Official End of Mt Gox thread
Post by: oda.krell on February 20, 2014, 05:14:21 PM
has anyone successfully got any funds onto gox in the past few days?

yes. sepa took about 48 hours excluding weekends (and I think monday was a holiday in US? maybe elsewhere).

just wondering... you wired money to gox to pick up coins cheap, which makes sense maybe economically, if the chance of total failure is outweighed by the chance of getting the coins out of gox and the possible profit you could make on that.

But you don't see any  problem at all that, by doing so, you're lending gox legitimacy that they very much don't deserve anymore? I mean, I know, it's a market, morality has no place in here but... really?

I'm not a moral arbiter. Especially not given that I don't actually *know* what is going on at gox.

I'm amazed how many people claim that they do.

Here's just one scenario out of a hat.

Gox knows that by allowing BTC withdrawals, they could potentially double pay (yes due to their own flawed algorithm - but still a risk all the same), and this would threaten solvency/customer deposits.

What needs to happen is that the free market will decide. If people are happy to tolerate gox's way of doing things they will carry on, if they don't gox will die.

If people want to make it a moral crusade that's their call. To me its just business.


I could say something about the paradox of the self-interested actor, something along the lines of the dominant strategy not necessarily leading to the optimal result for the individual that chose that strategy, but I would sound like a self-righteous, hypocritical dick. Carry on then.


Tragedy of the commons? true enough.

Sorry if i sound callous I'm just taking the 4-1 odds against mtgox crashing. I don't really share the seemingly common belief that what gox are doing/not doing is inherently good or bad for bitcoin. I think its just all 'stuff' like pirate wasn't good or bad for bitcoin, he was just bad for the people that fell for it. Like Madoff wasn't 'bad' for the dollar etc i dunno what i really think, just kind of riding the waves.


A small part of me wonders if, not just in Bitcoin valuation, but other ventures as well, we hit a local maximum because of our choices without ever being aware of the possibility that, had we acted different, we would have reached a higher point... but that's idle speculation.

Hence: I have no good reason to complain from a moral point of view. Objection withdrawn.

But I don't need to tell you that you'll get zero sympathy if you get burned on there. I've read enough of your posts to know that you're well aware of the risks and such. Good luck though :)


Title: Re: Official End of Mt Gox thread
Post by: BTC4Victory on February 20, 2014, 05:16:55 PM
Quoting this article solely because the bolded & italicized sentence was inadvertently awesome.  When all the dust has settled, I think "to Touch the Pink Cow" needs to become a euphemism for having a massively successful business -- with almost literally a license to print money -- that you somehow manage to completely f*ck up and drive into the ground merely because you're a staggeringly incompetent douchebag with your head stuck up your a$$.


Quote
By Takashi Mochizuki and Eleanor Warnock

TOKYO--Just six months ago, Mark Karpelès was sitting on top of the world. Mt. Gox, his Tokyo-based platform that had started as an exchange for Magic trading cards, had in a short time become the world's dominant platform for exchanging the new big thing--bitcoins.

Cut to a snowy February morning in Tokyo, and you find Mr. Karpelès trying to walk past a bitcoin trader holding a sign outside Mt. Gox's offices in the hip Shibuya neighborhood, asking: "MT. GOX--WHERE IS OUR MONEY?"

The trader, Kolin Burges, who had flown in from London, was only one of many customers of the company who have been pressing the trading platform to disclose more about its financial health after it froze customer withdrawals on Feb. 7.

The travails of Mt. Gox illustrate the convulsions of the bitcoin market as the first generation of companies trading the virtual currency face growing technical and security challenges.

Chris Larsen, chief executive of San Francisco-based Ripple Labs Inc., a startup associated with another virtual currency, ripples, likened the convulsions as the bitcoin market expands to the early days of the Internet, when it wasn't clear that the World Wide Web would really catch on.

Then, "it all just seemed like the craziest stuff--who would ever use this?--and now it's absolutely in the fabric of every enterprise on earth," he said.

Mr. Larsen developed Ripple with another bitcoin entrepreneur, Jed McCaleb, the founder of Mt. Gox, who sold it to Mr. Karpelès in 2011. The name Mt. Gox, which came from the Magic card game the company originally dealt in before Mr. McCaleb turned it onto bitcoins, is short for Magic: The Gathering Online Exchange.

Mt. Gox has been wrestling with problems since earlier this year, when it halted withdrawals in dollars.

Also in May, some of Mt. Gox's funds were seized by U.S. regulators, who said the exchange wasn't properly registered in the U.S. Mt. Gox said in a statement last month that it is has been properly registered as a money-services business in the U.S. since the end of June.

After Mt. Gox again abruptly halted customer withdrawals on Feb. 7, it blamed its issues on a glitch in the bitcoin software.

On Feb. 10, Mt. Gox said it had been hit by fraudulent requests for payment by users exploiting a feature in the core protocol known as "transaction malleability."

Initially, many in the bitcoin community argued that Mt. Gox had simply failed to use the correct internal procedures to protect its accounts. The next day, however, a hacking attack crippled other bitcoin-exchange platforms and raised questions about the security of the global network for trading the virtual currency.

Asked why the company hadn't addressed customers' concern sooner, Mr. Karpelès responded in an email interview with The Wall Street Journal on Monday: "I assume you refer to the malleability issue. We sincerely apologize for this incident; however, please understand that we are NOT the developers of Bitcoin." He added, "We are very surprised that anyone could fault MtGox instead of the bitcoin software."

However, he said, "We deeply apologize for any delays in our responses."

After Mr. Karpelès, who was running an IT company in Tokyo, bought Mt. Gox from Mr. McCaleb in 2011, Mt. Gox became the world's biggest bitcoin exchange by volume, with more than 80% of bitcoin trades, according to Bitcoinity.org, a service that tracks rates on various exchanges. During that time, the price of a single bitcoin rose from 92 cents to a peak of more than $1,147 last December, based on figures from CoinDesk, a bitcoin-data provider based in London.

Amid the turmoil surrounding Mt. Gox, CoinDesk removed Mt. Gox from its benchmark bitcoin index early last week. The index, which now includes just Slovenia-based Bitstamp and BTC-e of Bulgaria, stood at $624.63 in New York afternoon trading Monday, while Mt. Gox-traded bitcoin was valued at just $294.20. Its share of bitcoin trades had dropped to 25% on Monday, according to Bitcoinity.org.

But aside from the lower value of its bitcoins, investors are increasingly concerned about the status of their Mt. Gox accounts. The company's halt of bitcoin transfers to outside accounts led investors to speculate on online forums that the company had its bitcoins stolen by hackers or that it was out of cash and would default.

Tomoaki Ushida, who runs an IT consulting firm in Tokyo, has given up hope of recovering the two bitcoins he had in his Mt. Gox account. "I try to convince myself that I paid for a good lesson," he said. "If I ever get them returned, I'm lucky."

In the email interview, Mr. Karpelès responded to questions about the company's solvency or protection for customers' funds by saying that the matter is confidential. However, he said the company had discussed its business model with Japanese authorities "to ensure that we are operating within the law here."

At a weekly meeting Thursday of Mt. Gox investors and other members of Tokyo's small, tightknit bitcoin community at a bar about a 10-minute walk from Mt. Gox's headquarters, some 30 bitcoiners talked about bitcoins and exchanged the currency using cellphone-readable bar codes. Some members reminisced about tipping burlesque dancers in bitcoins at a bar called the Pink Cow in Tokyo's foreigner-rich Roppongi neighborhood that accepts bitcoins for payment.

But the conversation revolved mostly around Mt. Gox and whether the exchange would be able to honor deposits. Organizers had extended an invitation to Mr. Karpelès but said they didn't receive a response.

Ken Shishido, one of the group's organizers who works in the telecom industry, said, "Everyone's question is whether the company still has everyone's bitcoin and cash. That's a very critical thing we need to know."

Mr. Burges, the London investor, was among the bitcoiners Thursday night. The next morning, outside Mt. Gox's offices, he managed to get in a brief confrontation with Mr. Karpelès. "You still have everyone's bitcoin?" Mr. Burges asked while Mr. Karpelès tried to navigate around him holding a Starbucks cup and an umbrella.

In the wider Japanese business community, bitcoins aren't widely used or even well-known. Japanese officials are cautious about making any comments about bitcoins as they wait for the Bank of Japan to finish a study about the virtual currency. Still, some Japan-based lawyers say certain restrictions, especially on exchange platforms, should be considered in order to prevent criminal use of the currency, such as for money-laundering.

"I believe that regulating exchanges would be the best way to address these problems," said So Saito, a lawyer at the Tokyo law firm of Nishimura & Asahi.

Meanwhile, the turmoil at Mt. Gox has even touched the Pink Cow, home to the burlesque dancers, which has switched to another bitcoin payment process called BitPay.

Mt. Gox transactions are "taking an unacceptable length of time right now, so we are taking another route," said owner Traci Consoli. "Hopefully, a more stable system will evolve as it grows." [Suspicious link removed]j.com/article/BT-CO-20140217-704805.html


Title: Re: Official End of Mt Gox thread
Post by: DeathAndTaxes on February 20, 2014, 05:20:11 PM
"at last"

If there ever was an entity that met the definition of a "zombie exchange" it would MtGox.  They have done so many things which would have annihilated other companies a long time ago.  The only thing which historically would have been a worse bet than a multi-year short on Bitcoin would be betting on the demise of MtGox.

I am not sure where MtGox finds the neverending stream of new marks willing to relentlessly pour cash and coin into their coffers but no matter what happens they always seem to do. They are the only exchange to have a song written about them ( http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=K2ku1A5Ox8U ) and getting "goxxed" has been a community term which has been generalized to events beyond the exchange. 

I mean maybe that blue ball has magical powers?


Title: Re: Official End of Mt Gox thread
Post by: MatTheCat on February 20, 2014, 05:23:40 PM
GOX is a total and utter disaster.

There is no good part of it. The list of failures, scams, and setbacks continues.

Everything bitcoin ends up being a scam or con in some way or other. Instead of being a decentralized currency, bitcoin has turned into a shyster magnet.

Which is why governments had to move to clamp down on the wildcat currencies that sprung up across Great Britain in the 1800's. Hence the rule I think instated by Robert Peel that allowed only the Bank of England to print bank notes and only the Royal Mint to produce coinage.


Title: Re: Official End of Mt Gox thread
Post by: Bobsurplus on February 20, 2014, 05:27:13 PM
I death blow is right around the corner for gox, they will slip under 130 in the next few minutes and after that its a quick slide to zero zero land.


Title: Re: Official End of Mt Gox thread
Post by: wobber on February 20, 2014, 05:36:57 PM
It's so exciting watching gox now. I wonder if it will go under 100...


Title: Re: Official End of Mt Gox thread
Post by: krtek.net on February 20, 2014, 05:41:54 PM
I caught mtgox doing bad thing and published it couple of minutes before the big fall: https://twitter.com/krtek_net/status/436386804372344832 (https://twitter.com/krtek_net/status/436386804372344832) and https://twitter.com/krtek_net/status/436492419811405824 (https://twitter.com/krtek_net/status/436492419811405824). These 4 trades were made by single SELL LIMIT 1 order which was suppose to create a new low. The order processing went up to bids over or equaling the low, paused and waited for another bid to be placed from another trader and finished with last trade higher then the low. I call it order sorting, I'm aware that this has happened before but it happend to me today for the first time. I've lost goxtools logs of that one, but managed to replicate the same behavior after couple of tries. Trading terminal is connected on Tier 1 network, dedicated hw, no other apps running, 100mbit unmetered. I've checked that my order book is up to date using all available channels and there was no engine lag before and/or during the execution.

EDIT: See https://twitter.com/krtek_net/status/436730953005006848 and https://twitter.com/krtek_net/status/436731507743657984


Title: Re: Official End of Mt Gox thread
Post by: Bitcoin_is_here_to_stay on February 20, 2014, 06:19:07 PM
Whatever site you are using is crap

It's still 42k

Bitcoinwisdom and its the best site out there!

Obviously not, considering its depth is terribly off.
MTgox is currently under 100$

Also a lie.

OP likely meant euros, but we may soon be below $100 :(


Title: Re: Official End of Mt Gox thread
Post by: bitcon on February 20, 2014, 06:24:45 PM
i think one of the mods from BTC trollbox has 1.2 million on gox


Title: Re: Official End of Mt Gox thread
Post by: igorr on February 20, 2014, 06:25:11 PM
gox 111 usd !!!


Title: Re: Official End of Mt Gox thread
Post by: jasonjm on February 20, 2014, 06:36:45 PM
I'm surprised to see the lack of discussion on the subject, on how the entire bitcoin market system will get a big hit in confidence, when MtGox turns out insolvent.
The bitcoin market system always had this halo of an open source community around it. That the community consists of idealistic and therefor trustworthy people. Those who have dealt with bitcoin in depth, know better, but to the outsiders, the market system has looked relatively honest. When MtGox turns out to be insolvent, and news will show things like how bitcoin.org linked MtGox as the main recommended exchange, then this halo will disappear. Bitcoin will be linked more as an tool of those "exchange" operators to scam people out of their money. It's funny to see how most seem to miss that threat.

because everyone on this forum is a wannabe bitcoin millionaire.
its like going into church and pissing on Jesus, and then saying "Jesus sucks, lets talk about it"......
you get? attacked!

bitcoin community as a whole is ridiculously dishonest, turned out to be very disappointing imo. As a currency its no better than "insert douchbag government currency here".



Title: Re: Official End of Mt Gox thread
Post by: igorr on February 20, 2014, 06:39:39 PM
MtGox 111 usd, and what will happen when of these 500,000 Bitcoin comes to Bitstamp I can only imagine.


http://img607.imageshack.us/img607/627/8kda.jpg (http://img607.imageshack.us/i/8kda.jpg/)View Screen Capture (http://img607.imageshack.us/i/8kda.jpg/)


Title: Re: Official End of Mt Gox thread
Post by: wobber on February 20, 2014, 06:40:43 PM
fuck gox, lets watch it die!@

Bought you a beer bro.


Title: Re: Official End of Mt Gox thread
Post by: igorr on February 20, 2014, 06:41:07 PM
fuck gox, lets watch it die!@


500 000 bitcoin from MtGox willkill Bitstamp    !!!


Title: Re: Official End of Mt Gox thread
Post by: gentlemand on February 20, 2014, 06:43:06 PM
I'm surprised to see the lack of discussion on the subject, on how the entire bitcoin market system will get a big hit in confidence, when MtGox turns out insolvent.
The bitcoin market system always had this halo of an open source community around it. That the community consists of idealistic and therefor trustworthy people. Those who have dealt with bitcoin in depth, know better, but to the outsiders, the market system has looked relatively honest. When MtGox turns out to be insolvent, and news will show things like how bitcoin.org linked MtGox as the main recommended exchange, then this halo will disappear. Bitcoin will be linked more as an tool of those "exchange" operators to scam people out of their money. It's funny to see how most seem to miss that threat.

because everyone on this forum is a wannabe bitcoin millionaire.
its like going into church and pissing on Jesus, and then saying "Jesus sucks, lets talk about it"......
you get? attacked!

bitcoin community as a whole is ridiculously dishonest, turned out to be very disappointing imo. As a currency its no better than "insert douchbag government currency here".



Internet, drugs, relative anonymity, non reversible transactions, shit tons of money much of which is held by mean spirited libertarian types who lucked out. And you were expecting a utopian paradise?


Title: Re: Official End of Mt Gox thread
Post by: derpinheimer on February 20, 2014, 06:44:40 PM
MtGox 111 usd, and what will happen when of these 500,000 Bitcoin comes to Bitstamp I can only imagine.


http://img607.imageshack.us/img607/627/8kda.jpg (http://img607.imageshack.us/i/8kda.jpg/)View Screen Capture (http://img607.imageshack.us/i/8kda.jpg/)

You realize most of these are probably people who had bids at say, $700 when the price was $900.

Then it went to $600 and they sold at a loss, bought back at $500, sold at $400, bought at $300, etc...

There arent 500k coins on Gox.


Title: Re: Official End of Mt Gox thread
Post by: bitcon on February 20, 2014, 06:45:23 PM
Gox Statement Translation - "Please be patient a few more days while we milk this arbitrage opportunity"  we'll give you access to your coins after we're done goxxing.


Title: Re: Official End of Mt Gox thread
Post by: krtek.net on February 20, 2014, 06:47:57 PM
Gox Statement Translation - "Please be patient a few more days while we milk this arbitrage opportunity"  we'll give you access to your coins after we're done goxxing.
My take: http://issuu.com/krteknet/docs/20140220-mtgox-exchange (http://issuu.com/krteknet/docs/20140220-mtgox-exchange)


Title: Re: Official End of Mt Gox thread
Post by: Wardan_reloadeD on February 20, 2014, 06:48:18 PM
fuck gox, lets watch it die!@

http://www.reactiongifs.com/wp-content/uploads/2013/01/popcorn-yes.gif


Title: Re: Official End of Mt Gox thread
Post by: Elwar on February 20, 2014, 07:17:57 PM
This may have a bigger affect. Didn't MtGox buy the rights to the Bitcoin trademark or something?

The community seemed ok with it because they were safekeeping it from abuse by a few other people trying to get it.

But with MtGox dead, they could start executing their rights to the Bitcoin name to get back money to pay for things or it could be sold in a bankruptcy court to someone who could use it to stop people from using the Bitcoin name.

As much as I want MtGox to go away as a source of constant problems, it may not be the best result.

Best thing would be for a competent business organization to buy them out and run things professionally.


Title: Re: Official End of Mt Gox thread
Post by: Cassius on February 20, 2014, 07:38:42 PM
Quoting this article solely because the bolded & italicized sentence was inadvertently awesome.  When all the dust has settled, I think "to Touch the Pink Cow" needs to become a euphemism for having a massively successful business -- with almost literally a license to print money -- that you somehow manage to completely f*ck up and drive into the ground merely because you're a staggeringly incompetent douchebag with your head stuck up your a$$.


+10,000


Title: Re: Official End of Mt Gox thread
Post by: jasonjm on February 20, 2014, 07:46:27 PM
I'm surprised to see the lack of discussion on the subject, on how the entire bitcoin market system will get a big hit in confidence, when MtGox turns out insolvent.
The bitcoin market system always had this halo of an open source community around it. That the community consists of idealistic and therefor trustworthy people. Those who have dealt with bitcoin in depth, know better, but to the outsiders, the market system has looked relatively honest. When MtGox turns out to be insolvent, and news will show things like how bitcoin.org linked MtGox as the main recommended exchange, then this halo will disappear. Bitcoin will be linked more as an tool of those "exchange" operators to scam people out of their money. It's funny to see how most seem to miss that threat.

because everyone on this forum is a wannabe bitcoin millionaire.
its like going into church and pissing on Jesus, and then saying "Jesus sucks, lets talk about it"......
you get? attacked!

bitcoin community as a whole is ridiculously dishonest, turned out to be very disappointing imo. As a currency its no better than "insert douchbag government currency here".



Internet, drugs, relative anonymity, non reversible transactions, shit tons of money much of which is held by mean spirited libertarian types who lucked out. And you were expecting a utopian paradise?

yeah, actually was. Now that I look back it was probably stupid and naive. But at the time I initially got in I really thought it could be something.


Title: Re: Official End of Mt Gox thread
Post by: BitcoinTate on February 20, 2014, 07:48:20 PM
So more people flew to Japan and someone threatened to kick Kraples ass? Am I reading that correctly?
Quote
this week we have experienced some
security problems, and as a result we had to relocate MtGox to our previous office building
in Shibuya
https://www.mtgox.com/img/pdf/20140220-Announcement.pdf


Can anyone verify this address is real or they are actually there now?

Quote
MtGox Co.,Ltd. (Japan) has moved to the address below:

MtGox Co.,Ltd.
Cerulean Tower 15F
26­1 Sakuragaoka­cho
150­8512 Shibuya Tokyo
Japan
https://support.mtgox.com/home[/quote]


Title: Re: Official End of Mt Gox thread
Post by: gentlemand on February 20, 2014, 07:53:05 PM
I'm surprised to see the lack of discussion on the subject, on how the entire bitcoin market system will get a big hit in confidence, when MtGox turns out insolvent.
The bitcoin market system always had this halo of an open source community around it. That the community consists of idealistic and therefor trustworthy people. Those who have dealt with bitcoin in depth, know better, but to the outsiders, the market system has looked relatively honest. When MtGox turns out to be insolvent, and news will show things like how bitcoin.org linked MtGox as the main recommended exchange, then this halo will disappear. Bitcoin will be linked more as an tool of those "exchange" operators to scam people out of their money. It's funny to see how most seem to miss that threat.

because everyone on this forum is a wannabe bitcoin millionaire.
its like going into church and pissing on Jesus, and then saying "Jesus sucks, lets talk about it"......
you get? attacked!

bitcoin community as a whole is ridiculously dishonest, turned out to be very disappointing imo. As a currency its no better than "insert douchbag government currency here".



Internet, drugs, relative anonymity, non reversible transactions, shit tons of money much of which is held by mean spirited libertarian types who lucked out. And you were expecting a utopian paradise?

yeah, actually was. Now that I look back it was probably stupid and naive. But at the time I initially got in I really thought it could be something.

The future is unwritten. There's a class of operators on the way to beef up the infrastructure who realise the way to make real money is provide trustworthy services rather than rip folks off.

As long as you control your coins and hang in there I think the overwhelmingly bad smell that lingers over Bitcoin will rapidly fade.


Title: Re: Official End of Mt Gox thread
Post by: ledmaniak on February 20, 2014, 07:55:17 PM
So more people flew to Japan and someone threatened to kick Kraples ass? Am I reading that correctly?
Quote
this week we have experienced some
security problems, and as a result we had to relocate MtGox to our previous office building
in Shibuya
https://www.mtgox.com/img/pdf/20140220-Announcement.pdf

Maybe they were asked by the owner of the building to leave. Having protestors at the front of your door isn't good advertisement.


Title: Re: Official End of Mt Gox thread
Post by: Cassius on February 20, 2014, 07:59:23 PM
So more people flew to Japan and someone threatened to kick Kraples ass? Am I reading that correctly?
Quote
this week we have experienced some
security problems, and as a result we had to relocate MtGox to our previous office building
in Shibuya
https://www.mtgox.com/img/pdf/20140220-Announcement.pdf

Maybe they were asked by the owner of the building to leave. Having protestors at the front of your door isn't good advertisement.

That's what I understood - not sure where I read that though.
On the other hand, would you hang around with 500,000 of other people's bitcoins stuffing your trousers? Good reason to be anywhere but at the office right now.


Title: Re: Official End of Mt Gox thread
Post by: BitcoinTate on February 20, 2014, 08:01:05 PM
So more people flew to Japan and someone threatened to kick Kraples ass? Am I reading that correctly?
Quote
this week we have experienced some
security problems, and as a result we had to relocate MtGox to our previous office building
in Shibuya
https://www.mtgox.com/img/pdf/20140220-Announcement.pdf

Maybe they were asked by the owner of the building to leave. Having protestors at the front of your door isn't good advertisement.
That would make sense: http://www.pcworld.com/article/2099620/mt-gox-protesters-still-without-bitcoin-answers.html


Title: Re: Official End of Mt Gox thread
Post by: sgbett on February 20, 2014, 08:03:01 PM
has anyone successfully got any funds onto gox in the past few days?

yes. sepa took about 48 hours excluding weekends (and I think monday was a holiday in US? maybe elsewhere).

just wondering... you wired money to gox to pick up coins cheap, which makes sense maybe economically, if the chance of total failure is outweighed by the chance of getting the coins out of gox and the possible profit you could make on that.

But you don't see any  problem at all that, by doing so, you're lending gox legitimacy that they very much don't deserve anymore? I mean, I know, it's a market, morality has no place in here but... really?

I'm not a moral arbiter. Especially not given that I don't actually *know* what is going on at gox.

I'm amazed how many people claim that they do.

Here's just one scenario out of a hat.

Gox knows that by allowing BTC withdrawals, they could potentially double pay (yes due to their own flawed algorithm - but still a risk all the same), and this would threaten solvency/customer deposits.

What needs to happen is that the free market will decide. If people are happy to tolerate gox's way of doing things they will carry on, if they don't gox will die.

If people want to make it a moral crusade that's their call. To me its just business.


I could say something about the paradox of the self-interested actor, something along the lines of the dominant strategy not necessarily leading to the optimal result for the individual that chose that strategy, but I would sound like a self-righteous, hypocritical dick. Carry on then.


Tragedy of the commons? true enough.

Sorry if i sound callous I'm just taking the 4-1 odds against mtgox crashing. I don't really share the seemingly common belief that what gox are doing/not doing is inherently good or bad for bitcoin. I think its just all 'stuff' like pirate wasn't good or bad for bitcoin, he was just bad for the people that fell for it. Like Madoff wasn't 'bad' for the dollar etc i dunno what i really think, just kind of riding the waves.


A small part of me wonders if, not just in Bitcoin valuation, but other ventures as well, we hit a local maximum because of our choices without ever being aware of the possibility that, had we acted different, we would have reached a higher point... but that's idle speculation.

Hence: I have no good reason to complain from a moral point of view. Objection withdrawn.

But I don't need to tell you that you'll get zero sympathy if you get burned on there. I've read enough of your posts to know that you're well aware of the risks and such. Good luck though :)

Sounds a bit like game theory, which I'll admit to not really knowing anything about, other than it's a thing! You are probably right indeed. I think there is the eternal struggle between opposing forces in everything, the light and dark, yin and yang whatever. The emergent behaviour being the richness and complexity if everything around us. With $goxusdrate being just one tiny facet of an enormous symphony of variables.

Thanks for the good wishes, don't worry I'll be the first to poke my head up over the parapet for people to take potshots at should it all go pear shaped! It's all in the spirit of the game eh



Title: Re: Official End of Mt Gox thread
Post by: BitcoinTate on February 20, 2014, 08:14:30 PM
Would hate to be the secretary answering calls on this one. Anyone tried calling them yet? lol

Quote
A virtual office provides your business with the corporate image and business infrastructure of a multinational company without the cost. Your business will get a prestigious business address and a designated local phone number with a receptionist answering your calls in your company name. Professionally trained secretarial staff will manage your correspondence, and can provide additional administrative and support services as you need them.
http://www.executivecentre.com/virtual_offices/faq


Title: Re: Official End of Mt Gox thread
Post by: Wardan_reloadeD on February 20, 2014, 08:42:59 PM

 :D The Prety Most Biggest Eminent Highness Grand Caesar OYNLBWB* Imperator,  Goat quotes my gif... im geting excited



*Owner of a yellow nice lambo bougth with bitcoin




Title: Re: Official End of Mt Gox thread
Post by: Bobsurplus on February 20, 2014, 08:55:50 PM
This may have a bigger affect. Didn't MtGox buy the rights to the Bitcoin trademark or something?




If this is true, it could wreak havoc on the symbol BTC

Do you have any more info on this?


Title: Re: Official End of Mt Gox thread
Post by: Teppino on February 20, 2014, 09:17:12 PM
Being that in Japan only fiat is regulated should they decide to forcefully liquidate all their customers into fiat (at their current ridicoulos exchange rate)  there will be also no room for lawsuits against them.


Title: Re: Official End of Mt Gox thread
Post by: jasonjm on February 20, 2014, 09:38:44 PM
Being that in Japan only fiat is regulated should they decide to forcefully liquidate all their customers into fiat (at their current ridicoulos exchange rate)  there will be also no room for lawsuits against them.

well, if this is true, they can EASILY just build a fake sell storm on their platform, as they dont even need to have the BTC to sell, just sell millions of non existent BTC, drive the price down to $1, pay everyone back at $1 = 1 BTC rate, and get away no issues from the law at all


typical bitcoin scam as always.



Title: Re: Official End of Mt Gox thread
Post by: ArticMine on February 20, 2014, 09:44:26 PM
Being that in Japan only fiat is regulated should they decide to forcefully liquidate all their customers into fiat (at their current ridicoulos exchange rate)  there will be also no room for lawsuits against them.

This has been tried before by a certain pirateat40 in the US. It did not work when the US government went to court and made the case that to all effective purposes Bitcoin is money.


Title: Re: Official End of Mt Gox thread
Post by: Teppino on February 20, 2014, 09:45:11 PM
Being that in Japan only fiat is regulated should they decide to forcefully liquidate all their customers into fiat (at their current ridicoulos exchange rate)  there will be also no room for lawsuits against them.

well, if this is true, they can EASILY just build a fake sell storm on their platform, as they dont even need to have the BTC to sell, just sell millions of non existent BTC, drive the price down to $1, pay everyone back at $1 = 1 BTC rate, and get away no issues from the law at all


typical bitcoin scam as always.



Yes, but they probably have a lot of big fiat holders, a progressive crash would be more effective luring them into buying cheap coins whereas an instant crash to 1$ would be ineffective and also easily spotted leaving gox with much more fiat to give back.
Also note i'm pretty new and probably wrong.


Title: Re: Official End of Mt Gox thread
Post by: jasonjm on February 20, 2014, 09:48:48 PM
well mtgox is at 111

if any of you watch cricket, 111 is bad :)


Title: Re: Official End of Mt Gox thread
Post by: Bobsurplus on February 20, 2014, 09:48:54 PM
don't forget to post your funny memes and pictures here guys.

https://bitcointalk.org/index.php?topic=477704.new#new


Title: Re: Official End of Mt Gox thread
Post by: subSTRATA on February 20, 2014, 10:06:31 PM
In my eyes it's completely insane, that trading hasn't been halted -- it should have been a few minutes prior to the first announcement, that bitcoin withdrawals are suspended!

A honest business would have done that (suspend trading), but MTGox chose to defraud its customers.
When the MtGox price is 75% lower than Bitstamp, I think defraud is the right verb describing the situation.

+1


Title: Re: Official End of Mt Gox thread
Post by: barbs on February 20, 2014, 10:15:47 PM
In my eyes it's completely insane, that trading hasn't been halted -- it should have been a few minutes prior to the first announcement, that bitcoin withdrawals are suspended!

A honest business would have done that (suspend trading), but MTGox chose to defraud its customers.
When the MtGox price is 75% lower than Bitstamp, I think defraud is the right verb describing the situation.

+1

+1

They are blaming a technical issue but continuing trading ? Staying online / live w a technical fault ?

Absolute fraud


Title: Re: Official End of Mt Gox thread
Post by: jasonjm on February 20, 2014, 10:23:29 PM
and the surprise is?

to my knowledge there has yet to be a single long term business (years) whose main focus has been bitcoin that hasn't either

1) been hacked and lost a whole lotta stuff
2) pulled a runner
3) scammed everyone in some way
4) been shut down and lost peoples stuff


Title: Re: Official End of Mt Gox thread
Post by: epetroel on February 20, 2014, 10:43:24 PM
and the surprise is?

to my knowledge there has yet to be a single long term business (years) whose main focus has been bitcoin that hasn't either

1) been hacked and lost a whole lotta stuff
2) pulled a runner
3) scammed everyone in some way
4) been shut down and lost peoples stuff


I think CampBX would qualify there.  Can't think of anybody else though.  Maybe Cassicus if you count that.


Title: Re: Official End of Mt Gox thread
Post by: trepper on February 20, 2014, 10:50:00 PM
and the surprise is?

to my knowledge there has yet to be a single long term business (years) whose main focus has been bitcoin that hasn't either

1) been hacked and lost a whole lotta stuff
2) pulled a runner
3) scammed everyone in some way
4) been shut down and lost peoples stuff


I think CampBX would qualify there.  Can't think of anybody else though.  Maybe Cassicus if you count that.

You can count BTC-24 too...


Title: Re: Official End of Mt Gox thread
Post by: jasonjm on February 20, 2014, 10:52:59 PM
those still trading on gox right now, summons this image

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=O5zGkqAWsWE (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=O5zGkqAWsWE)


Title: Re: Official End of Mt Gox thread
Post by: seleme on February 20, 2014, 10:58:28 PM
No end of Gox, they'll buy loads of cheap coins they are obviously missing and some more. Then reopen withdrawals, and make money on the price going up again.

That's the only way to get out of the mess they got in with missing coins and only way to gain them again. That's why they didn't close trading.


Title: Re: Official End of Mt Gox thread
Post by: markjamrobin on February 20, 2014, 10:58:35 PM
What is this security issue?  We used to have animal rights protestors outside our door every other week.  It never bothered me that much.  If it gets bad you call the police.  I have never heard of anyone running away because of a security issue.  Besides that an office move can be incredibly disruptive if it is not carefully planned. I am smelling that smell again...

And if you tell everyone where you are going, they will go there instead...


Title: Re: Official End of Mt Gox thread
Post by: subSTRATA on February 21, 2014, 12:30:40 AM
This may have a bigger affect. Didn't MtGox buy the rights to the Bitcoin trademark or something?

If this is true, it could wreak havoc on the symbol BTC

Not really. It and other widely used Bitcoin graphics were put in public domain by their creator few years ago, check for it on this forum.


Title: Re: Official End of Mt Gox thread
Post by: DeathAndTaxes on February 21, 2014, 12:43:46 AM
and the surprise is?

to my knowledge there has yet to be a single long term business (years) whose main focus has been bitcoin that hasn't either

1) been hacked and lost a whole lotta stuff
2) pulled a runner
3) scammed everyone in some way
4) been shut down and lost peoples stuff


Tangible Cryptography. :)

Is January 2012 old enough?
Never lost a single satoshi of company or customer funds.  
Never broke a trade ("high risk" abort).
Paid back every satoshi borrowed with interest.
Was shut down by the state of virginia, nobody but company lost a penny, relocated, restructured, and now operates as a direct broker of bitcoins then never holds customer coins.   Nothing to have frozen because users hold their own coins up to the point of sale.

Still pretty sure BitPay would meet your criteria as well and I am sure there has to be at least a couple more.




Title: Re: Official End of Mt Gox thread
Post by: jasonjm on February 21, 2014, 12:57:24 AM
here comes 99!!!!


Title: Re: Official End of Mt Gox thread
Post by: igorr on February 21, 2014, 01:00:10 AM
Bitstamp also collapse!


Title: Re: Official End of Mt Gox thread
Post by: wayneyoyo on February 21, 2014, 01:13:14 AM
I hopes MTGOX gone out quickly so it wont disturb the price


Title: Re: Official End of Mt Gox thread
Post by: gentlemand on February 21, 2014, 01:14:58 AM
I don't think reducing the suffering they inflict on people is in their remit.


Title: Re: Official End of Mt Gox thread
Post by: Bobsurplus on February 21, 2014, 01:27:35 AM
$95


Title: Re: Official End of Mt Gox thread
Post by: wayneyoyo on February 21, 2014, 01:28:35 AM
$95

Its not matter anymore


Title: Re: Official End of Mt Gox thread
Post by: Mk2vr6 on February 21, 2014, 01:37:10 AM
Had to quote this from the Wall observer thread - Sums this up perfectly.

Twas the night before Goxxing, when all through Mark's house
Not a feature was working, not even Mark's mouse
The bitcoin were slung through trades with despair,
In hopes that St. Solvency soon would be there

The miners were slowing and profits were dead,
While visions of sugar-drinks danced in his head.
The llama they call Proudhon, and I in my cap,
Had long since forgotten the exchange that was crap.

When out from Mt. Gox there arose such a smatter,
I clicked on the link to see what was the matter.
Away from that window I clicked in a flash,
More opened and cluttered the further it crashed.

The doom on the boards from the new-fallen low
Gave the FUDsters some ammo with which they could sow.
When, with much thundering pain should appear,
But a bouncing blue ball, and a chap in headgear.

With a riddled fat rider, so ugly and sick
I knew in two seconds this guy was a dick.
Less rapid than sloth his announcements they came,
And he whistled, and shouted, and then bitcoin he blamed!

"Now, asshole! now, cancer! now answer and quicken!
Go, stop it! You're putrid! go, go ponder and fix it!
To the site you must lurch! you should stop with the stall!
Now bounce away! Bounce away! Bounce away ball!"

As dry leaves that before the wild hurricane fly,
When they meet with an obstacle, mount to the sky.
So up to the exchange the ball he did move,
With a mind full of ploys, and some syphilis too.

And then, with no thinking, he said quite aloof
His address was changing to a virtual roof.
As I saw what he said, and was browsing around,
The price just kept moving faster and further down.

They weren't impressed that's for sure, with this end to their loot,
The masses pressed onward, the response was quite moot.
A wallet of coins he had flung out the back,
He was leaving forever, he had had already packed.

His drinks-they were sprinkled! his pimples how cherry!
His face in weird poses, his complexion quite scary!
His droll little mouth was drawn up like a bow,
And the fat of his belly hid his penis below.

The stump of a drive he held tight in his teeth,
And I heard all the bitcoins cry out for relief!
He had a broad face and a giant round belly,
That shook when he sneered, like a bowlful of jelly!

He was a chubby chump, with a magic card shelf,
And I laughed when I learned it, in spite of myself!
A wink of his eye and a twist of his head,
Soon had me wondering if bitcoin was dead.

He spoke of goxbux, PHP - that would work!
And filled all the accounts, then turned with a jerk.
And laying a cheek aside of his ball,
And giving a nod, out the exchange he hauled!

He bounced down the street, and his katana glistened,
I told you stupid fuckers, you all should have listened.
But I heard him exclaim, as he bounced out of site,
"Happy Goxxing to all", and "you've all been fucked right!"




Title: Re: Official End of Mt Gox thread
Post by: ledmaniak on February 21, 2014, 02:19:10 AM
Awesome!

They should make it their official MtGox song. Every new user has to sing it and accept it before they can start trading(so they are aware of the dangers). :D


Title: Re: Official End of Mt Gox thread
Post by: dnaleor on February 21, 2014, 02:35:36 AM
I think, this time, Mt.Gox will really die and never be revived again...
And I really hope so. This was a cancer for the Bitcoin ecosphere.

When all this is over, and Mt.Gox is burried, the media will finally check bitcoinaverage in stead of Mt.Gox ;)


Title: Re: Official End of Mt Gox thread
Post by: seleme on February 21, 2014, 02:37:10 AM
I think, this time, Mt.Gox will really die and never be revived again...
And I really hope so. This was a cencer for the Bitcoin ecosphere.

When all this is over, and Mt.Gox is burried, the media will finally check bitcoinaverage in stead of Mt.Gox ;)

Gox carried away Bitcoin ecosphere for some time. They're shit now but let's not forget to speak truth and give credits where it's due.


Title: Re: Official End of Mt Gox thread
Post by: Lloydie on February 21, 2014, 05:23:58 AM
When gox is dead, Btc prices will be able to rise again.


Title: Re: Official End of Mt Gox thread
Post by: donjoe on February 21, 2014, 07:23:09 AM
Hate all you want, but maybe Gox's screw-ups are what's been keeping this market volatile the way you like it.

All I can see is that they've been the biggest exchange for most of Bitcoin's history, naturally this lead to having the biggest problems to deal with, and they did deal with them and kept going every time. They're having a harder price crash than ever this time, but all eyes are on them and they're still making statements, so I can't say I'm expecting anything other than the usual: the problem getting solved in the end and overall public confidence in the Bitcoin ecosystem getting another boost from that.

Now you can carry on with your hate thread.


Title: Re: Official End of Mt Gox thread
Post by: Zangelbert Bingledack on February 21, 2014, 06:26:29 PM
Hate all you want, but maybe Gox's screw-ups are what's been keeping this market volatile the way you like it.

All I can see is that they've been the biggest exchange for most of Bitcoin's history, naturally this lead to having the biggest problems to deal with, and they did deal with them and kept going every time. They're having a harder price crash than ever this time, but all eyes are on them and they're still making statements, so I can't say I'm expecting anything other than the usual: the problem getting solved in the end and overall public confidence in the Bitcoin ecosystem getting another boost from that.

Now you can carry on with your hate thread.

Indeed. Besides the lawsuits I can't see any particular reason for Gox to die. Keep in mind Gox has been working great, with only a few minor hiccups (and of course slow tech support), for those of us in Japan. It takes literally 2 minutes to deposit yen from a Japanese bank, and withdrawals have been smooth, usually 2-3 days, at most 2-3 weeks (this January). I hear SEPA withdrawals are working as well, though a few weeks delayed, and deposits seem to take a few days.

So, besides those in the US (and where else?), it's only been this recent BTC malleability issue - which was legitimized by other exchanges having similar issues concurrently - that has changed anything. Granted we can expect the usual bumbling, non-communicative, heal-dragging approach as always, but if they solve the malleability problem in a few weeks I see no particular reason to expect any kind of insolvency or discontinuation of service. They will of course lose a lot of customers and probably remain a buggy experience overall, but other than potential lawsuits I don't see what is supposed to be actually killing them at this time. Eventually, sure, they will die or become a niche service, but insolvency just because they probably got scammed out of some number of coins? Seems like idle speculation.


Title: Re: Official End of Mt Gox thread
Post by: MAbtc on February 21, 2014, 06:45:07 PM
So, besides those in the US (and where else?), it's only been this recent BTC malleability issue - which was legitimized by other exchanges having similar issues concurrently - that has changed anything.

To be fair, Gox appears to have failed tx problems going back at least 4 months. It is possible, if reconciliation processes were handled incompetently, that they were being exploited long before the recent attack.

http://www.reddit.com/r/Bitcoin/comments/1pdkk8/mtgox_have_failed_to_process_my_btc_withdraw/
https://bitcointalk.org/index.php?topic=324918.0


Title: Re: Official End of Mt Gox thread
Post by: ArticMine on February 21, 2014, 07:01:18 PM
Hate all you want, but maybe Gox's screw-ups are what's been keeping this market volatile the way you like it.

All I can see is that they've been the biggest exchange for most of Bitcoin's history, naturally this lead to having the biggest problems to deal with, and they did deal with them and kept going every time. They're having a harder price crash than ever this time, but all eyes are on them and they're still making statements, so I can't say I'm expecting anything other than the usual: the problem getting solved in the end and overall public confidence in the Bitcoin ecosystem getting another boost from that.

Now you can carry on with your hate thread.

Indeed. Besides the lawsuits I can't see any particular reason for Gox to die. Keep in mind Gox has been working great, with only a few minor hiccups (and of course slow tech support), for those of us in Japan. It takes literally 2 minutes to deposit yen from a Japanese bank, and withdrawals have been smooth, usually 2-3 days, at most 2-3 weeks (this January). I hear SEPA withdrawals are working as well, though a few weeks delayed, and deposits seem to take a few days.

So, besides those in the US (and where else?), it's only been this recent BTC malleability issue - which was legitimized by other exchanges having similar issues concurrently - that has changed anything. Granted we can expect the usual bumbling, non-communicative, heal-dragging approach as always, but if they solve the malleability problem in a few weeks I see no particular reason to expect any kind of insolvency or discontinuation of service. They will of course lose a lot of customers and probably remain a buggy experience overall, but other than potential lawsuits I don't see what is supposed to be actually killing them at this time. Eventually, sure, they will die or become a niche service, but insolvency just because they probably got scammed out of some number of coins? Seems like idle speculation.

I also had no problems withdrawing USD to my Canadian bank account up to 10 months ago. It was very smooth typically under 48 hours. That was then, today the situation is very different. It is not just a "US" problem. I tried withdrawing CAD to a Canadian bank account back in October 2013. Not possible. I ended up buying back my BTC (at a profit I must say due to the silk road crash) and withdrawing my BTC right after. Now the real question here is JPY withdrawals (domestic within Japan) in the last two weeks. How are they proceeding?


Title: Re: Official End of Mt Gox thread
Post by: glendall on February 21, 2014, 07:12:29 PM
I think Gox will survive and be just fine.

Why? Because people didn't stay away after they were large part of all the other big price crashes in bitcoin.

I really hope I'm wrong though. I wish they would just disappear. The management is a bunch of imbeciles and they have been shown to untrustworthy.

If I wanted a fractional reserve system I'll just stick to fiat thanks.


Title: Re: Official End of Mt Gox thread
Post by: Lloydie on February 21, 2014, 07:21:11 PM
I cannot understand why Gox has not issued a statement to the effect that x% of total funds was in their hot wallet versus cold wallet. That would reassure a lot of people. Just a really sad situation really. The management appears extremely inadequate in dealing with the public. They do not realise the impact they are having on bitcoin itself.


Title: Re: Official End of Mt Gox thread
Post by: ArticMine on February 21, 2014, 07:22:58 PM
I think Gox will survive and be just fine.

Why? Because people didn't stay away after they were large part of all the other big price crashes in bitcoin.

I really hope I'm wrong though. I wish they would just disappear. The management is a bunch of imbeciles and they have been shown to untrustworthy.

If I wanted a fractional reserve system I'll just stick to fiat thanks.

If they are running a fractional reserve on BTC, which I suspect that are now, it will get real ugly real fast. Why because the BTC/USD rate will go up sharply and when it does that will be the end. It was an increase BTC/USD rate that killed pirateat40, and once the market got out of denial, and accepted the fact that pirateat40 did not have the BTC to pay anyone the BTC/USD rate went up by a factor of 100.


Title: Re: Official End of Mt Gox thread
Post by: Lloydie on February 21, 2014, 07:34:44 PM
We have no evidence that Gox was running a fractional reserve system, unless someone can point us to data proving so? It's unlikely for them to do so precisely because of Btc appreciation versus fiat in the months leading up to November 2013.


Title: Re: Official End of Mt Gox thread
Post by: ArticMine on February 21, 2014, 07:47:44 PM
We have no evidence that Gox was running a fractional reserve system, unless someone can point us to data proving so? It's unlikely for them to do so precisely because of Btc appreciation versus fiat in the months leading up to November 2013.

One would think, except for the fact that the "delays" in BTC withdrawals have followed a sharp rise in the BTC/USD rate in November / December 2013.


Title: Re: Official End of Mt Gox thread
Post by: Zangelbert Bingledack on February 21, 2014, 07:54:51 PM
Now the real question here is JPY withdrawals (domestic within Japan) in the last two weeks. How are they proceeding?

Seem to be taking 3-4 weeks, faster if you have a Japanet bank account, according to https://bitcointalk.org/index.php?topic=428242.100


Title: Re: Official End of Mt Gox thread
Post by: sgbett on February 21, 2014, 08:02:33 PM
So is the allegation that gox facing solvency issues due to general mismanagement of finances, decided to 'buy' bitcoin with goxbux, whilst stalling on fiat withdrawals, thusly pushing the gox price higher, whilst selling them on the other exchanges for real fiat.

It continued to harvest fiat thus easing cash-flow issues, waiting for the inevitable market blow off. Once it was clear we were in a solid downtrend it reversed its strategy this time, blocking BTC withdrawals to capitalise on downward momentum, causing panic selloffs. With all the surplus fiat gox now had, it was able to cover the 'goxbux' liability, as well as acquire a whole bunch of additional btc for cheap, knowing full well that it would reduce its bitcoin liability to customers such that when withdrawals re-open, they are left sat on a whole load of spare bitcoin, which will inevitably trend back towards equilibrium with the rest of the exchanges.

So if thats the story...

Is karpeles is the genius criminal mastermind behind this?  ;)


Title: Re: Official End of Mt Gox thread
Post by: humanitee on February 21, 2014, 08:03:11 PM
My greatest fear is that they will come out of this stronger, with their fraudulent/immoral/unethical behaviour being further incentivized. Now traders will want to have even more money there to be prepared for the next great Goxxing.

I will not put any more fiat into the ecosystem, and will strongly suggest to immediate friends and family they they do the same, until I see Gox volume drop greatly.

This could set a dangerous precedent for the community, especially if no legal action results.


Title: Re: Official End of Mt Gox thread
Post by: sgbett on February 21, 2014, 08:04:15 PM
My greatest fear is that they will come out of this stronger, with their fraudulent/immoral/unethical behaviour being further incentivized. Now traders will want to have even more money there to be prepared for the next great Goxxing.

I will not put any more fiat into the ecosystem, and will strongly suggest to immediate friends and family they they do the same, until I see Gox volume drop greatly.

This could set a dangerous precedent for the community, especially if no legal action results.

let me tell you a story about how well the legal action is going with bitcoinica...



Title: Re: Official End of Mt Gox thread
Post by: humanitee on February 21, 2014, 08:05:06 PM
My greatest fear is that they will come out of this stronger, with their fraudulent/immoral/unethical behaviour being further incentivized. Now traders will want to have even more money there to be prepared for the next great Goxxing.

I will not put any more fiat into the ecosystem, and will strongly suggest to immediate friends and family they they do the same, until I see Gox volume drop greatly.

This could set a dangerous precedent for the community, especially if no legal action results.

let me tell you a story about how well the legal action is going with bitcoinica...



I actually haven't kept up with that. I'm guessing it's going quite shittily, yes?


Title: Re: Official End of Mt Gox thread
Post by: Lloydie on February 21, 2014, 08:05:34 PM
We have no evidence that Gox was running a fractional reserve system, unless someone can point us to data proving so? It's unlikely for them to do so precisely because of Btc appreciation versus fiat in the months leading up to November 2013.

One would think, except for the fact that the "delays" in BTC withdrawals have followed a sharp rise in the BTC/USD rate in November / December 2013.
I thought the delays were initially in fiat. Only after a few months, were Btc withdrawals delayed, which caused gox Btc rates to fall below other exchanges?


Title: Re: Official End of Mt Gox thread
Post by: sgbett on February 21, 2014, 08:28:22 PM
My greatest fear is that they will come out of this stronger, with their fraudulent/immoral/unethical behaviour being further incentivized. Now traders will want to have even more money there to be prepared for the next great Goxxing.

I will not put any more fiat into the ecosystem, and will strongly suggest to immediate friends and family they they do the same, until I see Gox volume drop greatly.

This could set a dangerous precedent for the community, especially if no legal action results.

let me tell you a story about how well the legal action is going with bitcoinica...



I actually haven't kept up with that. I'm guessing it's going quite shittily, yes?

The additional carriage return at the end of my post was indicative of the progress that appears to have been made.

Oh, and the legal people start making noises like all us plaintiffs might have to 'donate' to keep the case going.

Oh how I laughed :)


Title: Re: Official End of Mt Gox thread
Post by: sgbett on February 21, 2014, 08:29:45 PM
So is the allegation that gox facing solvency issues due to general mismanagement of finances, decided to 'buy' bitcoin with goxbux, whilst stalling on fiat withdrawals, thusly pushing the gox price higher, whilst selling them on the other exchanges for real fiat.

It continued to harvest fiat thus easing cash-flow issues, waiting for the inevitable market blow off. Once it was clear we were in a solid downtrend it reversed its strategy this time, blocking BTC withdrawals to capitalise on downward momentum, causing panic selloffs. With all the surplus fiat gox now had, it was able to cover the 'goxbux' liability, as well as acquire a whole bunch of additional btc for cheap, knowing full well that it would reduce its bitcoin liability to customers such that when withdrawals re-open, they are left sat on a whole load of spare bitcoin, which will inevitably trend back towards equilibrium with the rest of the exchanges.

So if thats the story...

Is karpeles is the genius criminal mastermind behind this?  ;)

It also crossed my mind, that if this (or whatever form of 1.stop deposits, 2.arb, 3.profit) has happened, then gox is going nowhere ;)


Title: Re: Official End of Mt Gox thread
Post by: humanitee on February 21, 2014, 08:30:57 PM
The additional carriage return at the end of my post was indicative of the progress that appears to have been made.

Oh, and the legal people start making noises like all us plaintiffs might have to 'donate' to keep the case going.

Oh how I laughed :)

lmfao, why am I not surprised.


Title: Re: Official End of Mt Gox thread
Post by: ArticMine on February 21, 2014, 08:40:17 PM
Now the real question here is JPY withdrawals (domestic within Japan) in the last two weeks. How are they proceeding?

Seem to be taking 3-4 weeks, faster if you have a Japanet bank account, according to https://bitcointalk.org/index.php?topic=428242.100

This JPY delay is what finally convinced me that MTGox is insolvent.


Title: Re: Official End of Mt Gox thread
Post by: markjamrobin on February 22, 2014, 12:40:31 AM
Now the real question here is JPY withdrawals (domestic within Japan) in the last two weeks. How are they proceeding?

Seem to be taking 3-4 weeks, faster if you have a Japanet bank account, according to https://bitcointalk.org/index.php?topic=428242.100

This JPY delay is what finally convinced me that MTGox is insolvent.

What are JPY withdrawal times at these days?


Title: Re: Official End of Mt Gox thread
Post by: TooDumbForBitcoin on February 22, 2014, 02:03:58 AM
I'm confused by the title of this thread.

Is this thread about the official end of Mt. Gox?

Is this the official thread about the end of Mt. Gox?

Has the official end of the the Mt. Gox thread been announced?




Title: Re: Official End of Mt Gox thread
Post by: hvezdasmrti on February 22, 2014, 03:21:39 AM
This is the only statement which gox announced for his customers: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=oHg5SJYRHA0


Title: Re: Official End of Mt Gox thread
Post by: zedicus on February 22, 2014, 04:17:20 AM
I'm confused by the title of this thread.

Is this thread about the official end of Mt. Gox?

Is this the official thread about the end of Mt. Gox?

Has the official end of the the Mt. Gox thread been announced?




   The community sentiment is "to stick gox with a pitchfork" and take turns twisting and turning but..

I believe gox will stay and pretend none of this happened!

Kinda like that **** Yufi from Avalon who is still selling miners with a bag over his head...
 
 
 



 



Title: Re: Official End of Mt Gox thread
Post by: MANofthePEOPLE on February 22, 2014, 04:56:44 AM
Wouldn't the obvious thing for gox management be to just send coins to other exchanges and sell? Might not be legal but would keep them alive


Title: Re: Official End of Mt Gox thread
Post by: Cassius on February 22, 2014, 08:10:08 AM
Wouldn't the obvious thing for gox management be to just send coins to other exchanges and sell? Might not be legal but would keep them alive

There was a point to that effect earlier in the thread - or that it's actually been happening for months.
Dangerous strategy if that's really going on, since sales of the volumes required would crash the price on those excha- oh, wait...
It seems pretty clear there's some illegal or at least very dubious activity going on, as well as straightforward incompetence and getting a bunch of coins stolen by hackers, perhaps for some time now.
I think the safest strategy is to assume that anything underhand, incompetent or brutally stupid that could have been going on at Gox has been.


Title: Re: Official End of Mt Gox thread
Post by: seldon on February 22, 2014, 08:41:11 AM
Feeling brave guys? I can confirm, that Sepa still works _both ways_. Last withdraw took 3 weeks, last deposit took 48h.
The fact that they still withdraw brings a glimmer of hope that they are not legally insolvent. The rest is greed and trying bitcoinbuilder for a nice 50% profit in 48h :)


Title: Re: Official End of Mt Gox thread
Post by: invisiblefriend on February 22, 2014, 09:32:13 AM
n its moving !


Title: Re: Official End of Mt Gox thread
Post by: seldon on February 22, 2014, 09:48:30 AM
n its moving !

Guess they process deposits in batches, whenever one gets done we see a spike.

Would be funny, if bitcoinbuilder actually is the tool to make gox survive another day. principles vs. greed


Title: Re: Official End of Mt Gox thread
Post by: Wilhelm on February 22, 2014, 10:53:41 AM
https://i.imgur.com/DBInRIO.jpg


Title: Re: Official End of Mt Gox thread
Post by: Zangelbert Bingledack on February 22, 2014, 02:23:01 PM
Now the real question here is JPY withdrawals (domestic within Japan) in the last two weeks. How are they proceeding?

Seem to be taking 3-4 weeks, faster if you have a Japanet bank account, according to https://bitcointalk.org/index.php?topic=428242.100

This JPY delay is what finally convinced me that MTGox is insolvent.

What are JPY withdrawal times at these days?

A few weeks. See linked thread for details.


Title: Re: Official End of Mt Gox thread
Post by: Zangelbert Bingledack on February 22, 2014, 02:25:37 PM
Feeling brave guys? I can confirm, that Sepa still works _both ways_. Last withdraw took 3 weeks, last deposit took 48h.
The fact that they still withdraw brings a glimmer of hope that they are not legally insolvent. The rest is greed and trying bitcoinbuilder for a nice 50% profit in 48h :)

50% profit in five seconds if you have a Japanese bank account.


Title: Re: Official End of Mt Gox thread
Post by: samson on February 22, 2014, 04:36:47 PM
Now the real question here is JPY withdrawals (domestic within Japan) in the last two weeks. How are they proceeding?

Seem to be taking 3-4 weeks, faster if you have a Japanet bank account, according to https://bitcointalk.org/index.php?topic=428242.100

This JPY delay is what finally convinced me that MTGox is insolvent.

You're going to be in for a bit of a shock when BTC withdrawals start up again and things return to normal.



Title: Re: Official End of Mt Gox thread
Post by: Wilhelm on February 22, 2014, 06:06:45 PM
Now the real question here is JPY withdrawals (domestic within Japan) in the last two weeks. How are they proceeding?

Seem to be taking 3-4 weeks, faster if you have a Japanet bank account, according to https://bitcointalk.org/index.php?topic=428242.100

This JPY delay is what finally convinced me that MTGox is insolvent.

You're going to be in for a bit of a shock when BTC withdrawals start up again and things return to normal.



Do you really believe it will return to normal? After taking so many people hostage for this long?
You probably have all your BTC in there....


Title: Re: Official End of Mt Gox thread
Post by: GeniuSxBoY on February 22, 2014, 06:44:45 PM
Now the real question here is JPY withdrawals (domestic within Japan) in the last two weeks. How are they proceeding?

Seem to be taking 3-4 weeks, faster if you have a Japanet bank account, according to https://bitcointalk.org/index.php?topic=428242.100

This JPY delay is what finally convinced me that MTGox is insolvent.

You're going to be in for a bit of a shock when BTC withdrawals start up again and things return to normal.



Do you really believe it will return to normal? After taking so many people hostage for this long?
You probably have all your BTC in there....


We don't have to believe. We know. Knowing is better than believing. And "normal" is defined to be the same as it was before the halt.


Title: Re: Official End of Mt Gox thread
Post by: Wilhelm on February 22, 2014, 06:51:04 PM
Now the real question here is JPY withdrawals (domestic within Japan) in the last two weeks. How are they proceeding?

Seem to be taking 3-4 weeks, faster if you have a Japanet bank account, according to https://bitcointalk.org/index.php?topic=428242.100

This JPY delay is what finally convinced me that MTGox is insolvent.

You're going to be in for a bit of a shock when BTC withdrawals start up again and things return to normal.



Do you really believe it will return to normal? After taking so many people hostage for this long?
You probably have all your BTC in there....

We don't have to believe. We know. Knowing is better than believing. And "normal" is defined to be the same as it was before the halt.

And what do you know? Who is "we"? And "knowing" is only trick of your consciousness :).


Title: Re: Official End of Mt Gox thread
Post by: yogi on February 22, 2014, 07:01:07 PM
I'm confused by the title of this thread.

Is this thread about the official end of Mt. Gox?

Is this the official thread about the end of Mt. Gox?

Has the official end of the the Mt. Gox thread been announced?

I think it's a typo, 'Official' should be 'Orificial', at least, I think that's why 80% of posters are talking out their ass.


Title: Re: Official End of Mt Gox thread
Post by: CC23 on February 24, 2014, 06:04:06 PM
Well, I can tell you as much as that the company is still in operation. I just received a reply to a customer service request (which had nothing to do with all this so its contents aren't relevant). It took ages, but obviously someone's still there doing customer service which doesn't guarantee but makes it more probable that everything is running sorta normally, relative to the circumstances.


Title: Re: Official End of Mt Gox thread
Post by: c0ldfusi0nz on February 25, 2014, 03:51:09 AM
Perhaps this is the end...


Title: Re: Official End of Mt Gox thread
Post by: Bobsurplus on February 25, 2014, 04:06:11 AM
Confirmed, this is the end.


Title: Re: Official End of Mt Gox thread
Post by: jamesc760 on February 25, 2014, 04:23:09 AM
Sad but true. MtGox support reps tweeted they got laid off. Thus ended the sordid affairs of MtGox.


Title: Re: Official End of Mt Gox thread
Post by: TooDumbForBitcoin on February 25, 2014, 04:26:48 AM
What is needed here is a clip of the last seconds of Barad Dur as told by Peter Jackson.


Title: Re: Official End of Mt Gox thread
Post by: DigitalHermit on February 25, 2014, 04:31:44 AM
Sad but true. MtGox support reps tweeted they got laid off. Thus ended the sordid affairs of MtGox.

Oh I'm sure the lawsuits will go on for years. MtGox: truly legendary.


Title: Re: Official End of Mt Gox thread
Post by: zero3112 on February 25, 2014, 04:33:19 AM
And it's gone https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-DT7bX-B1Mg


Title: Re: Official End of Mt Gox thread
Post by: MAbtc on February 25, 2014, 04:40:45 AM
Fuck. It really did go Full Tilt. GOXasset holders -- I am truly sorry. After waiting for 3 years, I should be receiving my Full Tilt payout next month.....


Title: Re: Official End of Mt Gox thread
Post by: Bobsurplus on February 25, 2014, 04:42:10 AM
Fuck. It really did go Full Tilt. GOXasset holders -- I am truly sorry. After waiting for 3 years, I should be receiving my Full Tilt payout next month.....

Fulltilt took me for over 12K and this was years ago.. Then 12K was the whole world to me.. Today is a very different story.


Title: Re: Official End of Mt Gox thread
Post by: sir faps on February 25, 2014, 04:48:16 AM
I bet those people who thought "I'm gonna buy all these cheap goxcoins because they're gonna be worth a ton when gox resumes withdrawls" are bashing their heads against a wall right now


Title: Re: Official End of Mt Gox thread
Post by: RyNinDaCleM on February 25, 2014, 04:57:13 AM
I bet those people who thought "I'm gonna buy all these cheap goxcoins because they're gonna be worth a ton when gox resumes withdrawls" are bashing their heads against a wall right now

It doesn't matter when you can't withdraw the money either  :-\


Title: Re: Official End of Mt Gox thread
Post by: YipYip on February 25, 2014, 05:02:37 AM
I bet those people who thought "I'm gonna buy all these cheap goxcoins because they're gonna be worth a ton when gox resumes withdrawls" are bashing their heads against a wall right now


...lolz u think


Title: Re: Official End of Mt Gox thread
Post by: cosmofly on February 25, 2014, 05:15:29 AM
Its all over, very sad for the 1 Million investors involved in goz trading


Title: Re: Official End of Mt Gox thread
Post by: Manticore on February 25, 2014, 05:15:47 AM
I love that under any other circumstance they would've halted trading. They've done it countless time during mini BTC crashes.

I suppose holding their customer's coins hostage and letting the price go down to nothing is their best exit. At this point, they know their days are numbered even in a best case scenario.

So they bide time, let the price crash, buy cheap coins, potentially arb them to make money for themselves and possibly pay back the customers that haven't sold out of panic, and they also attract new money from clients with enormous appetites for risk, enabling them to buy even more coins. So, they enrich themselves and possibly manipulate their way out of liability (possibly returning coins after they've flipped everyone else's coins several times over), then close shop?


This is essentially exactly what they described doing in their crisis strategy --

http://www.scribd.com/doc/209050732/MtGox-Situation-Crisis-Strategy-Draft

'1- Immediately reduce liabilities as much as possible with partners
 With actual assets using arbitrage/ injecting new coins to erase them from the books. Informing and asking selected Bitcoin main players to ask for their help. The MtGox price is low, making it possible to erase a significant portion of the debt, but it needs to be done quickly. Injections in coin are most useful (enough to run the exchange) but some cash is also needed to not run a fractional reserve'


Title: Re: Official End of Mt Gox thread
Post by: jasonjm on February 25, 2014, 05:44:39 AM
for the record I am going to say; EITHER -

1) mtgox is possibly one of the most incompetent businesses ever formed (makes BFL look pro).

2) someone at MTGOX is an evil genius, and is now rich and laughing.


I am leaning towards option 1.


the sad truth is that if gox has truly had 750k coins recently "stolen" from them, then this will not be good for bitcoin prices. you now have 750k coins that have a cost of zero, whichever parties are holding them can sell them or spend them for literally any price and still make fortunes as they have a zero cost.


Title: Re: Official End of Mt Gox thread
Post by: Syke on February 25, 2014, 05:47:18 AM
for the record I am going to say; EITHER -

1) mtgox is possibly one of the most incompetent businesses ever formed (makes BFL look pro).

2) someone at MTGOX is an evil genius, and is now rich and laughing.

Whether the evil genius was inside or outside, Mark was in on it. There's absolutely no way all their cold wallets could be drained without them noticing.


Title: Re: Official End of Mt Gox thread
Post by: jasonjm on February 25, 2014, 05:53:27 AM
for the record I am going to say; EITHER -

1) mtgox is possibly one of the most incompetent businesses ever formed (makes BFL look pro).

2) someone at MTGOX is an evil genius, and is now rich and laughing.

Whether the evil genius was inside or outside, Mark was in on it. There's absolutely no way all their cold wallets could be drained without them noticing.



agree with that logic. Not sure if its the truth, but logic is sound.


Title: Re: Official End of Mt Gox thread
Post by: traderCJ on February 25, 2014, 05:54:45 AM
for the record I am going to say; EITHER -

1) mtgox is possibly one of the most incompetent businesses ever formed (makes BFL look pro).

2) someone at MTGOX is an evil genius, and is now rich and laughing.

Whether the evil genius was inside or outside, Mark was in on it. There's absolutely no way all their cold wallets could be drained without them noticing.


Assuming this happened over the course of a few years .. they noticed, but as coins left their wallet, they saw their fiat holdings rise.  Obviously nobody checked the details.  Woops.


Title: Re: Official End of Mt Gox thread
Post by: CryptoGuy2014 on February 25, 2014, 06:01:53 AM
Mt. Gox website down????

RIP


Title: Re: Official End of Mt Gox thread
Post by: fonzie on February 25, 2014, 06:02:19 AM
ROT IN HELL!


Title: Re: Official End of Mt Gox thread
Post by: mccorvic on February 25, 2014, 06:02:36 AM
Gox is dead! WOOHOO! This is the last Goxxing ever!


Title: Re: Official End of Mt Gox thread
Post by: Satyre_Noir on February 25, 2014, 06:05:04 AM
Gox is dead! WOOHOO! This is the last Goxxing ever!

Have a mercy for victims.  


Title: Re: Official End of Mt Gox thread
Post by: CryptoGuy2014 on February 25, 2014, 06:17:02 AM
That's what happens when you have trust in Magic The Gathering Online eXchange for anything other than trading cards, what it was actually capable of operating as, but then to switch business models and turn into a currency exchange, it just isn't what it was meant to do...

But now we know....


Title: Re: Official End of Mt Gox thread
Post by: YipYip on February 25, 2014, 07:15:16 AM
Gox is dead! WOOHOO! This is the last Goxxing ever!

yay ... no more of that fat fuck bring crypto down !!


Title: Re: Official End of Mt Gox thread
Post by: derpinheimer on February 25, 2014, 07:26:43 AM
Gox is dead! WOOHOO! This is the last Goxxing ever!

yay ... no more of that fat fuck bring crypto down !!

Please, wait until the funeral is over. People are still mourning over the loss of our beloved.
https://i.imgur.com/dECQ4VS.jpg


Title: Re: Official End of Mt Gox thread
Post by: Lloydie on February 25, 2014, 08:46:32 AM
Karpeles should be going to jail for insolvent trading and defrauding people, IMHO.


Title: Re: Official End of Mt Gox thread
Post by: Searing on February 25, 2014, 09:37:34 AM
Karpeles should be going to jail for insolvent trading and defrauding people, IMHO.


Japanese regulators this last week said they have NO power to regulate bitcoin ..in that it is not real $$$....(google it)

so...he can walk with it all and no one can touch him it seems

I assume he will pay his debts pad his pockets and give some back or he'd never be able to leave his house again

but that would be down the road if/when he chooses to do so

well played well played indeed

Searing