Bitcoin Forum

Without silk roads, and the subsequent underground marketplaces that utilize Bitcoins as well, it would be completely worthless. What is the point of Bitcoin. I understand you can argue: decentralized, we'll that's literally the only advantage I can think of.

Now, before the Gawker post, Bitcoins were practically worthless, and now that there hasn't been much news about Silk Road, the price has steadily gone down.

What the Bitcoin community needs to do is advertise it's easy for buying illegal items. If we don't do this it will fail miserably.

Whenever I told my friends about Bitcoins, they thought it was the most ridiculous and inconvenient thing to buy. I mean c'mon. Bank account-->Dwolla/paxum/LR/SEPA/etc...-->Mtgox/Tradehill/CampBX-->Bitcoin.
Who wants to go through that timely process for some digital currency that can't be used anywhere, except some odd website that sells novelty items.

My guess is that "bringing BitCoin to more people's attention", especially with the idea that "it can buy illegal things" is a very controversial position.  I'd rather have a slow and steady system than one that goes through bubbles every few years.  And I'd rather it not have certain types of attention.

I am stating it is the only true thing it can be used for. Otherwise Bitcoin will only benefit early adopters using their coins out of the fact that they already have them. Silk Road is the only true use, and if you argue against this point you are a fanboy. It's only uses are for illegalities, donating to Wikileaks, donating to Lulzec, anonymous. It will never bubble again without another Silk Road post.

Silk Road wasn't the only reason for the bubble. Sure it helped, but at the same time it was being reported bitcoins were already gaining traction anyways, which is what lead to Silk Road being reported on to start with.

"So where can you use bitcoins?" "Well, I know this one place called Silk Road that uses it..." is pretty much how it became known in the press.

No they were not being seriously reported. They may have been mentioned, once or twice leading to the two dollar price tag that we are so close to reaching. And if all you can hope for is a bubble, then well you wouldn't exactly be a prime economist, by any current standards. In a true economy one hopes for commerce, then true value emerging. Not some idiotic bubbles that only the clairvoyant can realize their downfall.

Now as to the second paragraph of your post, you cannot even name a true reported commerce site that uses Bitcoins. Also any site that tries to accept Bitcoins is ridiculed and expected to give up all of their personal information to a bunch of random, disinterested forum posters, whom most likely scroll the internet throughout their days; instead of adding to the productivity of the nation.

I like how waves of new forum accounts come in and say exactly this. One wonders... I try not to be cynical and think it's because of the mainstream media.

Also, Freenet is for CP, Tor is for CP and silk road (more functionality), I2P is for CP and spam, and the Internet, well, for ordinary porn and spam. I would even go further and tell you that the Bittorrent has other uses than piracy but I suspect that wouldn't believe me...

For me, Bitcoin's true use is being able to send very small or very large amounts of money across borders easily. I support the system so that I can have monetary connections with more people with less trouble. It's not exactly fanboyism, it's called enlightened self interest. Not only that I am not comfortable with having to be in the open for every transaction I make, systems like PayPal aren't automatic for everyone in the world, especially developing regions of the world, where some of my real life contacts are. One trouble for me is artists though, they have very peculiar minds. There was this one guy which wanted to send and receive money between Siberia and Turkey, and he couldn't manage to do it in two years with banks. I wonder how I could even teach him how to use Bitcoin, let alone convince him to do that...  :-\

How could TOR only be used for CP and Silk Road. Are you out of your mind? It is one of the more useful software's out there. How can you support decentralization and Bitcoins and not support TOR at the same time.

My goal is not to make a new account to make an obvious point. I am here to speak the truth. And the truth is that Silk Road is the only reason Bitcoins have been publicized and discovered to this point. I mean did you register before, or after the Gawker's post. That is the question. By the way I've been active for months on these forums. Like my name says, I have a bombshell to release to the Bitcoin community that will most like ridicule some people, and further cement points.

Preach it sister  :D 

I would suggest taking the information from the post here http://www.reddit.com/r/Bitcoin/comments/imoc0/using_silk_road/ and finding a way to drop things into 5 easy steps, make a landing page with five huge images on how to buy with Bitcoins or whatever.     

Next step, is taking that information and putting it where it matters, in the hands of people who don't even usually use computers.    I would suggest creating that page with the easy steps, printing out hundreds of copies of the page, put said papers in public bathrooms, college bulletin boards, your local church, etc.

Where did I say anything about hoping for a bubble? You were the one saying another Silk Road post was needed for another bubble. All I was saying was the Silk Road wasn't the sole reason for the first one.


That line was just a jab at the lazy reporting that happened with bitcoin and Silk Road. Though for myself, no, I can't name any true reported commerce sites that use bitcoins; I haven't gone looking. Have stuck with using bitcoins to snag a vps off of Silk Road for a decent price, and for loaning some to friends that were getting a server that offered to give me a shell in exchange for doing so.


Okay? I haven't asked for anything of the sort like others have been.

I was trying to be sarcastic. 8)


Silk Road is not the "only true use" of Bitcoin, and not the only reason it has been publicized.

However it probably is the most sensational topic, so it's what made it interesting for laymen, especially via word-of-mouth. It's something you can talk about. I don't agree that it was the sole cause of the bubble, but is certainly one of the contributing factors. Some people might have thought that druggies and "other criminals" would be all over this, probably forgetting that cash is almost as good for those purposes.

It also possibly made it less appealing for serious businesses. They don't want to be associated with SR. And since, as you say, SR made that kind of publicity, it contributed to such an atmosphere surrounding Bitcoin, adding to all the "scam" talk that's been going on.

I think your point is, the way of SR is the way to go, am I right? That's way I objected in the first place. We got past a lot of negative hype about Bitcoin in the past year. It proved to be a secure system, and most of the economic questions have been answered. The structure surrounding it is getting stronger, and methods of how to remedy the scammer problem are being established (not only for Bitcoin, but any possible free currency). I'm hoping that association with drugs will get old in the long run as well. The full potential of Bitcoin can only be realized if it gets wide acceptance as the method of value transfer globally. I want it to be true, for my kids. And not because I want them to buy drugs online. ;)

If you are trying to support your own project with this rhetoric, I probably won't be too critical. Just don't advocate it as the sole outcome of the Bitcoin project. Looking forward to your bombshell.

(To answer your question, I've been using Bitcoin for longer than a year, read about it on Slashdot. Heard about it two years ago, but unfortunately the "deflationary spiral" demagogy on Slashdot somehow did make sense to me then.)

Silk road is nothing more than a distraction. I use bitcoin all the time, but would not even consider using their service.

There is no real commerce in bitcoin, including SilkRoad. Exchanging USD for BTC for USD only stabilizes BTC, not adds value. It does add value to the USD economy and profits to MtGox and the vendors selling their wares.

Probably 90%+ of bitcoins are being hoarded and not put to use. "Invest" a million USD into bitcoins and you get 13 cents of fiat paper value back, or a loss of 99.99%. The rest goes to the ballerz aka speculators aka the freeloaders.

Now SilkRoad COULD be gigantic to bitcoin, if the vendors complete the economic cycle and dont cash out or hoard. This possibility is what gives bitcoin hope, as a backup to the gov currencies. If the gov currencies stop working out, you can bet theres going to be a lot more interest in bitcoin.

But again, while the gov charade continues, no one cares...you are right. But when the credit card stops, which it will, and reality hits, hopefully something like bitcoin will be around to ease the suffering. Until the time of the NEW US dollar/gov currency...and then we play the game again...heck, the new USD could be a digital currency!

+1... I use bitcoin almost daily. I work with several people in different countries and being able to pay them and get paid with bitcoin instantly has been a godsend. Best innovation for global trade since the internet.

Silk Road is what caused the bubble, no point in denying it. I made mad bank off that so I have no problems with it. It's settled down down and is back to a more realistic price.
Gotta give props to all my SR niggas WOOP WOOP

Amen brother. I bought a $1 PDF file from a guy in China. Try doing that with..., well, anything.

I've never used Silk Road nor do I know anyone personally who has.  I do however know dozens of people personally that use bitcoins for everything from stockpiling precious metals without a trace, to gambling online.  I've found it's a great way to reward random people on forums for helping me with issues.  However, when it comes to buying drugs, the only people I could see paying the inflated Silk Road prices are nerds who wouldn't dare talk to a real drug dealer, kids, or people who recently moved to a new area and haven't found a real connection yet.  In my opinion, anyone saying Silk Road is the center of bitcoin is an immature kid who got his first dime bag online using bitcoins hashed from Mom & Dad's electricity.  That's a BitcoinBomb of reality for you.

You all have made valid points that all point in one direction. Bitcoins main use is for either disregarding monetary regulations, buying illegal items, and or for speculative purposes to make small amounts of fiat currency.

You're point on the convenience of turning Bitcoins into dollars is irrelevant. It's not like you can make dollars come out of your computer, it comes from hard work, Bitcoin is a bandwagon that has to be accepted early to make true profit. It is the niche of niches, you are following a ghost a non-existent man that can control and entire currency.

What good has Bitcoin done for anything except spawn an entire group of basement dwellers who are trying to get rich as quick as possible, with minimal to no work. How has Bitcoin added to the national debt in any way, it's market is worth less than a cities transportation budget. In fact Bitcoin is a way of money laundering.

If Bitcoin ever becomes big (let's just imagine) the IRS would immediately shut down Mtgox as a form of money laundering. It would be the easiest way to launder money since the liberty dollar.

And Mr. "Original Gangster" your attempts at justifying Bitcoins is absolutely awful. You only stated that it could be used for illegalities, therefore cementing my point. As long as people like you attempt to justify a currency that's main purpose is for illegal activities, then there is no room to grow. You yourself are probably just a teenager attempting to purport the fact that all people who use Silk Road are children who are taking advantage of their parent's resources.

You're actually quite an idiot, to mine the amount of Bitcoins to purchase an item on Silk Road would require serious amount of technical knowledge and intelligence. Something that a child does not have.

Wow, that's incredible.  You've registered today and have it all figured out don't you?  I use bitcoins to buy things on a regular basis, exactly like I would if I were using cash to buy something in person, such as at a yard sale or via craigslist.  I've bought handmade jewlry off of Etsy, small hardware such as thumbdrives, sd cards and even a cell phone, as well as pre-paid cell phone service cards and online game licenses.  I've paid for server rentals.  I've never bought anything remotely illegal, and have never even connected to Silk Road.  The IRS isn't going to shut down MtGox, and even if that were possible, there are a dozen more such exchanges ready to snatch up their market share across the planet in as many different countries that don't care what the US IRS wants.


My nephew has mined two blocks on his computer, he's a child.  I didn't show him how to do it, either.  I actually have never done so, or even tried.

Excuse me, What I meant by the Mtgox post, is that EVERY single exchange will be shut down for money laundering, IF Bitcoin becomes successful.

Based on the fact that you are a global moderator my guess is that you are an early adopter that has mined Bitcoins when the difficulty was extremely low. Therefore making it practical to attempt to use them on a regular basis. My point is that the inconvenience of trying to buy the currency to spend it on everyday things is too great to have a point. So at this point being a true adopter of the currency you are most likely in it for the niche (small amounts), speculation (small profits), or for online underground marketplaces.

And get off the sarcasm with your first sentence, you represent a community with that tag. Hostility is noticed, and noted. Who wants to join a community with irritable nerds at the helm?

It's a currency represent it as such.

1)  Bitcoin is already successful, it's just not widely reported yet.  As I have already pointed out, I have used it to buy many things online, both digital and physical.  Many others have as well, both within this forum and external to it.

2) You're excused.  If you think that it's even possible for every exchange to be shut down, even if every nation on Earth were to cowtow to the US government, you seriously lack understanding about how the exchanges work, or even how exchange works in general.  I've literally bought bitcoins for cash, in person.  I've never used MtGox or any other centralized currency exchange to get bitcoins, nor have I ever mined a single block (as I already mentioned and you ignored).  I've only dealt with individuals to buy more bitcoins.  I've speculated on MtGox, but I deposited in bitcoin and withdrew in bitcoin.  Never have I done so in any form of fiat currency, US FRN's or otherwise.


We are all early adopters, it's still early.


No, never.  Never even tried to mine.  Difficulty was low, only relatively.  It was never cost effective for me to mine.


I understand your point, I'm trying to show you your error, but you're ignoring the realities I'm presenting.  I've neither mined, nor bought a single bitcoin on any exchange for a dollar that I had to deposit.  Considering that, and the fact that I actually have some to spend, how the hell did I get them if they are inconvenient to get?  Maybe if you live on a farm in Kansas, but if you live in any major urban area in the US, you can buy bitcoins from someone in the next week.  You just might not like the markup.  If you live in NYC, Seattle or Chicago; you can buy some in person today without much trouble.


Apparently not yourself.  You're a troll, and the very reason that we have a 'newbie hell' section.  If you had asked a single question about how bitcoin works, I'd have been happy to explain it to you.  But you come in our house and sh*t on our dinner table and expect me to treat you with kindness?  There are 10K forums on the Internet for you to talk bad about bitcoins, but this is our home.  Guests come in here to learn about the system, and to trade and talk in peace.  Not to have some newbie jerk tell them all how bad everything is, that money laundering is what they are engaged it, or tell them that they are reporting them to the IRS.  Most of the good trolls have the sense to act respectablely until they make it out of newbie hell, before they go off on their missions to destroy all things bitcoin.  Some of them actually post things worth reading, even funny, and manage to stay here despite being trolls; after all, it's no fun listening to your echo.  But you couldn't even manage that.

I have, always.  I know what it is, which is why I'm here.  Since you don't really seem to want to know what it is, or how it works, don't count on a long stay.

Add to that the ability to send either small amounts, or to people without bank connections, and with little to no fees. I must re-iterate my sarcasm about freenet/tor here. You might think that you know what Bitcoin is used for, but your impression is simply wrong. The people who cared to reply to this thread prove that it has a wider range of use case than you've imagined. I've never used BTC to buy anything illegal where I live, and haven't speculated in currency. I bet but I don't gamble, and speculate in GLBSE. :)


Who? Care to expand this assertion?

• What nation are you talking about? USA? On the other hand, it's more efficient than banking, so it adds something to humanity as a whole.
• Mining is too much work. I'm telling this for the past year and nobody listens. Some of my friends got into the mining game, spend days building rigs and writing software, and in the end they are stuck with useless graphic cards. Use Bitcoin when you need it, it's just a tool.
• Pure currency speculation is a zero sum game, so total daytrader gain would be zero. I don't have anything against people who see Bitcoin as a long term investment tool though.
• Who launders money using Bitcoin if all users are run-of-the-mill nerds? I know of no one who has dirty money in their hands. Maybe you are talking about a few sellers at SR? What do you really think SR's trading volume really is?

IRS can't touch MtGox directly. Plus, exchanges in US are paying taxes, it probably would be another division's duty to shut them down. But I agree that in the long run, there is a slight chance that most States might turn against Bitcoin exchanges. I see it as a remote possibility though, because when it's big enough, countries harbouring exchanges will make a shitload of money from taxes. United States is becoming a prison every passing day, and some countries are following them to the end, I know mine is. States feed on control. But it's giving other States more to gain from being free.

Silk Road is the Lord Voldemort of bitcoin.

+1 and lol


but honestly, explaining bitcoins to non technogeeks or ecogeeks usually requires a mention a SR, otherwise people see it as a fad, sort of like camel bucks, sad but true.


Don't flame me, i know there's more but that is the first order perception.

Just because some "basement dwellers" are risking their own resources on a new technology that is utterly revolutionary, and may well profit from it, doesn't mean they deserve ridicule. In this world, you can make money through work, or through risk, and usually a combination of both. The people who risk their money and time on Bitcoin before the mainstream "gets it" are doing the world a huge service. If you don't see the potential of a frictionless currency that can be transferred across the world in less than a second, that breaks down national borders, that permits financial privacy and open markets, then you're welcome to avoid Bitcoin.

Speaking from my own experience, I've used Bitcoin extensively to pay and get paid for freelance work with people in the Philippines, China, and Spain. It has made my work more efficient, and more profitable. Bitcoin is a tremendous financial innovation. The best part? It's all voluntary. Unlike the fiat currency you clutch on to, nobody is forced to use it. Its demand comes from free men and women engaged in free thinking and free exchange.

If you look upon Bitcoin and see "money laundering"... then perhaps all hope is lost for you. You are so far down the statist indoctrination of what constitutes morality in monetary transfers that it's unlikely any of my words will appeal to you. Bitcoin lets free individuals exchange goods, services and labor across distance. It expands the global marketplace. It makes trade faster and more efficient. If that doesn't inspire you, what does?

The illicit drugs trade has as much influence on the bitcoin market as it does the fiat market (i.e. a lot)

My theory - having few bitcoins, but having read extensively on the subject and still decided to get in after the first bubble - is that the price fall of bitcoins has two separate and very much related aspects to it.

The first is that speculation works REALLY well only when supply is short.  Speculation helped fix the supply problem by creating a massive incentive for early adopters to cash out (which if they did in the 20's, they were smart because btc did not have anywhere near enough trade to support such pricing).  Speculation by people with either money to invest or money to lose vested heavily based upon short term gains seen this year.  The price trends over the few years prior is probably a better indicator or the raw cash value of the currency.

While BTC's used on silk road certainly would have a stimulative effect on trading price, I doubt it was responsible for roughly 130million in total valuation that was represented at the height of the bubble.  So... bubble!  Bubble inflates people jump on board adding to the number of people interacting with the currency.  The net number of people trading in the currency will naturally cause it to appreciate because there is demand for the currency.  (Look at gold)  As idiots and investors realized that they were speculating on something that really isn't NECESSARILY worth anything (neither is gold), they sold.  Fewer interacting with currency = lower prices.  More sellers = lower prices.

Second... there was a massive BTC heist that took place earlier this year which both stalled the speculation AND served to bring to market many many btc that had to be liquidated and also likely led many early adopters to begin a sell off.

So... you have early adopters with many BTC... you have speculation... you have investors betting and losing... you have a recession. 

Recessions are bad for people that want to sell and great for people that want to buy.

At the 12terrahash area of the spectrum we're at now... lets assume that 100 mhash production costs roughly $85USD today to build.  That puts the cash value of hard assets used currently in production at 9.96 million.  That figure has deprecated rapidly, bare in mind.  Presuming a fairly natural cost to profit curve in hashing rate, we'll just multiply that value times the value E and come up with ~27million spent on mining equipment that is used today (this presumes a natural constant of depreciation, I really don't have the math background to factor in moores law into this estimate).

IE you have 27,000,000 REAL dollars invested by different individuals that are QUITE interested in maintaining their investments.  That's a really rough guess, but low side equalibrium for bitcoins, presuming confidence is maintained by those invested in it (they don't get out), should be near market value of the investments depreciated over time plus the cost of production (power).

IE 27,000,000 + the cost of electricity to produce the coins in existence should approximately be the value of the currency presuming the miners refuse to sell at a loss.  Presuming the average hash:watt is around 2:1, you're looking at somewhere around 5.5megawatts being spent on bitcoin mining right now.  That's 132 megawatt hours per day or about $15,000USD per day being spent on just MAINTAINING FUNCTION.

That's 5.5million per year in electrical costs.

So, obviously this figure has ramped up a bit this year, but presuming that the curve associated with increased production has an inverse curve related to efficiency (having to do with the advent of gpu mining), we could again presume that costs extend back in a way as to provide a degree of accurate analysis.   I'm just going to use the 5.5 million projected energy cost in the future as an example because I never got past calc one and didn't learn how to compute this stuff. 

That puts the aggregrate cash value of bitcoins in pure dollar investment (no time, no commitment, no political ideals, no other element effecting the community's commitment) at about 32.5 million USD.

7.47 million BTC... trading at $4 per have a cash value of about 30million dollars. (which I believe to be just below equilibrium, I expect prices to rise in the next month or two to around 4.75/btc where they will stay until adoption begins to occur, keep in mind, when that happens it will again be accelerated and exaggerated by speculation)

I wouldn't expect it to go too much lower and would expect to find equilibrium a little higher than we are right now.  I estimated the value of BTC to be near $5USD a piece not including speculation and early adopters flooding the market trying to collect a short term reward.  I still expect to see the graphs to trend in such a way as to indicate things to be as such.

This is what I think the base price will be.  That is before adoption takes place on a larger scale.  Once more businesses start accepting BTC and more people start using it (because it saves massive amounts of money on bank transactions), the value will go up.  It will probably go up a whole hell of a lot.

Since I am see more and more adoption instead of less and less, I do not think the currency will collapse.  I've only invested about 1400USD into a mining operation, but I did so after months and months of research and while watching a precipitous drop in the value of the currency.

If I am right about my predictions, my getting in now should equate to something like a 1.75:1 return on my investments in a year without the full value of BTC realized.  If adoption occurs how I think it might, we might be looking at more like 20-30:1 in the next 5 years and 100-10000:1 in 10 years.

http://bitcoincharts.com/charts/mtgoxUSD#rg180zvztgSzm1g10zm2g25

If you look there you'll see the sell offs happened all at once.  I bet if you did some digging, it would be a minority of transactions representing the total sell off.   So it probably isn't typical trading.  It's large sell offs over and over again by people trying to pull cash out of bitcoin rather than using it as a long term hedge.

Oh... another thing.

If we can get namecoin domain (.bit) resolution into chrome and firefox, expect that currency to appreciate many thousands of times.

Who's we? If you want to help, then do it yourself and stop waiting for innovation.

What's your name on Something Awful? Oh wait you can't be a goon you're a complete idiot.

The surest sign of intelligence.  Trolling.

May I humbly submit myself before you, lord.

Ohhhh... I'm sorry.  I guess I shouldn't share any ideas because they're worthless unless I can enact them all for myself.

The Magna Carta was BS rag because it took many hands to make.

The great wall of china is a hoax, since the guy(s) that came up with it didn't make it happen for themselves.

[edit for posterity]

The point being... that one does not have to contain within himself every piece of knowledge or every tool in order to aide/create great things.  One merely has to press himself to the desired outcome and to work to that end.  Whether I code it all myself, or help in the design, or I donate to another that volunteers to make the changes... I am still a participant.

+1

The fact that you said "we" is a sign of commitment itself. ;)

Thank you!  I believe this community has the seeds within it of the next paradigm of humanity.  Collective, work based participation.

I want to start buying bitcoin because I believe in anarchy, and cryptography, and would like to push the boundaries of free expression.  Whether some want to use bitcoin to get high is beside the point; no one has ever made a system of currency based on mathematics until now, and it's exciting for anyone who believes that man will only be free when the last king is strangled with the entrails of the last priest.

How do I access it? I have TOR, and Aurora, but it doesn't pull up when I put in the URL. Is the site down a lot or what?

BitcoinBomb, I have one word to your assertion that the IRS could shut-down Mtgox whenever they wanted. WIKILEAKS. No doubt they''lll have some success but the genie is out of the bottle.

Please is there any site that is alternative to silkroadmarket.org? It seems they are shut down.

 :D Who made that link?    And was that a way to get on Silk Road without TOR or something?

I've heard of bitcoin forever, but it wasn't until I recently bought a radeon 6970 and someone mentioned it is good for mining, did I actually look into it. I am a very tech savvy person. If I didn't actually know how bitcoin worked, I can't imagine most ANY non-tech person would.

What I find most fascinating about bitcoin is its p2p nature, how bitcoins are generated, and the artificial scarcity.

If people only learned more about what bitcoin is, it could really take off.

The most off-putting thing to me is the difficulty to mine (hardware arms race). I REALLY like the prospects of Litecoin, CPU vs GPU really seems to level the playing field.

The value of bitcoin will come from the same place as the value of gold. Scarcity. No one can make it out of thin air.

Yes silk road is actually using bitcoin as it was intended.

early adopters will always do better than people late to the party. As for GPU mining, its become an arms race however the next generation of mining is already starting. FGPA's are the future, they provide a much better MHash/watt, which is becoming the most important aspect of mining bitcoins.

That being said, Although I just made an account, I have followed BTC & mined for several months, i recently sold all my GPUs and now going only CPU and litecoins for awhile until FGPAs mature. When they do, I'll setup dual LTC/BTC computers with them.

If you decide to mine, be sure to make a plan.

People with low post counts talking highly of Litecoin, color me skeptical lol


Though I can't help agree with the overall assessment of GPU versus CPU mining.  That is definitely a technical difference among those two coins that I think is enough to make a person have preference with one over the other.

I am my own person if that is what you are skeptical about  :D

I've been mining for a (long) while now, I just never made an account as i really had nothing to say, I figured with litecoins starting i should make one as I will be mining it while I wait for FGPAs to mature.

Silk road is down, I doubt they will be back, as their worth was slashed in half overnight.

Prices can adjust, if people want their service, they will just continue to buy at different rates is all, the actual prices of the products should remain unchanged.

Sad in China.
There's a Great FireWall, i can't use tor.

so is silkroad officially down?  if not then i want in

From what I can tell, it never has been, although there has been a concerted effort to produce the image that it's either down or gone.  Intentional digital camo, I suspect.  Many of the early outrage that came about due to the public articles has dispersed, in part, based on the belief by the TOR ignorant public (including a couple of senators) that Silk Road had been run off.  I've never bought anything on Silk Road, but everytime I tried to access it, due to trying to verify reports of it's destruction, I found that the reports of it's untimely demise to be exagerated.

It's back up. Hopefully for good now.

when i click "click here to join" it redirects me to login, are they not accepting new registrations?

You might be correct. I clicked Logout and then Click Here to Join and it does redirect to the same page again. I'm sure it'll be back up for new registrations as soon as the site is 100% back.

Agreed with OP.

Bitcoins are only useful for illegal activities, which is perfectly fine of course.

Anything else the U.S. Dollar will work just fine.

Why would it be useless for legal stuff?

IRL, I use Bitcoin and also have a Euro bank account. What's the method you would pick to transfer some funds to me?

Yes, why? I use it for legal purchases and find it far superior to credit cards, paypal, etc.
And for those who think it is perfect for illegal purchases, I hope you have done your homework. Bitcoin is NOT anonymous. It can be, if carefully done in conjunction with TOR and other methods.  I would guess that SR is constantly monitored by law enforcement. One day they are going to put all the data together and start rounding up customers.

Same here.  I've used it for many legal purchases.  The hard part about bitcoin commerce is getting the bitcoins in the first place.  Everything else is easy.


I don't doubt the former, but I do doubt the latter.  Certainly users and vendors will occasionally screw up and break their autonomy, but users have to be fairly tech and privacy savvy just to get onto Silk Road.  These guys are certainly not the "low hanging fruit" of the illicit drug trade.  Most of them would be as hard to prosecute as to locate.  How often do you hear of some rich, educated kid getting busted with drugs?  It's not like they don't buy it, they just deal with a smarter class of criminal.

Your probably right. It would be a complex case, and they would likely go after the sellers if anyone.
I'm not even sure what SR could be charged with? since they do not sell the drugs themselves.

The Silk Road is awesome. It is a true freemarket of goods and services. I hope it grows with new products and services

Bitcoin already is quite big. It takes at least a week to figure the thing out, yet has become the worlds largest distributed computing network in its two years of existence.

Silk Road is a good service but it would be better if there were several decent markets on the go. I know there is Black Market but it's pretty sparse there. More competition can only be a good thing!

If somebody could link me to SR forums plox

There's a link from the Silk Road main page here, but you have to be on Tor to get to it:  http://ianxz6zefk72ulzz.onion/