Bitcoin Forum

Hi Bitcoiners!

Is there a wallet for Ledger Nano S than Live Manager (It doesn't support my current android device version) that support or shows both segwit and legacy transactions? I tried Mycelium and it is only showing Legacy (I based on the date, I'm not that technical in Bitcoin yet). I also tried Citowise and it only shows Segwit (again based on the date). The problem is that I don't see my total hodlings.

As far as I remember, CoPay (https://github.com/bitpay/copay/releases/tag/v5.3.1) also supports hardware wallets, but I have never used it so I can't tell you more details. What's your android version?

Can confirm, it works on Copay as I've tried it in the past. But yea, don't even try looking it up on the Google Play Store OP, as it isn't there due to a vulnerability in the past(it's fixed now though).

https://github.com/bitpay/copay/releases

I think Mycelium will show both Legacy AND SegWit... (Unfortunately I'm away from home today and don't have my Ledger with me to double check). Mine is currently only setup to show the SegWit account at the moment.

So, fairly sure it'll do both... It's just that they won't show in the same "account" within Mycelium, as they use different derivation paths. This is basically the same way that Ledger Live works... Legacy and SegWit are separated.

So, while you would see the balance of both and they'd be separate balances, but Mycelium does also show a "Total Balance" that sums up all accounts.

I'm using android version 6.0. That's why I can't use Ledger Live on android.


I tried Copay already. It shows only new transactions, I think that is segwit only.


Really? I'm currently using Mycelium to monitor new transactions as they are segwit. I think segwit is the default. How do I re-import my Ledger showing the legacy balances?

I use Ledger Manager live in desktop and all transactions there are in total not separated. Is it the same with Ledger Manager for android?

Ok, so I've just checked this... and within Mycelium, all of my Ledger transactions, both "Legacy" and "SegWit", show in the same Mycelium account. When I click "receive", I can select the address type as "Legacy (P2PKH)", "Segwit compatible (P2SH)" and "SegWit native (Bech32)".

However, in Ledger Live... these transactions and addresses are divided between my "Bitcoin 1" account and "Bitcoin 1 (legacy)" accounts... Bitcoin 1 == SegWit "P2SH" addresses/transactions (ie. 3-type addresses)... Bitcoin 1 (legacy) == Legacy addresses/transactions (1-type addresses).

When I was setting up Ledger Live and setting up the "accounts"... It automatically detected the "legacy" and "segwit" accounts and created them as separate accounts (separate balance, separate transaction lists etc)


Really? ??? As I said above, my old "legacy" transactions and newer "segwit" transactions display in separate accounts with separate transaction histories.

https://talkimg.com/images/2023/11/15/zBk48.png

I will check this out later when I get a hand on my Ledger.


Yes, In my ledger manager desktop, it shows in one account. There are transaction from 2018 that never shown in Mycelium. That is why I suspected they are legacy transactions.

@HCP thank you! I just tried right now and it works. It shows both legacy and Segwit transaction. Show that it is now Segwit compatible in Mycelium. Not sure what happened, but I am sure I added it the same way::) anyway its working now! So thank you!

I'd advise everyone to stay away from CoPay/BitPay. They've become way too unreliable these days. The PC wallet glitches every time and I have to restore from backup everytime it loads.