|
Title: BTC Instant Sell vs Sell Order Post by: NeonFlash on November 10, 2011, 03:24:45 PM I wanted to know which is better to go ahead with? I am new to Tradehill. Till date, I was mostly mining and accumulating the Bitcoins. However, seeing the drop in prices of Bitcoin at a steady rate, I decided to go ahead and start selling them.
I noticed two options on the Tradehill Site for selling bitcoins. One being Instant Sell and other Sell Order. How well does Sell order work? If the current price of Bitcoin in market is 2.8 USD, what's the maximum sensible price to ask for while selling? Any points worth keeping in mind while going for the Sell option? Title: Re: BTC Instant Sell vs Sell Order Post by: avoid3d on November 10, 2011, 03:28:01 PM A sell order will only sell when people are prepared to buy at your price.
A market order will execute immediately at the current price people are willing to buy at. Since you are 'timing the market' why don't you rather decide when the price is right and execute a 'market' order. Title: Re: BTC Instant Sell vs Sell Order Post by: the joint on November 11, 2011, 08:31:39 AM Keep in mind that if you choose "instant sell," make sure that the quoted price is what you expected it to be. I made the amateur mistake a while back of assuming that the quoted BTC/$ price would hold for all of the coins I sold. Rather, the quoted BTC/$ refers to the highest bid.
Title: Re: BTC Instant Sell vs Sell Order Post by: avoid3d on November 11, 2011, 12:35:42 PM Neonflash, you are the one who asked for advice on how to sell 3BTC hey :)
this is the difference: If the price of USD/Bitcoins is 5$ per bitcoin: you market sell: you get 5$ per bitcoin you sell order: you set the minimum amount that you are willing to get per bitcoin and when the market moves to your price (i.e. the exchange rate moves to your price) the coins will sell if that never happens they will never sell Title: Re: BTC Instant Sell vs Sell Order Post by: deepceleron on November 11, 2011, 01:37:08 PM Keep in mind that if you choose "instant sell," make sure that the quoted price is what you expected it to be. I made the amateur mistake a while back of assuming that the quoted BTC/$ price would hold for all of the coins I sold. Rather, the quoted BTC/$ refers to the highest bid. That's not quite right regarding how instant sell works (or how it should work, maybe the bids changed right before you pressed "OK"). Lets look at an example, using an example order book of how many BTC different buyers want and how much they want to pay:
When you get a quote for an instant sell, Tradehill looks at all bids currently up and calculates how much you would get. Above, you see the first buyer wants to pay $2.88, but only wants 1 BTC at that price, so if you sold 1 BTC, it would quote you 1x$2.88. If you wanted to instant sell 25 BTC, then 1 BTC would go to the first buyer, and 24 would go to the second buyer, making the calculated earnings 1x$2.88 + 24x$2.875=$71.88, an average $2.8752 per BTC. If you wanted to sell 45 BTC, the quoted price would involve all five sellers, and would get you even less per BTC. Then you have ~5 seconds to press OK to execute the quoted sale. If instead you put in a market order to sell 25 BTC @ $2.88, you don't get a quote. What would happen is 1 BTC would instantly sell to the first buyer. However, the remaining 24 would be added to the 'Ask' order book for later sale. They would remain unsold until more buyers want to buy BTC at $2.88 or higher and submit new bids. If you put in an order priced above any current bids, say at $3.10, no BTC would sell right now. Instead, your complete order will be added to the ask book, and would not sell until the market price went up to your price (and others sellers may have lower-priced sell orders ahead of you). If you've been hanging on to your BTC this long (and seen the price you could have gotten for them go from 10->5->3), you may want to put in a higher sell order than the current price and wait; miner desperation to sell your hard-mined coins is what drives the price down. BTW, an instant sell is essentially the same thing as putting in a normal order, but with your price as $0.001. It will sell as many BTC as you ask, no matter how low the final price goes. Title: Re: BTC Instant Sell vs Sell Order Post by: the joint on November 12, 2011, 05:58:07 AM Keep in mind that if you choose "instant sell," make sure that the quoted price is what you expected it to be. I made the amateur mistake a while back of assuming that the quoted BTC/$ price would hold for all of the coins I sold. Rather, the quoted BTC/$ refers to the highest bid. That's not quite right regarding how instant sell works (or how it should work, maybe the bids changed right before you pressed "OK"). Lets look at an example, using an example order book of how many BTC different buyers want and how much they want to pay:
When you get a quote for an instant sell, Tradehill looks at all bids currently up and calculates how much you would get. Above, you see the first buyer wants to pay $2.88, but only wants 1 BTC at that price, so if you sold 1 BTC, it would quote you 1x$2.88. If you wanted to instant sell 25 BTC, then 1 BTC would go to the first buyer, and 24 would go to the second buyer, making the calculated earnings 1x$2.88 + 24x$2.875=$71.88, an average $2.8752 per BTC. If you wanted to sell 45 BTC, the quoted price would involve all five sellers, and would get you even less per BTC. Then you have ~5 seconds to press OK to execute the quoted sale. If instead you put in a market order to sell 25 BTC @ $2.88, you don't get a quote. What would happen is 1 BTC would instantly sell to the first buyer. However, the remaining 24 would be added to the 'Ask' order book for later sale. They would remain unsold until more buyers want to buy BTC at $2.88 or higher and submit new bids. If you put in an order priced above any current bids, say at $3.10, no BTC would sell right now. Instead, your complete order will be added to the ask book, and would not sell until the market price went up to your price (and others sellers may have lower-priced sell orders ahead of you). If you've been hanging on to your BTC this long (and seen the price you could have gotten for them go from 10->5->3), you may want to put in a higher sell order than the current price and wait; miner desperation to sell your hard-mined coins is what drives the price down. BTW, an instant sell is essentially the same thing as putting in a normal order, but with your price as $0.001. It will sell as many BTC as you ask, no matter how low the final price goes. Yeah, that. |