Bitcoin Forum

Guys, do you know good trading chats where traders share their ideas, discuss trading and so on? I know some in russian telegram, but wanna join english speaking community.

Also, how do you think if it is worth creating my own chat for traders? I see a lot of high rank members leaving comments on my topics and I see here some guys making market review on daily basis.
A lot of clever community members. As for me, trading is my passion and I have russian telegram channel where I give my thoughts on market and entry points with stop losses.

Can we cooperate to discuss trading, sharing some experience? Tell me your thoughts.

UPD:
Based on feedback I will try to create healthy community and let's see if it works
Guys, I don't want you to buy something from me, let's discuss trading .  In pinned message I've described my experience, road from 0.1 to 4btc, road from 100$ to 5000$ and comission cashback offer.
Here is link @golstrim_trade

Not too much focused with telegram chats and i do rather like to hangout with TradingView Chat (https://www.tradingview.com/chat/#bitcoin) with Bitcoin.
When im bored or do look up for someone to discussed with i do always go with this chat or even the WO (https://bitcointalk.org/index.php?topic=178336.0) thread is already enough for me in terms with discussion towards bitcoin and other related stuffs.I do like the place and soothes out my tense with trading if i do read up those memes.  :D

Why not? Go and have your telegram channel right away. It will cost you nothing but will be beneficial to many traders and trading aspirants if you share good tips and guiding new traders accordingly. You may announce your telegram channel in our service sub board and also you may earn for your trading calls from on that by selling subscriptions.

I wonder when trading is your passion, how do you manage to find time to spend for such chat activities. Because, when you are good at your analysis then you might be too bust at your trading. Yes, this is how most traders are doing and this is the reason we are not getting "proper" chat channels for discussing trading related things.

I joined some trading channels in Telegram and Discord maintained mostly by crypto twitter accounts.
- TA Discussion by The Boot https://t.me/TheBootTADiscussion
- TraderX Discord https://discord.gg/wcyJn8Z

As long as you can provide value (i.e. trading education, tipping some good calls, etc), why not? I'm not (yet) a good trader myself but I really like reading other's thought processes and decision making on a trade.

Chatbox in the exchanges are often sharing ideas, there is yobit and hitbtc where traders can chat. Its not however going to end well when someone is always there to post something different like fud and shilling will interrupt you. Information in Telegram channels came from them, unless you trust them so much you can follow the signals. 

Crypto still is in the wild west era, there is never a chance that the era will end even when regulations are here. I have joined some trading chats where they share which are going to be pumped but it was never really that true that they are the ones pumping.

Give it a try if you're willing to spend time and exert an effort to do it. You could make a Telegram channel to communicate with traders. Sharing thoughts with traders would help you make firm decisions in trading in the future. It will also be better if you'll make an educational trading channel where beginners could learn the basic strategies.
Just be mindful of sharing information about crypto and make sure that it would not cause confusion to traders that will join your channel.

Theres a lot of group in telegram and discord that share their ideas and chart plotting by the way I'm using tradingview and tabtrader to monitor the price action of cryptocurrency you che k it and have a try to experience this chatting tools.

Does the exchange you're using not have a built in chat? It's a good place to get into discussions about different coins if they do. However, watch out for trolls. They don't call it the trollbox for nothing! There will be people trying to sell you on crap just because they have sell orders in that they want filled. But, you can find some intelligent people in the chats of exchanges. Just make sure that they seem like they may actually know what they're talking about and you'll be fine.

Also, Twitter isn't a bad place to get into discussions about trading. Just look for a big signal group making posts on there. There will be discussions about their picks in the comments of every Tweet.

Some of the Trading telegram channels and discussion groups are @crypto_trading_signal_group (https://web.telegram.org/#/im?p=@crypto_trading_signal_group), @whalepoolbtc (https://web.telegram.org/#/im?p=@whalepoolbtc), @CryptoSignals_Discussion (https://web.telegram.org/#/im?p=@CryptoSignals_Discussion), @binanceexchange (https://web.telegram.org/#/im?p=@binanceexchange) etc. You can join any of these telegram groups.

These trading discussions are just for reference. You need to know many things about trading analysis and need a lot of research before trading any coins.

There is lot of community out there, most of these kinds of the community can be found on discord or telegrams.
But before this, you should first know some advantages and disadvantages of joining these kinds of group chats.
You can encounter some disadvantages like; shitcoin shillers, scammers or maybe some fake accounts just pretending to be someone (this case is really spreading on telegram) so be careful.
Advantages are really lot especially when you can communicate and mingle with other traders out there like you can share your Technical Analysis (TA).
Try to search in Telegram: Mystery Wave, they have a different channel for Bitcoin & Ethereum technical analysis discussion and altcoin discussion.

As far as i know these "trading chats" are nothing but pump and dump groups that try to screw it's members over and over. If it's not that, you'll find yourself in a group full of scams and ICO advertisements. If you ask me you'll be better off reading trading tips on these forums or on reddit.

You just need to be more specific on what you want to know and post the topic. If it makes sense then people with sense will reply and converse with you.

That was depend of what group you join and not all of them is only for crypto signal and pump and dump  group in telegram . I am member of facebook chat group for  traders .but after the bear market season that group has been quiet and in active maybe because there  are many members has been lost so much for trading .

in my experience chats and channels are always filled with a lot of spam and bad advice because people always end up suggesting their bags of shitcoin which is losing value to others to encourage them into buying them so that they could dump it themselves. the best thing i have seen so far which isn't that good (best among bads) is tradingview website.
in the end when it comes to trading everyone is on his own. it is a dog eat dog market.

I don't think chatting too much will help our experience increase or get a good revenue. We should be silent to practice, which is the experience that gives you instead of much discussion to get new ideas in trading.

I think chat groups like that are mostly found around us but of many groups, some are unclear spam groups. My advice anyway, you better join an international trade community, usually they have a chairman or moderator so that chat group is directed.

Next, I found a blog that discusses a number of chat groups, indeed most of it is paid but certainly paid groups ones have far better quality than free. The point is those who are in it experienced people and you can exchange ideas about trading.
https://tradingreview.net/best-day-trading-chat-rooms/
https://www.benzinga.com/money/best-trading-chat-rooms/

I'll add one more vouch for the TradingView chat. It's a good place to gauge market sentiment, get feedback on your trading ideas, challenge your biases with other peoples' charts, etc. It's got a great UI for chart sharing. I learned a lot there in my earlier days and I've also met some great people in there who I still keep in touch with.

Unfortunately they changed it from "Bitcoin" to "Cryptocurrencies" a couple years ago and the content somewhat reflects that. For some of you, that's probably a good thing though.

Why do people think that chat to get ideas for trading is good? I think this is similar to showing the weakness of new traders.
Yes, we need to improve our experience to be successful and better, but for this field, chat is never good because there are many traps. I have witnessed one person enticing a lot of new people to buying BQQQ tokens at a fixed price, because there is not enough liquidity on the exchange for him to sell all of them at a good price. He said that the price of BQQQ will soon grow and entice people to buy and after only 3 months, the price of BQQQ will fall from $ 0.012 -> $ 0.0008.
This is a proof that we should not believe or chat with strangers.

I don't think you will get the right information related to the chat,  because many groups are not shared base on their analysis. But they share the other people's analysis of their groups and pretending they do that to make sure their members. Besides that, I don't think you will find other information from the chat in the exchanges because they spread the news that will give benefits to them. It is better to stay away from that and only search or analysis by yourself so that you can avoid the scam.

I don't like using this feature when an exchange have this, I always having trouble on back reading the important conversation because it is getting flooded by nonsense chat sometimes. A Telegram group chat is really good compare to what you have said, anytime you could go back and reread what you want to reread, there is no hassle because you could take your time reading and the conversation is still there.

Unlike in exchanges, when you logged out and log in, a new set on conversation is in the chat panel, it is annoying to be honest.

Are you going to ask for payment from members who enter the channel or is it absolutely free.

A couple years ago I join telegram channel which share about entry points and so on, but he separately the channel in two group free and paid channel, and he collected more money from paid channel compared his trading profit  :) and I decided to leave the channel, start to learn by myself about trading

There are lots of groups on Telegram for traders. You just need to be careful with some though so they don't make you trade like newbies or make you lose confidence in your trading abilities/skills. 
I think if you Google "telegram groups for cryptocurrency traders" you will find lots of them. Some of the groups I knew back in 2017/2018 are probably quiet now due to the poor state of altcoins.

There are many trading chat channels over internet for trading discussion of cryptocurrencies,forex market and other financial products. Some of channels are charging fee for giving their trading calls and some channels offer free services but not all of these channels are legit, you cannot blindly take their calls and  trade based on it. Anyone can join and check trading calls/discussion for some days, if it is worth taking just go for it else leave the channel, even many paid trading channels are providing free services for days , one can subscribe those channels to check trading discussion /calls.

I personally make decisions in trading assisted by telegram trading channels, because no matter how great our analysis
as traders need input from others. So in making decisions can minimize mistakes. If indeed you have the ability and willingness
to form trading chat channels on telegrams, please just make it. But do not forget it is not easy to manage it, not until it is neglected.
Because managing chat trading channels takes time more. Moreover, channels with members of the community speak English and are free of charge,
which can later be joined from the whole world. And means active for 24 hours. It's very hard to manage. Try to think carefully, my advice is the same
others try to join the discussion in the free chat channels in the telegram or the discussion in the chatroom in each exchanges. But remember
don't trust 100% with a shared signal, learn the signal first. We wish you success in trading, because of me also really like trading. ;D

You need to sort things out as this telegram group mostly shares tips and ideas of coins that they've already holding. It's very important to anyone who want to benefit from those tips. You need to go deep and do your research before following  those tips. By doing that, you are adding knowledge and good chance to your invested funds to grow. Pay attention and never  stop learning. Don't be careless in following, you should be wise because if you're not,  you will only just  put your investment at big risk.

These telegram trading chats actually come in forms, some are basically signal groups those ones just create FOMO and dump the coins. Another being a normal chat community where users just share tgeyr ideas on trading, tops on how to be successful and stuffs like that. There are actually many of these in telegram already, available in different languages.

usually trading chat is only used for other traders to pump or dump even from group chat can make other traders panic by giving bad news, although like that sometimes we can also be affected by other traders, must remain vigilant when you are in chat like that.

Really appreciate! Will learn all of them. If you have something more, share with me and I will try it for sure.

I mostly margin trader and I am interested in liquid assets and short term trades, scalping

You should find a traders discussion group that other traders sharing ideas .
Pump and dump group is not really helpful you may be lost if you will follow every thing they  say on that group.

 Do Not to follow  individual trades just to earn learn others strategy try if that strategy will work on you, if not then learn new things that can help you in trading.

World is not as good as we assume it is. I would suggest to never join such channel. Reason? Most of such channels are created with hidden conspiracy. They will act like they are giving some valuable suggestions but in reality they will suggest you coins which they already bought at lower price. And when price will pump due to large number of people buying such coins on their words, they dump their coins making profits.

Well, firstly I don't want to pump or dump something, these P&D schemes are for newbies ready to lose money. Once I've participated in pump on yobit, although I knew about risks, I've tried just for experience. I lost all of my money, so stay away from pumps. What I want to create is community, some networking with other traders, sharing experience and so on

As for reddit, it is not for me. I am not that guy searching for memes. I know that major part of english speaking audience in crypto community use reddit instead of telegram.
But it is hard for me to feel whole culture of reddit and be a part of it

I have not yet met a chat in which I would be interested in the opinion of each participant. As a rule, too many newbie traders “clog” the chat with their analyzes and questions.
I don’t blame them, they do everything right, but I’m not interested in such a chat. I would like to see something where most traders have rich experience behind them.
Even if in such a chat it would be forbidden to comment on people without experience, it is always useful to observe the work of professionals.

Ok, but if you are good enough, then share your own ideas on market movements and people will appreciate it and your reputation will grow. Nobody is making you to listen other people, but why don't you share own ideas and go networking?

Yes, please do it and we'll see how it goes.
I've seen the telegram group now have 4 members, hopefully, it will grow shortly.


Telegram chat groups can be arranged in such a way to prevent spam and people who promote shitcoins.
For group administrator should apply some features to prevent members from posting specific kinds of content such as disable send media, add users, send sticker and gifs, embed links, polls, and change chat info. If the group has so many members, admin can prohibit spammers to send messages in the group, just disable "send messages" for any members you want, so they will remain silent.

Troll and fudder, i think that 2  kind of people will always come. Maybe trading chat will only filled with people who already bought a coin and make it hype. Or maybe fudder to get the coin in cheap price. Really need to filter people who want to join so you can get healthy community and will make benefit for all members.

Those channels are mostly for affecting people or having benefits over the others through paid things etc. Wallstreet brokers aren't here, they are not on telegram as well. You don't share if something is really working. As far as I can see, these channels say that if bitcoin breaks out 8000, it will become 8001 or if it breaks down, it will become 7999 :) They provide the resistance and support levels and say similar things to above.

Speaking about brokers, who knows how experienced they are. And don't mix brokers and traders, it is absolutely different!

You know, while btc was around 12000 Goldman Sachs made a report , like BTC is going to brake 13500. At the same time I told my subscribers in public that BTC is going to 8500 and below.
We have made a challenge out of it.

So I was right, what would you say on that matter, фre Wall street guys those you can trust to?

Some in chat never really share their learnings or if they will share there might be a reason for sharing maybe an influencer or have some job related in crypto. Better do research on some advise given, but never do it right away without studying or double checking it even if it came from exchanges. Chat box sometimes use to impress or to create hype.

One way or another, any chat on the stock exchange spreading empty chatter and the main goal of all these conversations is to mislead their competitors.  In some cases, speculators get a large percentage of the profit due to the fact that they caused a stir in the chat rooms, which was reacted by newcomers or traders with little experience.

Although I sounds like a broken radio here but, don't risk yourselves in asking in telegram groups what to trade. Believe me, I joined many TG groups that lead me to danger. The first time is was when I have .005 btc and then there was a call in trade I won .002 btc that because I all in'd. Then after the next trades the balance became 0.

It is good to have healthy discussion with others because that way a person comes to know many things and discovers how others look at something. Two minds are always better than a single one and there is always one more thing to learn. Like you said, it is a give and take community. You share knowledge, experiences, ideas and opinions, and these all help in becoming a good investor, especially in bitcoin market.

In that case, it would be best to not only discuss your ideas and problems with others here but also do some research on your own. That way you will learn more than simply relying on what others say. Such forums are best for knowing the latest news and the predictions for next peak. Being honest, when majority here is of the opinion that we will be having a rise soon, it literally happens. Bitcoin is a precious asset so one must do most on his own.

I remembered joining a discord group wherein they shared their knowledge about trading (A local group). I have started from there, basic technical analysis with simple terms for us to easily understand it, helped me a lot. It works, I assure you that. But what disappointed me is that one user make a scam to the other users. I left the group already.

Also, if you feel of creating your group chat with significant use and purpose, go for it. Telegram channel is widely used by many and nothing will lose if you'll pursue it. I will follow you and will share also my knowedge in technical analysis. Shared ideas will be great in making a profitable trades. Best of luck, bro.

Yes, but I don't like these troll boxes. Also in telegram we are closer to each other, can dm, share charts and so on. In troll boxes everyday new members appear and I don't like it.

By the way we have like 5 members in our chat right now. Not so much, but I'am not going to create big group

If someone really gives an example of the fact that exchange chat has benefited him, then I can change my attitude towards them.  Any questions that arise regarding the exchange, I solve in telegram chats or on the help channel.  But exchange chat is strangers who still need to learn to trust, and trusting a stranger is a big risk.

There are some threads on speculation sections with predictions charts with everyday update,you can watch that threads for price charts with an explanation but remember no one is going to tell you exact predictions and not possible to do so don't give too much attention to other's prediction.

There is a ton of trading chats. I echo the sentiment of others in commending the TradingView chat, it is one of the most entertaining chatrooms in regards to crypto speculation there is, and probably one of the most active as well.

My problem with Telegram chats is that most of them quickly turn into just a shill breeding ground for a particular altcoin that the admin/mods are sponsored by, or it doesn't encapsulate sufficient opinions from a true cross section of traders so that it creates sort of an echo chamber.

There probably isn't a lot of value to be had either by creating an entirely new chat, because you'll likely not attract any seasoned traders per se. If you enjoy it and don't mind putting in the effort for probably little to no reward, then go ahead. Otherwise, just hop onto tradingview.

I too was looking for the same thing previously. But i found that you don't want to join discord or telegram groups -- these are just full of spam, scams, and ICO advertisments. What you want is to follow well known traders and learn or even trade based on their advise. And for this, i've found that sites like TradingView or Investagrams are quite useful. I usually guage market sentiment through these websites and sometimes along with popular crypto news websites like Cointelegraph.

You could create your own trading chat group in Telegram or in messenger. This is good as it everyone will learn thru sharing of ideas and some vital information that could help anyone to improve from the group. For now, there are already existing trading chat group in the telegram then its up to you if you want to join them.

I haven't seen those threads. For sure I don't seek for a magic pillow and I like to make my own predictions rather than watch on someone else analysis. Anyway these conversations would be healthy for all members.

1 member entered in chat yesterday and he had an experience of working with big institutionals, so he described me how things are going there with very strict multiple level structure in taking decisions, higher risk management. So his experience is also beneficial for me, I learn something new from these conversations

I used to be a member of a similar chat but I left it. First, it seemed to be helpful but then I realized that it was more of a distraction. In such chats, in addition to useful information, you read constant pointless conversations and receive stupid memes. So currently I replaced it by a bot that informs me about important crypto news and price changes – https://t.me/CexIoInfoBot. It is both more helpful and less distractive.

Guys check out this review https://neironix.io/news/researches/how_the_breakeven_level_of_mining_allows_one_to_determine_the_pivot_point_of_bitcoin

what do you think is it possible to trade at break-even levels of miners. It seems to me an interesting thing, because coincides with the levels of classical technical analysis.

So before joining a group trading chat, you should know the identity of the members who you want to have a conversation about. Trading is very complex and critical, it is not easy because you need to understand every detail in the process of transactions. Group chats are helpful in some way but they are also dangerous to use because of what you've said SCAMMERS. So that's the main reason why you should seek information first.

Try to make some friends online then create a group, don't rely too much on telegram chat as there lots of fudders out their.
Actually trading chats in telegram with a big numbers is not idea, just take for example the Binance telegram chat, I think there are a lot of legit users their but I am not getting the information I need to improve my trading ability.

You wont be scammed if you dont pull out some money in your pocket.You can observed and your common sense would tell you if theres something wrong with the group.
You can differentiate out if the said group do have fake members or just simply asking for some premium subscription but if you do able to see that they are sharing their own
valid ideas and analysis then it isnt bad to have a second look and it might be also helpful into your own analysis too.

I doubt if there are legit group chat for trading nowadays since most group chats on telegram are fake and is intended for giving fake trading signals. But i agree that we have to look for a few similarities of a fake trading signals group and be cautious because earning money nowadays is hard.

I am looking with all chat box on exchange market to start trading and give me source which one good coin for investing, almost exchange market have box or conversation chat for every investor want to start trading, some one want to make you panic to buy or sell an altcoin and some one give us good recommendation which one coin have to buy and get profit.

I think using the chat box in the market is not good, because my experience many people there actually just want the coin to be bought not as a true guide, but only for their own interests. and as far as I know the chat box on the market is a place to make fomos, so sometimes beginners are made panic.

Its a great idea. I've never been to trading chat yet. Well I read some trading ideas and comments but not really into chatting live. Its better you pursue it to have many options to look into about trading. Trading chat is somehow a good social interaction and  directly you can have answer to your questions from expert people.

If he's really telling the truth that he  turned 0.1 BTC in 4 BTC within 2 weeks then, good for him and I would be happy for him as this is not an easy thing to do, but as for me, won't go and invest to him as I doubt he really wanted to help people, his purpose seems just to use their fund for his own benefit most, well, still respect for him as he made a good job if it's real.

Those trading chats are almost same to other bot chats because there are no free to earn money in trading and same as they predict price in the market they should follow.

Yes I have seen a chatbox in yobit as well, in there you may able to see many traders talking about the coins that they are hodling and some of them will convince you to buy yours too, you may see some trade tips over there but there are some FUD too, better to learn to read charts  candlestick and read news in twitter , it will help you more rather than joining chats.

But let's also be reminded that most of the time, there were also paid fake traders just trying to do fomo and hype in some exchanges, so let's not rely on them, and don't believe in everything they are saying, especially if they are saying that they found out source or they have a whale friend that told them they will pump the price of this certain coin.