Bitcoin Forum

I just want to join paid crypto trading group..anyone pls tell me ,this type of group doing scam or not? and does it work?

Follow their free channel and see how good their calls are (follow with 1%-5% of your portfolio). If they do well you should, only then, consider joining them (after a week or a month of following).

All trading is risky and you might want to follow what they suggest to trade by looking at a chart as some get paid to advertise buying coins that have just pumped or are about to the minute the person gave the call (as in groups and whales admins compound what they have and buy the start to push the price up leaving their users - and the market - to keep the price inflated while they cash out). Which means it's a good idea to check for common scam trends in the area.

Also don't custodian your crypto to anyone and don't use a bot unless you're confident in its functions.

If you lucky, you will find a legit group, obviously not a financial advice but not a pump and dump group too. If you joined in a pump & dump group, you will ended up losing your money because they are trying to scam you by their pump and then after you bought the token on top, they will dump it immediately.

yes I agree with what you said, if you are curious, you better try it first, and it proves or even makes you lose the value of your portfolio. because as far as we can see, such groups cannot be found for free. if any, it is very difficult to filter which ones are really profitable. a group filled with great people and analysis, should have a price in every piece of information they share. so if it makes you feel confused, try to learn to read the price movements according to your needs. start learning the basics.

I would like to say is that you just be careful. I don't want to draw a conclusion that crypto trading groups are scammy or it never works. I don't have any experience with them because there are so many groups like this but as we heard most, they can't be trusted nor their trading signals is effective.

But it's up to you to try then, that gonna be a sort of experience and so it helps your awareness. But for me, I have to use my own TA, because the reality is that, no one could predict right for the future happening. All these signal are just the same if we do ourselves, it can be right or even wrong. 

There's no shortcut to success. Why waste money on paid signals, yet there's a lot of information out there on how you can also learn how to trade, carry out technical analysis and make a higher percentage of right calls in your trades?
Why depend on someone for fish every time you are hungry, yet you can also teach yourself how to fish?  ;)

Most paid signals are scam. I wouldn't even spend a cent on them. Instead, I would use the "subscription fees" as my capital to gain more experience in trade.

You do not have to pay crypto trading group as you can find many free crypto trading groups at the telegram.
But you do not know which groups can teach you about trading and give the coin's signal to buy or sell, and that is hard to get the right group.
I suggest you learn trading by yourself and search for many lessons from many sources, so you can trade without using their signal.
But you can use their signal to analyze and find more information about the coin movements, so you can find the time to trade and you can use it for your own benefits.

There are scams, and there are legitimate ones.

And with the legitimate ones— there are ones that are actually profitable to some extent, and there are others that are simply just bad(which is mostly the case).

Should you pay for them? Completely up to you, and though I'm personally not a fan of them, probably try for 1 month? If the price of 1 month membership doesn't cost that much that you don't mind wasting that 1 month payment, then go ahead and try for yourself. Just to get an idea on how a "trading signal" group (which are mostly just pump and dump groups) work.

It can be a free or paid group but the final results depend on a person who uses given signals.

• Not all users follow given signals. When group operator gives good signals to slowly accumulate at bottom price, for days receivers might ignore signals. They will join and FOMO when price is rising.
• Risk management: @jackg gives a good point. You have to beware of the risk and avoid to use all or most of your capital for trading.
• Don't trade too much with low cap altcoins. Again altcoins are risky but low cap altcoins are much more risky
• A good group can give you 90 good signals per 100 total signals. If you are in 10 bad signals or 1 to a few with all of your capital. You are loser whilst most members of the group ends with profit

Personally, to be dependent in your thoughts and decisions, you should not join groups.

thanks for information.

---

You are right..Thanks for information.

---

thank u.

[moderator's note: consecutive posts merged]

It is depends on your paid group strength and true policies. Mostly beginners are try to analyse our own method and join some free telegram groups, Reddit news and youtube analytics. Because these kind of social media is truly improve the trading method, once you understanding well in crypto trading automatically you can start day trading in crypto platform.

Definitely, considering paid trading signal is not a bad ideas and had helped so many new traders as well, but before venturing, have a thorough investigation on the channel to be a legitimate one to avoid been scammed on the way. Also there are some significant rules to follow when in trading signal
1. Never use all your portfolio to purchase one coin when  notified.
2. Always trail your profit when a trade goes to your favour using OTC order.
3. Be smart enough to set up stop loss and take profit when due.
4. Not all notified coin given by the provider should be traded, do some diligent research too.

Scam mostly. It doesn't work.
Don't waste your money paying those crypto trading groups that say they'll send you a signal. What they do is going to send you an altcoin to be bought by you for you to help them pump it.
There's really no signal about it, what they do is organized pump and dump and what's worse is when you're left behind.

Crypto signal group/channels are just pure scam as wildly followers get rekt by taking trade on those signals and signal providers get huge profit on those signals as they take early entry before giving those signals. So, it's better to take trades on any coins/tokens according to major events if anyone don't have so much knowledge of analyzing any charts or don't have enough time to monitor those. But anyone can increase their trading skill by understanding charts from those signal providers and asking yourselft like: "what indicators are bullish for that coin/tokens or why that coin/token will be pump according to TA/FA?.... etc. So, it's always been a better option to do trades with own skill instead of following other signals, IMHO.

You shared very helpful opinion about Telegram crypto signal channel and i agree with your Opinion and as my opinion before investment or Trading, need 1 week analysis about following telegram channel's all signal then Trading will best for my opinion.                 

There’s a lot of free signal on twitter which is more effective based on their past analysis. Once you got the signal, you still have to analyze it for your own benefit so I don’t suggest to fully depend on any trading signal because that’s risky. If you’re willing to paid for any signal, better to use it for you to learn and analyze on your own.

Right, and I would say majority is really doing it to scam, specially newbies. And this is not new, I've seen that this kind of scheme grow during the bull run of 2017, and now they are back at it again. Of course, there are genuine trading signal groups, but I do think that it is a close-knit group, and probably almost all of them know each other personally so it's hard to enter on that group.

Not sure. but you need to chose a traditionally  and profetonally group .many time people lost and many time earn profit .if you join any paid group also need a agreement .i know some trading paid group but still not join.

Indeed. We don't know if that signal from other people can be right or they get the signal from others and share it on their social media. Whenever you get the signal from many sources, you must analyze it to find the truth because if you use it for trading, you don't know if that will give you a chance to make a profit. Analyzing more from the signal is the recommended thing that you must do after you got it. But I do not suggest paying for that signal because that is not worth it for you to trade. You can analyze by yourself, and what you need to do is believe in your skills. Make it as your lesson if you can't make a profit to increase your skills to better.

There are few is good but still you cannot rely for long term profitability so best advice we can give to you is not to buy those VIP signals offer and just avail the free provided since its also good to learn with those hints. Also try to learn trading since we don't have any excuse not to learn it since there are so many tutorials provided everywhere so best to start learning the basics now.

okay we can help you out but with one condition please tell us the name of that paid group that you are interested first for us to have an idea if the group sounds familiar or not . if not we can hunt information regarding with that group for you .
 if you want to know if all paid groups are scams the answer will be yes and no .
yes because they use the name paid group to attract subscribers that are willing to pay and not because they are offering a service and subscribers are going to pay for that .

I suggest you better avoid joining a paid crypto trading group, because it's better for trading to rely on your own abilities. If you follow other
people's trading signals, especially the paid ones you have to shell out first. Then your trading skills will never develop, and you will always
depend on other people. Even more frightening, not all paid crypto trading groups are legit, if you are not careful then you will become
a victim of fraud.

never believe in them , They are scammers lol.

You can only count in fingers those signal groups that is really doing their Job according to how much we are paying/
But majority are scammers and i'm sure it will take you long before finding the legit.
you will lose more money first before having one so why not just use those money in trading and learn from your own?

Cryptocurrency trading signal work and does not work because they usually post good signal at the beginning and after gaining your trust they will use you as prey and also as an instrument to pump the price of their die crypto.
In the meantime, the crypto signal is just another scam group scamming people by providing fake information and it better you follow whales/institution accumulation than join the group.

Most signal groups are scams. You will waste your time and money if you follow those channels. My suggestion is, you build your own trading skills, you will get much better results than following such signal groups. Now there is a lot of information about trading on the internet. If you can get that information properly, you will be able to build trading skills.

I say from my own experience, I have collected a lot of information from the internet which I have used to increase my trading knowledge. So don't waste your precious time looking for scam signal groups and use that time for good so that you can predict the movement of the market in the future.

It should be think deeper before paying those paid groups, assess yourself if what's your goal before entering this
kind of business.

Tradig is not as easy as many thinks as it is, even you have those paid signal there's no assurance that you'll gained
from it without personal knowledge, most of the time, you'll lose more than you possibly earn from this paid signals.

I advise you to not do it. It's just a payment that you might not learn anything or something. It's still best that you go into learning and paying for courses that could benefit you in the long run. You should make your own decisions and be aware with different possible trading strategies.

If you want, it's better to buy a trading tool that could benefit you continuously, like Gunbot (https://gunbot.ph).

You'll never know exactly if that really works or not, why not try? But don't be surprised how these trading signals and these people give you losses.

I may, I don't use them either but those who have the experience with this can say it was just a waste of time following them. Because that will be a true and reliable source, why not they use it by themselves? and why they need people to test it? There is something hidden with their back and that to get some prey and milking them.

Newbies are very vulnerable in their trick and that's why most of their targets are them. Every bull run, when most people are excited and wanting to be in the crypto market, I don't understand why it is the first thing that they think of. Making themselves want to have assurance through these pump and dump groups but they really don't know that let's say a few are legit but the majority of them are scams and will just take their cash telling them to buy a dead coin.

no surprise that the question is coming from the newbie. i hope he will learn a thing or two from all those suggestions and pieces of advice here. i joined a free crypto trading signal group before, just to see how it goes with them.
and realised that, they gave the signal when it was already too late for you. and you will end up buying the peak, and it means most of the time, those are their coins selling at a high price. and you will end up losing in the trade. so yeah, better learn the crypto trading and not trust these signal groups, whether paid or not. they will drain your money for their own gain.

We should be careful of trusting different groups that tried to help us. Much better to pick those people who's experience in analyzing with trading several coins. Never trust from any non reliable source, because scammers is really aggressive nowadays to deceive us. Personal coaching is important and that what I've been doing now, I seek advice from my friend who owned huge amount of capital in trading.

If their signals made you some profits then you are in the right group but in my opinion, this is just a pump and dump group that will make a fool of anyone who joins their group, also worth mentioning that these groups are pay to join which is fishy at best.

Some it works at first, but as they got your trust, it eventually changed.
I understand that we need to have a profitable and good experience in trading, and we are looking for someone who could help us. These people give you what you want but don't get disappointed as they were just making you lose that achieving your goal. It is a mistake asking for help from these people because they are just making you fool.

It will not be easy to follow their signals as what I know, the pump and dump will happen without we can detect unless they tell the right time. Even if you can follow their signals, you will hard to buy, hold, and sell at the right time because that means you need to watch the market closely and have a target price to sell. Without having that, I am afraid that you can buy at a high price and make you in the trap at the market. So I hope he can be careful if he joins in the signal trading groups.

A lot of trading tutorials online that could help us to understand how trading works but much better if someone, a friend of yours teaches you, not these groups of scammers. I don't understand why many were still asking for their services besides, we can still learn with them. Oh, these lazy people would like shortcuts and do whatever they say and lose. It surprises us neither because that actually will our future if we keep relying on these people.

Everything can possible if we work hard but it doesn't mean we need to force ourselves to become a trader if we find ourselves not fit this. It is better to let go and find another way to make money.

Unfortunately many of those people just give you "profitable" leads if they can, not because they won't. For example, the idea that "they will help you first and gain your trust and then they will take your money" means that they first need to know how to make a profit from trading, if they knew something like that they would actually make a profit from the crypto world non-stop, wouldn't even need you because they would be making a profit from it.

What they do however is that they share 10 things from a "secret" group and they will forward the only profitable ones to you showing how the secret group makes a profit and as soon as you get in, you will end up with losing money, which is why I think it is obvious that they do not know how to profit. So that means you should stay away from them even from the first moments, there is no reason to put money into those people.

Not a scam but i's completely illegal and might the SEC, IIRC were making an action if they know that there is a project that involves such activity due to that law was under by SEC.  That was also known as a "pump and dump" group scheme, but the most will get profit is the one who organized the group and might possible they are playing with all of you as a member, IMO.

So I suggest you avoid this group because there's a high possibility that they might lead you to a loss in trading.  You can trade on your own with the courage of proper research, there's no need to cheat in trading just to earn.  The paid trading group aren't long last, it will always exit altogether with your money.

Paid groups come in two forms, there are traders that know what they are doing and will give signals based on what the chart speaks to them and there are copy cats that will copy free/paid signals and post them as vip  signals and in the long term you will lose your funds so I might say there are legit and scam groups.

Yes they do but you won't always win trades! The best you could do is learn how to trade as an individual, not an easy journey though,good luck.

OP should avoid this pump and dump scheme, It would be bad if he joined on a paid trading signal service who are just literally doing this scheme. There are proper trading signal groups that offer their Technical analysis that supports their signal which for me is the right thing to do. But knowing how to trade yourself and knows how to create and read the TA of others will greatly help. Groups that give TA signals work and you can use it to gain more knowledge in trading along the way on your journey on making yourself an independent trader.

My suggestion is for you that don't join any paid Crypto trading group. They just business. This type of group signal don't work properly. Start trading by yourself. Start slowly. Start acquiring knowledge about coin. Spend time to get knowledge. Hope you do well.

Trading signal works well, if the crypto trading group admins are very competent traders; you should be aware that not all of their calls would be right and this is why you always have to use stop loss to keep yourself in check and limit your losses. There are fraudulent signal groups; and there are free signal groups. I am not a fan of paying for signals, do your research, learn trading, use signals and stay safe.

I have always hated these things, you know how they work and you know why they "should" work technically and we all know why they will not work as well and that bothers me. I know that crypto is a great trading deal and we make profit from it, indicators and strategies and TA all done and giving you signals when something is hit, like let's say BB drops under 20 so it gives a signal to buy etc etc, but none of these are guaranteed to work. Whereas signals are shared like they are "guaranteed", most telegram signal groups basically promote themselves like they are amazing and that is why there is a problem in that ecosystem.

If it was "these are warnings" type of deal, that would have been great, I would have liked signals, but the reality is that they are not marketed that way, they are not warnings they are suggestions according to people who build them.

That's how most of them work, they'll give you signals and if it's free, don't expect that you'll have a good signal because it's free. What you should be thinking is that why they're giving it for free. It's already a sign that you should be cautious about it because it's either they're giving you for free because the pump's done or they're giving it for free because it's just a random coin that they want you to purchase, just to make you feel that you're receiving it for free.

You can find lots but be careful on which one you would join up and dont easily believe into their calls and be observant on anything you are engaging into because not all would really be that sincere or true
analysis but rather a deceptive one which do mainly target out noobs so better be careful.

Asking if crypto trading does signal work? Its either both ways because market could only move in two paths which is increasing or decreasing.

I dont see the point on why someone would really be relying too much with these kind of groups if you could really make your own and it is much worth for you to focus on.

It does work as long as you join with the trusted trading group. I have several times to join the paid trading group and I paid arround $50 per months and indeed it has given me a profit.

But it is just for a while, I can't trade by myself and just depend on the signal. If the signal comes then I'll trade but if there is no signal I just looking the chart movement that I don't understand.

Trading is a good way to earn money, you can make it as your source income. So, you have to be serious to pursue this field. There are many sources that you can use to learn how to trade well and learning some strategies. But, I just suggesting you to buy some trading books becauss it is more useful than you learn on youtobe video and some articles.

There are some groups that can really cause you profit you'll be able to find a legit one since scammer were all over the Internet now it is truly hard to find but with proper searching or if you will be available to know someone or you know someone who can prove to you he earn from and who really benefited from it you can try to join them. I have join a group in my country who already tested some signals and I can say it's worth a try.

Crypto trading signals can work well, but we do have to be very careful when choosing a reliable crypto trading signal group. Incorrectly joining
the crypto trading signal group, can make a big loss. Because not all crypto trading signals provide accurate trading signals and now there are
a lot of group trading scams. My advice should be that before joining the crypto signal signal group, we really have to learn the basic knowledge of
trading first. So we can find out which crypto trading group is legit or scam.

^ No please, it will probably there is a victim and probably you are one of them. That is a scam to me, because anytime when you have a mistake in their forecast your will probably lose your fund. Just like what happened to my friend before, he was told me that he joined a pump and dump group in the telegram, he said, he will make an advantage always, he sells early as they announce pump altcoin. But later on, it does not work, instead, he faced a sudden loss of his initial capital of almost 50%.

I think that those who sell signals, why do they do it? If I am successful with my trades, why sell? Perhaps with the sale you get more than what you earn doing the trades?

One day they put me in telegram and I was careful about their signals, I saw that they only rely on technical analysis to give the signals, does this give security? I think no, most of the time these sign sites or groups end badly. I do not recommend it, the best thing is to study, look for books and learn.

Most of the time those groups are scams and the few that are not are never going to deliver the results they promise, but why is that? Why is it almost impossible to obtain profits with those groups? And the answer is that you need to think about this logically, if you had a way to predict what the market was going to do and you had reasonable expectations of making profits, will you actually give that away for a few dollars and give up the right to make a fortune in the markets? And if the answer is no then why you think someone else would do it for you?

I think that is because they want to make more money by providing the signal to many people, so they decide to offer the signals to people but need to pay for the services. If that is because of the money, and if that is related to money, people can be greedy to make more money. People need to be careful with that services because the signals can not always work, making you lose your money.

That's like the most basic question to ask yourself whenever someone wants to help you get more money. Saved me a lot of heartache and money just by asking myself these questions and then asking them after that and most of the time, they really don't want to help you and all they want from you is to help them make more money. My advice is to be careful with signal groups because they are in a way trying to manipulate the market.

It may works sometimes but maybe not somethings. It depends on who's giving the signals and how experienced he or she is.
It actually depends on facts about the token.
If you can catch those you Don't need to wait for the signal.
You can take decision on your own.
So its better to learn How to analyze the market

Yes, Signal provider must be experience, Otherwise signal can miss the target. Trading signal work if any experienced trader provide signal. If trader use any fake/spam/untrusted signal then he can loss in trading.

You are wrong here buddy because no matter how experienced you are doesnt mean that you would able to hit the target or wont missed out.When it comes to trading analysis then it would neither
be a hit or miss because not all traders are perfect no matter how professional you are but still losses are inevitable or cant be avoided.If those trading signals were precisely on point, do you really
think that they would go in public and tell out their trading signals which they do know that it is that precise? No one would ever do that but instead they would be trading on their
own and make more money.This is why taking trading signals shouldnt really be that on extent, yes you can check out some of it but doesnt mean that you will fully rely on it.

I always find those crypto trading group somewhat dubious. I know most of those groups are made for pumping and dumping shit coins. Only the owners and their "entourage" makes the profit while the rest loses everything. As far as I know, this is how those shit groups work. The top level people chooses a shit coin with low volume. They then make a call saying that the price of this shit coin is going to increase and then they pump up the coin a little. Other "unsuspecting" members of the groups starts to invest in it. Once the price rises, the owners starts to dump their investment and "calls it". Those who exit late, loses everything.
But I have also heard there are some legit groups. So make sure you know where you are joining.

Well, you have stated it correctly and you are right.
The most who will get more benefits on this group was a leader because that leader controls everything that they wanted to pump even if it is a shit coin.
I don't see any good thing to them, it seems they are an illegal activity that frauding others to follow for the sake of their making benefits.
However, if a group did not have this kind of activity the pump and dump, that is a good sign to join. Because there is a group of trading in social media like a telegram that discuss only on trading activity. Not on the pump and dump group, you will be informed if there's upcoming news that gives you an early signal.

The most important thing when investing in the crypto market is that you must make your own investment decisions, never invest on anyone's advice.
The sellers of trading signals are mostly scammers, your money is yours to make your own decision with it.

They are many scam trading signal groups out there, you better be careful before you pa to get the premium signals and get scammed, trading signal groups do work just that it's not 100% sure that all the trades will be winning trades, remember if their trade calls are always right they won't ask for a dime from you, I just wonder why alot y'all ask about trading signals, if you are going into trading full-time the best thing you can do is to learn and become your own boss, rather than make trade via trade signals.

If anyone can correctly signal a trade then they can simply use it to make money instead of selling to others. Then they just need to think about spending money instead of enticing others to invest with them.
I have seen a lot of groups selling crypto signals but in the end all of them are scams.

The main reason why most traders are ignoring this kind of service is that they find out that it is not effective. It is a big trick and turns into a scam. A lot of people become a victim to thing and that be enough to educate us especially noobs not to engage with these people because they are not helping is but instead, they are pushing us to lose our money.

If we are able to learn in trading, make our self do this alone or to a person that we fully trusted, not these people.

My advice to you is that don't get easy to believe or just get the hype with their promises in the channels you wanna get in.
Moreover, you don't need to depend on your profit into signal instead of that, it is much better to learn and get it from the experience
you can able to face the actual trade exchange platform.

This is absolutely true. Many of these trading signal groups are scams in which you'd lose your money if you joined them. I think the best way to know if they are legit is to join their free channel. Check their success rate in the free channel for a month or two. Check to see if they are actually good at reading the market and giving accurate signals.
However, if you really want to get the most of the market, it is advisable to learn trading yourself. That way, you're solely in charge of your trading losses and profits instead of giving power to someone else to determine that.

That's true.
I won't rely anything to anyone to avoid blaming each other.

Same thing I recommend to all my friends who asked the same thing.
Don't get seriously attached to trading signal offers.
Take it, try it and make money out of it.  Use it and combine with your own analysis.
They might offer something else after that and that's when you get out. Try joining a new group to avoid scams. Just the free ones.

Crypto trading is signal work. But not easy handling the trading process. So before starting the trading. Frist lean it. Then easy to change and easy to facing issues. Time to change the Price. Safely start the training. Don't lose your trust. Trust is help to connect with more country people. Then easy to lean eventing and Shar the more information. So time to act the trading process.

The only person that you would enrich is the channel creator.

Search up how pump and dump schemes work. The TG channel admins buy the coin that they are going to P&D, set an arbitrary target that is way above their actual target, and as soon as people start buying the coin they are going to take profits and get the hell out of there.

Sure, you could possibly make a few bucks here and there if you are lucky, but essentially it would be no different than gambling - except the odds are even more stacked against you.

yes it works certainly if you manage to join the good ones but you can make use of their free group and see their result. anyone that wants to collect money for a service should be able to at least provide himself with some free services. to be honest, these are just for temporal sake. the best is for you to analyse and pick trades yourself and be consistent.

It works but you can't expect all the times. At first you should find signal from good trader. Try to avoid some telegram paid signal because they don't know about trading. They are scamming regularly by giving fake signal.

As a rule, each paid channel has a free version, in which signals are selectively served so that you can check their accuracy. It is quite possible that you will be satisfied with these free signals for your trading and will be able to do without the paid version. But in any case, you should know that there are no paid channels in which all signals work out at 100%.

Using free signals is a good idea to start with, getting familiar with a certain range of signals makes a lot of sense. I have used chart analysis for a while now, there are so many good indicators we can get from past trading data. Also,  I would definitely recommend to test out the signals for a while before actually trading on them. We don't know how reliable the company and their data is, so making a few paper bets without real money would be good to check their performance.

That is the kind of question that you always need to ask yourself when it comes to any kind of business opportunity you may see, what is it in for them? What do they gain by sharing this information with me? If they are charging you no money then most likely this is a pump and dump group that is trying to lure people into buying bad coins so they can dump them on them when the time comes, it is because of this that groups like those should be ignored by those that are serious about making money on the markets.

Crypto trading signals are regular trading recommendations or ideas to buy or sell a specific cryptocurrency at a certain time and price. Any reliable cryptocurrency trading signal, must have exact entry, stop loss and take profit points to improve your trading performance.At Technical Trading Signals, all of our cryto trading signals are generated by highly experienced cryptocurrency traders who are regularly monitor and analyze major cryptocurrencies including Bitcoin, Etheruem, Ripple and many more to identify best trading opportunities for our subscribers.Technical Trading Signals sends trade signal directly to your Whatsapp, email and telegram.

Honestly, it works at first but later on, you will see huge changes from them, and they likely make you scam. Because if they are true with their signals and if that really works, they will never share it with us, of course, I never have to share this, if I have. But because it is impossible, they will fool greedy people and trick them.
That exactly how it works and can't deny that many were still a victim to this because they will show strong support that encourages you as well until they got a lot from you and leave.

- Channel creators will be richer sooner than other members when they give signals and I believe they have bought those assets for a long time but they also don't completely take advantage of everyone in this situation, they are pioneers, making extra profit is essential, there is no free meal, the signals they give are not all bad. These signals are never random, it's calculated based on real numbers, we can analyze before we join, a few correct signals are enough for us to make a profit, just shut up and follow, lack of analysis only makes us fail.

That is not good to start, trading signal just will give you a temporary profit, most likely you will just gamble with your money. I suggest, you need to learn first about trading strategy, like technical analyst, there are so many part about technical analyst, also you need to learn about fundamental analyst, reading some news before you make an entry so as you will know the market sentiment.

That is a good way to start comparing to join some trading signal. Indeed, there are some legitimate trading signal especially premium signal, but I don't think it will be worth for long time. You will just depend on trading signal everytime you entered the market but you don't know the reason why you make an entry either buy and sell.

I've never been in a paid trading group. But I heard that there are a lot of groups that give a good signal at the start and disappear in the end. That's what made me confident to study on my own and I think I've made it this far. Besides that, actually there are also several trade groups with free signals or just a discussion that I participated in. I only take advantage of the moment from the group if according to the results of the analysis it is appropriate then I will enter if I don't let it go. This means we have to be good at filtering and taking advantage of the moment.

I believe there are scammers and fair people and it is very difficult to find which one is which one, if it was simple to differentiate between the two, signals could be useful, they are not 100% right even when they are fair but at least it would be a warning type of deal, combine that with whale alerts and you could have yourself a decent bot but the reality is that even on those rare situations where the fair ones do help you, there is a chance you could be scammed trying to find them.

This is why I stay away from it, if they charge you money just get out because there is no need to spend money on signals, it is simple to calculate it based on their indicators if you look for it yourself, or just buy as much as you can and put it aside, that would be helpful enough for most people because long term is the only way to go for many people who are not super rich.

Both paid and free signal are not an assurance to be profitable, why bother sell if you are getting decent from your knowledge.
Very common question but still no clear explanations.

Work with your own knowledge and if ever you encounter this free or paid signal try to analyze and see if what basis are they
sharing before following any call that they provide.

I have been in some and you have missed nothing by not being in one at all. I can tell you that most of them are either fake, or they are giving information that anyone can find anywhere, even youtubers share that daily as well if you follow some trader youtubers, I have seen even stramers who make moves that you can watch for free as well, so all in all nothing special goes around in those groups.

Most of them is like "oh macd is this, so you should sell" or "oh weekly is this so you should buy" and so forth, which never really means that bitcoin will do what they claim it will do, sure it "may" do that, but that doesn't mean that it worths money, I think what they do is not something that worths paying for. I think they should do streaming and if they are right, they would be making the moves themselves, and if they are wrong they lose money as well, at least brings some credibility to it.

Free or paid, they are just all the same and nothing spectacular for you to convinced yourself to join up with these paid or free groups when it comes to crypto trading signals.
On asking out if they do work then this is just the same on making out your own speculation and knowing the outcome or result will always be neither on heading on what
you anticipated or simply goes to the other side of things.You wouldnt know until you do see your very own eyes and also it is much worth if you do make your own
analysis rather than on listening or following others which you dont know if those are having some good analyzed signals or just completely made from hunch.

a crypto trading signal is just an organized pump and dump group. their focus will be a low cap, low volume, and low liquidity crypto only. let say they tell you that coin A will be pumped, at this point they already bought it before they give you the signal. stay away from people who give you "target price".

even if you join a paid signal, there's no guarantee. the only guarantee they will give you is just another paid signal. for example, they give you a signal today, but if it's not going well. they give you another signal the next day.

if you don't have a skill in trading, try to read about copy trading. however, it's still better to trade by yourself.

Well depends signal groups are bad but if there are signals based on the trading data it can work out for you. Just it's hard to find someone who will do that and it's willing to share that.

Look there are both kinds of groups, scams and some good ones who cannot be 100% accurate but still provide decent enough signals and news. I am keen to join groups that give explanations and reasoning behind their signals more than just blind signals without any logic.

I have not paid any group till now because there are some good free ones, although I was invited to the group so I cannot share the link or help you join them.

Most of the groups are scams and it is not easy to judge if a group is scam or legit, just keep analyzing their signals and check how they perform in the market and once you feel they are good enough with decent accuracy maybe ask them for the paid version.

I would never pay a group to provide me paid signals though, that's just me because I rather believe in myself and gathering data from free groups instead of paying someone. I feel like if someone needs money from a user to help him make money, something isn't right.

I prefer to join a discussion group because we can ask and share insights about why the price could go up or down with some real-time data, news, and technical analysis.
however, those discussion group is also a place for coin shillers who wants to shill their bags.
even the group team/admin wants to shill their coins because they have a partnership or something with those coins they shill.
if you have a nice group (and free) just share it here  ;D

You will not know unless you try. But be mindful that in the vast world of cryptocurrency trading, there will be lots of possible scammers that can took advantage of your weakness so you must always keep your guard and be aware of the possible prospects those scammers will do so that you can avoid getting yourself victimized by them. You will be lucky to find a legitimate group out of this broad industry and I wish you good luck on seeking and finding one. But if you can just carry out doing it on your own, that will be a greater choice to be done for you will at least justify your own learning about trading and you will no longer in need to get along with a group.

in trading there is no such thing as working or not, all back to our own analysis. You can join any group but if you can't do the analysis properly, it seems that trading is not working optimally. maybe my advice is to find a mentor to learn trading so you can learn step by step

Any signal comes from a subjective assessment of the market by those who give it and may differ from your perception of the market. But I'm always interested in analyzing the signal and figuring out why it is exactly like this. In any case, the final decision will always be made by you.

I have never used a paid signal, some premium paid signals are not 100% accurate, in case of shocks to bitcoin technically as good as anything will be invalid. I recommend the channel https://t.me/thebull_crypto so far I am looking for a signal there is very accurate and have not gotten any losses higga at this time. Just don't invest 100% of your assets in one coin, when the coins according to try to buy back.

Dont waste up money on joining up these groups because they do basically nothing giving out something into your trading learning but somehow if you do join up with
free ones then it isnt bad to look for some valuable information but doesnt mean that you will really rely or depend on it because it would be still ending up on your
own decision when making up trading actions.Most of them are scams which are typical pump and dump schemes so better be careful.
It is much more better if you do trade and learn up for yourself.

Many people are scamed for some dollar. But have a lot of group they give advice for trading. You can take it free or paid. Always i follow some YouTube channel they regularly advice some good coin and i earn some money.

I always suggest me to avoid crypto trading signal telegran group, channel, whatsapp group, channel or any other platform. I Just hate them all because of they are the real scammer on this crypto platform.  Just see their working strategy first they buy a old group or channel or they customize their old channel by a new name. Then they buy member after that they show some fake proof of profit. Then they invest on a project then give you a signal soo that you guys are buying that coin and make the coin price pump. Then they sold their holding and they dump the price. Soo isn't this type of work we can say its a strategy of scamming. I don't blame those real people who are trying to help others but the divided is 0.01% are legit out of 100% . 99.99% are fake. So its best to avoid them.

the credibility and quality of the signals given will be clear evidence if these signals are really analyzed and executed by themselves.
I also have friends who have private signal groups reserved for some of my other friends and some people. he does not just provide information in the form of numbers, but complete with an analyzed chart, so that it is not just a number.

I believe there are many signal groups that are only concerned with the profit of the signal owner, but I also believe that there are still many signal groups that have quality and are not just signals, but there is education about trading and strategy.

Those youtube channels are also biased sometimes when they're paid to advertise a project. They're taking the deals because they have to earn from it.
Just be watchful when they're shilling your projects that you're aware that it's not a good investment and not all the advice from them should be taken seriously.

Not all of them are scammer but most. However, that is truly hard to tell and say who can be trusted among them and it is because scammers can easily make a change of their names and sometimes they copied known names and personalities just to brag people and give their trust.
Avoiding them is the best solution but I'd just to wonder why many have still become a victim despite the awareness we spread around which means that scammers still win.

Following the free channel and testing the quality is suggested before paying the subscription fee for the premium group. From my experience, these types of trading signal groups don't share the losses and they only promote the winning calls. I will not afford the money for getting the product that I can find free on markets.

Yeah, maybe it is more useful to join a group or channel where they provide news about upcoming potential coins and tokens but make sure they are not paid to promote those tokens. Maybe a good explanation of why they are recommending some particular coins would help clear that they are not paid to promote the projects. Signals of pump and dump or such things I don't think even exist let alone someone help you if they spot it.

But the point is, if they are competent and profitable traders/signal providers why would they give signals instead of asking users to invest under them because that should yield better profits for everyone. I know the risk factor is there but it can be minimized by some video calls and some trust gained by small investments and making a name for themselves slowly.

There can be some good ones, although I haven’t seen any of these groups like this that are really working, but there will surely be some of them that are legit, just that the fake ones are not letting us see them. And another thing you have to know is that all these signals are still under probability, they can’t really predict what will happen at 100% accuracy, it’s just what might happen but it also might not happen. That’s how it works. But it’s best to always give it a trial by using their free groups or their trial period if they have any, and if it’s working you can then decide as to whether you should pay for the premium or not.

The Crypto signal will never work 100%.
Actually, if you are really going to join a certain crypto signals, ensure that it is really legit and not a scam. Nowadays, there are so many scams about this, depositing or paying for the services to get crypto signal ad then there is no signal or even the signal doesn't work.
This should be more and more careful when choosing the crypto signal.

honestly, I also join the crypto signal, for a group in my country and mostly members I also know them. I use their signal to compare with my own analysis (because I am not good enough for TA), so it becomes one of the consideration nd part of my analysis. And mostly their signal can work (but not always all are accruate). Soem of them are not accurate but still can be controlled well. They always make discalmer about this that there is no signal that is 100% accurate.

So if you find out the group that guarantee 100% work, you should be careful of it.

Or try joining those free crypto signal groups first. To see how they do things and to have an idea if that will work for you. Joining paid signal groups is not advisable by many people here. For one, they will just rekt your money for fees, and then, later on, you will realize that instead of earning profits, you will lose money. Better learn the ropes on your own. Trade small and see how you can improve your trading skills. Also, when it comes to cryptocurrencies, there is no defined strategy here. Especially if you encounter pump and dump coin. Your TA knowledge and trading skills will not matter on this type of coin. But the more you know about the coin, the better for you to get insights on what may possibly happen to their market.

Now that you posted this things I am pretty sure that if any of the scammer will read your topic here, they will take advantage on you and will send you pm privately were in the end they will encourage you to invest, therefore if I were you, more careful is the best thing you need to do at the moment. Never get easily believe in the the channel group especially in the telegram group in pump and dump.

If your professional paid group admin are professional trader then you lucky. This type group are some scam and some legit. Now your choice what you want to do.     

It depends on the Trader you're going to follow. I think the only thing you need to do is to risk your money on that Trader, I mean the fee, risk it. Of course before you subscribe to their service, observe first if they trade successfully most of the time, and if it is positive then go for it. But signals are gonna be wasted if you don't know how to read the Technical Analysis they are going to drop in their channel, so yes, it is important to learn the basic first.

No one has yet provided information, with supporting facts, for someone to follow a signal and get a good enough result. In most cases, we only express our opinion, but no facts. But the only thing that raises no doubts is that many have a negative attitude to trading signals. And if you copy someone's trade transactions, then you need to do it somehow else, since there is no real way to track the transactions of reputable traders.

Trading signals are very effective and concise and atleast 65% accurate most times; but it all depends on who is providing the trade charts. It betrays the trading ethics to pay for a signal group when you can get several trading tips on youtube. And also, you will not be able to determine a fake or real trading signal group by just chatting.

I suggest you join the binance, okex and ftx group for your country; interact with your countrymen and from there i am sure there will be enough free trading signals for you. Prior to getting trading signals, proceed to learn how to interpret trade charts and identify TP, SL, OP

If you are looking for a group with cryptocurrency trading signals, then you should know that it is very difficult to find a good group and that there are a lot of scammers. How do you make the right choice? To do this, you need to study each proposed group and you need to do this free of charge. After all, if you are asked to pay right away, then where are the guarantees that their signals are working? You should be given the opportunity to make sure that the synals are working for free and you will not lose your funds. All this is a complex process and will take time to study accurately. The main thing in this matter is not to rush, but to get as much information as possible, try out several free signals and only then make a decision.

  Signals, well the bottom line is that what you are doing is allowing "other people"  to decide when to buy and sell, (it's not their money) it's yours.   IF they signal to buy when you should be selling, or to sell when you should be buying...    it's a problem, there are trading bots, that do basically the same thing.   They are difficult to setup, often buggy and most of them are profoundly inept at what they say that they are supposed to do.   Then there are the exchanges to consider.   IF you are using an exchange that "stacks" the deck against you then no matter how great the "signal" or how good the "Trading software is"  you are going to find it exceedingly difficult to profit in any meaningful way.

Take for instance the coinbase pro platform, selling on that platform is severely degraded by use of a laging assigned value that they (to my knowledge) do not publish.

  So you look at the spot price, watch the assigned value, (portfolio value) which is updated so slowly that any value is slow to update and quick to degrade.

  An example of this would be if your assigned portfolio value was 18,900 and the spot price were 59,600.00  then the spot price jumps to 60,388.00  But the portfolio value does not update to the new price, this is because it is not updated in real time, it is only updated during the quick down trend.   They are not using Asynchronous updates to the value that they assign to the portfolio.   It is because of this that when you try to sell at the higher spot price, the trade will only execute at the lower price assigned to the portfolio.   This is a profound disadvantage to the trader.  In reality signals mean nothing IF your trading platform is substandard.

I joined with any signal trading discussion and have free or paid group, I think is work because we can't control all altcoin and have joined with signal discussion we know which one coin left from our checking. Every day I check one by one with signal group what new coin good to buy and better for earn much profit, by joining with many telegram signal group we can know with many coin have to buy.

They are 100% scam, jut stay away from them. If these signal men are that much proficient then why they are collecting few bucks, they must be millionaire. Spend 1 or 2 hour here  and you will learn so many things about crypto and that too for free.

I've people that said that very few of them can be legitimate. And I think those people who have said that have experience and really went through those few legit signals.
But the same as you, I think that most of them are really scam. They're the predators of those joiners and blinded thinking that they really are following good guys for signals.

I usually do not recommend newbies and beginners to go after paid signals, because the cryptocurrency market prices are not accurate and predictable. Either they can go up or down in value without warning, as there are no astronomical guaranteed returns. It's better that you trust your own instincts rather than relying on these paid or pump and dump signals. Just saying.

Extremely right.

Paid or not paid signal group is very risky to join and we know that the crypto market is unpredictable and they even don't know how to predict it.
Regarding the pump and dump, this won't help newbies, because not all of them got profit and will I guess, the organizer of the pump and dump group, will most likely gain more profit than the member. I'd rather suggest newbies try copy trading will I guess work out than this trading group.

If you don't have enough skills and knowledge in trading, there's no such thing as gaining profit if you are in hurry. Learning, studying, searching and the last one experiences on how you execute trading.

You joined a trading signal group that works because you are lucky but I will advise you not to be excited about it because they are doing this to gain your trust when it time they will provide you wrong signal which will only profit themselves. Why don't you invest in new altcoin which Grayscale just added since alot of institutional investor will accumulate it soon?

Trusted signal group provide signal by analyzing markets. The condition of market not follow that analyzing everytime. It’s normal to not hit target everytime. So, It’s a good decision to trade only in know cois for first time.

For sure there are many crypto trading groups with good signals and most times their calls move as there predicted but at same time there are still trading groups which aren't good enough and also there are scam groups as well too, so at first I would suggest u make inquiries from Maybe the group members to know how  well the group has been fairing and not only that if you don't trust the signal group that well try not to use huge capital to trade, try with little capitals to test run their signals, tho no one can actually predict the price movement perfectly but some good analysts can actually predict the price movement to some certain point and it favours them, so what am saying is before taking the signals for trade be sure the source is a reliable one which has good records and also apply risk management.

Absolute scam. If you really into trading there is no short cut.  Everyone has their own attitude and behavior toward risk appetite. Everyone have to go through the learning curve.

No shortcut, right. Newbies are the ones who likely to fall for such signals. They like shortcuts into making a profit in crypto and they have mostly the same thoughts about the process how to trade and how to make money from the market.

I won't say many but based from what I've seen and read in the past years, only a very few of them can be said as good. And they are not actually a signals group but people there are just sharing analysis.

Crypto trading signals are ideas or suggestions for trading a coin at a certain time and price. The signals can be facilitated by a trader manually, but professionally, or automatically with bots and algorithms.

The signals provide a protective layer with take profits and protective stop losses. Crypto signals can be free, however, to make them more dependable, a subscription fee can be paid to a crypto signal service provider. Monthly, quarterly, and annual subscription plans are all available to choose from according to the trader's needs.

Then, the crypto signal will be brought to your devices and communication systems, and emails, and through whatever faster apps. The signals can also come at a routined time for your better advantage.

Of course there are alot of scam signal groups on telegram, even fake arbitrage groups telling you bitcoin is lower on Binance and higher on one scam site, I just hope you don't fall for those low porn-scams, anyway about trading signal groups/channels there are some real ones that I have come across on telegram e.g @CryptoVIPSignalTA (copy and paste, use Telegram search), this is actually a channel though, and AFAIK have seen them forecast some trades and it went exactly as they said it, but if you are going into trading full time, I think its best you learn and gain experience rather than use this channels/groups, they are not always 100% right, remember.

Like you, I don't recommend new traders to patronize signal services with the hope of gaining profits off their capital. While it may work for a while, it doesn't do so well in the long run since the trader in question hasn't really grown as a trader as they're always relying on others for the signals. It becomes a problem when they don't get to trust their own analysis and calls when they finally get to learn it. At the end of the day, it's not about being given fish on daily basis, it's about how much fish one can catch on their own. You don't become the trader of your dreams by sitting on the sidelines and waiting for signals.

In my experience, crypto trading signal groups are not entirely accurate, although sometimes some signals they provide are accurate.
So in my opinion, following a group of trading signals is not satisfactory. It might be detrimental if their many signals are inaccurate.
I think if you are serious about crypto trading, you should study trading seriously to get a good profit.

This is not going to work because most of those traders that give signals keep most of it to their paid clients, which makes sense, why are you going to give all of this information for free when you want to get paid for it? However I have always thought this is bad idea, even if you were to find a good trader that actually shared his insights about the market, what are you going to do once that trader stops doing that? You are just as lost as you were at the beginning so it is just better to learn how to trade by yourself than to rely on someone else.

They also predict the market just like everyone so they can either be right or wrong. Their technical analysis could not be always right because crypto market is very unpredictable. It is up to you if you will join those paid groups but from my experience, it could also benefit you because people there have the same interest as you and there is someone to guide you if you're learning to trade. Just verify if the person giving signal on that group really knows what he is doing. There are some groups I joined before that is purely pump and dump. The admin just follows the trend without a clear plan on what he is trading.

Being serious and independent is essential when you spend all your time on trading as every action of the day leads to weekly and monthly profits but I bet very few people consider this a major job, we are just part-time members for this job, sometimes we only have a few hours to look at this market and I don't know how serious and successful you can be. Stop asking higher when you don't have much time, observing the signals is enough for you, the biggest benefit here is that it's reference and it's free, payments can have bigger benefits but I do not recommend

crypto trading signals in my opinion help but only 40% of the overall profit earner. because actually the natural technique in us is still the main thing. we can still get big profits even without crypto trading signals, and we rely on our natural abilities. So even though it helps, it doesn't help in a big way

Agreed,
Crypto trading signal can help sometimes to get profit. But, If anyone join in fake signal group then he will lost her joining fee and also he has risk to lost his assets, which he used in trading.

I agreed with you if those signals are genuine I wouldn't see any reason why they (signal providers) have not been making huge or massive profits while trading themselves rather than giving them out freely or paid service something is fishy and suspicious, I will rather learn to trade personally rather than to subscribe to unsure trade signas from an anonymous provider.

With just common sense then you would really able to say that thing if they do have those working signals then they wont really be minding that much on making more money
via sharing up some paid groups which is totally nonsense if i were to say.Its not bad to get some hints or ideas with those free paid signals but dont put up yourself
into the point that you are already relying on it.It isnt really worth for you to follow up something which it would really be just as good when you do make your own.
It would be more worth if you do follow your own analysis than on following into these kind of groups which doesnt really give out something important.

Signal group, as in signal for when the pump happens?, if it's just that then the answer is no, they do not work, mostly because bots will be buying the mentioned coin/token way faster than you and you will probably end up buying the top most of the time and there's actually more chance of losing money.

But if you're thinking about one of the TA guys that just send buy signals on good trading set ups then that's another story and the best would be to follow some of their free calls and see how they do and whether it's worth it, the good thing about following these signals is that you learn some Technical analysis along the way too and you're not just following signals blindly.

I think deciding on your own trades and being in a group doesn't really have to be two separate things. I believe you can be in many many different groups, try to find what people are saying about which coins and then use that to fuel your own trading strategies and research. Do not do what others tell you to do, it is really not something that makes sense, but I do think that investing into something that would be huge gain for you only comes from personal research, but there is no harm in checking out what others would be thinking about.

Long story short I believe you could make your own decisions, you could trade however you want, and you will be definitely profiting from that as well, but that doesn't change the fact that you could also get a decent amount of help from groups, specially signal groups, do not do what they say, but you can research what they say.

No, not really that they help even with that percentage. Most of them won't give that profit as they only give you altcoins that you don't know and you just let them do their own analysis.

That's right. Not only about natural ability but you really have to study on your own and gain a lot of lesson throughout your trading experience.

Crytocurrency signals work but not all the time.I will advised you to backtest the signals on your demo account  to see if it works or not before using it on your real account.You can also use the signals along with your knowledge of price actions or indicators to be a safe side.

Backtesting is something is recommendable anytime you do see some analysis floats online which you do seem that it is worth to try or be adding up into your own made analysis.

Demo's isnt something that i much off preferred because it is totally different when you are already on the live market using live money or fund.So better to test out with small

amounts and when you do get the tempo or method then thats the time on changing things up when it comes to intensity and everything will be depending on you.

Yeah, why not try to know if they can be trusted or their signal will help but we don't need to hook them up just for an easy escape in case we have to do it.  This gonna be a sort of experience and probably we can learn something from them. But we still have been cautious by then, we know the scamming events are rampant, and most it happens that they are asking money for returns. If that will going to happen, you better not continue your plan about joining them, they might just milking you without the assurance of getting returns of your money. It definitely a big loss on your side.

There was this telegram pump and dump group back in the day, they picked some low volume coin on poloniex if I am not wrong (this is a veeeery old story when poloniex was number one after cryptsy was recently hacked) and that meant that people actually ended up using a system on that telegram group where depending on the result of a blockchain hash at each day on the certain hour, there would be a coin picked. So, if it was 0 it was x coin and if it was 1 it was y coin and that type of thing.

This way nobody knew how it would be done and nobody would be able to buy beforehand and nobody made a bigger profit than others by cheating the system. Of course it wasn't as simple as that and eventually people started to build bots to acknowledge and trade accordingly, which is why many people started to lose money and system started not work so they disbanned it as a whole.

If we are going to rely on them, we are just simply ruining our future then. Not to say that it is 100% of these trading signal never works but it gonna be very closed to that. If we have an idea about crypto trading, will never know why it never works and that because we know that the market is not predictable. Because if these trading signal really works and those people who send it to their members, I'm not sure if they were going to share it but to use it with their own. But it won't and that they wanted to make others suffer losses just like them.

Yep, even if you follow one of those guys that are pretty good at TA, there are many times that their call and buy signal for a trade does not work out as intended and you should wait for a while to get any profit, and in some cases even that coin/token starts dumping, well, because market is unpredictable and you can only improve your accuracy up to 70-80% and that means you still will be wrong 20-30%.

The good thing about this is when you're paying for some TA guy giving you signals, it usually comes with some TA education as well which could make it worth it, specially if you have been following their signals for a while and they have at least 70% accuracy.

Well, I think it is not a bad option if you join a paid crypto trading group especially if you don't have enough knowledge of trading. However, just like the others, we were all doing the same thing making a TA and such. It's not that they are above us and completely getting 100% accuracy upon their trades, they are also been making a mistake and guess it wrong because the entire market is unpredictable after all. You can subscribe to them but you gotta check first if their signals are really that effective. My recommendation is that, since we are all been doing the same thing making a TA out of an unpredictable market why not learn it for yourself so you don't need to spend that money to subscribe rather add it up on your capital and trade it, that's sound better.

In cryptocurrency,  there are no official signals and valid information. Because maximum time people fall into scams and face unexpected situations. So it is not fair to paid of signals. There are many free groups who give you some important suggestions that's may be work.

There are some groups which share the news for gaining popularity, though often by the time this info is released to the group the main ones have already made a move so you could just be buying it too late and get rekt.

It is all in the circle of trading, I do think though that trade signal can be good only if you can act within the next few seconds otherwise it will be too late. So, yh, they can be useful but I wouldn't trust them 100% and at all times. Timing is extremely important.

Well when your time window to act is only a few seconds then you should know there is something wrong with that, the timing is simply too narrow for a regular person to be able to do something about it with that information, it is better to develop your own system and to develop one that at least can give you a window of a few minutes otherwise it is going to be almost impossible for your average newbie trader to make profits when they have to take such a split second decisions.

That's not true mate, there are good signal group out there are purely legit to their customers where they provide good trading signals consistently, signal group require mostly thorough research about how they truly are. Apparently, it'd be good to be careful with your portfolio, entering in every call will certainly drains you down someday.

Basically even though there is help from trading signals, it is nothing more than just a guide. To get profit, it remains on our skills, because what I know is that the current trading signal cannot help completely and only helps a little for us to be able to trade, sometimes there is still a risk of an error trading signal and we have to think about what happens in the future

Trading signal usually isn't mere help but most of people who joins it consider it as their main information of their trading activities and their trading decision generally depends on the trading signal and that's exactly why trading signal group are usually called pump and dump group because they could manipulate their member.
Though trading signal could sometime work most of them turns to be a tool for the group owner but I do agree though people should let their trading decision based on their own analyzation.

there are lot of crypto signal that is free in the telegram, do not put 100% trust on signals, just trust yourself in trading coin, learning more trading techniques is better than crypto signal, you create your own profit buy trusting yourself in trading. reading some crypto news also effective about upcoming legit projects.

I now one group with signals, he have a great analysis and not scam , he have a ig profile and tg channel , in tg channel delivered the signals, very nice service and do not cheap

Yes, I agree. We should better to check and verify the signals that we get. There are free signals that being given in community platform like discord and telegram. I think most of the time they are accurate, but still depend on the groups that we joined in. I think sometimes paid trading signals can be worth it. We can immediately check the signals or graph that they provide if they show in group, and we can learn to trade practices if we will subscribe to them. Don't forget to always apply risk management to every trade. We still need to depend on our own so that someday we can give a high probability of trade.

Well it really depends. Some might really give you a good signal, being kind as they are. But some might not, there are always chances that they are a scam, or just trying to manipulate the members to do exactly how they wanted it to be.
I guess you need to still be cautious, like joining the group and seeing how it goes first, even if you want to try, don't immediately put a big amount, try it little by little until you're sure that they're trusted.
Anyway, it's still better if you don't really depend on that, but might use them for additional source of information or such.

Yes, we shouldn't trust signal from any personal. I saw many people take it as a business but they are not well familiar with trading. Most of the signal group are scam and we should avoid them. It is better to learn trading by market analysis.

This is true!

If those people are really making out some profits then they wouldnt really be going into the public and trying to run up with some paid signals because they can eventually
make up some money with just simply making trades on their own without wasting up their effort on trying to handle out people.Its just really no sense at all.

There are lots of groups that do pop out even free ones which theres always a tendency that its always just a simple speculation that even yourself
could do such thing.So i dont see the worth.

But those are the exception rather than the rule, most of those groups that say that they are giving signals for free or for a fee are actually pump and dump groups trying to scam their customers by telling them that a coin is going to go up very rapidly in price and hyping them to the point they are willing to follow the advice of the scammer without any doubt, then when they tell them in which coin to invest they do so and then those scammers dump their coins and earn a fortune in the process.

Crypto trading signal is like a game, when one is lucky it profit. But you need to e aware of scam.

I don't really believe in trading signal groups, actually there are some trading signal groups that are legit and really pays but most of them are scam. Whenever you want to buy a coin you don't have to depend on anybody before buying a coin the only thing you have to do is make research about the coin check the necessary things you have to know about the coin any upcoming event, total supply, exchanges listed on and exchanges about to be listed on. You have to be active in there social media and Telegram group to know there next step. That's what must of the groups you paid for do. And after getting signal. From group make sure you make your own personal research before buying the coin don't just buy a coin because you get signal without making your research.

Even though they are paid, not all crypto groups will not commit fraud. Indeed, with paid facilities it is more convincing for traders to join the group. However, keep in mind the risks can occur at any time. Don't be easy to trust paid crypto groups right away, unless the reputation of the group is good, maybe you can try. Because if the reputation is not clear, this will be a big question mark, especially if the reputation of the company can be said to be not good (bad).

In order to convince yourself to join the paid group, start looking for news about the company, can be about its reputation. After you feel that the company has a good reputation, you can start joining them. However, don't believe it too much. Start joining a small fund first, to see how the process is performing. From there you can monitor it, whether the funds you have provided are running properly or not. The problem of working or not can be seen from when you put some of your funds to trade. You, as the person who owns the funds, have the right to know the progress of the trade.

Mate most of trading group or channel are paid and some group are free for crypto trading. But some trading signal has give us most helpful signal in trading market to take profit. But it's not mean all signal are right way on that request so becarefull if you take a great profit in market so it's very easy learn first of market and signals after that you have not any fear about it. Some trading signal are right and some are not so first you have learn of crypto market and after enter this
Thanks for interesting question

They work, but it all depends on many factors. Firstly, this is partly random, but a good trader will predict the initial movement without problems.
Secondly, the trader always has an advantage, because he places orders first. Thirdly, you should use the widest possible range of signals, since not all of them will show profit at the same time.

It works sometimes but not always. They actually do Research and give signals based on their research.  So its quite good and lots of time their signals hit the target.
But you Shouldn’t relay on them completely. After their signal you should better to research more and then take your decisions

But that is precisely what people do not want to do, signal are so popular because people do not really want to take the time to learn how to trade, subconsciously they understand that trading is very hard and there is a high chance that they are never going to be successful on their own, so what to do? The obvious choice is to never trade but that is going to limit or completely end the dreams they have about making a fortune in the market so they look for someone that is able to promise them that they will obtain profits if they follow what they say, and unfortunately as we know most of the time they fall prey of scammers when they do that.

Maybe there is but the problem is how to locate or know them. Do you have links to their group?
Because I'd never find any of them, that might they are just hiding around or they are not used to bump their group for the reason that nobody is believing them.

Instead of wasting a lot of time searching for them (legit signal group), it is much better to work on our own and stop relying on others. We might say that they are an expert to trading but of course, we can do it by ourself if we are going to push ourselves to learn more. That it takes times but for sure it worth it.

If it comes to the personal benefit of learning, I think it will depend on the person if he will just rely on that signal group forever. There are many signal groups existing today and I know there are some trading groups that offer basis or proof to their signals, They are providing TA, chart patterns latest news about the certain coin, and others more. It will be on the trader if he/she will use the basis of signals as a source of learning how to trade. I believe that a good trading signal group is an effective source of learning depending on how you will use it.

Yes, of course I agree with you because if you want to trade after getting the announcement of any telegram signal group, you must know well about that token then you have to buy token because telegram has some scandalous signal group so I will buy token by checking and sorting while trading.

I had been in cryptocurrency trading and ever since I started here I never try to use any of the tools in trading signal, because I also read to some of the community who used this didn't succeed most of them actually. So, instead of using this tools, it is still good to apply the natural way of trading whether Bitcoin or Cryptocurrency in my own perception only.

There are a few legit trading groups in the midst of those scam groups out there, you can find so many trading groups on telegram, but I would advice you tread with caution scammers are on alert as always, make sure they have winning trades before thinking of paying for their VIP trading group, and when you find a legit group try not to go all in at once cause even the best trader lose at times, don't use 100% of your capital to trade just because it's a VIP group,i just hope you know this won't help you become a better trader.

At least approach the people who share and ask them clearly the reason behind the failure, even your experience is quite important, this outside information is just a little perspective and not thorough, sometimes many people fail because they approach the wrong information and move ahead of the signaling groups, blaming is the common mentality to ignore personal responsibility. Signal groups will have a mix of good and bad, their credibility is something you can learn through the discussion groups they create

Obviously it will be depended in your paid crypto trading group. If they give the right signal, then you are lucky.Coz at first you need to trading signal.I thik this type groups  are legit.

because I know trading signals do not all work for people, sometimes the concept of people is different and it is not in line with trading signals. for example, maybe trading signal analysis describes a 10% profit but we expect a 30% profit. it simply can't be accurate. but even though it is not accurate for beginners it can help a little to find how to trade the right pattern

I recommend you get the hang of exchanging without anyone else and look for some exercises from numerous sources, so you can exchange without utilizing their sign. I do feel that it is an affectionate gathering, and most likely practically every one of them know each other actually so it's difficult to enter on that bunch. On the off chance that you use it for exchanging, you couldn't say whether that will allow you to make a benefit. Breaking down additional from the sign is the suggested thing that you should do after you got it.

It works when you carry out your personal research to know the things you need to obey and things you don't need to use in crypto trade. Many people that missed their benefits in crypto trading signal work are those investors that don't pay attention to genuine information in their group forums.

In forums, there really is good information that you can take but for crypto trading signals, you're not going to get genuine information there especially if you've paid peanuts for it. That's why many avoid joining crypto signals because they're asking premium fees.
Well, if some of them are existing and legit, they're few.

To tell the truth, I also use VIP signal trading so far. But it is not for the exact trading, but one of my considerations to choose coins and also get the technical analysis from them. Then, I use it as part of my own consideration and also analysis.
However, not all groups may be legit. I cannot say that I join the legit one but so far, it works and can help me much to add consideration.

be careful in the signal group that always ensures you get 100% signal work. Because there is no 100% signal always work, there will be any differences or crash

I suggest that such signals are only for our consideration in trading. do not let us depend on such signals, because no one knows where the market will move, and our job is to learn so that later we have a strong trading basis. and we can survive in the world of trading

Man, this article (https://cryptogeek.info/en/blog/trading-signals-channels) "Crypto Signals Telegram Channels: Should We Trust Them?" was written for you. You don't even have to thank me;)

You need to learn and keep enhancing your knowledge, depending from paid signals are very risky

as you don't  know how this  tipsters made their entry, very possible or most of the time they already

got the bagholds before they'll tell you or provides the signal, making sure that aside from the payments

from the participants they'll also gaining from the coin that they are sharing.

If you are going to use those signal groups in order to learn then you may have a point as it is always easier to learn when you have a teacher and you can get feedback about what you are doing, but we know that the majority of people are not using group signals in that way, what they do is that they select a group and then just rely on the group to give them some profitable trades, and it is obvious that if they do not know anything about the market then they're going to win more with those signals than with their own efforts but I do not really see them becoming successful long term with that strategy.

No matter how good the trading signal is still the best is a trading signal through self-knowledge, because we can control our trading patterns and run according to what we want. because as far as I know crypto trading signals sometimes experience errors and these problems can hinder our trading process

most of channel with trading signal that I have seen are scam created ad hoc for selling "premium package" or trying to collect tips from user. Worst situation when they suggest trading in scam exchanges!
Plus it's very common they will add random user.
Another big group of channels it's famous for pumping and dumping strategies in low cap shit coin.
It can work in some cases, but nobody will give free money so the risk of being late or waste money is always possible.

Some trading signal works and some are not beacuse all trading signal provider not experienced person.
It’s depend on you if you join good trading signal group then you get good profitable call if your admin experienced.

Now time too many scam signal group so find genuine group and at first use free signal then you will know how much work their paid group.     

I don't really find this to be that accurate at all, most signal groups fail simply because the one that is giving the signals doesn't really knows what they are doing, they believe they do but that doesn't make it true and as long as that is the case then you cannot really expect to get a lot of success out of those groups, after all if the person that was behind the group knew so much then why give signals in the first place when you can keep that knowledge to yourself and make a fortune that way.

Even we are buying signals from experienced traders, there will be no guarantee those signals will be working all the time. Because, sometimes providers will be sending signal in delay which will be not making any profit for us as we will be missing out perfect entry. So, timing must be very important in trading and in making use of signals as well.

But, signal providers are not considering the importance of timely signal which is really annoying and even after paying subscription fee we are facing such problem in most cases.

Indeed. That's why we don't rely on the trading signal group only. Not every time the signal can be easy to predict, also who give the signal is also a human, there should be a chance for a mistake.

Those professional traders who are joining the premium signal group, mustn't rely on the signal from the group only. They should have their own ways to examine the signal from the group and even have their own ways to get the signal themselves. It means the signal from the group is only one of the sources to collect the information, to follow or not, depends on the decision made by the trader.

Perhaps, there is no difference from what they do. Their market predictions might say it was better than us but the fact that we don't know the incomings, it guaranteed nothing, and it just like the same of what we do. To find to no use about trading signals, they will surely tell us that it really works, maybe it was but that be different as the market eventually changing from time to time.

Because for me, trading signals is just an additional tool for trading but we never have to rely on everything with it.

Another factor that is seldom considered is that trading with your own strategy in which you know exactly what you are doing is already hard enough, trading by using signals that you do not understand is going to be incredibly difficult and once you begin a losing streak then you are going to stop following the person giving the signals thinking he does not know what he is doing and then may follow another person making the same mistakes over and over again.

You might want to check out also free crypto signals groups there are also legit ones that you may find.

Try joining a telegram group like /freepfsignals, this is one of crypto group I've been following for a while.

I can say that they're legit and will always answer your query anytime regarding their platform.

Hope this helps you.

As far as I know most of the group they did scam to their members. But I'm not saying still not so sure about it, so better
be careful dude on your plan. And my only advise to you is make your own way in terms of doing activity in crypto trading this is
a natural way of trading where I know for sure you will get an idea about here.

Yes, I am as well hearing a lot of bad news about signal providers. They are also buying from some other providers and then re-selling to 100s of their own subscribers. It means they are paying for one subscription and collecting 100x profits out of no efforts. I'm sure reselling the signal is something no providers will be preferring still I do see some people are doing that in telegram/whatsapp groups.

Each person would really be considering this kind of reselling towards those tips into a particular source which it isnt something new and this is why we do
keep seeing that they flooding out into the market about those signal providers which arent actually real traders even though lets talk about the main
source and talking if it does work or not then it neither both chances but paying up for something that you can make out your analysis is something
not really worth to do so.Better create your own than on relying into someone.

Do they ask you for some fees or a VIP membership if there are step-up services that you want to avail from that group? that's the usual thing in these signals groups.
They won't just give you free signals and if there's a fee, that's actually where they're earning by giving their opinions about the market.

I think they will have that kind of arrangement, if you are new to their channel, they will accommodate as best as they can up until you will ask if there will be VIP membership. But anyhow, it is okay to be part of these free trading signal groups as you can get some ideas. But if you need to pay for their tips, I don't think that's a very smart move. Better do your own trading and learn some tips and tricks along the way. Most paid trading signal groups are not really worth your resources.

I guess there will not be a problem for any trader to pay them a fee when those signals help traders to earn something. But, traders will feel the real pain if they need to pay fees for signals and those signals lead them to book losses at most of the times.

There are many free signal groups as well but their effectiveness against all types of market fluctuations will be very less. Making use of trading signals for getting some idea on market behavior will be a smart approach in my opinion as well but most people just start with signal like that and then get used to buying signal rather than trying to generate their own.

If proven to be helpful and effective, we're like that, we would be happy to pay them but if those signals are nothing and they're mere opinions of those group owners, nothing to be expected then.

The ideas that you will get to them freely might also be found by doing searches on search engines.

Depending on the intention and experience answers vary, the most popular premium signal groups take all data and trying their best to find the best possible ROI after analyzing market sentiment. If you have no experience, avoid paying subscription fees and just enjoy the free Telegram signal groups. Otherwise, trading fake pump signals with your hard-earned money and monthly fees will melt your trading capital.

Some do, some don't. I've had been following Blockchain Whispers myself but their free version because their premium is not affordable for me and I'm happy with the free results itself. That guy gave Theta when nobody took interest in it because all the altcoins were being seen as just pump and dump materials and nothing, but Theta proved its worth and made many people hundreds of thousands of dollars.

Crypto signal giving by a member or a channel. There have been some good call but some are very bad signal. Some premium channels is giving trading signal for which you have to pay a good amount of money. Everyone can not pay to premium signals channel. It is very difficult to say about these signals. Traders should search about market and cryptocurrencies and invest into them. That will be much satisfying for us.

In my opinion, most of the groups that sell signals for trading are scammers. Why don't they themselves trade by their own signals? Real traders are unlikely to trade signals. Real successful traders will just trade. And as a rule, people who sell signals do not bear any responsibility for anything. They immediately make a reservation that the signal may be incorrect. It is better to independently study the principles of entering a position and stop depending on scammers.

Yes, only when they are not confident about the accuracy of their own signal they might want to make money by selling signal itself. Because when you are having accurate signal and even with very little capital you could make big money. Signal is the all thing in trading and when you're having that then definitely you can become rich given that accuracy of your signal is more than 90% at least.

So selling signal instead of trading with, definitely triggering doubts. Probably they are scammers or not ready to believe into their own signals.

Yes that is true. We must need to trade on our own responsibility and we cannot blame those signal provider for any inaccurate signals. When we are subscribing to their services then we need to accept these kind of Tos.

The bottom line of being successful trader must be, generating your own signal by developing your skills for good technical and fundamental analysis.

joining a telegram group like the one you follow is a must-do, but I think maybe we should still rely on our skills to be able to keep trading well. so trading signals through any group are actually good, it's just that we need to keep doing our own analysis based on our skills

I do not think it is a must-do. It can be an optional IMO.

At the same time developing our own skills and then depending on our analytical skills for generating accurate signal will help all the times instead of joining telegram or any other social media groups. You may join social media groups for educational purposes but definitely not for trading purposes.

I guess when social media groups are doing good then no one will go for learning technical analysis to generate their own signals. AFAIK, very rarely people are sharing about good telegram groups and all other are reporting about pump and dump attempts.

it works if you are lucky to get a good one to join. majority are scams thats why you need to be careful and watchful before you pay for anyone. find the free channels of such paid groups and follow their free calls, sometimes their free calls are better than the paid group thats why you need to watch carefully. i prefer to follow who will teach how to fish than who will give fish.

Crypto trading once  you got the signal you still have to analyse. it for your own benefit of right calls in your trade .if any want don't have so much knowledge of analysing .any chat or don't have enough time to monitor this but anyone can increase that reading skill by understanding . Uhshort form the signal provides and asking your shift like if you are willing to paid for any signal better to use it for you to learn and analyse your neurone.

I wouldn't consider joining one TG groups on there that claim to be signal groups. The amount of scammers these days on TG is HUGE and you're banned to get cleaned out.

One good way to deal with this is to follow a group that you think is good before you join/commit to check its authenticity and if the signals provided work - I'm aware some don't give you access to the info. but best to try with the ones that give you at leats something to check how credible they are.

Still the best advice is don't rely on these signals, find the info yourself if you can - it will take time but it will be worth it.

It is often seen that many people have a lot of signals. However, in the case of cryptocurrency trading, the signal is often not right.Again, if you trade according to the signal for some time, you can get a good profit from there.Sometimes the signal is very useful and the market continues according to the signal.

My opinion for you is that you have to learn by yourself first and don't even believe on these groups because I don't even think that this thing can give you a profit, probably most of them are just for wasting people's money, most of the time happens to me and I had lost my most of the profit through these scammers.

Try joining their free channel first, if it takes you long enough to join and get the benefits of the signal, please upgrade to paid. But so far I've been out and about trying to follow paid channels. Because I prefer to learn from the basics until I understand my own trading style. So that I know what is lacking in my knowledge. So don't depend on other people.

It is important to know how much skill you have in trading, no good results can be expected by buying signals and trading. I was once in a paid signal group for the purpose of trading. As far as I understand from their activities, they also give random trending tokens / coins, and then they will take credit for the trades that will turn to profit. On the other hand, the tokens of the signal given by them are dumped.

Paid trading groups are one of the most dangerous things in the crypto market. So if you spend time building your skills, you will be able to do better in the future. Trapped in such a paid group can lead to huge losses.

Cryptocurrency signal group can be found on facebook,  telegram and other social media.  You need to get however that bulk of decision making will be coming from you.  These signal group can only give you there own assessment and interpretation of where the market might be heading,  you will need to read between and make decisions that will be in your favour!

Sure some trading signals works very fine, while some did not. Though as we all know with or without trading signal, trading involves risk, even if we have trading signal to use it and trade is very risk also. So trading in general involves risk, patience and deep research in other to have more profit.

yes signals is very important in crypto but the signals is strong because in crypto its tottaly depend on news if news is come of any coin and you follow the rules and signals then it is clear that you will pick good profit from market but you follow those signals whos verify and gouranted by those well experiance staff

They arent useful because market is totally unpredictable and to those people who  do claim out that they have working strategy then its just pure bullshit and trying to make out money into those people who
do like on easy things when it comes to trading and believed that holy grail or methods do exist and make themselves rich.Market is unpredictable and every strategies made do only have
two possible outcomes whether its working or not basing on how the market behaves but knowing it before is just an impossible thing for you to believe on.

From what I have seen in trading signal groups, only the owners are the ones who are really benefitting from their signals. Usually, when they release the coin or the exact time of the pump, you are already late. So what will happen is, you will be the one left holding possible worthless coins. That is my experience in free trading signal groups. But high likely, it will be the same even in paid groups. They are just taking advantage of their followers. Better do your own study, analysis and trading. Don't rely on someone else's because in time, you can also use also those learnings, tips and tricks in your trading journey. So it is not a waste of time learning on your own.

yes in crypto trading there are lots of well experience traders and signals provider available but it is notes that 80% signals hits the targets and 20% not hit because reason is that depand on market situvation and if market dump then signals not hit and we sugest you that take away from market and keep wait for good time to pick the coin and make some good profits

You are correct and it is Very important that before joining in any paid signal provider channel, we can check their result for their free signal, it is important becouse for this everyone can understand that really their signal is working or not and also i see a person who provide free signal through his free signal group and if somebody satisfied with his Free signal then they can join his paid Group.                     

My suggestion is to add some free group first. Then follow their signals. Then you will know for yourself whether it is fake or real.
Then you can go and take the paid signal. Do not take the paid signal in a hurry.

Most is a waste of our time and money, but we have the right not to trust them 100%. Trading signals that can help you learn the basics and identify currency pairs that are trending in the market then combine its own in-depth analysis to make the most optimal decision. It's better to join their free group first and see what their success rate is.

Disregarding my view that there's no such thing as a trading signal group, even how legit they are, it doesn't mean that by following them you will have a good run and a sure profit in the long run. You need to be always active when the time signal is called and at the same time, you need some funds to support your run.

Now going back to the real deal, most paid trading signal groups are untrustworthy and scams as far as the overall status of it in the crypto community is concern. It's easy to just call a signal without fundamentals. And the fact that you need to pay first, that's already shady. If you encounter a free trading signal group, you can follow them. I'm not saying they are totally scams but at least you don't need to spend money for subscriptions and you can take those signals as reference.

And remember, professional traders are too busy to do that kind of activity. Beware of those invites, if you encounter one.

There are many trading signal groups on social media.  for trust you can see from the admin managing the trading signal and for success I think it depends on the management of the trade.  because trading signals are not 100% accurate and must still be properly managed by the trader himself

Those free that they give are nothing usual, they're all basic and everyone can do that. Just don't join any of the paid groups whether they give real or fake, it all ends up to the idea that they're all just mere opinions.
Just don't pay whether they give those offers that are too good to be true, they aren't so good and you're likely to lose your money. Instead of making money through your trades alone, you're paying them in return of nonsense.

In general, yes, if this is a bull market, it is difficult to make mistakes on it, and if it is an experienced crypto trader.
Also, you should understand that you will have to enter 90% of the signals, otherwise you will just play at random. Indeed, out of 100% of the signals, only 55 can be positive, and in order for it to work, you need to use everything.

I don't see any percentage on how a signal could have that precise hit of those kind of guesses or presumptions because due to unpredictability of the market then you couldn't really actually tell the odds.

Generally speaking about trading signals then I don't really believe  that much because everything is random and following someone with their signals is something not ideal just for me.

It would be rather be better to create on your own on at least you do lost up money but you wont really regret because its yours decision to make.

But do the Experienced Traders will offer this for free?

i believe that the thread runs for Free signals(as we cannot be assured to take rightful even if we pays so best to expect free offers)

lol 55 is positive? i have been in so many signal offering group and only 10-20% comes correct and majority is just a BS speculative.

Paid signal is good but all channels are not. Every signal channel provide free signals before make paid package. First you join their free signal channel and see if their signal works. If all goes well then you make your own decision.

for the introduction it is mostly given free of charge, until finally entering the paid stage, if we believe in this signal, of course following it is not a bad thing, so we can learn how to enter the market and how to exit the market, until finally we will understand and be experienced in trading. Of course, no school is truly free

One of the very first rule of trading is never ever join any paid signaling group. I have such signaling group in my country where people pay 25$ per week to remain in that group. There are around 50,000 users in that group, which means group owner is getting 1250000$ per week. There is no story of winner in that group rather all are coming out losing money. I am sure stories are very much same in rest of the world.

Try it and see what they update about signal, how many time give correct prediction about bitcoin and altcoin price, but check how faster update signal about altcoin price, does update after coin pump or he give information when altcoin still dump. many trading signal always give late information when altcoin have raise higher price about 10% until 20% and very risk to entry because price can back dump again, but you can join it and check one week how signal info good or not.

I want to tell you one thing, the groups in telegram which are paid didn't necessary or compulsory for the newbie, I'm not talking about others but this is just my opinion because I didn't know about others, what they think? I must tell you the day which you want to learn from yourself will be the day for your profit, and another thing don't believe on these groups too much.

If you are lucky you can get a good group. Many groups scam. Many searches may get. But most groups scam.
In my opinion, you can make a good profit by researching coins on your own without joining a group. Everything is possible if you work hard.

If you are lucky you can get a good group. Many groups scam. Many searches may get. But most groups scam.
In my opinion, you can make a good profit by researching coins on your own without joining a group. Everything is possible if you work hard.

So so much free information available + social trading, I really don't see a point of paying for anything.

depending on the group itself if it's good then it will help you but it's too risky. trading has a risk of fraud so we have to be more careful. if the group has a free channel then you can follow it first and see the progress in it whether it is worth continuing or not. as far as I know there are some free group services about trading and you can follow them without having to pay for them. but if you are sure to join the group that costs then like my advice you can try it for a while and see how it goes.

It doesnt really need luck but rather in depth research and own jurisdiction when trying out to find out which one is really worth for you to join on because there are some free groups which does give out some
considerable signals which you can neither add up into your own analysis or would simply be following it and since you do have the full control or decisioning then its up to your choice.
You are the ones who could determine if its really worth for you to consider or would simply avoid or skip out.

I use ujkaletf Signals Channel since 2019. and that they stayed a similar. they need each free and paid teams. each ar smart and you'll be able to opt for what's higher for you. If you're weekend dealer than free cluster is nice for you. Signals ar very quick and quality. I created several smart scores in this cluster.