Bitcoin Forum

As a trader, things can get difficult and discouraging if you cannot relate with any other person who will have a good understanding of what you are saying concerning trading, to solve that challenge, are you part of any trading community or group that you share tips and new strategies? What other ways can you say you have benefited from being in a community asides sharing of tips and strategies. Are you doing better than when you did things on your own. Can there be any major disadvantage being a member of such a trading groups? What is your advice to people?

The advantage is that you can be there and get wiser about what happens there so that you can build your own experience also. As a newbie, you may be eager to join such group hoping that it is where you make profit easily and faster but ask yourself how big is the owner of the group? He is just as a trader like you. You may be lonely as a trader but you can read online, watch trading videos.

I will not suggest and I also will not prohibit beginners from joining communities or trading groups. That can be fine as long as the goal is to gain knowledge and share experiences with each other on what to do in trading. Also it will not be good if the initial goal is wrong, such as following other people's trading methods, or swallowing what people in the group say. And also don't be mistaken for having a trading community or group, because many of them only take advantage of new members for their own interests, such as selling trading signals or something like that.

I wouldn't advice any one join a trading community or group, neither will I kick against it, everyone has a learning capacity that is different from the other, so if you've checked and you'll learn better with any one of them or even both, then go for it.

Afterall, we tend to learn better and faster when we learn from others experience, so in as much as the aim of acquiring knowledge and getting better is not defeated, go for what works better for you.

For beginner need more literation and education actually by joining trading community or group will help them for choosing good or not some coins for trading, but when my position as beginner I need many community and group for updating about which one potential coins for investing, but not all communities or group give effort and help beginner because several group try to make beginner loss by investing with coins have up drastically.

Need additional research for beginner if want learn and try investing in cryptocurrency, don't accept with all recommendation about which worth coins for investing and need to know how far that coins going up.

Joining a trading community that is similar and transparent like this forum is good, although this forum trading discussion is not enough in my opinion.

Good for newbies to be careful of those telegram groups, many can lead to scam.

If the newbies already know how people can use trading services to scam and avoiding it and only believe in trading by himself, I do not see anything bad there for him not to join a trading group.

But a trader is best for himself when he do not depend on anyone or group or forum about trading.

My advice would be:
- do not trust anyone enough to share any personal information or details.
- Do not click on links shared on whatever platform it is unless you are absolutely sure.
- the majority can also be wrong. So, do your own research.
- The admin of the group would never send you a DM. So, do not be deceived.
- As soon as you feel suspicious about the activities of the group or you feel that they are derailing from the purpose for which the group was create, leave the group.

Depends on the person itself, people prefer to be alone to learn or just being a silent reader to actually learn something instead of communicating via trading groups in social medias. There is nothing wrong with either two of that because if you are planning to learn something you will have the benefit to learn it and with the minus point as well.

By joining trading groups, you will have more circle of people that are interested into same thing so you can discuss stuff more such as trading so you have better understanding about tips and trick in trading. But, you have also the risk of being a victim of FUD and FOMO because there are always bad side about those groups. It does have the benefit, the point is how do you filter those knowledges so you can use it in your real trading scene.

For crypto trading it is not preferable to depends on those trading signal groups. Currently, there are many scammers who unnecessarily open these groups or communities to provide these services. So I think it is better to avoid them.
But as a newbie, if you don't know anything at all, some authentic groups can be followed, and the ability to analyze can be easily adopted by following.

If this group claims that it will help you to profit, or that they are professional traders, or that you follow their trading strategy, or any form of payment to members of the group, then it is better to stay away from those groups because you will not learn, but rather you will be exploited to make an investment that will benefit them.
Open groups in which people share their opinions and analyzes away from any biased point of view are the best, and Speculation board in this forum is an example of that.

Depends on your intent, if you are really that minding on getting some ideas from those experienced traders out there, then it wont really be that a bad idea on doing so but if you are already that putting yourself

on relying on what they are really that making then it would really be just that bad.Being a new trader, then its really hard to stood with your own feet but we know that it cant just be that impossible.
There are various ways or those common ways or methods on sustaining yourself.It is really just a matter of research and actual engagement which would give out realizations which would really be that
helpful in towards into your trading career. Learn up on your own and make yourself get used on being independent.

Joining a trading community or group has many advantages and can increase our understanding of trading and can even exchange ideas among members.
But I myself would never advise beginners to immediately join a certain trading community or group, I would rather advise beginners to do their own research first and increase basic knowledge about trading.
Because in my opinion a trading community or group is currently mostly vulnerable to fraud, although not all communities but most of the current fraud communities take advantage of beginners who have absolutely no understanding and basic knowledge about trading.
So I think it's better and wiser if we advise beginners to know and add basic knowledge independently first, after they have sufficient understanding they can determine or join a community so they are not easily exposed to fraud.

I do not see wrong joining a legit trading community especially for beginner traders as it will open him to the realities of trading, and he can certainly learned from the experiences of other traders as long as the community or forum itself is transparent and no intentions to lure beginner traders. This is actually an advantage for them, but the bad thing is if these beginners will trade quickly because of greed of profits, once they will be tempted to use other trader’s strategies knowing some strategies may work for others but won’t work for them. It’s still best to trade on your own and learn on yourself.

There’s nothing wrong to join any free groups about trading, because they can help you as well especially if you raised a questions to them and want to have clarifications. Trading can be very hard at times and even if you read books doing that in actual can be different, so asking those who already have experienced in trading is a big help. What I don’t advise is to depend that much on that group, it is still better if you can trade on your own.

I won't suggest/advise beginners or experienced traders to join any trading community/group. If they get problems in the community/group, they will blame me.  ;D  We know there are too many scammers trading communities/groups, there is a big chance to be scammed there, especially for newbies/beginners. The best advice/suggestion is to focus on learning and getting experience first before joining any trading group/community. So, they won't be easy to be scammed if they already have enough knowledge and experience.

Actually joining a trading group and signal groups is quite right from one perspective but in other ways it has implications, which I believe that the implications might result positive neither negative, its encouraging to be independent in anything concerning trading so that whenever you experienced lost you will not portion the blame to anyone,  making good trade you most be committed by devoting time to acquire more knowledge of Trading with adequate research  of Trading, joining groups might mislead you with a none valuable information.

There are actually some advantages on joining a trading community, you share trade ideas, you learn from the experiences of others, you find immediate friends to support you on your trades especially when you’re devastated, and while the interest keeps growing, your learning will also not stop. However, if you join these communities to pay others to do trading for you, that is a disadvantage on your part. Although you can be stress free and trade effortless, but in the end you learned nothing and just become loser when those people who trade for you will leave the community. It’s good to engage yourself in a trading community, but never rely on them for your decision making in doing your final trades.

it's always good to have a place where you could ask question related to investments and trading and I think newbies should always join that kind of community since usually newbies are lacking in experience, if the choice is to join or not to join then it's no brainer that one should be joining group for the sake of having information, etc.
but never ever take advice that's kind of influencing you into buying some random coins since that could be well just taking advantage of you since you are considered new, there has been many cases that some of these trading groups are manipulating their members so that they could gain profits.

It depends on what kind of trading community group we are referring to.

There are so-called trading groups where in fact, just a shilling group offering some trading signals and so on with a paid service and subscription. On the other hand, there are trading groups that really discuss important stuff related to trading and will feed the mind of any newbies there.

If found a good trading group, there's nothing to lead newbies on that group to somehow be guided by experienced ones while still on the learning phase.

At first it will look strange, but I think involving oneself in a group that has a similar mindset to yours is a solution that will help you learn from them, but there is usually some disadvantage, which is that you may not really get the right or best strategy to use because some people think their own best strategy is their secret, and the only way to get that information from such people is when you are both friends. Some trading groups are just a waste of time, and I cannot possibly advise a newbie to join such groups without noting some warnings. Instead, let the newbie visit some material online and also watch some tutorials on YouTube.

As long as a recommended community or group is filled with reliable traders who are always sincere in sharing their insights on trading then suggesting such a group to novice traders is not a bad thing.

beginners can learn from the experiences of their colleagues in the community they enter. But it's just that the worry is that beginners are always easily influenced. so beginners need basic knowledge first which they can search for on their own from the internet. Joining a trading community can sometimes bring good results but can also bring bad psychological ones. like we are affected psychologically when we see other people are able to get the maximum profit easily. beginners can rush to imitate it without knowing that there are many things they have to learn first to get maximum results like everyone else.

No, they pollute the mind. Better get some book, put lessons into practice and learn from happenings.

I say dependency is bitch, do not depend on anyone for your welfare, as much as possible and trading groups are certainly avoidable. When you depend only on yourself there is less chance for blame game too.

Even if you don't understand what they are saying or can't relate to it, later in your journey you will realize and understand it. It is really recommended for someone to join a community or group because you can ask them questions. This refers to like joining trading forums; there are threads there for newbies, meaning you can understand them so you keep reading and asking questions there. This sort of thing helps you improve easily; find another person that you can ask and rely on, and mostly, you can hang out with them to have fun.

Trading group is good but be sure that the members are solid, there are a lot of trading communities nowadays that are consider as trash because of the toxic environment that they have. Choose a trading community that can help you to become better, a trading community that can teach you a good attitude and also to be consistent profitable in trading. I really recommend someone to join in a trading group for their own improvement because their curve of learning can lessen by joining in trading community.

What's hard is not joining, it is about choosing community. There are communities who are sharing their personal trades and for me it is not good community because the newbies will tend to become comfortable wherein they will be dependent on someone else just for them to trade. What I like is a community who will teach how to trade properly, the process and also teach you how to think like a trade while your analyzing a chart.

What do you mean by relating to other people or another person? You don't need that to trade. You have to understand the market and trade accordingly. I don't believe it's a requirement to have some connection with other people or even be part of a trading community to trade. You can improve yourself in those ways, but it's up to you if you ever go on your own and try to trade on your own.

I don't think there's a big disadvantage, but one main concern is that you will be following a group, which could influence you. You could get lost in all of it and maybe distract yourself from ever trading because the trading community or something influences you.

From my previous reaction or response in this thread, they is a part I stated that joining a group might mislead you because you be taking all the advice or the informations that comes from the group as necessary one, so I believe that with your research you can be independent, because what we are emphasising on, is your capital and you need to protect it by making your own consultation concerning trading so that you will fully capture the risk which is involved into Trading and other things you will found out without someone briefing you or educating you.

Communities and groups are basic tools which enable newbies to be able to open a trading positions that will earn them enormous profits. These communities mostly dropped free trading signals in the market and they're 80% accurate. Getting intouch with top influencers and experience traders in the market when joining trading communities and groups will aides in helping a newbie become more confidence and speedy to understand how the market operates. One can not be able to learn everything alone, rather he or she needs full assistance from others who have been in the space before him or her.

You are pointing in right direction, regardless of what info you are getting from trading group or community the biggest downside is that you don't use your own mind in making decisions. In other words we rely on easy money i.e. based on other ideas and research we follow a strategy that can give good return.
It may work one or two times but in the long run one is deemed to bear losses. Make your own decisions, even if they are wrong you will learn something.

Trading community? Look, I ain't big on rolling with a crew when it comes to trading—I'm more like a lone ranger in the wild west of stocks. But I've caught wind of success stories from traders who found a tight-knit fam in these groups. Exchanging tips, strategies, that's the main draw. But let me drop some wisdom: the most vital thing I picked up as a trader is trusting my gut and my own sleuthing. See, trading communities can sometimes lure you into groupthink, where everyone's riding the same wave and not really thinking for themselves. So, yeah, trading communities got their perks, but remember to stay independent and trust your own analysis.

It's your choice, no matter what group you choose, as long as you adapt the one that will be beneficial and help you.

But in my experience, even though I didn't join a group, I learned to trade based on what I actually do in the centralized exchange and DEX. But if you really want to learn, watch the tutorial trades on YouTube, even if the content creators are not detailed, you will surely get tips and lessons there.

You might get overwhelmed by the tons of advices that they can give to you.

I mean there is nothing wrong with joining a trading community or group because I also joined one or two when I was still new to trading. The problem that I encounter is that, the amount of information that they're giving to a newbie is too much that you might get overwhelmed because of the terms, the tips or the strategies that they are giving. It comes to a point where I don't want to read their comments anymore because it's too much for me. I don't know if there is somebody aside from me whose experiencing this, but I see it as a disadvantage, and can affect your learning journey.

My advice? I'm not an expert in trading like most of us, but learning on your own pace will help you. This helped me learning trading. I watched Youtube videos, tried some strategies personally, and fortunately I'm getting some profits in trading already.

The problem is that when they still don't have any basis in trading, it looks like they are standing by to those who are already there and I have felt that before because they were there, the assumption was that we could get leaked signals for free without needing to think about analysis or anything, because already There is.
Indeed, to increase knowledge is a good thing, but we cannot be completely complacent with it because we also have to keep learning to be better so that the condition is not detrimental to ourselves in the end.

That's only the essence of it; the person gathers a lot of information or lessons that would still be useful as they keep improving, but the disadvantage is that the newbie, who may really want to make quick profit, will want to try almost every suggestion or strategy, which can result in a loss for them. But if the newbie gets lucky, they can have a friend that may be willing to help them all along, and they could easily ask questions in the group if they make mistakes. I just think it is wise to warn a newbie about some dos and don'ts before advising them to join a trading group.

I used to be a part of a community or trade group on WhatsApp before but now I prefer to be a passive member who doesn't chat much with other people and only with people I know closely. And in the past, I've often recommended new people I know to join me so they can learn from people who know more about trading.

In the WhatsApp communities and groups, beginners (my friends) can learn a lot about trading, tips and strategies or ways to analyze and we all learn together through those groups and communities. We can also introduce other beginners to join, but we must first get to know the members who have joined the community or trading group so that beginners feel comfortable when they join.

As much as possible, I will not suggest or advise a beginner to join a trading community but instead, I will suggest legit resources where he could learn more about trading which will be helpful for him to grow in trading industry. If he knows the basics as well as the risks of crypto trading, then that's the right time for him to join groups. Joining trading community at an early phase might only cause him confusion and it might plant a wrong mindset in a beginner so it will be best for him to focus on educating himself first.

I think the real question should be what should newbies consider before joining an online trading community. Mind you, it is totally safe to join an offline trading community organized by friends. Basically, it is like the pros and cons. Some pros of joining an online trading community for newbies is that, they get the opportunity to get support from community members, they would have access to trading resources which will be tailored to meet their needs at the newbie level, it will also serve as a platform where trading ideas, tips and tricks are shared. However, do not just join any group, what is their reputation like, does your trading goals and interests aligns with that of the ? Consider these questions and have them in mind when doing your research on the group.


I totally agree with this point. Me thinks that this is where most newbie traders get it wrong. Because they are in a hurry to make $1000 in first 30days, they easily fall prey to so called trading gurus who talk big and promise them the masterclass of their life that will turn them into millionaires in 10 days if they can buy their course, book a seat in their class so as to take advantage of their award wining trading strategy.

If it is for the purpose of accumulating knowledge as well as exchanging experiences or skills, it should be encouraged. But if he is lazy and joins groups or communities for the purpose of looking for signals or copying someone's trades, then that should be banned in the first place. But to give advice on a particular group is beyond my ability as I am not aware of such groups myself, I have never tried to find or contact anyone for this purpose. I'm not good at trading either, but I'd rather spend my money in exchange for the experience than give my money to someone else to spend.

No man is an island just the same way a tree can't make a forest. It's highly advisable that traders should belong in a trading community they find fit, despite how learned or professional they think they're. If they aren't learning, they will be teaching noobs. Knowledge shouldn't be hoarded. It's either one is giving or one is receiving when it comes to life (trading).

Yes, as a trader, I also belong to certain trading communities. Belonging to them doesn't mean that one will always take whatever trade calls or perspectives made therein. However, I'm better off being in these trading communities than if I weren't. They helped broaden my horizon.

Nope, there shouldn't be any disadvantages. One doesn't lose anything cross fertilizing ideas with others. Nonetheless, one has to be very careful to avoid scam groups.

From onset I always read educative threads related to trading on this forum and also member of forexfactory where trading strategies and tips is discussed, though it mainly on forex trading and I must confess I had learnt a lot from those communities with regards to trading tips, learning fundamental and technical analysis and testing of different trading strategies and there isn't any disadvantage for being a member of those forum infact I always eager to read latest information on possibly upcoming trading opportunities related to a particular trading strategy.

Yes, you should definitely join a trading community or group. But you should only join it to learn how to trade and when to trade and when not to trade; if you are only joining to get free calls from the group, then I would suggest you not do so. Trading on other people’s calls is not good, at least not for a beginner. If the call turns out to be good, then you're going to praise the person who gave you the call, but if the call turns out to be bad and by chance you lose your hard-earned money for it, then you're going to curse that person for the rest of your life. So it’s important to learn trading from scratch. If you are a newbie, then it’s better to have theoretical knowledge at first, then go for live trading.

Trading is an activity where we manage money, and therefore we need to take it seriously, without emotions. Over the years, I have managed to gain a lot of experience and I will tell you this: Technical analysis works, but only partially. Do not trust technical charts built on a timeframe of less than a month. Be able to track support and resistance levels. Also build them on increasing timeframes, up to a year, or even the entire lifetime of the token.

You are right that it can be discouraging to have no one to talk to about things you do or like, and it is always to have a group of people that share the same views or similar ones and who can understand you and relate to what you say, but where do you find such groups these days? All I could find are those trading groups that are locked for the general public and only admins post signals and analysis and stuff and ask to join premium paid groups.

And, I wouldn't really recommend joining these kinds of groups as they do no good to you but all they do is make you join their paid groups so that they can earn some money. If they are really that much expert in trading they wouldn't need to charge people to give them a couple of signals per day.

Benefits of being part of a trading community:

• Keeping biases in check
• Learning from the experience of others
• Sharing trade ideas
• Support in difficult times
• Maintaining interest
• More opportunities in the market

I was part of it and got inactive.

Two things that I've seen in these trading communities.

1. It's inevitable to see some sales pitches and plugs on that group especially if it's coming from the admin or moderator of that group. That's how they make money from it.

2. There are legitimate talks about trading and many discussions are just for free. But as someone who trades before, you can determine which ones are the shill and genuine talks.

I think I'm better without part of those active community trading, the forum is more than enough to look at those great traders sharing their experiences.

One word Yes, But here are some of my bits of advice before I start explaining why someone needs to join Community / Group for trading.

• Do not join for signals
• Do not Fall into Greed with others' stats
• Think Before following

So joining a community can help in many ways, the primary reason for joining a community or group in trading should be to learn from experienced users. Communities and Groups can keep you updated with the market news & updates which is nearly impossible for a single person to watch out. Communities and Groups can guide your analysis and you can avoid future mistakes. These groups can work as the fuel for the motivation engine inside you which will force you to harder and more effectively. You can learn how to diversify your funds from there and much more but signals are dangerous in groups especially.

Actually, in this condition I have thoughts that are not much different from some people who have expressed their opinions.
If indeed they join only to find more information to add to their insights in trading that will indeed be very good. But the conditions for beginners are also actually a bit vulnerable because when they enter without knowing the basics of trading and really still don't understand the ins and outs there, it's obvious this is like giving them the assumption that when they are there they will be profitable. This is clearly wrong because indeed if they think like that then they will definitely get lost before even starting.

If there is a reputable trading group, it may not be a problem and will probably help the newbie to learn more about crypto trading. There must be some discussions and as long as the discussion is very informative without any fake info, I think it is still okay. But indeed, there must be many opinions, and ensure that your friend is not confused with them. Additionally, you must also tell your friend that trading is a high risk and not to trade immediately. learn at first by collecting more knowledge, experiences, and also opinions from the group. But, don't only follow what they do because sometimes the strategy will not apply better in yours.

Having hubs or groups on certain interests is really helpful IMO. Without them, you won't really get some insights in what you're doing and you can't really consult anyone whether what you're doing is right or you're missing some key details. I would encourage anyone who is new to trading to join a group that discusses their trades and just anything related to trading, and advice them to stay clear of groups that only discusses the next possible pump and what to buy as if the members are shoving their bags in each other's mouths. It's easy to find trading groups nowadays compared before where you won't be able to join unless someone vouches for you.

for me the first thing to do to join the community group is that we have to make our own decisions, this means that we don't just follow the analysis posted by other members, and of course that analysis is used as a consideration for our personal analysis. that way we won't be confused when there will be many different analyzes from other group members. over time we can compare and correct each of our personal analysis, so that we can find our trading style

Unfortunately it's hard to find a trading group whose content is sharing knowledge to improve the skills of traders, a lot of it only contains sharing about signals or sharing other things that end in fraud, that's why I prefer to leave a community group like that, but if it really exists and can help to improve our skills, why not? For novice traders it seems that it would be better to learn from tutorials on the internet and also learn many kinds of fraud so they don't fall for it when they enter trading groups.

Joining a community or group to learn crypto trading will really help a new traders to catch up with what other potential traders are doing in the community to maintain their incomes. There are so many things new traders can acquire from a community or group that will make them to understand all the strategies involved in crypto trading, and how to follow the steps till the right time to buy or sell is available. Since I joined bitcointalk.org , I have learned so many things that is helping me to know the type of coin to buy in a particular season that will bring income at the end of the investment.

There are few in social media but again there are tons of trolls also but here in our forum you can find threads that you can learn and exchange information about trading but i dont see a website that is a forum that is intended for crypto trading unlike in forex that I've seen reputable one and they are not giving signals, they are giving their strategy for others to analyze and improve more which i would say if you are newbie you cant relate at all.

I think we can join a trading community or group while in that place we can get more lessons about trading to help us improve our trading skills. Usually, we join a trading community or group because of a friend's invitation, which will make us more familiar with trading. In addition, we also share experiences.

The disadvantage is that some people may offer something that could interfere with the goals of the community or trading group. But that's okay if we don't get annoyed by their ads.

I don't think anyone can benefit from any community or groups. At least not in the long run. In short run, you may follow other or trade according to their data. You may get some profits, but when it comes to do it on your own, you are lacking the base material to do it. And they are human too. They can't give you 100% accurate prediction every time.
Nowadays, all I see is people creating community or groups in order to scam people. It's all just pump and dump scheme. Mostly happens in alts market. And joining any community or group makes you depend on other people rather than gaining knowledge on your own. I still believe that what you learn by yourself, you will never forget that in your life.
This is just my opinion. So I try to do it on my own.

The question here is how to find such communities, or as I understand it, closed groups of traders. It is necessary for someone to invite you to such a group, or you found it yourself, I don’t think it’s easy to do.

But the idea is probably not a bad one, if I had the opportunity to visit such a group and look at the level and results of traders, then I could decide how useful this group is. But I also understand that successful traders do not need to share their experience and results, so I am still skeptical about this.

Yes, it's better for beginners to join several groups with the aim of finding references and experience, besides that you will get new knowledge and insights in the group. But on the other hand you also have to be smart in choosing groups, sometimes they are only concerned with themselves and don't contribute to each other with their members, and there are not a few groups that only contain fraud.

Do you know how to find a trustworthy trading group or community? It's hard to tell the difference.

It depends on what group of people you are in since some aren't there to teach you but instead they want to take your money when trading especially the so-called trading signal group. It's best you avoid them and find a reliable trader who does actually teach you how to trade.

But nowadays, I don't think you can find a legit one since a real trader are busy making profit in the market and if you happens to find one but they asked for payment then don't. It's better to do some research and learn your way up than waste your time on them since the information you needed is all free on the internet and majority of these so-called experts aren't actually teaching you how to make profit. They are all just good at talking but not really at making money in trading.

I have a strange impression about trading community groups, such groups are just a show off of wealth rather than discussing strategies and trading plans. Thinking about things like this makes me tend to ignore trading groups or communities, of course this is never fun especially when you really expect a lot of knowledge to be shared.

After all, a trading community or group that is not well-moderated by the owner is just a bad alarm for emotional management failure. Someone may be influenced by other people's decisions and they have to accept losses because of wrong decisions.

I think you are guilty because you are only depending on others. But why not tip those traders that give you a winning signal? That should ease the guiltiness that we feel and then we can also try learning on our own so that we can be independent later on. We can still be part of that community but this time we are the ones who will share our knowledge.

It was like we are bringing back the favor to them and it was a way of saying thanks for their help once we are still a newbie in the scene of trading. A community or a group is always great to have so that we will have a company with us. We can talk to the people with the same interest as us. It kills boredom or being alone, so it's always a must to have.

Most of the time, you will read successful stories but they won't share their failures and reasons why such failures.
Maybe for the sake of getting insights, you can join them as long as it is free.
But if they will start asking for a fee, then, better get out. You can earn your skill or knowledge on your own.
You can actually discover a lot of tricks if you will do your own trading. Just start small and be patient with your journey.

Joining a trading community can be beneficial for sharing tips, strategies, and resources, but traders should be cautious of echo chambers and hype-focused communities. It's important to do your due diligence and evaluate any community before joining.

Community group is a good thing but you have to define the purpose from beginning. As a community, you main objective is to learn one or two things from different people, as they used to say that there is no knowledge that is a waste, you will get the opportunity to learn one or two things from other traders but never made a mistake of using another trader strategy, it may not end well. Another important thing you should look out for is scammers, they have one it two of them in every most community, try and avoid them and don't fall for their traps, knowledge should be your target.

I completely agree with your opinion, for beginners who are really just starting trading, I think it's best to seek knowledge independently, whether by reading or watching videos about trading education or learning directly from someone who has good capacity or knowledge in trading.
because right now I think most trading communities or groups have now been made into wetlands for commercialization or in other words if we want to join that group or communities and take knowledge there we have to pay first so that we have full access and more knowledge in that community.
In fact, there have been many cases of trading communities founded by well-known people or even some influencers, it turns out that they are defrauding beginners who really don't have any knowledge of trading.

Joining a trading group can be of advantage and disadvantage to those newbies that choose to join on their own. As for me, I find it hard to join a trading community not to talk of advising a newbie to join one. I can only advise someone to join what favors me more than what doesn't. Why I do that, is not to be blamed tomorrow on how he lost to trade or how someone managed to give him a wrong signal on how to trade.

Since I suffered a terrible loss following trading signals that a friend offered me, I try to keep away from trading in the cryptocurrency space.

It's not bad joining on those trading groups as long as you don't pay them or make pure do your trades because that trading group told you so. You are trying to improve this is why copying other won't do any thing good to you. I personally joined some trading groups on my social media but I don't really rely on it that hard, Some of the members of those groups shares there insights about their current trading moves and what they are currently trading, This gives me an idea on what to potentially trade and what kind of approach I can use to trade that kind of token. Joining on a groups that you know you will learn is never be a bad thing .

When you do join up some groups then you would really be basically be prone to lots of shills and fomo or even on fud from those people who had joined that group.Its very common that you would really be
prone or would be exposed into this one and if you are a newbie who arent that emotionally that stabled or prepared then for sure it would really be affecting your overall plans and methods which you had planned earlier.This is why i dont recommend on joining up some groups but if you do intend to join for the sake of interaction with other users and not been able to get easily affected for whatever
shills and fuds around then its isnt really that bad to consider on joining as long you do know on what you are doing.

Joining a trading community actually create an advantage especially for beginner traders. You will know how to succeed and be profitable in trading because the members will surely share tips and ideas on how trading works. So you will learn to expand your knowledge in trading, and with different experiences from traders, you will know how to avoid mistakes and losses. Just don’t trade using other strategies because it might not work for you and it will ruin your trades. Always have your own way to trade, and develop your skills and strategies from trading    that you think will definitely work on you, and not because it work for others.

It is always good to have a community or group that will update us about trading.  It also help us gain experience by listening to the people's rant and stories on how they perform well or bad in their thread.  Learning isn't about our own personal experience, it is richer to learn other people's stories of success and failure.  Life is too short to experience all of them so better learn from others.  

Aside from that being in a group makes us enjoy things since interacting with other people is proven to make us learn a thing or two.  So yes, it is a good thing to join a trading group.

The only disadvantage I see is if we let ourselves be exploited by other traders.  Other than that, I think it is all good.

Trading with other people's strategies is not recommended, it's good that a group is created so that professional traders can interact with each other and novice traders.
I have many trading groups that provide a lot of knowledge about trading and I use it to create my own strategy.
If you only depend on other people's strategies then there will be no progress.


Exploited by other traders, maybe because of a lack of knowledge so that it can be used for the benefit of others.
There are some professional traders who do provide knowledge for free and there is no intention behind it, but there are also those who provide knowledge but have a hidden intention to benefit themselves.

Recently, I came to the conclusion that most if not all these trading community do not know what they are doing, it is full of noise and those selling trading courses are there to take your money and to my surprise most of them are not making money trading but just selling calls to you. If you think you need help, it is better to form a group of like minds not more than five, that you can share your ideas together, through this you get better

I have joined several non-paid trading groups, but in the end I have to say the same thing.
Of course, not everyone in the group is the same, but for the most part it's hard to get them to say something useful especially the strategy. Only paid groups may be good to consider in some case, the rest is considered at your own risk.

Considering the fact that you are a newbie, it does make sense to be in a group where other traders are do share their day to day trading experiences and market analysis. with this you can get improved over time while in the group, and too the courage to keep learning and to becoming a better trader tomorrow as you will be learning from different ideas, plus seeing others share solution to some challenges that you are facing in the market.

The best thing about joining groups is that you will be able to do any decision related to your success and people are sharing their thoughts about buying and selling and about arising of new project so it's better to get involved in groups rather than doing by your own thoughts. Actually people get scared about groups because they heard that in group people only share wrong information for getting money but not all groups are same. so just involved in a group and focus on their ideas After that it's up to you that whether you like it or not but hearing others ideas and getting involved in group is better way to get experience.

It can't be denied, but it's a common thing in various trade groups. I also join several group on telegram and facebook, even though a lot of insignificant things are discussed there, especially outside the context of trading. Strategies that are expected to help are sometimes not good because most of them take advantage of market hype. Well I agree with some of your opinions, but there must be different benefits about trading group.

Also I remember some paid trading group, usually they share good analysis and predictions about certain assets. The chances of making profit tend to be better when you are in a paid trading group, but there are always risks, of course.

Beein in such groups has a lot of advantages, but the strategies given are not always reliable, it is a good idea if a trader will de his/her own research well then add it up with the strategies and come up with an amazing trading experience.
Therefore, being a member if such group is not a bad idea but it is not fully reliable as it can also bring you down completely.

That’s a good advantage for me, since new traders would gain more knowledge and improve their crafts when they receive tips and ideas from other long time traders. And it will help them develop transparency and flexibility when it comes to overcoming different problems that most traders face in the market. As long as they develop their own strategies from scratch, I think that will definitely work for them.

A new trader can definitely join the community. But if that community group is managed by a good experienced person then I would say definitely a new trader can learn something good by joining that community. It is only by joining the community that he will learn something wrong, but not necessarily that he will learn something good from the community. Besides, by watching some videos on YouTube, you can get some ideas from there, thus a new trader can become experienced with ideas.

If you are assuring yourself that you wont really be following some investment or tips out of other peoples analysis and suggestions then it should be fine but its not bad to test out for yourself and be wary whether those analysis would work or not but in overall idea which all of us are just speculators.We do only differ on knowledge and methods on how to deal with the market since  there are noobs and there are experts and veterans which it would really be just understandable their main differences.

That's true, they may have some insightful things to say but it's not always effective for everyone. It's not that bad at all to be in a group but it's better to avoid most groups and just be yourself and start doing your own trades without their help. Some help could be a good starter but you don't have to lean on them for most times because it's not that going to work easy on you. But it's up to the newbie trader if he thinks that it's best for him to have some consultation with these groups. My take on it, resources are all over the internet and you just have to study all of them and try every possible strategy that you see and test which one is effectively working on you.

always joins them for the experience that you still haven't had, you will know how to figure out which pump are fake, basically you could gain knowledge from there massively, but only if you are willing to learn.
majority are joining groups just to get signal anyway, they just want their financial decision affected by external people cause they don't really care about creating their own analysis so they just wanna join the train.
i'd say it's essential if you still lack knowledge in regard of trading and investing in general. but of course majority of such groups are just full of noise if you don't become selective, most of them are just shouting about which coin they think better than the other else which could be causing you massive loss if you just follow blindly.

Yes i am a part of Trading Community being part of a trading group has helped me gain insights into different markets and make informed decisions, leading to greater profits. However, conflicting opinions and views on strategies can be a major disadvantage, and it's important to use personal judgment when making decisions.
My advice to people is to join a trading group or community, but use their advice with caution. Listen to multiple views and take the time to research and analyze your own strategy before taking any decisions.

There's advantages and disadvantage of joining a community of if traders, I believe the disadvantage are more dangerous than the advantages. The advantages has to do with you guys sharing ideals and helping each other out but whenever people are gathered in a community, there's always distraction and other negativity that plays out.

When distraction affect you, I'll be hard to ignore that distraction and in this situation you'll be seeing more of the distraction as you keep hanging out with the same traders. You can also easily encounter jealousy while been in the community which will lead to people trying to sabotage your trade, etc.

A new trader can become experienced by following different directions. If he starts trading with the advice of experienced people, he will risk losing some money in the first stage.  And watching videos from YouTube gives a good idea. Once he becomes an experienced trader, he will have no chance of losing money.  Because he will be experienced about trade. There will be little risk in new situation. It is better to start business with small money first.

The problem with the trade community is multiple opinions on the same problem. Someone says - now there will be growth, and cites his arguments, who says - no, now there will be a fall. Of course, one of them ends up being right - but who? As a result, the beginner will falter, make mistakes and lose money. That is why it is better for a beginner to sit down to study strategies, and do it all by himself. This is my opinion.

Yes, I would want to encourage him for that. It will be an edge for him if he will be aware first on the real events happening in real trading scenario so that he will have the ideas on how he will create strategies on how to win his trades. Moreover, if he can develop his own strategies and skills out from the shared experiences from other traders, that will also his edge in the market.

There is a challenge in every sector of human life, trading is one of such sectors that requires team contributions, it may not be in form of direct involvement of team members in the trading affairs of others, but team involvement in trading can come in the form of expert advise and vocal engagement by sharing experience and giving guidance where necessary.

-And belonging to a trading community can help but doing so under few members can give the most satisfying outcome to a newbie's traders, unlike having a large community full of multiple opinions and choices that will end up confusing.

-so I can belong to a trading community but that is if members are not more than 4/7/members and anything out of this is a no-no for me.

It's perfectly normal to be honest that you don't know what the terminologies are. It's like in any other field where you don't know what alien language are those people around you talking about. Even if you had read thousands to millions of books, I guarantee you that there would terminologies in trading that you would even forget and cannot even remember what it means, so to answer your question, it would help newbies to narrow down what they have to learn.

In my day trading days, there's only like 2-5 terms that I had remembered and it was enough to at least get me familiarized around Binance when I traded, meanwhile there are thousands of terminologies that applies to every single strategy out there.

It's not a disadvantage, but it might be overwhelming and might give you that "Impostor Syndrome" since all those people around you talk or write terms that you are not familiar with.

If it will contribute to his growth as a beginner then yes, I will advise him to join a trading community as long as it's legit and trusted. Experienced traders share their knowledge and experiences through groups which can help newbies to feel motivated to learn and explore more. Along with that, I will also advise him to search for everything about the risks of trading and that there's no such thing as perfect trading for him to have the proper mindset so he won't misinterpret or feel overhyped by the success stories of other traders.

when the group in question is a discussion group to share trading strategies and experiences, it will be good for the development of novice traders. but if the group contains only trading signals, it will be bad. because precisely that makes traders continue to depend on the signals given. even if the signal does not have good accuracy. in the mindset of novice traders is short profits with their limited skills. so they rely on instant signals to try their luck.

I 'm Being part of a trading community or group can be beneficial in many ways. Here are some of the advantages:
Access to knowledge and expertise: Trading communities allow you to connect with other traders who have different levels of experince and knowledge. This can help you learn new strategies, share ideas, and gain insight into the market.Trading can be a stressful and emotional experience. Being part of a trading community can provide you with a support system to help you stay motivated and focused during tough times.

I won't because the chances of misleading a new trader in a wrong way is possible when join a group and follow their tips because its known fact that most of the trading groups are nothing but pump and dump groups operated by whales or an individual for manipulating and trying to make money out of it. Whereas to get the knowledge we doesn't necessarily to join in a community we can learn since everything is available on internet.

That’s also the risk of joining a trading community when your intention is not to increase your knowledge in trading but to follow strategies from others, thinking what’s fit for them might also fit for you. You will only lose your trade as a beginner if you behave like that. However, if you only join because you want to learn more about trading and how it should be deal with, I guess that is an advantage for a beginner having exposed to what’s happening in a real trading scenario.

When you are just noob then you would really be having those main thoughts on which you would really be that easy to believe on what others analysis has ended up too on which you do make use of it and then later on
you had just experienced the other way around which we know that it isnt something that ideal on tending to follow someone.Its not bad to see up some good analysis which you could apply into yours but of course
you should really be that keen on doing that. Its up really depend on how someone would be able to adapt on things and wont easily get hooked up on being hyped and been shilled out.
Its up to yours whether joining group would be relevant or not.

Perhaps, it was a good decision as these people within the group can somewhat give useful advice and tips which could really help us to grow and improve our strategies as well. I do look for a group in our place, but unfortunately, it was really hard to find especially when they are also anonymous which is why I just end up getting with my old friend. I'd never expect to work well but it looks like it works more than being in the group so I decide to stop looking for them anymore.
Many heads are better than one or two but being a congested group and with consist of different people, that is somewhat hard to keep them. I'd rather keep alone or just with my friend so we can talk clearly and effectively.

There’s no harm if you advice a new trader to join a trading community as that will help him to learn more about trading strategies and skills, and to heighten his knowledge on trading. However, this will only harm a trader if he trade quickly thinking that he could also be profitable like other members in the community. Trading is not like that, you will only be profitable and successful in trading if you have achieved the required knowledge and skills, and that you can already be efficient in reading the market and making good analysis on it.

A newbie must know their limitation when it comes to trading and must also know their needs before starting trading.
Because it was not enough to just collect ideas and hear their advice/tips about trading but also it need to study the market and apply those things. Honestly, there is no perfect teaching about trading and their tips are sometimes not suitable for the market conditions which is why we also have to practice not relying on them but rather studying the market behavior as well in order to fully understand how trading works.

I think they should join a trading community because it's going to affect their learning process, being in a community with others who are interested in the same thing as you can affect the speed of your learning and if they're the lazy type the community can also help boost and correct their lackadaisical attitude.

And they can also gain orientation from they, as a newbie who is just entering a new domain they need as much information as possible to be successful in that field of theirs and trading is no different, and also at some point in time they'll also need guidance I'm not talking about YouTube tutorial guidance I'm mean a real interactive guidance and they might be lucky enough to get that from a community.
The only thing I wouldn't advice is when they start copying and letting others make their trading decision for them, that's the only unacceptable thing that a newbie should avoid.

I am agreeing with you in this point that there is nothing wrong with a new trader joining a trading community or trading group for good guidance and learning. But here I want to say something more that to become a professional trader, it is not enough to always rely on a few such communities or groups, you have to explore yourself and follow their guidelines as well as visit more communities, it is very important for learning.  Will be helpful.

Obviously, one cannot choose a specific limit area for learning. If one wants to learn, he has to gain knowledge from different fields. Moreover, even if a new trader understands the language of the professionals, he will need to acquire more knowledge. Because to be successful in trading, I think he needs to acquire different types of knowledge.

Yes recently I have joined some such groups, and yes their suggestions and tips are serving me well.  Being associated with such communities and groups I think helps a lot to increase your knowledge about trading and get all the latest updates easily. So I think there should be more positive things here
I would call a major disadvantage when a member is dependent and tied to only one group or community. By doing this, instead of increasing his knowledge, he may be confined to one place. So my advice would be to trade with your own strategy and knowledge and join these communities or groups as an extra helping hand.

The issue is that even if you join most of these communities, it won't change the fact that it is risky to be new and join a trading community without any experience. It's also important to consider the security of protecting your assets because most of these communities could be scams and you could become their victim. However, once you have some experience, you can, in my experience, distinguish between scams to some extent. as for me knowledge first, and I would not advise a new trader to go into trading without basics.

Joining a trading community or group can definitely be helpful, especially for those that are new to trading. It allows them to learn from others experiences, share strategies, and discuss market trends. They can also find help in those communities and groups when things  doesn't go well for them.
But yeah, it's essential to find a reliable and a legit community. Let's be honest, most of the groups are filled with trader trying to promote shit coins for their own benefit. Those groups promise unrealistic returns to lure traders and push specific coins so they can dump it on them. Even if they do join those groups, they should always do their own research and should not blindly follow anyone's advice.

No. Strategies will never change from the old buy low sell high game. In Spot at least, that is the most effective. Rest of the modes of trading are all gambling, not trading. This is not a college study group where reading more gives you more knowledge or sharing notes.

Disadvantage indeed. You will have the habit of checking that group everyday and pondering over it. Instead of wasting your time on that you should focus on family and friends to keep your mind fresh after trading.

100% of the content in these groups is bullshit and useless, so focus on your one man army of traders and also give time to things that you love to wind down.

It's easy to say, to do one's own research when one is still, in fact, a novice. He is not yet qualified to do any research. So almost any opinion confidently expressed will seem right to him. That's why a beginner just shouldn't join a trading community.

Participation in trading communities and groups can be very beneficial for traders as it provides them with the opportunity to connect with other traders who understand their situation and can share their experience and knowledge. This can help reduce feelings of isolation and improve market understanding.
In addition, in trading communities and groups, you can exchange new strategies and ideas, get feedback on your own strategies, and analyze the market together with other traders. This can help a trader expand their horizons and improve the quality of their own decisions.

If it is free, that's more than fine as you can gain some insights with the trading strategies.
But if they will start charging you, then, think about their motive.
Joining a free trading group would be a good one for your trading journey.
But remember, you should filter what they are suggesting as it may not be applicable to your situation.
You can always read their opinions, insights but it doesn't mean, you need to follow each one of them.

I would never hesitate to advice a newbie to join a trading community so that he will be aware on what is real trading is all about. That way, he will gain more insights on how to be a successful trader and a consistent profitable one. But I would always want to clear this thing in the first place that trading is certainly more losses for newbies than real gains. And whatever trading strategy that might work for others does not guarantee that it will also work for you. I guess he will be more cautious to trade knowing that.

depends on who you follow not all the groups are scammers there's good people you can learn from for free

i wish i could show you some picture here with proof but i can't post link here if you need real trading community to learn

how to trade for free just message me.

I don't know if I'm the only one who haven't come across real trading group you discuss, the ones I do see are channels that is operated by just one person and in that kind of channels, you can't discuss anything with other members. The groups for discussion are always litered with scams, unnecessary messages and noise makers that shill other shitcoins. It is good if we habe those kind of groups and community where we can interact with other traders but I will not advice other traders to jump into trading immediately with other peoples ideas, it can back fire anytime.

You aren't the only one since i havent joined any groups or whatsoever in correlation with these kind of stuffs which i do consider myself as self learn in all the trading methods and strategies that i have learn.The rest of learning could really be acquired though real experience or engagement with trading.Just like what others been saying that it wont really be that necessary to join up these groups since information and things could really be learnt up online since information is really just here for us to search up and learn from it.Doesnt matter whether you do join or not but i would recommend that it would be better to go solo and alone when it comes
to learning on which you could find out for yourself on what trading strategies and methods that suits you in.

Joining a trading group or community is a great idea, Infact, I consider it to be an important part of trading, it helps to focus, and also to have easy access to important informations very quick, as you don't get to dig for every information yourself all the time.

When I was a serous trader, I joined a lot of trading groups on telegram, though majority of those groups were filled with spammers and scammers looking for the weak ones to dupe, but there were still few of the groups that had some serious business minded people on it, and my stay in those groups were really fun and very informative, and educative to me..

So indeed, as a trader, finding a good trading community or group to join is indeed very helpful, much more than we can imagine.

Joining communities is also a way to familiarize trading and a sort of learning tool. Of course, we can't expect that everything we wanted to learn will come from them, not these people knowing the fact that some of these members might be scammers. That is why we should still not rely on them, they can be useful for other things but not enough to give trust to anyone in this group. We can learn some things from them somehow but we also have to work hard personally.

The only major disadvantage when you are a member in a trading group is when you start believing that trading is so easy that any trader can be so much profitable like the veteran traders in the group. So you did your own trade quickly without analyzing the market well, just imitate the same strategy that work on others, and then you end up trading at a loss. Not realizing that strategies that work for others might not work on you. The reason why we have to develop our personal trading strategy.

Just make yourself stick into realistic things, dont make yourself get easily believe on what others been saying or trying to show.The case when you do see these things then it wont really be bad to test it out
but its better not to make yourself that get affected or changed up your mind. They would really be trying to claim that it do works and on this time then you would be changing yours.
This is where it would continue out and if you do stick into this kind of behavior then it would totally be affecting your trading career path. Nothing beats out if you do rely
with your own style and preference on making and creating strategies.

Hello. I think its individually. I began my journey in thematic communities and groups too. I think for beginners this is the best way to quickly and efficiently understand the topic. I have now switched to p2p arbitrage, this is a more Low-risk trading strategy. By the way, now I began to train beginners and created my own P2P arbitrage team. If anyone wants to join, welcome ;D

Joining a trading community is like diving into the deep end of a pool without knowing how to swim. On one hand, you could find yourself surrounded by seasoned experts ready to teach you the ropes. But on the other hand, you could find yourself in a pool of piranhas, ready to strip you of your hard-earned cash.

That's why you need to do your homework and find a community you can trust. Don't be lured in by promises of instant riches or unrealistic returns. Remember, if it sounds too good to be true, it probably is.

Even in the most credible communities, you need to stay sharp and think for yourself. Don't be a lemming blindly following the herd. Always do your own research and make informed decisions.

And when the market gets rough, don't forget to laugh. Trading can be a wild ride, but a good laugh can make it all worthwhile. So join a trading community, but keep your eyes open and your sense of humor intact. It's the only way to survive in this unpredictable market.

Experience is the best thing and if a person is newbie then involving in a place where you gain knowledge will be better way to be a success investor. Engaging in group is crucial activity and everyone should engage in group, get knowledge from group is good but following every person is not good because these days there are so many groups the main purpose of which is to collect money from others and spread wrong information so they are called as scammers therefore if want success then try to get information about the group admin if he is not scammer then follow his rules otherwise believe without any query does not sound good.

And that's the purpose of having a trading group, you can teach them personally but I've got a different vibe with it. It's hard to distinguish those groups that have an experience rather than just opinions that will be shared with them. Maybe it was the experience was just different and didn't went well for most of us and that's why the impression remains but I think I'll adhere to that feeling that many of these groups aren't really good. I'll agree for newbies, there's an advantage just to having somewhere to start but in the long run, it depends until the group starts asking some fees to keep going on and that's the time to start the trading journey unassisted.

You are right that joining a group can also increase someone's knowledge on trading especially when you have zero knowledge about trading and what trading is.It is always good to engage in a discussion with people to know their experiences in the trading,their mistakes,flaws and when they got break-through in trading.This kind of groups gives you ample opportunity to have more knowledge about what trading is really all about because so many ideas will be brought by different people,telling how they had difficulties in their first trading session,and the things they did inorder to see break-through in it.This same group will also make you have someone you can call your mentor,who will teach you about the different strategies in trading,and what you will do to be a successful trader.

I'm a member of a Trading community on telegram but I barely have to communicate there but rather I watch the whole discussion over there and follow or learn from what experiences others are sharing and this is one thing I will advice newbies do when coming into the trading industry.
There are alot of scammers out there who promise to give trading signals and after for money to join their vip trading signal which I don't approve of such because I don't encourage people depend on signals from others but rather use those signals to direct or make their own final decisions.
It isn't a bad idea to join a trading community bit it isn't a nice idea to rely solely from informations and signals gotten from those communities especially if it isn't profitable for long

Yeah, a lot of random people message me in telegram also, they're offering something like a trading signal and a website that can earn money easily. New people who just join in crypto will easily fall into the scammer trap, so I guess it's better to find a friend to guide new traders so they won't easily fall to the scammer persuasion

Seriously as a trader, I believe it's good to join some trading communities, you can learn new things from there, but I won't recommend you join any trading signal community, and if you are looking for trading communities that are providing trading strategies, just know that other people's strategies might not work for you, so when trading make sure you do your research and discover the appropriate strategies that will work for you, the trading strategy that might be working for your friend might not work for you.

No offense, but mostly in the telegram in my experience is a scammer. First time I tried joining a group of people for me to enhance my knowledge about trading and investing, but lately I've realized that they are scammer after they start to direct message me with fishy conversation that led to sending money. Good thing for you to have a nice group of people but I also prefer to learn by myself online if I want a second opinion about crypto, I ask in group chats or even here forum.


This is what I'm talking about earlier, but about asking for a calls for other people about your decision in crypto would be a dumb thing to do for me. Even if you ask to a pro in crypto, you can't blame them if they have a bad call that causes you to loss your money. Because it's always up to you to decide in risking your money that's why its better for you to have a proper knowledge about crypto and don't let your emotion overpower to your decisions since it's your money at stake.  

my advice to people you have to make estimates or targets where you buy and sell your trades, I suffered a loss because I was greedy and did not obey the rules that I made myself, I was very annoyed but from there I will learn,for now I stop for a moment to raise capital and calm the mind first.

There is no bad thing in getting involved in groups for getting knowledge but try to join in those groups which provide information without any charges because some people ask for money but their provided information is not correct so it will be better to  get engaged in groups but try to accumulate information about the admin.

There is a benefit of joining groups but person cannot make his own decision because of a doubt for his own decision and he just rely on the information and decision of groups.

The truth for me what I recommend to Anyone who wants to join a commercial group is not bad,but as long as you do not pay any type of subscription,apart from the Fact that the group can provide analysis and many ways of thinking, in the debate you can It will achieve many things, here with regard to the crypto market things are handled at another level, because the volatility is quite strong, and they can give us any type of results if we start looking for a lot of information, it is good, but Explain why so it can be learned, but if they make a Mistake, know why they failed.

It’s great that, you are trying to learn from your mistakes, but the OP’s question was whether new traders should join trading communities or not. So I would say always try to increase your circle, meet varieties of people, talk with them and at last learn from their mistakes or winnings. A newbie trader can learn a lot from these trading groups when he/she starting their journey. But yes if they joining the groups only to get good and majority calls, then definitely they need to stop. As from the calls they won’t learn the technique of analysing and calculation. Moreover if they getting losses from the calls, they will only blame the community for the calls. So OP needs to be smart enough to decide for what purpose he wants to join the groups.

That is a better method than joining a trading group. Keeping an Excel sheet for the buying and selling or possible planned selling and buying can help a lot of the new traders as they move from dummy trading or as a log of trades for long term records.

In trading groups and all you will only get spam from hyips and shitcoins and that random bot seller who attempts to scam you which all end up being a distraction and a waste of time.

Friends and colleagues who trade together win and are successful together. There's always more benefit when you are with a group of people with the same aim. Imagine getting personal tips and strategies from people with years of trading experience. Imagine being part of a group where you access trading knowledge and expertise free or charge. Imagine getting the emotional support and encouragement you need when it seems you hit a brick wall in your trading journey.
Well my two cents on joining a trading community are to join one where you know one or two persons personally who are in the group and are doing well. It is a clear pointer that you will find what you are looking for there.

It will be very helpful for a new trader  to join a community of traders.It will speed up the learning process, coming up with a trading concept, avoiding mistakes ,getting corrections from experienced members and lastly help the new trader to have confidence in what he is doing unlike If he is doing it all alone.

Helpful if you do see that you do need to have some idea at least on what others been doing but its not literally that much needed considering that everything could really be learnt up online.It is really just that a matter
of effort on which it would be put through considering that your efforts is something would be depending on how you would be learning up things along the way.If you do see that joining groups would be fastening out
your learning then go on it, you are the ones who would really be handling out your time and if you do seem that it would really be that something sensible to do then go for it but honestly
we can really learn on our own if we are really that serious on doing so.