Bitcoin Forum

Other => Meta => Topic started by: LoyceV on February 27, 2024, 06:42:21 PM



Title: sembt.com clones entire Bitcointalk topics
Post by: LoyceV on February 27, 2024, 06:42:21 PM
Look what I just found (use Tor browser or VPN, don't expose your IP to this site): https://sembt.LINKBREAKERcom/thread-15254-1-12.html.
Now compare that to https://bitcointalk.org/index.php?topic=5481114.0 (the OP looks like chatbot spam, but that's not the point).

That site pretends to be an active forum, but simply clones Bitcointalk! Their user images are probably AI generated.

PrivacyG turned into LynnWalter, pakhitheboss turned into 8564Jg, pooya87 turned into SBSBB and Edwin, hd49728 turned into steven136 and hugeblack turned into brandon58 :D


Title: Re: sembt.com clones entire Bitcointalk topics
Post by: dkbit98 on February 27, 2024, 08:51:21 PM
That site pretends to be an active forum, but simply clones Bitcointalk! Their user images are probably AI generated.
I can't remember exact links but I am sure this is not the first time we see someone cloning bitcointalk forum.
Looks like this specific clone was made in China, and maybe they wanted to create fake conversation mixed with their own posts.

PrivacyG turned into LynnWalter, pakhitheboss turned into 8564Jg, pooya87 turned into SBSBB and Edwin, hd49728 turned into steven136 and hugeblack turned into brandon58 :D
You didn't say how they renamed you  ;)
I see they didn't included all boards and they added a lot of hearts with every action  :P


Title: Re: sembt.com clones entire Bitcointalk topics
Post by: SamReomo on February 27, 2024, 09:11:44 PM
I visited that forum and noticed that all of the threads were created today. The boards on that forum are named differently, and I have noticed that they have changed names of almost each member of this forum.

They named me as 2Philip, 1miau as MortonAddison, Bitmover as AllenTennyson, and DdmrDdmr as DonahueChaplin. The one who created that forum might know about Bitcointalk or might be a member of this forum I guess.


Title: Re: sembt.com clones entire Bitcointalk topics
Post by: Catenaccio on February 28, 2024, 02:38:41 AM
They cloned Bitcointalk and maybe they are doing it to gain traffic. When they see enough website traffic, they will stop cloning Bitcointalk and sell their site to something else.

Their site will not be shut down if they clone exactly the Bitcointalk forum from topics, posts to usernames. Do anyone know possible reasons of using random usernames on that clone site?

[SCAM] fake Bitcointalk forum clone BitInfo.cc !!! (https://bitcointalk.org/index.php?topic=5193535)
Duplicate of Bitcointalk. (https://bitcointalk.org/index.php?topic=5280111.0)


Title: Re: sembt.com clones entire Bitcointalk topics
Post by: Poker Player on February 28, 2024, 05:32:05 AM
Their user images are probably AI generated.

Only the images? I wouldn't be surprised if at least part of the text is too.

They named me as 2Philip, 1miau as MortonAddison, Bitmover as AllenTennyson, and DdmrDdmr as DonahueChaplin. The one who created that forum might know about Bitcointalk or might be a member of this forum I guess.

Any idea who am I there? I have visited the forum, but as the structure is different, they have not cloned thread by thread this forum, I do not just see myself there.

They cloned Bitcointalk and maybe they are doing it to gain traffic. When they see enough website traffic, they will stop cloning Bitcointalk and sell their site to something else.

Well, I don't know, surely if I had done it I wouldn't sell it when it starts to work. I'm curious, since we already have movies made by AI in which the actors who appear are people who do not exist, and are made without scriptwriters or cameras or anything that is used to make a movie traditionally. Could such a forum be monetized? I mean if apart from the traffic there are also bots generating text with AI.



Title: Re: sembt.com clones entire Bitcointalk topics
Post by: hugeblack on February 28, 2024, 05:49:46 AM
It appears they used the forum database to create their own content. The content is a little different and they have other sections that appear to be clones from other forums.

PrivacyG turned into LynnWalter, pakhitheboss turned into 8564Jg, pooya87 turned into SBSBB and Edwin, hd49728 turned into steven136 and hugeblack turned into brandon58 :D

These usernames are random and vary depending on the topic. I searched for some topic and found that they changed the username several times.
Some forum codes seem broken here


Title: Re: sembt.com clones entire Bitcointalk topics
Post by: LoyceV on February 28, 2024, 06:30:05 AM
I can't remember exact links but I am sure this is not the first time we see someone cloning bitcointalk forum.
I've seen them, but those were either fishing sites, or just full clones. This new one looks like it's trying to be a forum and uses "our" posts to make it look active.

You didn't say how they renamed you  ;)
I didn't find myself, but it looks like they didn't keep a fixed name for each user. The copied posts get a new random name.


Title: Re: sembt.com clones entire Bitcointalk topics
Post by: Helena Yu on February 28, 2024, 06:36:01 AM
Based on my research. sembt.com is owned by ggcoins.net

Innovate encryption, and safeguard digital wealth: Join our wallet discussion community (http://sembt.com) to co-create the future of wealth!

They're greedy since they only want to grow their own sites without giving any credit to other forum (Bitcointalk), that's why they create their own forum.

Whoever own ggcoins and sembt, f*ck you!


Title: Re: sembt.com clones entire Bitcointalk topics
Post by: SamReomo on February 28, 2024, 07:03:15 AM
Any idea who am I there? I have visited the forum, but as the structure is different, they have not cloned thread by thread this forum, I do not just see myself there.
They have named you as AndrewMarshall, you can see it by opening this link (https://sembt.com/forum.php?mod=viewthread&tid=15364&highlight=The%2BHonduras%2BSpecial%2BZone%2Bofficially) just be sure to use a VPN or Tor or a web proxy in order to visit the link.  ;)


Title: Re: sembt.com clones entire Bitcointalk topics
Post by: paid2 on February 28, 2024, 07:22:56 AM
Look what I just found (use Tor browser or VPN, don't expose your IP to this site): https://sembt.com/thread-15254-1-12.html.
Now compare that to https://bitcointalk.org/index.php?topic=5481114.0 (the OP looks like chatbot spam, but that's not the point).

-snip-

I am so disappointed; the website is down from my side. I was super curious!

I wanted to meet my Chinese own version.  ???


Title: Re: sembt.com clones entire Bitcointalk topics
Post by: FatFork on February 28, 2024, 07:50:34 AM
Look what I just found (use Tor browser or VPN, don't expose your IP to this site): https://sembt.com/thread-15254-1-12.html.
Now compare that to https://bitcointalk.org/index.php?topic=5481114.0 (the OP looks like chatbot spam, but that's not the point).

-snip-

I am so disappointed; the website is down from my side. I was super curious!

I wanted to meet my Chinese own version.  ???

The website is not down. Use VPN or Tor if you are geoblocked. (You should use them anyway when visiting such sites.)


Title: Re: sembt.com clones entire Bitcointalk topics
Post by: paid2 on February 28, 2024, 07:54:50 AM
The website is not down. Use VPN or Tor if you are geoblocked. (You should use them anyway when visiting such sites.)

It was with my VPN, tried with different servers.

Working fine with Tor thank you!

Lol so my chinese double is named Alger


Title: Re: sembt.com clones entire Bitcointalk topics
Post by: DdmrDdmr on February 28, 2024, 08:21:37 AM
<…> Lol so my chinese double is named Alger
The same Bitcointalk account seems to have multiple names over there. I’ve see a single account here have a different name on each post it made within given thread over there.

I don’t know if all the images of faces that appear on the profiles within the site are made by the same software, but a lot of them include a watermark on the bottom right corner indicating "StyleGAN2 (Karras et al.)". Stylegan2 is a generative AI that constitutes a research project by nVidia (https://github.com/NVlabs), so that´s the software being used to generate the face type images. Non-face type images don’t seem to be using the said software, but rather are copied from stock images and/or social networks.


Title: Re: sembt.com clones entire Bitcointalk topics
Post by: ABCbits on February 28, 2024, 09:13:47 AM
Great discovery, although i recall it's not first time it happens where that other clone do worse (by imitate Bitcointalk UI).

Based on my research. sembt.com is owned by ggcoins.net

Innovate encryption, and safeguard digital wealth: Join our wallet discussion community (http://sembt.com) to co-create the future of wealth!

They're greedy since they only want to grow their own sites without giving any credit to other forum (Bitcointalk), that's why they create their own forum.

Whoever own ggcoins and sembt, f*ck you!

On top of that,
1. Article created ggcoins.net seems to be generated by AI and there are many article with similar topic (almost all article on it's homepage talks about hardware wallet in general). So i agree with @Poker Player that some thread/reply on sembt.com could be AI generated.
2. Some article i checked always links to sembt.com.


Title: Re: sembt.com clones entire Bitcointalk topics
Post by: criptoevangelista on February 28, 2024, 10:59:25 AM
How crazy is that! On this forum I turned into Charles640 with a cat avatar (at least that's cool)

What do they want with that? some kind of experiment? apply scams? Or is it some password capture site? because a member here may go there and try to enter your password to try to access... (never doubt what a person is capable of)


Title: Re: sembt.com clones entire Bitcointalk topics
Post by: Upgrade00 on February 28, 2024, 12:51:02 PM
What do they want with that? some kind of experiment? apply scams? Or is it some password capture site? because a member here may go there and try to enter your password to try to access... (never doubt what a person is capable of)
It could be a way to optimize their search results in search engines or building something that looks somewhat like a legitimate website to steal information from those who visit it.

I doubt it's a phishing attempt, if it were, they would have used very similar url and everything else.


Title: Re: sembt.com clones entire Bitcointalk topics
Post by: Learn Bitcoin on February 28, 2024, 02:20:05 PM
I guess this is what is called a grabber if I am not wrong. If I remember correctly, I have seen a lot of YouTube grabber scripts on the Masterland forum and I guess I have tried some of those scripts as well. I do not have coding knowledge, but I have tried to ready-mate scripts. I have seen a lot of people code grabber scripts of youtube, even porn websites, and news websites.

I haven't seen any forum scripts. What is the benefit of running such websites since all of those are just bots? If there is no genuine discussion and no one replies, I don't see what could be their benefits. Probably they are trying to get some traffic from google search to make some money from adnetworks! 


Title: Re: sembt.com clones entire Bitcointalk topics
Post by: dkbit98 on February 28, 2024, 05:41:28 PM
I didn't find myself, but it looks like they didn't keep a fixed name for each user. The copied posts get a new random name.
And they added a nice random AI generated profile images :P
They didn't cloned me also, so I guess we are not attractive enough for them ;)

I just found they cloned some of our local members Pmalek and FatFork, they became timothy617 and alex720.

Original posts:
https://bitcointalk.org/index.php?topic=5454670.msg62381063#msg62381063
https://bitcointalk.org/index.php?topic=5454670.msg62401089#msg62401089

copy-pasted posts:
Code:
https ://sembt.com/forum.php?mod=viewthread&tid=16639&page=7&authorid=6461
https ://sembt.com/forum.php?mod=viewthread&tid=16639&page=7&authorid=4126



Title: Re: sembt.com clones entire Bitcointalk topics
Post by: robelneo on February 28, 2024, 11:14:29 PM
The forum uses Discuz theme

https://www.talkimg.com/images/2024/02/28/fwL1H.png (https://www.talkimg.com/image/fwL1H)


Quote
Discuz! is an Internet forum software written in PHP and developed by Comsenz Technology Co., Ltd (Chinese: 康盛创想).[2] It supports MySQL and PostgreSQL databases. It is the most popular Internet forum program used in China.[3]

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Discuz!

Exploring further

Domain Information
Domain: sembt.com
Registrar: Alibaba Cloud Computing (Beijing) Co., Ltd.
Registered On:2019-10-31  Expires On: 2024-10-31 Updated On: 2024-01-24
Name Servers: dns29.hichina.comdns30.hichina.com

Its China-based platform trying to compete with Bitcointalk, they started their operation just last month so expect a lot of cloning of topics


Title: Re: sembt.com clones entire Bitcointalk topics
Post by: The Sceptical Chymist on February 29, 2024, 01:13:33 AM
Looks like this specific clone was made in China, and maybe they wanted to create fake conversation mixed with their own posts.
Not for nothing, but who could have guessed its country of origin?  No offense to any Chinese here who might not be in favor of counterfeiting, but....

You didn't say how they renamed you  ;)
There's no way I'm clicking on that link to check, but am I correct in assuming I haven't been cloned?  If not, I'm brokenhearted, I tell you.  Just brokenhearted.  Lol.

This fake forum sounds about 10 times worse than that shitty forum Yobit created a few years ago, where plagiarism from this site was rampant.  Cryptotalk.something I think it was?


Title: Re: sembt.com clones entire Bitcointalk topics
Post by: CODE200 on February 29, 2024, 02:45:44 AM
Not for nothing, but who could have guessed its country of origin?  No offense to any Chinese here who might not be in favor of counterfeiting, but....
Here's China again trying to copy something and trying to make it their own, this happened with Clash of Clans too back in 2022 if I recall correctly although they didn't need to copy the whole game, they want to move it to a different server so it's only Chinese players, I'm winging it here with the reason that China is copying Bitcointalk but I think they want to do the same thing as Clash of Clans, they want a Bitcointalk forum of their own but seeing how they're being conspicuous and that you need to use a VPN or Tor to browse their website, I feel like this is just something to scam other people that have no idea that this forum exists, a lot of things can be done in a clone website after all.


Title: Re: sembt.com clones entire Bitcointalk topics
Post by: LoyceV on February 29, 2024, 06:50:58 AM
Looks like this specific clone was made in China, and maybe they wanted to create fake conversation mixed with their own posts.
Not for nothing, but who could have guessed its country of origin?  No offense to any Chinese here who might not be in favor of counterfeiting, but....
I don't think it's the Chinese government doing this, just someone who had "a great idea" to make money. It happens in many other countries too.


Title: Re: sembt.com clones entire Bitcointalk topics
Post by: NotATether on February 29, 2024, 07:42:14 AM
I don't think it's the Chinese government doing this, just someone who had "a great idea" to make money. It happens in many other countries too.

Where does the money for this "great idea" come from? Ads? I can't see any. (Or maybe that's because I have my adblocker on.)


Title: Re: sembt.com clones entire Bitcointalk topics
Post by: LoyceV on February 29, 2024, 08:35:57 AM
Where does the money for this "great idea" come from? Ads? I can't see any. (Or maybe that's because I have my adblocker on.)
This meme-format comes to mind:
Step 1: copy content.
Step 2: get visitors.
Step 3: ....
Step 4: Profit.

Now that I think about it: I'll remove the clickable link I created in this topic. They don't deserve a backlink.


Title: Re: sembt.com clones entire Bitcointalk topics
Post by: Timelord2067 on February 29, 2024, 08:37:46 AM
Users might want to stear away from those fake forums entirely.

You may be able to mask your I.P. via Tor, but not details surrounding your browser, screen size and similar which would be linked to the profiles you visit while on that site (which would usually be your own user profile).

(And some of you have identified what the random profile name is you have been looking at that corresponds with your profile here).


Title: Re: sembt.com clones entire Bitcointalk topics
Post by: LoyceV on February 29, 2024, 08:41:38 AM
You may be able to mask your I.P. via Tor, but not details surrounding your browser, screen size and similar
Although off-topic: this is exactly what Tor browser helps prevent.


Title: Re: sembt.com clones entire Bitcointalk topics
Post by: Pmalek on February 29, 2024, 05:53:56 PM
I just found they cloned some of our local members Pmalek and FatFork, they became timothy617 and alex720.
They should have given me the name Timmy instead of Timothy. Those who watched South Park back when it was worth it, they know who I am talking about.

https://www.talkimg.com/images/2024/02/29/fnwhJ.jpeg