Bitcoin Forum

Bitcoin => Mining => Topic started by: k on January 24, 2012, 11:33:28 PM



Title: Are there any mining contracts offering the right to choose how to vote for P2SH
Post by: k on January 24, 2012, 11:33:28 PM
Just wondering?
Are any miners selling their hashing power along with the right of the purchaser to choose how to vote on the P2SH question?

Could be an opportunity to make an extra premium.


Title: Re: Are there any mining contracts offering the right to choose how to vote for P2SH
Post by: slush on January 26, 2012, 01:16:44 PM
Technically one entity (one miner, one pool) cannot vote for or against P2SH in the same time. So your only choice is to pick pool or mining company which has the same opinion like you.

As an example, MergedMining company is (afaik) supporting P2SH because they're mining on my pool.


Title: Re: Are there any mining contracts offering the right to choose how to vote for P2SH
Post by: [Tycho] on January 26, 2012, 01:21:15 PM
Technically one entity (one miner, one pool) cannot vote for or against P2SH in the same time
Actually it can.
Just insert /P2SH/ tag in appropriate % of your blocks :)


Title: Re: Are there any mining contracts offering the right to choose how to vote for P2SH
Post by: slush on January 26, 2012, 01:32:23 PM
Technically one entity (one miner, one pool) cannot vote for or against P2SH in the same time
Actually it can.
Just insert /P2SH/ tag in appropriate % of your blocks :)

Actually they cannot. They can *insert* the text into the coinbase, but one entity cannot actually mine for both chains (except some strange solution) at the same time, so putting p2sh header in some blocks don't have the sense.


Title: Re: Are there any mining contracts offering the right to choose how to vote for P2SH
Post by: [Tycho] on January 26, 2012, 03:15:39 PM
Actually they cannot. They can *insert* the text into the coinbase, but one entity cannot actually mine for both chains (except some strange solution) at the same time, so putting p2sh header in some blocks don't have the sense.
Actual mining should be decided accordingly to the voting result.