Bitcoin Forum

I've just completed an Introduction to BitCoin (http://bitcointalk.org/index.php?topic=7269.0) that we can sticky for newcomers, but I'd like to add an index at the end to some canonical threads around recurring questions, like:

"How do I get started using BitCoin?"
"Is BitCoin a Ponzi or pyramid scheme?" completed (http://bitcointalk.org/index.php?topic=7815.0)
"Where do I get the free money?"
"What if someone bought up all the existing bitcoins?"
"Won't loss of wallets and the finite amount of bitcoins create excessive deflation, destroying BitCoin?"
"What happens if someone starts another blockchain or cryptocurrency?"
"Could miners collude to give themselves money or fundamentally change the nature of BitCoin?"
etc.

In the long run the solution we want is a professional Q&A site (http://area51.stackexchange.com/proposals/30763/bitcoin-crypto-currency), so go there first and vote for on/off topic questions to help define the site.

After you've done that, come back here and help suggest which other questions recur here often enough that they should get their own thread, linked from the index.

The idea I have for these threads is that I (or someone else) will begin the thread with a clear and concise answer to the question.  Newbies will then be free to ask for help, clarification, etc.  These threads will be clearly labelled and designated Newbie-Safe Zones so that those who are annoyed by new/ignorant users can simply avoid them.  If a newcomer asks an answered-a-million-times question on another part of the forums, they can simply be referred to the canonical thread.  Any further posting on already-answered questions outside the thread will be considered off-topic, as will unhelpful comments by "oldies" inside the marked threads.  Would I be able to get some moderator support for this?

As these forums continue to grow at an overwhelming rate, hopefully this will help the user experience for both newcomers and oldies.  Suggestions/comments/feedback?

Just so you all know:  for every 100 views this post receives without reply, I kill a kitten.

The kittens are safe for another hundred views!

I just added a few more example questions, since it appears that's what we need now.

"Why is the exchange rate so volatile? Will prices in Bitcoin ever stabilize?"
"Are Bitcoin transactions anonymous? How can someone link my identity to information in the block chain?"
"Doesn't Bitcoin favor early adopters, since they were able to spend comparatively fewer resources to gain a significantly larger reward?"
"Is Bitcoin a pyramid or ponzi scheme?"

The Ponzi scheme one is a good one.  I'm going to be editing my first post and including the questions I intend to launch threads for myself, though I'm happy to have help.  Also, how should the canonical newbie threads be clearly marked?

"How do I create a Bitcoin account?"

Good suggestion--I added the more general "How do I get started using BitCoin?"

Is an example of a Ponzi scheme a Final Salary Pension?

Hope this saves the kitten anyway.  :-\

I'd like to add:

"What if some people start an other block chain?  Or ten of them?  Won't that depreciate bitcoin's value?"

"What if miners collude to reward themselves more bitcoins?"

And above all:

"Since bitcoins are not backed by anything, aren't they ultimately worthless?"



PS.  But aren't all these questions in the FAQ already?  What am I missing?

I would like to see something like "What Are Bitcoins Largest Vulnerabilities - MONTH - YEAR" type questions being posted/answered on a regular basis.

In other words, what should we be working on most furiously at that point in time?

What about a "Keeping your bitwealth secure" section. It seems to me that some basic understanding of how and why to keep your wallet file safe is knowledge everyone should know.

P.S. feel free to kill a kitten anyway.

I can hash cheezburger?

(A legitimate question on getting free money, if only a little redundant)

Alright, I think I have enough to work on for now.  The "Security practices" is a good one too that I will work on if I have enough time--or someone else is welcome to.

@grondilu some of these questions are answered somewhat briefly on the wiki, but having them listed right up there in a stickied post makes it feel fairer for newbs to be redirected there and have their own threads closed if necessary.  There are also a lot of users browsing without logging in who would probably click through.  It's basically just an effort to improve the user experience of the forums.  And you're right that many of these concepts will be covered in my "introduction to bitcoin" itself.

eMansipater you may wanna add a link to vladimir's post how to secure a wallet http://bitcointalk.org/index.php?topic=5194.0 (http://bitcointalk.org/index.php?topic=5194.0)

Definitely-will do.  I'm also going to be marking my canonical threads with "(Newbie-Friendly)" unless someone has a better suggestion.

I have some more questions to add:

- Can Bitcoins be transferred to any country? What about China?
- Is Bitcoin a green technology or does it harm the environment more than necessary?
- I like Bitcoin. How can I help?
- What happens, when I don't run the Bitcoin client on my computer? Am I still be able to receive transactions?

Greetings, Danube

"How can I / the average person ever get any bitcoins when mining takes so long?"

The idea that mining is the normal way to get bitcoins is pretty pervasive, probably because of how it's introduced, and this question keeps getting asked.

Yes, this will all be covered in the "Where do I get the free money?" thread.

Thanks Danube--some of these will be included in the existing threads.  Specific questions about using BitCoin in China, for example, will probably not warrant a canonical thread unless they show up again and again--they can simply be asked normally on the forums.


Just to warn you all, I'm going to disappear for a while now--it takes a long time to write and proof good answers to these types of questions!

Thanks for all your work eMansipater. Someone should put your document on weusecoins.com too.

What about:

"Is bitcoin legal?"
"What can I buy with bitcoins?"

Would it be possible to adapt eMansipaters work for the wikipedia entry about BitCoin? Probably there we have a big exposure to the public.

In keeping with my policy on informing those I rate:

I am giving Emansipator a +1 for the following reasons:

1. Maturity, friendliness and helpfulness when dealing with newbies
2. Their work on the Canonical BitCoin Questions
3. General positive attitude, politeness and sense of humor

Thanks for being a part of the BitCoin community.

Thanks Script!  You just made my day  :)

Is BitCoin a Ponzi or pyramid scheme? (http://bitcointalk.org/index.php?topic=7815.0) thread completed, work begun on "Introduction to BitCoin" and "Where do I get the free money?".  Questions/comments/suggestions/feedback?  Please post it here rather than in the actual thread, which should be left for newbies.