Bitcoin Forum

Other => Meta => Topic started by: a nice guy on May 24, 2012, 06:02:33 PM



Title: Random "you're were banned for trolling"
Post by: a nice guy on May 24, 2012, 06:02:33 PM
Hello,

I get this error message once in a while:
"Sorry a nice guy, you are banned from posting or sending personal messages on this forum.
Trolling 12"

Sometimes it stays there for 10 minutes and sometimes it's gone when I reload the page.

Is this a glitch in the software, or what's going on?

kind regards,
a nice guy


Title: Re: Random "you're were banned for trolling"
Post by: Raoul Duke on May 24, 2012, 06:07:43 PM
You are using Tor and got an IP that someone who got banned for trolling used? lol

I only see that message when I'm really banned. And if your "ban" only lasts for 10 minutes you're lucky. Mine usually lasts 7 days ;D


Title: Re: Random "you're were banned for trolling"
Post by: a nice guy on May 24, 2012, 06:12:37 PM
You are using Tor and got an IP that someone who got banned for trolling used? lol

I only see that message when I'm really banned. And if your "ban" only lasts for 10 minutes you're lucky. Mine usually lasts 7 days ;D

Could be, but it's a bit weird since registering through Tor is "not possible" on this forum and
Theymos registered this account for me.
I thought the system bans users and not ips, someone could get a new ip-address within seconds.

kind regards,
a nice guy


Title: Re: Random "you're were banned for trolling"
Post by: rjk on May 24, 2012, 06:14:10 PM
You are using Tor and got an IP that someone who got banned for trolling used? lol

I only see that message when I'm really banned. And if your "ban" only lasts for 10 minutes you're lucky. Mine usually lasts 7 days ;D

Could be, but it's a bit weird since registering through Tor is "not possible" on this forum and
Theymos registered this account for me.
I thought the system bans users and not ips, someone could get a new ip-address within seconds.

kind regards,
a nice guy

Access thru Tor is allowed, but registration is not. Bans are account level and IP level. Try a new exit.


Title: Re: Random "you're were banned for trolling"
Post by: a nice guy on May 24, 2012, 06:15:57 PM
You are using Tor and got an IP that someone who got banned for trolling used? lol

I only see that message when I'm really banned. And if your "ban" only lasts for 10 minutes you're lucky. Mine usually lasts 7 days ;D

Could be, but it's a bit weird since registering through Tor is "not possible" on this forum and
Theymos registered this account for me.
I thought the system bans users and not ips, someone could get a new ip-address within seconds.

kind regards,
a nice guy

Access thru Tor is allowed, but registration is not. Bans are account level and IP level. Try a new exit.

Thank you


Title: Re: Random "you're were banned for trolling"
Post by: theymos on May 24, 2012, 06:23:00 PM
Yeah, you were just caught in someone else's ban. Often when I ban a user, I ban all of the IPs they've used.

I removed some of the banned IPs for that ban.


Title: Re: Random "you're were banned for trolling"
Post by: merlin1234 on August 01, 2012, 07:32:34 PM
I am also banned.....


Title: Re: Random "you're were banned for trolling"
Post by: HeavyMetal on August 11, 2012, 05:41:20 PM
I find little to gain by banning tor IPs when using the forum with tor is allowed. It is very very unlikely that such a ban would hit the intended target, collateral damage is far more likely.

I understand that when banning IPs it may not be obvious that it is a tor IP, but a script could regularly clear these.

Best to either whitelist all tor ips or blacklist all tor ips. A mixed policy(intended or incidental) regarding tor will only hit random people.


Title: Re: Random "you're were banned for trolling"
Post by: Gabi on August 12, 2012, 02:11:34 PM
Yeah, you were just caught in someone else's ban. Often when I ban a user, I ban all of the IPs they've used.

I removed some of the banned IPs for that ban.
Are you joking am i right?

Do you realize that in Europe we use dynamic IP? Wich means everytime i restart the router i get a new IP? Banning the IP i have used would be not only epic useless, but harmful because some other will end up using them. So basically by IP banning you only harm other people.

Oh and yes, Europe exists. USA is not the only country in the world!


Title: Re: Random "you're were banned for trolling"
Post by: iqbal15st on July 23, 2015, 12:23:10 PM
Yeah, you were just caught in someone else's ban. Often when I ban a user, I ban all of the IPs they've used.

I removed some of the banned IPs for that ban.
whether logged in 2 ip simultaneously also prohibited, and could cause our account banned?


Title: Re: Random "you're were banned for trolling"
Post by: jambola2 on July 23, 2015, 12:59:43 PM
whether logged in 2 ip simultaneously also prohibited, and could cause our account banned?

As far as I know, no that is not a reason for being banned.
It's just that if your account is banned, both those IPs will be banned.