Bitcoin Forum

Economy => Exchanges => Topic started by: sneak on January 05, 2015, 09:17:36 AM



Title: Bitstamp issues statement and temporarily suspends service
Post by: sneak on January 05, 2015, 09:17:36 AM
https://www.bitstamp.net

Quote
BITSTAMP SERVICE TEMPORARILY SUSPENDED

We have reason to believe that one of Bitstamp’s operational wallets was compromised on January 4th, 2015.
As a security precaution against compromises Bitstamp only maintains a small fraction of customer bitcoins in online systems. Bitstamp maintains more than enough offline reserves to cover the compromised bitcoins.

IN THE MEANTIME, PLEASE DO NOT MAKE DEPOSITS TO PREVIOUSLY ISSUED BITCOIN DEPOSIT ADDRESSES. THEY CANNOT BE HONORED!

Customer deposits made prior to January 5th, 2015 9:00 UTC are fully covered by Bitstamp’s reserves. Deposits made to newly issued addresses provided after January 5th, 2015 9:00 UTC can be honored.

Bitstamp takes our security and soundness very seriously. In an excess of caution, we are suspending service as we continue to investigate. We will return to service and amend our security measures as appropriate.

Bitstamp Team


Title: Re: Bitstamp issues statement and temporarily suspends service
Post by: flipstyle on January 05, 2015, 09:37:18 AM
lololol

Here we go again...another service bites the dust...mt gox part 2379248723897234879234. This shit will never end until it takes bitcoin down with it.  Unbelievable.


Title: Re: Bitstamp issues statement and temporarily suspends service
Post by: BldSwtTrs on January 05, 2015, 09:38:58 AM
2015 is so 2014.


Title: Re: Bitstamp issues statement and temporarily suspends service
Post by: BitCoinNutJob on January 05, 2015, 09:49:33 AM
lololol

Here we go again...another service bites the dust...mt gox part 2379248723897234879234. This shit will never end until it takes bitcoin down with it.  Unbelievable.

Im thinking they currently just have a technical issue, im not using them or have any money in there but its doesnt look like a gox situation.


Title: Re: Bitstamp issues statement and temporarily suspends service
Post by: gondel on January 05, 2015, 09:53:07 AM
this is so 2000 and lame


Title: Re: Bitstamp issues statement and temporarily suspends service
Post by: flipstyle on January 05, 2015, 09:53:38 AM
lololol

Here we go again...another service bites the dust...mt gox part 2379248723897234879234. This shit will never end until it takes bitcoin down with it.  Unbelievable.

Im thinking they currently just have a technical issue, im not using them or have any money in there but its doesnt look like a gox situation.

The fact of the matter is...regardless how 'bad' this situation really is...it shows that bitcoin money is safe nowhere.  Exchanges can basically take your money and run at any instant and claim they were hacked...with no repurcussions or explicit proof.  If that isn't enough to scare away any potential future adopters, I don't know what is.

Having lost various amounts at cryptorush and coinex...hearing stories like this don't even phase me...it's just another broken record that you basically expect.



Addtionally...anyone ever notice how these exchanges just so happen to conveniently go bust right when bitcoin is experiencing huge price volatility (either good or bad).  It's like the scammers don't even really care about hiding their motives anymore, because they know they can get away scotch free.


Title: Re: Bitstamp issues statement and temporarily suspends service
Post by: BitCoinNutJob on January 05, 2015, 10:00:06 AM
lololol

Here we go again...another service bites the dust...mt gox part 2379248723897234879234. This shit will never end until it takes bitcoin down with it.  Unbelievable.

Im thinking they currently just have a technical issue, im not using them or have any money in there but its doesnt look like a gox situation.

The fact of the matter is...regardless how 'bad' this situation really is...it shows that bitcoin money is safe nowhere.  Exchanges can basically take your money and run at any instant and claim they were hacked...with no repurcussions or explicit proof.  If that isn't enough to scare away any potential future adopters, I don't know what is.


Yes its a real problem and it makes an advert for regulation and bitcoin banks.  We need safe simple wallets and exchanges.


Title: Re: Bitstamp issues statement and temporarily suspends service
Post by: MyLucky7 on January 05, 2015, 10:00:45 AM
Mtgox again?  ???

January is a bad month for Bitcoin


Title: Re: Bitstamp issues statement and temporarily suspends service
Post by: Palmdetroit on January 05, 2015, 10:01:00 AM
This have something to do with recent BTC price?  I'm guessing yes.



Title: Re: Bitstamp issues statement and temporarily suspends service
Post by: flipstyle on January 05, 2015, 10:11:46 AM
This have something to do with recent BTC price?  I'm guessing yes.



Want to guess who's been dumping :)

Bitstamp CEO probably on an extended vacation in his newly acquired island mansion in Dubai.


Title: Re: Bitstamp issues statement and temporarily suspends service
Post by: Mellnik on January 05, 2015, 10:12:59 AM
Mtgox again?  ???

January is a bad month for Bitcoin

No, not Mtgox again. Mtgox lost all bitcoins whereas Bitstamp states cold storaged coins are fine.
So either you can't read or you don't trust Bistamp.


Title: Re: Bitstamp issues statement and temporarily suspends service
Post by: Come-from-Beyond on January 05, 2015, 10:14:26 AM
Im thinking they currently just have a technical issue, im not using them or have any money in there but its doesnt look like a gox situation.

Your post is not very entertaining. I want a better conspiracy theory, like "they tried to stop plummeting Bitcoin price with money they didn't have".


Title: Re: Bitstamp issues statement and temporarily suspends service
Post by: dserrano5 on January 05, 2015, 10:14:50 AM
No, not Mtgox again. Mtgox lost all bitcoins whereas Bitstamp states cold storaged coins are fine.

I also think this isn't gox 2 but remember, all gox cold storage coins were "safe" too.


Title: Re: Bitstamp issues statement and temporarily suspends service
Post by: mayax on January 05, 2015, 10:15:35 AM
Bitstamp is hacked. It's a fact. I think they can cover the loss from their HUGE profit they made last year IF they want that, of course  ;)

There are rumors that their bank account is closing too.


Title: Re: Bitstamp issues statement and temporarily suspends service
Post by: mayax on January 05, 2015, 10:17:51 AM
Mtgox again?  ???

January is a bad month for Bitcoin

No, not Mtgox again. Mtgox lost all bitcoins whereas Bitstamp states cold storaged coins are fine.
So either you can't read or you don't trust Bistamp.

Do you trust them? Remember that MtGox said the same in the first instance. :)

Maybe it's a "small" incident and everything will be cool or maybe not...


Title: Re: Bitstamp issues statement and temporarily suspends service
Post by: pawel7777 on January 05, 2015, 10:25:25 AM
Bitstamp is hacked. It's a fact. I think they can cover the loss from their HUGE profit they made last year IF they want that, of course  ;)

There are rumors that their bank account is closing too.

So what is the 'huge profit' they made? Source?

Their latest filed accounts (for 2013) doesn't show P&L as they qualified as small company, but their P&L reserve was at $0.8m, impressive for a start up, but far from 'huge'.


Here's the coindesk article on the recent events:

http://www.coindesk.com/bitstamp-reports-hot-wallet-issue-tells-customers-not-deposit-bitcoin/ (http://www.coindesk.com/bitstamp-reports-hot-wallet-issue-tells-customers-not-deposit-bitcoin/)


Title: Re: Bitstamp issues statement and temporarily suspends service
Post by: Denker on January 05, 2015, 10:26:24 AM
Bitstamp is hacked. It's a fact. I think they can cover the loss from their HUGE profit they made last year IF they want that, of course  ;)

There are rumors that their bank account is closing too.

Any sources to proove this or just speculation?
I never trust any exchange. After gox everyone should have realized to store his coins in a cold wallet.At least not on an exchange account.


Title: Re: Bitstamp issues statement and temporarily suspends service
Post by: mayax on January 05, 2015, 10:36:26 AM
Bitstamp is hacked. It's a fact. I think they can cover the loss from their HUGE profit they made last year IF they want that, of course  ;)

There are rumors that their bank account is closing too.

So what is the 'huge profit' they made? Source?

Their latest filed accounts (for 2013) doesn't show P&L as they qualified as small company, but their P&L reserve was at $0.8m, impressive for a start up, but far from 'huge'.


Here's the coindesk article on the recent events:

http://www.coindesk.com/bitstamp-reports-hot-wallet-issue-tells-customers-not-deposit-bitcoin/ (http://www.coindesk.com/bitstamp-reports-hot-wallet-issue-tells-customers-not-deposit-bitcoin/)

whose is reporting the whole profit?  there is no company is this world to do that. they will pay taxes. remember, BitStamp is one of the biggest exchangers.

also, look to the amount of the transactions they had last year and look to their fees. it's pretty easy to make a summary calculation.





Title: Re: Bitstamp issues statement and temporarily suspends service
Post by: pawel7777 on January 05, 2015, 10:48:48 AM

whose is reporting the whole profit?  there is no company is this world to do that. they will pay taxes. remember, BitStamp is one of the biggest exchangers.

Every registered company does.
Are you accusing them of hiding the profit? Tax evasion? If so - anything to support such statement?

also, look to the amount of the transactions they had last year and look to their fees. it's pretty easy to make a summary calculation.


Then do it.

If you run your 'summary calculation', all you'll get is their turnover (still won't be accurate) but definitely not their 'profit'.


Title: Re: Bitstamp issues statement and temporarily suspends service
Post by: coinits on January 05, 2015, 10:51:22 AM
lololol

Here we go again...another service bites the dust...mt gox part 2379248723897234879234. This shit will never end until it takes bitcoin down with it.  Unbelievable.

Im thinking they currently just have a technical issue, im not using them or have any money in there but its doesnt look like a gox situation.

The fact of the matter is...regardless how 'bad' this situation really is...it shows that bitcoin money is safe nowhere.  Exchanges can basically take your money and run at any instant and claim they were hacked...with no repurcussions or explicit proof.  If that isn't enough to scare away any potential future adopters, I don't know what is.


Yes its a real problem and it makes an advert for regulation and bitcoin banks.  We need safe simple wallets and exchanges.

No; we need Automated Transactions and Smart Contracts to put all exchanges out of business.


Title: Re: Bitstamp issues statement and temporarily suspends service
Post by: Q7 on January 05, 2015, 10:59:43 AM
Kinda of news that will make people lose trust in bitcoin security and its viability as a safe currency as a whole. When new or potential investor read this, they will have doubt about putting their money into bitcoin. Bad news indeed... I wonder amount of btc that has been compromised.  :(


Title: Re: Bitstamp issues statement and temporarily suspends service
Post by: HarmonLi on January 05, 2015, 11:16:37 AM
Kinda of news that will make people lose trust in bitcoin security and its viability as a safe currency as a whole. When new or potential investor read this, they will have doubt about putting their money into bitcoin. Bad news indeed... I wonder amount of btc that has been compromised.  :(

Yeah, you are right, this is very bad PR. And the saddest thing about it is that Bitcoin itself isn't flawed at all. The core technology doesn't have anything to do with these breaches and robberies. Bitcoin itself was, and will always be, safe.


Title: Re: Bitstamp issues statement and temporarily suspends service
Post by: GGGGG on January 05, 2015, 11:21:53 AM
WTH?? The ship can start sinking too fast...


Title: Re: Bitstamp issues statement and temporarily suspends service
Post by: Cummins59 on January 05, 2015, 11:29:55 AM
I like bitcoin but believe it is dying and will be worthless. The reason is that there is ZERO security, ZERO public knowledge, ZERO advertising and ZERO good news. Combine this with Apple Pay whom basically took the btc idea and ran with it. Forget the "fiat" currency BS. The losses that the masses of btc owners have incurred over the last year would take eternity to recover. Too many scammers and with the cost of electricity and difficulty and ZERO profits, the entire attraction of btc is GONE. All the cloud miners are worthless. It's has more signs of a demise than any currency or commodity out there. I am cashing out and hitting the small cap miners.


Title: Re: Bitstamp issues statement and temporarily suspends service
Post by: pawel7777 on January 05, 2015, 11:31:12 AM
Kinda of news that will make people lose trust in bitcoin security and its viability as a safe currency as a whole. When new or potential investor read this, they will have doubt about putting their money into bitcoin. Bad news indeed... I wonder amount of btc that has been compromised.  :(

Massive price drop followed by major exchange's problems, doesn't look good indeed. It's just a matter of time till the major news start reporting on it.

But on the other hand, if the amount compromised is not significant and BitStamp is able to cover it from its own funds (+ identify the cause and fix the problem), that could actually add to their trust and show they're serious business and can cope with difficulties.


Title: Re: Bitstamp issues statement and temporarily suspends service
Post by: dserrano5 on January 05, 2015, 11:31:44 AM
I like bitcoin but believe it is dying and will be worthless. The reason is that there is ZERO security, ZERO public knowledge, ZERO advertising and ZERO good news. […] I am cashing out

Can I get your coins at ZERO cost? Thanks!


Title: Re: Bitstamp issues statement and temporarily suspends service
Post by: HarmonLi on January 05, 2015, 11:33:06 AM
I like bitcoin but believe it is dying and will be worthless. The reason is that there is ZERO security, ZERO public knowledge, ZERO advertising and ZERO good news. Combine this with Apple Pay whom basically took the btc idea and ran with it. Forget the "fiat" currency BS. The losses that the masses of btc owners have incurred over the last year would take eternity to recover. Too many scammers and with the cost of electricity and difficulty and ZERO profits, the entire attraction of btc is GONE. All the cloud miners are worthless. It's has more signs of a demise than any currency or commodity out there. I am cashing out and hitting the small cap miners.


Bitcoin itself is completely safe. There hasn't been a single theft due to mistakes or errors in the core protocol! Apple Pay has almost nothing to do with Bitcoin. Bitcoin thrives to be a separate currency with a completely different foundation. Apple pay is merely a payment system used on top of credit cards. It has nothing to do with being a currency that is backed by a trustless and decentralized consesus-system.


Title: Re: Bitstamp issues statement and temporarily suspends service
Post by: crazy_rabbit on January 05, 2015, 11:36:51 AM
WTH?? The ship can start sinking too fast...

True. I used to be really depressed about the price drop- but now I'm rather excited. Bitcoin itself isn't going anywhere- the prospect of honestly cheap coins is quite exciting to me.


Title: Re: Bitstamp issues statement and temporarily suspends service
Post by: Bitalo_Martin on January 05, 2015, 11:42:29 AM
there are highly sophisticated solutions available, for example bitalo.com where site owers simply do not have access to the bitcoins at all

user-side generated private keys that are fully encrypted on user side and where coins are stored in multi-signature wallets with a backup transaction so that you get the coins out, even when the service is completely offline. In this case you also do not need any "audit", because the audit is simply checking the blockchain if your coins are there or not.


Title: Re: Bitstamp issues statement and temporarily suspends service
Post by: Bitcoinpro on January 05, 2015, 11:45:51 AM
I like bitcoin but believe it is dying and will be worthless. The reason is that there is ZERO security, ZERO public knowledge, ZERO advertising and ZERO good news. […] I am cashing out

Can I get your coins at ZERO cost? Thanks!

yes but your going to have to pay


Title: Re: Bitstamp issues statement and temporarily suspends service
Post by: 2dogs on January 05, 2015, 12:09:16 PM
Wallet Breach Causes Bitcoin Exchange Bitstamp to Temporarily Suspend Service

https://www.cryptocoinsnews.com/wallet-breach-causes-bitcoin-exchange-bitstamp-to-temporarily-suspend-service/


Title: Re: Bitstamp issues statement and temporarily suspends service
Post by: mayax on January 05, 2015, 12:12:55 PM
and it seems they have a problem with their  bank account too....


Title: Re: Bitstamp issues statement and temporarily suspends service
Post by: cr1776 on January 05, 2015, 12:26:07 PM
I like bitcoin but believe it is dying and will be worthless. The reason is that there is ZERO security, ZERO public knowledge, ZERO advertising and ZERO good news. Combine this with Apple Pay whom basically took the btc idea and ran with it. Forget the "fiat" currency BS. The losses that the masses of btc owners have incurred over the last year would take eternity to recover. Too many scammers and with the cost of electricity and difficulty and ZERO profits, the entire attraction of btc is GONE. All the cloud miners are worthless. It's has more signs of a demise than any currency or commodity out there. I am cashing out and hitting the small cap miners.


Stop with the FUD.  Bitcoin is not bitstamp or mtgox etc. 



Title: Re: Bitstamp issues statement and temporarily suspends service
Post by: Velkro on January 05, 2015, 12:32:36 PM
They are handling this incident good :) im happy with them still


Title: Re: Bitstamp issues statement and temporarily suspends service
Post by: mayax on January 05, 2015, 12:34:45 PM
They are handling this incident good :) im happy with them still

yeap but many people will still lose a lot of money from the Bitcoin depreciation.


Title: Re: Bitstamp issues statement and temporarily suspends service
Post by: Lordoftherigs on January 05, 2015, 12:35:17 PM

Bitstamp Service Temporarily Suspended

We have reason to believe that one of Bitstamp’s operational wallets was compromised on January 4th, 2015.

As a security precaution against compromises Bitstamp only maintains a small fraction of customer bitcoins in online systems. Bitstamp maintains more than enough offline reserves to cover the compromised bitcoins.

IN THE MEANTIME, PLEASE DO NOT MAKE DEPOSITS TO PREVIOUSLY ISSUED BITCOIN DEPOSIT ADDRESSES. THEY CANNOT BE HONORED!

Customer deposits made prior to January 5th, 2015 9:00 UTC are fully covered by Bitstamp’s reserves. Deposits made to newly issued addresses provided after January 5th, 2015 9:00 UTC can be honored.

Bitstamp takes our security and soundness very seriously. In an excess of caution, we are suspending service as we continue to investigate. We will return to service and amend our security measures as appropriate.

Bitstamp Team




Seems fine to me


Title: Re: Bitstamp issues statement and temporarily suspends service
Post by: mayax on January 05, 2015, 12:37:30 PM
yes, it is an honest announcement BUT the problem remains. Bitcoin price will go down and many people will lose a lot of money today.
The China market will react tomorrow when a lot of chineses will sell


Title: Re: Bitstamp issues statement and temporarily suspends service
Post by: johnyj on January 05, 2015, 12:54:23 PM
That's always a problem with centralized exchanges, you never know what is happening behind the scene, everything that published could be a make-up story

The problem is people's mindset has not changed to decentralized way of thinking, they usually seek a centralized organization for security and convenience, and this behavior might not change in generations



Title: Re: Bitstamp issues statement and temporarily suspends service
Post by: Lordoftherigs on January 05, 2015, 12:56:15 PM
http://www.reddit.com/r/Bitcoin/comments/2re2pw/18864_coins_stolen_from_stamp_that_doesnt_look/


Title: Re: Bitstamp issues statement and temporarily suspends service
Post by: mayax on January 05, 2015, 12:59:43 PM
we are talking about 14% of their coins lost ? pffff... :)
a lot of money lost. millions !


Title: Re: Bitstamp issues statement and temporarily suspends service
Post by: Daedelus on January 05, 2015, 01:02:51 PM
http://multigateway.org/ (http://multigateway.org/)  8)

I was thinking the same  :D


Title: Re: Bitstamp issues statement and temporarily suspends service
Post by: 1Referee on January 05, 2015, 01:07:01 PM
we are talking about 14% of their coins lost ? pffff... :)
a lot of money lost. millions !

Where do you see 14% of their total coins is lost?

I think they just lost a few hundred coins max.


Title: Re: Bitstamp issues statement and temporarily suspends service
Post by: General_A on January 05, 2015, 01:10:33 PM
http://bitcoiner.sk/content/images/2014/Mar/10.jpg


Title: Re: Bitstamp issues statement and temporarily suspends service
Post by: mayax on January 05, 2015, 01:11:07 PM
we are talking about 14% of their coins lost ? pffff... :)
a lot of money lost. millions !

Where do you see 14% of their total coins is lost?

I think they just lost a few hundred coins max.


http://www.reddit.com/r/Bitcoin/comments/2re2pw/18864_coins_stolen_from_stamp_that_doesnt_look/


Title: Re: Bitstamp issues statement and temporarily suspends service
Post by: tokeweed on January 05, 2015, 01:23:22 PM
we are talking about 14% of their coins lost ? pffff... :)
a lot of money lost. millions !

Where do you see 14% of their total coins is lost?

I think they just lost a few hundred coins max.


http://www.reddit.com/r/Bitcoin/comments/2re2pw/18864_coins_stolen_from_stamp_that_doesnt_look/

this sucks.


Title: Re: Bitstamp issues statement and temporarily suspends service
Post by: MicroGuy on January 05, 2015, 01:24:19 PM
https://i.imgur.com/HMwb1CL.jpg


Title: Re: Bitstamp issues statement and temporarily suspends service
Post by: Lordoftherigs on January 05, 2015, 01:27:18 PM
we are talking about 14% of their coins lost ? pffff... :)
a lot of money lost. millions !

Where do you see 14% of their total coins is lost?

I think they just lost a few hundred coins max.


http://www.reddit.com/r/Bitcoin/comments/2re2pw/18864_coins_stolen_from_stamp_that_doesnt_look/

this sucks.

There's still an option that the address belongs to bitstamp and these are all bitstamp withdrawals. I personally hope so.


Title: Re: Bitstamp issues statement and temporarily suspends service
Post by: gadman2 on January 05, 2015, 01:34:55 PM
Solution: use bitcoin the way it was meant to be: without 3rd party *anything*...


Title: Re: Bitstamp issues statement and temporarily suspends service
Post by: Lordoftherigs on January 05, 2015, 01:42:28 PM
https://twitter.com/nejc_kodric/status/552091195795845120


Title: Re: Bitstamp issues statement and temporarily suspends service
Post by: tokeweed on January 05, 2015, 01:47:53 PM
Solution: use bitcoin the way it was meant to be: without 3rd party *anything*...

we need this:

The new altcoins have been hogging all the fun new toys, and it's time we showed you can teach an old(ish) doge new tricks...

CATE (Cross-chain Atomic Trading Engine) is a bridging application that sits between any two Bitcoin Core 0.9+ derived clients (although only tested with Bitcoin and Dogecoin so far) and enables transactions between the two blockchains. Testing is ongoing, and right now it's really only intended for developer use/experiments, but the basics all work, and you can see the code right now at https://github.com/rnicoll/cate

Immediate priorities are improved documentation, further testing (especially AuxPoW blocks), producing a specific intermediary library to add altcoin support to python-bitcoinlib (instead of just using a fork of that library), and giving it a half-decent UI, but the code's far enough along for others to start poking at it now.

You can read up on the theory of how this works at https://en.bitcoin.it/wiki/Atomic_cross-chain_trading


https://www.reddit.com/r/CryptoCurrency/comments/2re9sz/bitcoindogecoin_crosschain_transactions/


Title: Re: Bitstamp issues statement and temporarily suspends service
Post by: philiveyjr on January 05, 2015, 01:50:57 PM
It is still out.!! No idea how long it's going to take.!! this sucks.!! I personally dont think it is a similar situation to mt.gox..! but anyways they should sort it out soon.!


Title: Re: Bitstamp issues statement and temporarily suspends service
Post by: pawel7777 on January 05, 2015, 02:12:39 PM
It is still out.!! No idea how long it's going to take.!! this sucks.!! I personally dont think it is a similar situation to mt.gox..! but anyways they should sort it out soon.!

That may not happen today, we're not talking about some minor bug here. They need to properly investigate the issue prior to re-opening.

Quote
Thank you all for your patience, we are working diligently to restore service and hope to have an ETA later today.
https://twitter.com/nejc_kodric/status/552090819659071488 (https://twitter.com/nejc_kodric/status/552090819659071488)


Title: Re: Bitstamp issues statement and temporarily suspends service
Post by: Come-from-Beyond on January 05, 2015, 02:50:41 PM
https://bitcointalk.org/index.php?topic=914852.0


Title: Re: Bitstamp issues statement and temporarily suspends service
Post by: redsn0w on January 05, 2015, 02:51:37 PM
Check :  https://www.predictious.com/economics/bitstamp-insolvency-2015/before-monday-january-12


Title: Re: Bitstamp issues statement and temporarily suspends service
Post by: Paul Revere on January 05, 2015, 03:05:22 PM
Are the unusually high amount of Ophans in the last day related to this somehow? 3 of them on Ghash alone.


Title: Re: Bitstamp issues statement and temporarily suspends service
Post by: mayax on January 05, 2015, 03:05:29 PM
Bitstamp lost 18K BTC. https://blockchain.info/address/1L2JsXHPMYuAa9ugvHGLwkdstCPUDemNCf


sell your Bitcoin. the price will go DOWN ......!!!!


Title: Re: Bitstamp issues statement and temporarily suspends service
Post by: GGGGG on January 05, 2015, 03:33:28 PM
Bitstamp lost 18K BTC. https://blockchain.info/address/1L2JsXHPMYuAa9ugvHGLwkdstCPUDemNCf


sell your Bitcoin. the price will go DOWN ......!!!!

I bet this is Bitstamp themselves making some tricky maneuvers.


Title: Re: Bitstamp issues statement and temporarily suspends service
Post by: Paul Revere on January 05, 2015, 03:39:59 PM
Bitstamp lost 18K BTC. https://blockchain.info/address/1L2JsXHPMYuAa9ugvHGLwkdstCPUDemNCf


sell your Bitcoin. the price will go DOWN ......!!!!

I bet this is Bitstamp themselves making some tricky maneuvers.

Sooo, create a panic sell and snap up BTC when the price drops and then pay out their depositors with cheaper BTC and pocket the difference? Gee, why would anybody do a thing like that??


Title: Re: Bitstamp issues statement and temporarily suspends service
Post by: mayax on January 05, 2015, 03:43:48 PM
it is very curious that the Bitcoin price didn't fall YET.

normally, any real "stock" market would have reacted until now. the "players" would have sold...I think Bitcoin foundation is not strange of this.


Title: Re: Bitstamp issues statement and temporarily suspends service
Post by: GGGGG on January 05, 2015, 03:52:23 PM
Bitstamp lost 18K BTC. https://blockchain.info/address/1L2JsXHPMYuAa9ugvHGLwkdstCPUDemNCf


sell your Bitcoin. the price will go DOWN ......!!!!

I bet this is Bitstamp themselves making some tricky maneuvers.

Sooo, create a panic sell and snap up BTC when the price drops and then pay out their depositors with cheaper BTC and pocket the difference? Gee, why would anybody do a thing like that??

You'd go ask MtGox. Hope they are OK, though.


Title: Re: Bitstamp issues statement and temporarily suspends service
Post by: justforbtc on January 05, 2015, 04:20:45 PM
Bitstamp lost 18K BTC. https://blockchain.info/address/1L2JsXHPMYuAa9ugvHGLwkdstCPUDemNCf


sell your Bitcoin. the price will go DOWN ......!!!!

Here is the main cold wallet of Bitstamp: https://blockchain.info/address/1JoktQJhCzuCQkt3GnQ8Xddcq4mUgNyXEa

From the earliest transaction of the address: https://blockchain.info/tx/8f1d3a8ef6b2d4a25d2f499279e01518b4770819ccbc39a765c4c326170c61b3

the source addresses and destination address are all cold wallets of Bitstamp.  The total amount of these cold wallets are about 200K.

The 18k BTC lost is about 10% of total reserve of Bitstamp.


Title: Re: Bitstamp issues statement and temporarily suspends service
Post by: mayax on January 05, 2015, 04:27:08 PM
Bitstamp lost 18K BTC. https://blockchain.info/address/1L2JsXHPMYuAa9ugvHGLwkdstCPUDemNCf


sell your Bitcoin. the price will go DOWN ......!!!!

Here is the main cold wallet of Bitstamp: https://blockchain.info/address/1JoktQJhCzuCQkt3GnQ8Xddcq4mUgNyXEa

From the earliest transaction of the address: https://blockchain.info/tx/8f1d3a8ef6b2d4a25d2f499279e01518b4770819ccbc39a765c4c326170c61b3

the source addresses and destination address are all cold wallets of Bitstamp.  The total amount of these cold wallets are about 200K.

The 18k BTC lost is about 10% of total reserve of Bitstamp.

it is NOT Bitstamp reserve. it's the CLIENT's money.


Title: Re: Bitstamp issues statement and temporarily suspends service
Post by: mike81 on January 05, 2015, 04:30:39 PM

Here is the main cold wallet of Bitstamp: https://blockchain.info/address/1JoktQJhCzuCQkt3GnQ8Xddcq4mUgNyXEa

From the earliest transaction of the address: https://blockchain.info/tx/8f1d3a8ef6b2d4a25d2f499279e01518b4770819ccbc39a765c4c326170c61b3

the source addresses and destination address are all cold wallets of Bitstamp.  The total amount of these cold wallets are about 200K.

The 18k BTC lost is about 10% of total reserve of Bitstamp.

So is this the hot wallet then?: https://blockchain.info/nl/address/1Drt3c8pSdrkyjuBiwVcSSixZwQtMZ3Tew


Title: Re: Bitstamp issues statement and temporarily suspends service
Post by: justforbtc on January 05, 2015, 04:34:32 PM
Bitstamp lost 18K BTC. https://blockchain.info/address/1L2JsXHPMYuAa9ugvHGLwkdstCPUDemNCf


sell your Bitcoin. the price will go DOWN ......!!!!

Here is the main cold wallet of Bitstamp: https://blockchain.info/address/1JoktQJhCzuCQkt3GnQ8Xddcq4mUgNyXEa

From the earliest transaction of the address: https://blockchain.info/tx/8f1d3a8ef6b2d4a25d2f499279e01518b4770819ccbc39a765c4c326170c61b3

the source addresses and destination address are all cold wallets of Bitstamp.  The total amount of these cold wallets are about 200K.

The 18k BTC lost is about 10% of total reserve of Bitstamp.

it is NOT Bitstamp reserve. it's the CLIENT's money.

My mistake, so Bitstamp lost about 10% of client's BTC.


Title: Re: Bitstamp issues statement and temporarily suspends service
Post by: justforbtc on January 05, 2015, 04:35:14 PM

Here is the main cold wallet of Bitstamp: https://blockchain.info/address/1JoktQJhCzuCQkt3GnQ8Xddcq4mUgNyXEa

From the earliest transaction of the address: https://blockchain.info/tx/8f1d3a8ef6b2d4a25d2f499279e01518b4770819ccbc39a765c4c326170c61b3

the source addresses and destination address are all cold wallets of Bitstamp.  The total amount of these cold wallets are about 200K.

The 18k BTC lost is about 10% of total reserve of Bitstamp.

So is this the hot wallet then?: https://blockchain.info/nl/address/1Drt3c8pSdrkyjuBiwVcSSixZwQtMZ3Tew


Just don't care about it as there is only very small balance.


Title: Re: Bitstamp issues statement and temporarily suspends service
Post by: mayax on January 05, 2015, 04:39:01 PM
how did you calculate this "small" balance? it's around of 5 MIL USD.

How much does have Bitstamp? 50 MIL? Let's get real. :)

Even so, Bitstamp MUST have these money in bank, right? I think most of these money came from bank deposits.


Title: Re: Bitstamp issues statement and temporarily suspends service
Post by: justforbtc on January 05, 2015, 04:42:28 PM
how did you calculate this "small" balance? it's around of 5 MIL USD.

How much does have Bitstamp? 50 MIL? Let's get real. :)

Even so, Bitstamp MUST have these money in bank, right? I think most of these money came from bank deposits.

I meant the balance in https://blockchain.info/address/1Drt3c8pSdrkyjuBiwVcSSixZwQtMZ3Tew is very small and we don't need to care about it.


Title: Re: Bitstamp issues statement and temporarily suspends service
Post by: fran2k on January 05, 2015, 04:48:08 PM
lololol

Here we go again...another service bites the dust...mt gox part 2379248723897234879234. This shit will never end until it takes bitcoin down with it.  Unbelievable.

Im thinking they currently just have a technical issue, im not using them or have any money in there but its doesnt look like a gox situation.

The fact of the matter is...regardless how 'bad' this situation really is...it shows that bitcoin money is safe nowhere.  Exchanges can basically take your money and run at any instant and claim they were hacked...with no repurcussions or explicit proof.  If that isn't enough to scare away any potential future adopters, I don't know what is.

Having lost various amounts at cryptorush and coinex...hearing stories like this don't even phase me...it's just another broken record that you basically expect.

Addtionally...anyone ever notice how these exchanges just so happen to conveniently go bust right when bitcoin is experiencing huge price volatility (either good or bad).  It's like the scammers don't even really care about hiding their motives anymore, because they know they can get away scotch free.

Most businesses who stole money are gone to have or are already having legal charges. Is not so easy.


Title: Re: Bitstamp issues statement and temporarily suspends service
Post by: fran2k on January 05, 2015, 04:54:43 PM
we are talking about 14% of their coins lost ? pffff... :)
a lot of money lost. millions !

Where do you see 14% of their total coins is lost?

I think they just lost a few hundred coins max.

http://www.reddit.com/r/Bitcoin/comments/2re2pw/18864_coins_stolen_from_stamp_that_doesnt_look/

this sucks.

Very interesting address. Specially the very high fees payed for ultra fast confirmations.

https://twitter.com/nejc_kodric/status/552091195795845120

Could just they made proof of reservers, like signing the twit with some cold storage addresses ?


Title: Re: Bitstamp issues statement and temporarily suspends service
Post by: mayax on January 05, 2015, 04:56:08 PM
ask the money back from Bitstamp.
Almost all their BTC should be backed by real money (USD or EURO). these money are into their bank account.

they "lose" the BTC but the real money will remain to them if you will accept the "loss".
So, ask your money back by bank wire asap. Their bank will froze the account shortly.


Title: Re: Bitstamp issues statement and temporarily suspends service
Post by: redsn0w on January 05, 2015, 04:59:23 PM
...
Very interesting address. Specially the very high fees payed for ultra fast confirmations.


It is not true , with 1btc you have the same time/chance to receive confirm (include in a block) as 0.0004 btc . It's a question of lucky ....


Title: Re: Bitstamp issues statement and temporarily suspends service
Post by: fran2k on January 05, 2015, 05:00:12 PM
it is very curious that the Bitcoin price didn't fall YET.

normally, any real "stock" market would have reacted until now. the "players" would have sold...I think Bitcoin foundation is not strange of this.

Totally.

Bitstamp lost 18K BTC. https://blockchain.info/address/1L2JsXHPMYuAa9ugvHGLwkdstCPUDemNCf

sell your Bitcoin. the price will go DOWN ......!!!!

I bet this is Bitstamp themselves making some tricky maneuvers.

Market making you say? Hehe..

Bitstamp lost 18K BTC. https://blockchain.info/address/1L2JsXHPMYuAa9ugvHGLwkdstCPUDemNCf


sell your Bitcoin. the price will go DOWN ......!!!!

Here is the main cold wallet of Bitstamp: https://blockchain.info/address/1JoktQJhCzuCQkt3GnQ8Xddcq4mUgNyXEa

From the earliest transaction of the address: https://blockchain.info/tx/8f1d3a8ef6b2d4a25d2f499279e01518b4770819ccbc39a765c4c326170c61b3

the source addresses and destination address are all cold wallets of Bitstamp.  The total amount of these cold wallets are about 200K.

The 18k BTC lost is about 10% of total reserve of Bitstamp.

This is actually good news!


Title: Re: Bitstamp issues statement and temporarily suspends service
Post by: fran2k on January 05, 2015, 05:04:37 PM
...
Very interesting address. Specially the very high fees payed for ultra fast confirmations.


It is not true , with 1btc you have the same time/chance to receive confirm (include in a block) as 0.0004 btc . It's a question of lucky ....

If the space is limited, and i.e. we have a tx with lot of inputs/outputs (high size) then a high fee creates incentive for priority inclusion.


Title: Re: Bitstamp issues statement and temporarily suspends service
Post by: Rampion on January 05, 2015, 05:11:23 PM
...
Very interesting address. Specially the very high fees payed for ultra fast confirmations.

It is not true , with 1btc you have the same time/chance to receive confirm (include in a block) as 0.0004 btc . It's a question of lucky ....

If the space is limited, and i.e. we have a tx with lot of inputs/outputs (high size) then a high fee creates incentive for priority inclusion.

That's true but the commissions of those transactions are unnecessarily big. You don't need 1, 0.5 or even 0.1 BTC to guarantee that your transaction will be in the next block. With a transaction of 0.001 BTC you are pretty much sure you are paying a fee big enough for the faster confirmation possible.


Title: Re: Bitstamp issues statement and temporarily suspends service
Post by: Nagle on January 05, 2015, 08:12:34 PM
Bitstamp CEO probably on an extended vacation in his newly acquired island mansion in Dubai.
No, Vegas:
Quote
Bitstamp retweeted: (https://twitter.com/bitstamp)
Nejc Kodrič @nejc_kodric  ·  9 hours ago

Due to circumstances I skipped my connecting flight and spend the night in NYC. I am flying to Vegas today to attend CES.


Title: Re: Bitstamp issues statement and temporarily suspends service
Post by: General_A on January 05, 2015, 08:17:04 PM
it is very curious that the Bitcoin price didn't fall YET.

normally, any real "stock" market would have reacted until now. the "players" would have sold...I think Bitcoin foundation is not strange of this.
Maybe the price drop of the last few days was whales factoring this news in.


Title: Re: Bitstamp issues statement and temporarily suspends service
Post by: johnyj on January 05, 2015, 09:50:38 PM
On bitstamp: "Customer deposits made prior to January 5th, 2015 9:00 UTC are fully covered by Bitstamp’s reserves. Deposits made to newly issued addresses provided after January 5th, 2015 9:00 UTC can be honored."

But if you look at the transactions of that possible hacked bitstamp address, the first transaction happened on January 4th, 2015 2:26:20 UTC. and the last transaction happens 2015-01-05 18:12:07, it is still accepting transactions after 9:00




Title: Re: Bitstamp issues statement and temporarily suspends service
Post by: pawel7777 on January 05, 2015, 10:03:17 PM
On bitstamp: "Customer deposits made prior to January 5th, 2015 9:00 UTC are fully covered by Bitstamp’s reserves. Deposits made to newly issued addresses provided after January 5th, 2015 9:00 UTC can be honored."

But if you look at the transactions of that possible hacked bitstamp address, the first transaction happened on January 4th, 2015 2:26:20 UTC. and the last transaction happens 2015-01-05 18:12:07, it is still accepting transactions after 9:00


Someone wasn't aware of what's going on and send to the old address maybe?


Title: Re: Bitstamp issues statement and temporarily suspends service
Post by: johnyj on January 05, 2015, 10:09:06 PM
On bitstamp: "Customer deposits made prior to January 5th, 2015 9:00 UTC are fully covered by Bitstamp’s reserves. Deposits made to newly issued addresses provided after January 5th, 2015 9:00 UTC can be honored."

But if you look at the transactions of that possible hacked bitstamp address, the first transaction happened on January 4th, 2015 2:26:20 UTC. and the last transaction happens 2015-01-05 18:12:07, it is still accepting transactions after 9:00


Someone wasn't aware of what's going on and send to the old address maybe?

The transactions after 9:00 are all small, maybe some testing going on, so most likely it is a cold wallet that still belongs to bitstamp. My guess is that this is not the compromised hot wallet, the compromised hot wallet is still unknown


Title: Re: Bitstamp issues statement and temporarily suspends service
Post by: mike81 on January 05, 2015, 10:51:24 PM
Seems to me those are the funds from the hot wallet: http://www.coindesk.com/bitstamp-claims-roughly-19000-btc-lost-hot-wallet-hack/

On another note, where did this statement come from? Was it made directly to Coindesk at CES maybe?


Title: Re: Bitstamp issues statement and temporarily suspends service
Post by: Keyser Soze on January 05, 2015, 10:52:25 PM
Seems to me those are the funds from the hot wallet: http://www.coindesk.com/bitstamp-claims-roughly-19000-btc-lost-hot-wallet-hack/

On another note, where did this statement come from? Was it made directly to Coindesk at CES maybe?


I've been wondering the same thing, can't find the statement anywhere else.


Title: Re: Bitstamp issues statement and temporarily suspends service
Post by: pawel7777 on January 05, 2015, 10:58:19 PM
If they indeed lost ~ 19,000 BTC, they're seriously fucked. There's no way they have enough own reserves to cover it. And I doubt they have insurance covering such event.


Title: Re: Bitstamp issues statement and temporarily suspends service
Post by: redsn0w on January 05, 2015, 11:08:53 PM
If they indeed lost ~ 19,000 BTC, they're seriously fucked. There's no way they have enough own reserves to cover it. And I doubt they have insurance covering such event.


They can buy 19k btc with the fiat value , it is not an impossible thing to do....  (and maybe the price will raise a little).


Title: Re: Bitstamp issues statement and temporarily suspends service
Post by: pawel7777 on January 05, 2015, 11:30:08 PM
If they indeed lost ~ 19,000 BTC, they're seriously fucked. There's no way they have enough own reserves to cover it. And I doubt they have insurance covering such event.


They can buy 19k btc with the fiat value , it is not an impossible thing to do....  (and maybe the price will raise a little).

But I don't think they have ~ $5m reserves to do that. Their latest financial statements (for 2013) showed P&L reserves of ~ $0.8m.

They'd likely need a loan for that, maybe from their shareholder Pantera Investments?


Title: Re: Bitstamp issues statement and temporarily suspends service
Post by: mike81 on January 05, 2015, 11:38:42 PM
The 19000 BTC isn't even half of the volume that was traded per day the last couple of days. It is a big hit but i suppose it is recoverable.

I'm more worried about the wording in the statement where it states:
Quote
We are working to transfer a secure backup of the Bitstamp site onto a new safe environment and will be bringing this online in the coming days. Customers can stay informed via updates on our website, on Twitter (@Bitstamp) and through Bitstamp customer support at support@bitstamp.net."

I don't think it should take days to copy and check their environment, why would it take this long?

And updates haven't been provided since this morning on either Twitter or their website. No source for the last statement on Coindesk. I'm worried we won't hear anything for a few days now. And that reminds me of Gox...


Title: Re: Bitstamp issues statement and temporarily suspends service
Post by: b!z on January 05, 2015, 11:43:31 PM
The 19000 BTC isn't even half of the volume that was traded per day the last couple of days. It is a big hit but i suppose it is recoverable.

I'm more worried about the wording in the statement where it states:
Quote
We are working to transfer a secure backup of the Bitstamp site onto a new safe environment and will be bringing this online in the coming days. Customers can stay informed via updates on our website, on Twitter (@Bitstamp) and through Bitstamp customer support at support@bitstamp.net."

I don't think it should take days to copy and check their environment, why would it take this long?

And updates haven't been provided since this morning on either Twitter or their website. No source for the last statement on Coindesk. I'm worried we won't hear anything for a few days now. And that reminds me of Gox...

I don't think Bitstamp is going to disappear overnight like Mt. Gox. They've got a lot to lose.

Quote
The company has generally been respected within the bitcoin community. In May 2014 it passed a proof-of-bitcoin-reserves audit overseen by BitcoinJ developer Mike Hearn, and in June it beat other bitcoin companies to win the Europas' Best Virtual Currency Startup Award.


Title: Re: Bitstamp issues statement and temporarily suspends service
Post by: mike81 on January 06, 2015, 12:01:12 AM

I don't think Bitstamp is going to disappear overnight like Mt. Gox. They've got a lot to lose.

Quote
The company has generally been respected within the bitcoin community. In May 2014 it passed a proof-of-bitcoin-reserves audit overseen by BitcoinJ developer Mike Hearn, and in June it beat other bitcoin companies to win the Europas' Best Virtual Currency Startup Award.

A lesson learned from the whole Mt.Gox debacle is that they need to keep communicating. This doesn't seem to be a priority at the moment. I'm still wondering where that statement on coindesk came from. It isn't on their website or twitter. So how would customers know (apart from reading coindesk).

Having said that I don't think they'll go bust because of this. I've been using them since long before Mt.Gox started to slide and they've proven to be a reputable exchange.


Title: Re: Bitstamp issues statement and temporarily suspends service
Post by: smoothie on January 06, 2015, 12:48:06 AM

I don't think Bitstamp is going to disappear overnight like Mt. Gox. They've got a lot to lose.

Quote
The company has generally been respected within the bitcoin community. In May 2014 it passed a proof-of-bitcoin-reserves audit overseen by BitcoinJ developer Mike Hearn, and in June it beat other bitcoin companies to win the Europas' Best Virtual Currency Startup Award.

A lesson learned from the whole Mt.Gox debacle is that they need to keep communicating. This doesn't seem to be a priority at the moment. I'm still wondering where that statement on coindesk came from. It isn't on their website or twitter. So how would customers know (apart from reading coindesk).

Having said that I don't think they'll go bust because of this. I've been using them since long before Mt.Gox started to slide and they've proven to be a reputable exchange.


That is how it works....they appear reputable until they aren't. Just like someone isn't a scammer until they scam...by then it is too late.

You can't see the future so my personal outlook is to be very skeptical on everything they claim until they show their hand fully.


Title: Re: Bitstamp issues statement and temporarily suspends service
Post by: smoothie on January 06, 2015, 12:50:44 AM
The 19000 BTC isn't even half of the volume that was traded per day the last couple of days. It is a big hit but i suppose it is recoverable.

I'm more worried about the wording in the statement where it states:
Quote
We are working to transfer a secure backup of the Bitstamp site onto a new safe environment and will be bringing this online in the coming days. Customers can stay informed via updates on our website, on Twitter (@Bitstamp) and through Bitstamp customer support at support@bitstamp.net."

I don't think it should take days to copy and check their environment, why would it take this long?

And updates haven't been provided since this morning on either Twitter or their website. No source for the last statement on Coindesk. I'm worried we won't hear anything for a few days now. And that reminds me of Gox...


The big question is will they allow a run on Bitcoin and fiat withdraws?

Anyone who has a large sum trapped there would likely want out ASAP.

If they allow this and bite the bullet I will give them credit where it is due. Otherwise they are insolvent.


Title: Re: Bitstamp issues statement and temporarily suspends service
Post by: OhShei8e on January 06, 2015, 12:54:26 AM
Statement Update:
Quote
January 6, 2015, 12:34am UTC: We have temporarily suspended Bitstamp services. Bitstamp customers can rest assured that their bitcoins held with us prior to temporary suspension of services on January 5th (at 9am UTC) are completely safe and will be honored in full.
On January 4th, some of Bitstamp’s operational wallets were compromised, resulting in a loss of less than 19,000 BTC. Upon learning of the breach, we immediately notified all customers that they should no longer make deposits to previously issued bitcoin deposit addresses. To repeat, customers should NOT make any deposits to previously issued bitcoin deposit addresses. As an additional security measure, we suspended our systems while we fully investigate the incident and actively engage with law enforcement officials.
This breach represents a small fraction of Bitstamp’s total bitcoin reserves, the overwhelming majority of which are held in secure offline cold storage systems. We would like to reassure all Bitstamp customers that their balances held prior to our temporary suspension of services will not be affected and will be honored in full.
We appreciate customers’ patience during this disruption of services. We are working to transfer a secure backup of the Bitstamp site onto a new safe environment and will be bringing this online in the coming days. Customers can stay informed via updates on our website, on Twitter (@Bitstamp) and through Bitstamp customer support at support@bitstamp.net.
- Bitstamp Team
https://www.bitstamp.net/

More than one wallet was compromised. Nearly 19,000 BTC lost.


Title: Re: Bitstamp issues statement and temporarily suspends service
Post by: RealMalatesta on January 06, 2015, 12:56:46 AM
The 19000 BTC isn't even half of the volume that was traded per day the last couple of days. It is a big hit but i suppose it is recoverable.

I'm more worried about the wording in the statement where it states:
Quote
We are working to transfer a secure backup of the Bitstamp site onto a new safe environment and will be bringing this online in the coming days. Customers can stay informed via updates on our website, on Twitter (@Bitstamp) and through Bitstamp customer support at support@bitstamp.net."

I don't think it should take days to copy and check their environment, why would it take this long?

And updates haven't been provided since this morning on either Twitter or their website. No source for the last statement on Coindesk. I'm worried we won't hear anything for a few days now. And that reminds me of Gox...


Naugh, this takes time if they don't know yet the mechanism how someone got into the system.


Title: Re: Bitstamp issues statement and temporarily suspends service
Post by: mayax on January 06, 2015, 01:27:45 AM

I don't think Bitstamp is going to disappear overnight like Mt. Gox. They've got a lot to lose.

Quote
The company has generally been respected within the bitcoin community. In May 2014 it passed a proof-of-bitcoin-reserves audit overseen by BitcoinJ developer Mike Hearn, and in June it beat other bitcoin companies to win the Europas' Best Virtual Currency Startup Award.

A lesson learned from the whole Mt.Gox debacle is that they need to keep communicating. This doesn't seem to be a priority at the moment. I'm still wondering where that statement on coindesk came from. It isn't on their website or twitter. So how would customers know (apart from reading coindesk).

Having said that I don't think they'll go bust because of this. I've been using them since long before Mt.Gox started to slide and they've proven to be a reputable exchange.


Coindesk are as bad as mainstream media channels these days and had at least one outright BS article lately, this ones pushing ripple so wouldn't be surprised if there's FUD in there. Getting hard to get good news these days, this forums spammed by astroturfers and there's a lot of FUD on the popular news channels, especially the forex coverage. Hope when they've something to say its something good but the biggest scumbags on the planet are fighting back now so the only thing certain is coins you have the keys for.

what good news do you want? 50% fake transactions. the big exchangers are manipulating the price along with the Bitcoin Foundation, the exchangers are earning millions when the Bitcoin price is going down....this is the Bitcoin world; full of speculators and this how it will be from now on...I am not sure for how long...
there are not too many NEW fouls to "invest" :)


Title: Re: Bitstamp issues statement and temporarily suspends service
Post by: GGGGG on January 06, 2015, 01:48:11 AM

I don't think Bitstamp is going to disappear overnight like Mt. Gox. They've got a lot to lose.

Quote
The company has generally been respected within the bitcoin community. In May 2014 it passed a proof-of-bitcoin-reserves audit overseen by BitcoinJ developer Mike Hearn, and in June it beat other bitcoin companies to win the Europas' Best Virtual Currency Startup Award.

A lesson learned from the whole Mt.Gox debacle is that they need to keep communicating. This doesn't seem to be a priority at the moment. I'm still wondering where that statement on coindesk came from. It isn't on their website or twitter. So how would customers know (apart from reading coindesk).

Having said that I don't think they'll go bust because of this. I've been using them since long before Mt.Gox started to slide and they've proven to be a reputable exchange.


Coindesk are as bad as mainstream media channels these days and had at least one outright BS article lately, this ones pushing ripple so wouldn't be surprised if there's FUD in there. Getting hard to get good news these days, this forums spammed by astroturfers and there's a lot of FUD on the popular news channels, especially the forex coverage. Hope when they've something to say its something good but the biggest scumbags on the planet are fighting back now so the only thing certain is coins you have the keys for.

what good news do you want? 50% fake transactions. the big exchangers are manipulating the price along with the Bitcoin Foundation, the exchangers are earning millions when the Bitcoin price is going down....this is the Bitcoin world; full of speculators and this how it will be from now on...I am not sure for how long...
there are not too many NEW fouls to "invest" :)

Exchangers earn very good on short-term price movements, but in the long-term downtrend "buy positions" secure only 70%-80% from the supply, in reality it' a sluggish bloodsucking.


Title: Re: Bitstamp issues statement and temporarily suspends service
Post by: smoothie on January 06, 2015, 03:29:09 AM
If they indeed lost ~ 19,000 BTC, they're seriously fucked. There's no way they have enough own reserves to cover it. And I doubt they have insurance covering such event.


They can buy 19k btc with the fiat value , it is not an impossible thing to do....  (and maybe the price will raise a little).

So you are assuming they have $5million laying around of their own funds to do this?

I doubt it.


Title: Re: Bitstamp issues statement and temporarily suspends service
Post by: RGBKey on January 06, 2015, 03:39:16 AM
Goddamnit, not again.


Title: Re: Bitstamp issues statement and temporarily suspends service
Post by: rz20 on January 06, 2015, 04:00:30 AM
I hope they come back soon


Title: Re: Bitstamp issues statement and temporarily suspends service
Post by: R2Pleasent on January 06, 2015, 04:03:56 AM
If they indeed lost ~ 19,000 BTC, they're seriously fucked. There's no way they have enough own reserves to cover it. And I doubt they have insurance covering such event.


They can buy 19k btc with the fiat value , it is not an impossible thing to do....  (and maybe the price will raise a little).

So you are assuming they have $5million laying around of their own funds to do this?

I doubt it.

Let's assume that Bitstamp was audited by Pantera in March 2014 before they invested $10M venture capital into the company.  Considering this was done shortly after the MTGOX debacle, I think it's safe to assume anyone dropping a $10M investment into a bitcoin exchange requested a verified and substantial financial audit of the company.

If they have been running a legitimate 100%+ reserve since that investment was made, they can likely weather the storm.


Title: Re: Bitstamp issues statement and temporarily suspends service
Post by: smoothie on January 06, 2015, 04:14:28 AM
If they indeed lost ~ 19,000 BTC, they're seriously fucked. There's no way they have enough own reserves to cover it. And I doubt they have insurance covering such event.


They can buy 19k btc with the fiat value , it is not an impossible thing to do....  (and maybe the price will raise a little).

So you are assuming they have $5million laying around of their own funds to do this?

I doubt it.

Let's assume that Bitstamp was audited by Pantera in March 2014 before they invested $10M venture capital into the company.  Considering this was done shortly after the MTGOX debacle, I think it's safe to assume anyone dropping a $10M investment into a bitcoin exchange requested a verified and substantial financial audit of the company.

If they have been running a legitimate 100%+ reserve since that investment was made, they can likely weather the storm.

Time will tell.

Assuming they had a 10,000 BTC per day trading volume that turns into 40 BTC in trade fees per day...

For 1 year (365 days) that is 14600 BTC. That would be their entire yearly profit from fees.

They lost 18000+ BTC in one fell swoop.

Not sure if I would think they have enough reserves in profit even if it were 20,000 btc per day trade volume (which is way over estimating).

The past 365 days of bitstamp trading daily volumes/price.

http://bitcoincharts.com/charts/bitstampUSD#rg360ztgSzm1g10zm2g25zv

Looks like 10k BTC per day is a nice reasonable number to assume is their average daily volume traded.

Based on those numbers I do not believe they have enough to cover said losses in full. Remember now they have expenses over that year.


Title: Re: Bitstamp issues statement and temporarily suspends service
Post by: Nagle on January 06, 2015, 04:15:29 AM
So you are assuming they have $5million laying around of their own funds to do this?

I doubt it.
That, indeed, is the problem. They have to come up with $5 million to reopen.

They can't reopen without the money. If and when they allow withdrawals again, everybody is going to take their money and Bitcoins out. If they try to pull some of the stunts Gox pulled about stalling withdrawals, this thing will come unglued even faster.

Bitstamp is a UK company. UK bankruptcy laws (https://www.gov.uk/statutory-demands/overview) are much more pro-creditor than US or Japan bankruptcy laws. As soon as a company owes you money and isn't paying its debts, you can file a "statutory demand"  The company has only 21 days to pay before you get to go to court to have them forced into liquidation.

Any creditor of Bitstamp can do this. Tomorrow morning, if they want.

There's also a UK court procedure for a "money claim", for amounts up to £100,000. This is only available if you have an address in the UK. That can be done on-line. You have to send a letter demanding payment first, but you only have to wait 14 days before filing a money claim.

Don't wait. That didn't work out with Mt. Gox.


Title: Re: Bitstamp issues statement and temporarily suspends service
Post by: smoothie on January 06, 2015, 04:18:49 AM
So you are assuming they have $5million laying around of their own funds to do this?

I doubt it.
That, indeed, is the problem. They have to come up with $5 million to reopen.

They can't reopen without the money. If and when they allow withdrawals again, everybody is going to take their money and Bitcoins out. If they try to pull some of the stunts Gox pulled about stalling withdrawals, this thing will come unglued even faster.

Bitstamp is a UK company. UK bankruptcy laws (https://www.gov.uk/statutory-demands/overview) are much more pro-creditor than US or Japan bankruptcy laws. As soon as a company owes you money and isn't paying its debts, you can file a "statutory demand"  The company has only 21 days to pay before you get to go to court to have them forced into liquidation.

Any creditor of Bitstamp can do this. Tomorrow morning, if they want.

There's also a UK court procedure for a "money claim", for amounts up to £100,000. This is only available if you have an address in the UK. That can be done on-line. You have to send a letter demanding payment first, but you only have to wait 14 days before filing a money claim.

Don't wait. That didn't work out with Mt. Gox.

Interesting. Thanks for sharing that information.

Good to see the UK have much better laws for the consumers/customer's benefit in place.


Title: Re: Bitstamp issues statement and temporarily suspends service
Post by: Inotanewbie on January 06, 2015, 04:28:11 AM
The 19000 BTC isn't even half of the volume that was traded per day the last couple of days. It is a big hit but i suppose it is recoverable.

I'm more worried about the wording in the statement where it states:
Quote
We are working to transfer a secure backup of the Bitstamp site onto a new safe environment and will be bringing this online in the coming days. Customers can stay informed via updates on our website, on Twitter (@Bitstamp) and through Bitstamp customer support at support@bitstamp.net."

I don't think it should take days to copy and check their environment, why would it take this long?

And updates haven't been provided since this morning on either Twitter or their website. No source for the last statement on Coindesk. I'm worried we won't hear anything for a few days now. And that reminds me of Gox...


The big question is will they allow a run on Bitcoin and fiat withdraws?

Anyone who has a large sum trapped there would likely want out ASAP.

If they allow this and bite the bullet I will give them credit where it is due. Otherwise they are insolvent.
I don't think it would be wise to allow trading to start back up until they are ready to start processing withdrawals again. One could speculate that the reason the price of bitcoin has not fallen since bitstamp announce they suspended service is because they have been trying to buy up as much bitcoin as possible in order to have a 100% reserve level


Title: Re: Bitstamp issues statement and temporarily suspends service
Post by: donk4u on January 06, 2015, 06:23:35 AM
Another exchange that has betrayed the trust of their customers.


Title: Re: Bitstamp issues statement and temporarily suspends service
Post by: reyhan12 on January 06, 2015, 06:41:24 AM
The btc price has been hovering  in the 270-276s. It's as if the bitcoin world is at a standstill and is waiting for bitstamp to come alive again. Or maybe it's the calm before the storm...


Title: Re: Bitstamp issues statement and temporarily suspends service
Post by: Soros Shorts on January 06, 2015, 08:33:21 AM
Looks like 10k BTC per day is a nice reasonable number to assume is their average daily volume traded.

Based on those numbers I do not believe they have enough to cover said losses in full. Remember now they have expenses over that year.

For most financial companies holding other people's money, losing 5-10% of assets under management pretty much guarantees insolvency. $5 million in operating cash is probably more than what a typical $1 billion hedge fund would have.

Do they have insurance?


Title: Re: Bitstamp issues statement and temporarily suspends service
Post by: mayax on January 06, 2015, 09:01:17 AM
Looks like 10k BTC per day is a nice reasonable number to assume is their average daily volume traded.

Based on those numbers I do not believe they have enough to cover said losses in full. Remember now they have expenses over that year.

For most financial companies holding other people's money, losing 5-10% of assets under management pretty much guarantees insolvency. $5 million in operating cash is probably more than what a typical $1 billion hedge fund would have.

Do they have insurance?

of course they don't. who will insure them? they are not regulated :)

I think their "boss", DAN MOREHEAD will give them money.


Title: Re: Bitstamp issues statement and temporarily suspends service
Post by: donk4u on January 06, 2015, 01:00:30 PM
same bs as with gox including the sorry for the inconvinence. No reason for them not to allow withdrawls as deposit addresses comprimised they are broke and looking for a way to parachutte out  like gox.


Title: Re: Bitstamp issues statement and temporarily suspends service
Post by: RoadStress on January 06, 2015, 01:07:06 PM
Where are the europeans converting their BTC to fiat these days? BTC-E seems to have very big fees for wire transfer withdraw.


Title: Re: Bitstamp issues statement and temporarily suspends service
Post by: ciappa on January 06, 2015, 01:13:46 PM
Where are the europeans converting their BTC to fiat these days? BTC-E seems to have very big fees for wire transfer withdraw.


Try it on bitcoin.de


Title: Re: Bitstamp issues statement and temporarily suspends service
Post by: johnyj on January 06, 2015, 03:34:33 PM
They could just do like chinese exchanges: Let clients pay it with a hair cut  8)

Or they could operate using fractional reserve method, a 90% reserve is still much much better than any banks which only have 10% of client money at hand


Title: Re: Bitstamp issues statement and temporarily suspends service
Post by: dave111223 on January 06, 2015, 03:47:40 PM
Time will tell.

Assuming they had a 10,000 BTC per day trading volume that turns into 40 BTC in trade fees per day...

For 1 year (365 days) that is 14600 BTC. That would be their entire yearly profit from fees.

They lost 18000+ BTC in one fell swoop.

Not sure if I would think they have enough reserves in profit even if it were 20,000 btc per day trade volume (which is way over estimating).

The past 365 days of bitstamp trading daily volumes/price.

http://bitcoincharts.com/charts/bitstampUSD#rg360ztgSzm1g10zm2g25zv

Looks like 10k BTC per day is a nice reasonable number to assume is their average daily volume traded.

Based on those numbers I do not believe they have enough to cover said losses in full. Remember now they have expenses over that year.

You are overlooking old accounts, which probably make up a good portion of reserves.  For example people who deposits $10 worth of BTC, like 3 years ago and forgot the account even exists.

They could probably do a cash grab on those accounts (ie people who haven't logged in for 3 years) and make up a large amount of their losses, without anyone being the wiser.  Just locked out all those accounts, and if someone happens to try to login just give them the run around and "no record of your account"....sure it's shit; but it beats going bankrupt or giving everyone a haircut (and going bankrupt in the future).

Or claiming that everyone deposits after their January 6th warning to old addresses were "lost' even if they weren't....basically going through the couch cushions they could probably scrape together 10% of reserves.


Title: Re: Bitstamp issues statement and temporarily suspends service
Post by: Nagle on January 06, 2015, 08:07:27 PM
Or they could operate using fractional reserve method, a 90% reserve is still much much better than any banks which only have 10% of client money at hand.
That's not what "fractional reserve" means. For a bank, a loan is an asset - someone owes them money. Banks get into trouble  when many loans go bad, as happened when the real estate bubble popped. Or they get into trouble if they have short-term deposits and long term loans, and too many depositors want their money out at once.

That's not Bitstamp's situation. They don't own 30-year mortgages.  They have no big illiquid assets they can sell off. They have nothing except their customer balances, and, according to their financial statement filed with Companies House, a few hundred thousand in paid-in capital.

Bitstamp needs $5 million within days, or they're going into bankruptcy.


Title: Re: Bitstamp issues statement and temporarily suspends service
Post by: Rampion on January 06, 2015, 08:11:53 PM
Bitstamp needs $5 million within days, or they're going into bankruptcy.

This is a fact. Considering they have been making tens of k's of BTC in commissions since 2011 and that they have been a running a relatively "low-cost" operation, they should be able to have 19k BTC laying around with no prob. Nevertheless it would be a big hit, and it's not guaranteed they managed their funds wisely in order to have such a "cushion" laying around.

Let's see how this plays out. I'm just glad that, as usual, I did not have any significant amount of coins in hands that are not my own.


Title: Re: Bitstamp issues statement and temporarily suspends service
Post by: Pustul on January 06, 2015, 08:20:30 PM
Apparently they say they will resume operations in the next 24 hours:

https://www.cryptocoinsnews.com/bitstamp-resume-operations-next-24-hours/


Title: Re: Bitstamp issues statement and temporarily suspends service
Post by: GGGGG on January 06, 2015, 08:33:38 PM
Apparently they say they will resume operations in the next 24 hours:

https://www.cryptocoinsnews.com/bitstamp-resume-operations-next-24-hours/

Let's see. Hope this is not another BS. Though I have a relatively small amount with them compared to other members, it feels pretty crappy.


Title: Re: Bitstamp issues statement and temporarily suspends service
Post by: Nagle on January 06, 2015, 08:34:03 PM
Apparently they say they will resume operations in the next 24 hours:

https://www.cryptocoinsnews.com/bitstamp-resume-operations-next-24-hours/
No indication of what they mean by "resume operations", though. If they resume withdrawals with no restrictions, they may be OK. If they resume trading or deposits but restrict withdrawals, this is Mt. Gox again.


Title: Re: Bitstamp issues statement and temporarily suspends service
Post by: johnyj on January 06, 2015, 10:58:24 PM
Or they could operate using fractional reserve method, a 90% reserve is still much much better than any banks which only have 10% of client money at hand.
That's not what "fractional reserve" means. For a bank, a loan is an asset - someone owes them money. Banks get into trouble  when many loans go bad, as happened when the real estate bubble popped. Or they get into trouble if they have short-term deposits and long term loans, and too many depositors want their money out at once.

That's not Bitstamp's situation. They don't own 30-year mortgages.  They have no big illiquid assets they can sell off. They have nothing except their customer balances, and, according to their financial statement filed with Companies House, a few hundred thousand in paid-in capital.

Bitstamp needs $5 million within days, or they're going into bankruptcy.

It is the same, although banks claim that they have this and that asset, when they suddenly need money, those loans can not come back in one night or one month. In fact 90% of the deposit money are just sitting in the bank's account without moving, that is the original reason banks loan out those money to earn interest on those dead money

What those coins in bitstamp's cold storage are doing? Collecting dust. They can actually loan out those coins and operate more like a real bank, but without loaning anything out they are much safer than a traditional bank if a large scale of withdraw is happening. For normal bank, if more than 40% of customer are doing withdraw simultaneously, they will run into a liquidity crisis and go broke. But unless more than 80% of bitstamp customer withdraw from bitstamp at the same time, they will be fine (Of course I suppose that they are doing 100% reserve, if they already practice FRB then no one knows how serious the situation is)

BTW, they don't need $5 million, they only need 19000 coins, no big deal for them. But if bitcoin price suddenly rise by 10 times, they might run into problems, just like MTGOX experienced, their initial loss of 200K coins caused by 2011 hack becomes so huge amount of wealth after 2 years that they can never earn it back


Title: Re: Bitstamp issues statement and temporarily suspends service
Post by: mayax on January 06, 2015, 11:05:04 PM
Apparently they say they will resume operations in the next 24 hours:

https://www.cryptocoinsnews.com/bitstamp-resume-operations-next-24-hours/

Let's see. Hope this is not another BS. Though I have a relatively small amount with them compared to other members, it feels pretty crappy.

it depends what it means small amount for you, it could be big for other. :)


Title: Re: Bitstamp issues statement and temporarily suspends service
Post by: smoothie on January 07, 2015, 12:45:40 AM
Time will tell.

Assuming they had a 10,000 BTC per day trading volume that turns into 40 BTC in trade fees per day...

For 1 year (365 days) that is 14600 BTC. That would be their entire yearly profit from fees.

They lost 18000+ BTC in one fell swoop.

Not sure if I would think they have enough reserves in profit even if it were 20,000 btc per day trade volume (which is way over estimating).

The past 365 days of bitstamp trading daily volumes/price.

http://bitcoincharts.com/charts/bitstampUSD#rg360ztgSzm1g10zm2g25zv

Looks like 10k BTC per day is a nice reasonable number to assume is their average daily volume traded.

Based on those numbers I do not believe they have enough to cover said losses in full. Remember now they have expenses over that year.

You are overlooking old accounts, which probably make up a good portion of reserves.  For example people who deposits $10 worth of BTC, like 3 years ago and forgot the account even exists.

They could probably do a cash grab on those accounts (ie people who haven't logged in for 3 years) and make up a large amount of their losses, without anyone being the wiser.  Just locked out all those accounts, and if someone happens to try to login just give them the run around and "no record of your account"....sure it's shit; but it beats going bankrupt or giving everyone a haircut (and going bankrupt in the future).

Or claiming that everyone deposits after their January 6th warning to old addresses were "lost' even if they weren't....basically going through the couch cushions they could probably scrape together 10% of reserves.

I highly doubt there is that much extra "forgotten" cash sitting in unused accounts.

Even I who have moved a good amount of fiat through bitstamp don't leave even $1 on there if I do not have to.

I need that $1 to buy me some cheeseburgers! LOL  :D :D :D


Title: Re: Bitstamp issues statement and temporarily suspends service
Post by: smoothie on January 07, 2015, 12:55:50 AM
Or they could operate using fractional reserve method, a 90% reserve is still much much better than any banks which only have 10% of client money at hand.
That's not what "fractional reserve" means. For a bank, a loan is an asset - someone owes them money. Banks get into trouble  when many loans go bad, as happened when the real estate bubble popped. Or they get into trouble if they have short-term deposits and long term loans, and too many depositors want their money out at once.

That's not Bitstamp's situation. They don't own 30-year mortgages.  They have no big illiquid assets they can sell off. They have nothing except their customer balances, and, according to their financial statement filed with Companies House, a few hundred thousand in paid-in capital.

Bitstamp needs $5 million within days, or they're going into bankruptcy.

It is the same, although banks claim that they have this and that asset, when they suddenly need money, those loans can not come back in one night or one month. In fact 90% of the deposit money are just sitting in the bank's account without moving, that is the original reason banks loan out those money to earn interest on those dead money

What those coins in bitstamp's cold storage are doing? Collecting dust. They can actually loan out those coins and operate more like a real bank, but without loaning anything out they are much safer than a traditional bank if a large scale of withdraw is happening. For normal bank, if more than 40% of customer are doing withdraw simultaneously, they will run into a liquidity crisis and go broke. But unless more than 80% of bitstamp customer withdraw from bitstamp at the same time, they will be fine (Of course I suppose that they are doing 100% reserve, if they already practice FRB then no one knows how serious the situation is)

BTW, they don't need $5 million, they only need 19000 coins, no big deal for them. But if bitcoin price suddenly rise by 10 times, they might run into problems, just like MTGOX experienced, their initial loss of 200K coins caused by 2011 hack becomes so huge amount of wealth after 2 years that they can never earn it back

more than 10% of their coins in their possession stolen.

So how do they handle the instant run on bitcoin and fiat once they reopen?

Institute bullshit daily limits?

That won't fly well given their situation. I would imagine there would be a pretty big uproar among customers/users should they not allow FULL btc and fiat withdraws.


Title: Re: Bitstamp issues statement and temporarily suspends service
Post by: jaberwock on January 07, 2015, 01:09:41 PM
Apparently they say they will resume operations in the next 24 hours:

https://www.cryptocoinsnews.com/bitstamp-resume-operations-next-24-hours/

GOX said more than once they would resume operations.

Let's see if they will honor what they say or if things will go even worse


Title: Re: Bitstamp issues statement and temporarily suspends service
Post by: mayax on January 07, 2015, 01:35:31 PM
Apparently they say they will resume operations in the next 24 hours:

https://www.cryptocoinsnews.com/bitstamp-resume-operations-next-24-hours/

GOX said more than once they would resume operations.

Let's see if they will honor what they say or if things will go even worse

yes, take a look and remember :   https://www.cryptocoinsnews.com/mtgox-withdrawals-resume/

almost the same title  :D


Title: Re: Bitstamp issues statement and temporarily suspends service
Post by: Nagle on January 07, 2015, 09:37:57 PM
Apparently they say they will resume operations in the next 24 hours:
https://www.cryptocoinsnews.com/bitstamp-resume-operations-next-24-hours/
25 hours later, still down.

Bitstamp's announcement of setting up a duplicate site in San Francisco reminds me of Mt. Gox claiming their "new trading engine" would fix their problems.  That was just an excuse for stalling.  


Title: Re: Bitstamp issues statement and temporarily suspends service
Post by: OhShei8e on January 07, 2015, 09:54:39 PM
Bitstamp's announcement of setting up a duplicate site in San Francisco reminds me of Mt. Gox claiming their "new trading engine" would fix their problems.  That was just an excuse for stalling.  

I don't think that they going down yet. But they have serous problems. So let's hope the best!



Title: Re: Bitstamp issues statement and temporarily suspends service
Post by: mayax on January 07, 2015, 11:53:28 PM
Bitstamp's announcement of setting up a duplicate site in San Francisco reminds me of Mt. Gox claiming their "new trading engine" would fix their problems.  That was just an excuse for stalling.  

I don't think that they going down yet. But they have serous problems. So let's hope the best!



they will drag down Ripple and other sister companies related to them. the scandal will be huge if they don't pay :)


Title: Re: Bitstamp issues statement and temporarily suspends service
Post by: johnyj on January 08, 2015, 03:01:53 PM

more than 10% of their coins in their possession stolen.

So how do they handle the instant run on bitcoin and fiat once they reopen?

Institute bullshit daily limits?

That won't fly well given their situation. I would imagine there would be a pretty big uproar among customers/users should they not allow FULL btc and fiat withdraws.

Just consider that as a long term loan to a hacker. MTGOX managed to operate 2 years before they could never make the lost coin back, but MTGOX is unlucky since they were hit by the ASIC evolution of bitcoin mining, and the bitcoin price rose by 100x because of ASIC miners

At current situation, with no large mining tech advance in horizon, bitstamp have plenty of time to make those coin back


Title: Re: Bitstamp issues statement and temporarily suspends service
Post by: RoadStress on January 08, 2015, 03:24:15 PM
Just consider that as a long term loan to a hacker. MTGOX managed to operate 2 years before they could never make the lost coin back, but MTGOX is unlucky since they were hit by the ASIC evolution of bitcoin mining, and the bitcoin price rose by 100x because of ASIC miners

I wish it would be that simple to raise the bitcoin price :) I am doing my part in buying ASICs, do you?


Title: Re: Bitstamp issues statement and temporarily suspends service
Post by: smoothie on January 08, 2015, 09:46:30 PM

more than 10% of their coins in their possession stolen.

So how do they handle the instant run on bitcoin and fiat once they reopen?

Institute bullshit daily limits?

That won't fly well given their situation. I would imagine there would be a pretty big uproar among customers/users should they not allow FULL btc and fiat withdraws.

Just consider that as a long term loan to a hacker. MTGOX managed to operate 2 years before they could never make the lost coin back, but MTGOX is unlucky since they were hit by the ASIC evolution of bitcoin mining, and the bitcoin price rose by 100x because of ASIC miners

At current situation, with no large mining tech advance in horizon, bitstamp have plenty of time to make those coin back

How will they make those coin back?

If users are allowed to withdraw...I can see their daily trade volume for the next year going down much lower than it has been due to lack of trust.



Title: Re: Bitstamp issues statement and temporarily suspends service
Post by: mayax on January 08, 2015, 11:08:39 PM
many people forget that Bitstamp "reserve" it's the client's Bitcoin.

That Bitcoin doesn't belong to Bitstamp.

Bitstamp must cover the loss from their pocket. 5 MiL USD. Huge amount.

Imagine how it is to count 5 MIL USD.... :)

They know very well that they won't rebuilt their reputation soon so they money won't come to them. Maybe they will risk to cover the less... 5 MIL.Would you? :)


Title: Re: Bitstamp issues statement and temporarily suspends service
Post by: Rampion on January 09, 2015, 12:01:57 AM
many people forget that Bitstamp "reserve" it's the client's Bitcoin.

Pretty much this. People forget customer's money is NOT a Bitstamp asset. They have to cover up the losses from their income, which is based on trading fees.


Title: Re: Bitstamp issues statement and temporarily suspends service
Post by: celebreze32 on January 09, 2015, 12:15:17 AM
many people forget that Bitstamp "reserve" it's the client's Bitcoin.

Pretty much this. People forget customer's money is NOT a Bitstamp asset. They have to cover up the losses from their income, which is based on trading fees.

And $10 million investment of venture capital money, plus sales from ripples which they sold at way above market price.


Title: Re: Bitstamp issues statement and temporarily suspends service
Post by: mayax on January 09, 2015, 12:20:35 AM
many people forget that Bitstamp "reserve" it's the client's Bitcoin.

Pretty much this. People forget customer's money is NOT a Bitstamp asset. They have to cover up the losses from their income, which is based on trading fees.

I may add...and not only on trading fees. You cannot make millions from 0.03%. This is like free so they have other source of making money from this biz; maybe the price difference... :)


Title: Re: Bitstamp issues statement and temporarily suspends service
Post by: celebreze32 on January 09, 2015, 12:26:08 AM
many people forget that Bitstamp "reserve" it's the client's Bitcoin.

Pretty much this. People forget customer's money is NOT a Bitstamp asset. They have to cover up the losses from their income, which is based on trading fees.

I may add...and not only on trading fees. You cannot make millions from 0.03%. This is like free so they have other source of making money from this biz; maybe the price difference... :)

There's also withdrawal fees for both cash and bitcoins.


Title: Re: Bitstamp issues statement and temporarily suspends service
Post by: mayax on January 09, 2015, 12:55:52 AM
in short, 5 Millions USD are not easy to be covered from fees.

You need millions of transactions in one year just to cover .

How many transactions does have an exchanger like Bitsmap per day?


Title: Re: Bitstamp issues statement and temporarily suspends service
Post by: celebreze32 on January 09, 2015, 01:28:58 AM
in short, 5 Millions USD are not easy to be covered from fees.

You need millions of transactions in one year just to cover .

How many transactions does have an exchanger like Bitsmap per day?

There was a discussion about this.



Now, there are not a million options here:
1. Bitstamp pays $5M with the fees they charged. That's tough, because they had about $1.5M worth of trading each day. At a 0.3% average, that gives $4500 per day. It would take them 1111 days of such fees to pay for those $5M, running costs non accounted for. Impossible.
2. They get $5M from their insurance. I've been working with insurers for such matters myself. Can't find one that would do that, so I'd bet they weren't insured for such a hack.
3. They get $5M from investors. That's tricky. New investors won't be stepping into this mess, so that leaves the previous VC that brought $10M. But this money was probably spent. If not, why bringing it in in the first place? Maybe they'd add $5M to protect the $10M they invested prior to the hack, but that's a dangerous move. Not impossible, but doubtful...
4. They run on fractional reserves. Easy, as long as 88% of the funds remain there.

On which option would you bet?



I think your numbers are very misleading. At a price of $300, thats 5k coins a day. Most of the time they are doing significiantly higher volumes than this and the price was higher. I think you could reasonably double your volume estimate and the average price for last year for a more reasonable estimate, quadrupling your total, and quartering you time estimate. Not impossible.

Agreed.  

The average weekly volume for 2014 was ~BTC 96 000 (~BTC13 700 per day) . (Based on raw data from http://bitcoincharts.com/charts/bitstampUSD)
0.3% x2 of 96 000 * 52 =BTC29 952 in fees.  I'm not sure about the 0.3% number.  The times two is because it's charged on both sides of the trade.
You are assuming they have to repay the full loss.  We can reduce the loss by any safety margins they have already, although they may wish to re-establish those (at a higher level?).
The fee number needs to reduce by operating expenses.

So we have 19 000 less what they have already vs 30 000 less opex.

Where it lands up after those adjustments is anyone's guess.

If they had been converting to USD at higher prices then that would reduce their burden significantly (if they can buy back at current low prices).


And Bitstamp's profits from selling ripples needs adding to the total. You could buy ripples directly from Bitstamp at a price they decided, which was always way above the going market price.


Title: Re: Bitstamp issues statement and temporarily suspends service
Post by: singular on January 09, 2015, 01:59:22 AM
many people forget that Bitstamp "reserve" it's the client's Bitcoin.

Pretty much this. People forget customer's money is NOT a Bitstamp asset. They have to cover up the losses from their income, which is based on trading fees.

I may add...and not only on trading fees. You cannot make millions from 0.03%. This is like free so they have other source of making money from this biz; maybe the price difference... :)

Fees are from 0.4 to 1% at bitstamp (buyer and seller pay from 0.2-0.5%), they generate majority of the profits, check volume and you will see, so they can cover loss with that.


Title: Re: Bitstamp issues statement and temporarily suspends service
Post by: mayax on January 09, 2015, 02:25:34 AM
many people forget that Bitstamp "reserve" it's the client's Bitcoin.

Pretty much this. People forget customer's money is NOT a Bitstamp asset. They have to cover up the losses from their income, which is based on trading fees.

I may add...and not only on trading fees. You cannot make millions from 0.03%. This is like free so they have other source of making money from this biz; maybe the price difference... :)

Fees are from 0.4 to 1% at bitstamp (buyer and seller pay from 0.2-0.5%), they generate majority of the profits, check volume and you will see, so they can cover loss with that.

let's not forget that they reported a profit of about 800k USD in 2013....

even we double it because Bitstamp may report fake numbers in order to avoid possible taxes....it's 2 mil USD per year net profit roughly.

we can say they need 2 years to recover the loss (IF they will have the same amount of clients; clients who will run away ones the Bitstamp will open the withdrawals).

in the mean time, they have to open their pockets and hoping that everything will be as in 2014.... very hard to believe that,



Title: Re: Bitstamp issues statement and temporarily suspends service
Post by: Nagle on January 09, 2015, 03:21:18 AM
This is conjecture on my part, based on Bitstamp's Twitter statements, such as "Working alongside the team from San Francisco, progress towards redeployment is strong. Huge thank you to for your confidence and patience."

Bitstamp desperately needs a few million dollars right now. Where are they going to get it? They're two unknown guys in their twenties, in Slovenia, with a mail drop in London. Nobody is going to fund that. If they were in Silicon Valley, they might be able to get VC funding. They have a user base; they're fundable. That's probably the motivation for the move to San Francisco.

Whether they can get funding remains unknown. If they'd closed a deal, they would probably announce it. So it's unlikely there's a deal in place.


Title: Re: Bitstamp issues statement and temporarily suspends service
Post by: Walsoraj on January 09, 2015, 03:25:06 AM
This is conjecture on my part, based on Bitstamp's Twitter statements, such as "Working alongside the team from San Francisco, progress towards redeployment is strong. Huge thank you to for your confidence and patience."

Bitstamp desperately needs a few million dollars right now. Where are they going to get it? They're two unknown guys in their twenties, in Slovenia, with a mail drop in London. Nobody is going to fund that. If they were in Silicon Valley, they might be able to get VC funding. They have a user base; they're fundable. That's probably the motivation for the move to San Francisco.

Whether they can get funding remains unknown. If they'd closed a deal, they would probably announce it. So it's unlikely there's a deal in place.

I think Walsoraj figured it out:

Stamp might be sitting on loads of unclaimed bitcoins from traders who are incarcerated or failed to submit kyc documents. However, most governments require unclaimed funds be turned over to the State. Perhaps Stamp believes it has legal standing to keep bitcoins on grounds that such laws apply to fiat funds only? Weak argument, but may buy Stamp some time.

Just a few months ago, Stamp required ALL traders to verify their identities to avoid forfeiture of balances.


Title: Re: Bitstamp issues statement and temporarily suspends service
Post by: smoothie on January 09, 2015, 04:32:05 AM
Forfeiture of balances?

If true...then wow!

Not sure if that is legal anywhere on the planet to just take shit because they didn't get verified in a certain time frame.


Title: Re: Bitstamp issues statement and temporarily suspends service
Post by: Keyser Soze on January 09, 2015, 05:32:30 AM
Forfeiture of balances?

If true...then wow!

Not sure if that is legal anywhere on the planet to just take shit because they didn't get verified in a certain time frame.
From my understanding they sent out various warnings over a ~1 year period about verifying accounts. After the period was up, accounts that were unverified had to give up their identity before any transactions are processed. I guess if you refused to verify and did not withdrawal within the given time, then you would have to verify or lose you balances.


Title: Re: Bitstamp issues statement and temporarily suspends service
Post by: crazy_rabbit on January 09, 2015, 06:46:56 AM
This is conjecture on my part, based on Bitstamp's Twitter statements, such as "Working alongside the team from San Francisco, progress towards redeployment is strong. Huge thank you to for your confidence and patience."

Bitstamp desperately needs a few million dollars right now. Where are they going to get it? They're two unknown guys in their twenties, in Slovenia, with a mail drop in London. Nobody is going to fund that. If they were in Silicon Valley, they might be able to get VC funding. They have a user base; they're fundable. That's probably the motivation for the move to San Francisco.

Whether they can get funding remains unknown. If they'd closed a deal, they would probably announce it. So it's unlikely there's a deal in place.

Well they have already had VC capital investment if I remember correctly, and they won a big European startup award so they are hardly unknown.  It's true though, I don't think they could have earned $5 million in fee's so they probably DO need investment from somewhere.

The theory that by moving to USA they might be able to keep the seized bitcoins is a good one as it indeed could not only buy stamp time but their lawyers could make a very good case in court. It's much better to fight the government in court, and if you lose, end up with a fine that the government would be more than happy to negotiate a pay schedule with you for (The US government isn't in the habit of putting companies out of business with fines) rather fight countless customer lawsuits. So yeah- I could imagine those seized funds going to cover the losses.

Although I suspect they will try their hardest NOT to do that, as it's just kicking the bucket down the road, but if they must- they may.

Personally, for me the promise of a return in 24-48 hours and that promise expiring has an omminous tone to it. :-(


Title: Re: Bitstamp issues statement and temporarily suspends service
Post by: tiwi on January 09, 2015, 07:08:08 AM
More days than not running exchange, the greater the losses for them. Most likely they are waiting, when customers come to terms with the idea that they cheated. Total "statements" of their boss does not bear any serious information, do not work with potatoes, they have our money. It's time to start regulating such offices, in the same way as banks and other major office, otherwise suffer many more people. Where can I apply in such cases? Who will protect us from fraud? Who adjusting the activity of these persons at the moment and where? Can not just wait and trust formal replies in Twitter.


Title: Re: Bitstamp issues statement and temporarily suspends service
Post by: celebreze32 on January 09, 2015, 10:41:42 AM
Forfeiture of balances?

If true...then wow!

Not sure if that is legal anywhere on the planet to just take shit because they didn't get verified in a certain time frame.
From my understanding they sent out various warnings over a ~1 year period about verifying accounts. After the period was up, accounts that were unverified had to give up their identity before any transactions are processed. I guess if you refused to verify and did not withdrawal within the given time, then you would have to verify or lose you balances.

Can anyone estimate how many coins they hold in unverified accounts? Are there any records anywhere? I read a few threads started by people who refused to verify and must have forfeited their coins.


Title: Re: Bitstamp issues statement and temporarily suspends service
Post by: pawel7777 on January 09, 2015, 04:14:46 PM

Some new details on the story:
http://www.coindesk.com/analysis-bitstamp-hacker-stolen-additional-1-75-million/ (http://www.coindesk.com/analysis-bitstamp-hacker-stolen-additional-1-75-million/)

Quote
Analysis: Bitstamp Hacker Almost Stole Additional $1.75 Million

Bitstamp narrowly avoided losing an additional $1.75m in bitcoin during its recent hack, according to a blockchain analysis by an independent researcher.

In the final hours of a $5.1m heist that took place at the exchange five days ago, the $1.75m in bitcoin was quickly moved to an address thought to be used for cold storage by Bitstamp, analyst Danno Ferrin has found.
...


Title: Re: Bitstamp issues statement and temporarily suspends service
Post by: eneloop on January 09, 2015, 05:11:37 PM
A lot of talk about previous profits: If the owners cashed it out in their own pocket (absolute legit), then they would think twice to throw their own money back into the exchange. If they reopen, I expect a cashout run. This will last till their reserves are empty and thats it, bankruptcy.


Title: Re: Bitstamp issues statement and temporarily suspends service
Post by: pawel7777 on January 09, 2015, 05:29:19 PM
A lot of talk about previous profits: If the owners cashed it out in their own pocket (absolute legit), then they would think twice to throw their own money back into the exchange. If they reopen, I expect a cashout run. This will last till their reserves are empty and thats it, bankruptcy.

Might have happened, but in their first period of trading (up to 31 Oct 2013) they left some $0.8m P&L reserve, they could've paid it out to themselves straight away.

It proves nothing, but may indicate that they've seen importance of holding a reserve.

https://bitcointalk.org/index.php?topic=785256.0 (https://bitcointalk.org/index.php?topic=785256.0)


Title: Re: Bitstamp issues statement and temporarily suspends service
Post by: celebreze32 on January 09, 2015, 06:18:19 PM
They've just updated their whois data to an anonymous whois protector:

Whois Record ( last updated on 2015-01-09 )

Quote
Domain Name: BITSTAMP.NET
Registry Domain ID: 1665186950_DOMAIN_NET-VRSN
Registrar WHOIS Server: whois.tucows.com
Registrar URL: http://tucowsdomains.com
Updated Date: 2014-10-01T17:45:23Z
Creation Date: 2011-07-04T12:09:15Z
Registrar Registration Expiration Date: 2024-07-04T12:09:15Z
Registrar: TUCOWS, INC.
Registrar IANA ID: 69
Registrar Abuse Contact Email:
Registrar Abuse Contact Phone: +1.4165350123
Reseller: Domenca d.o.o.
Reseller:
Reseller: +386 4 5835 444
Reseller: http://www.domenca.com
Domain Status: ok
Registry Registrant ID:
Registrant Name: Contact Privacy Inc. Customer 0128129599
Registrant Organization: Contact Privacy Inc. Customer 0128129599
Registrant Street: 96 Mowat Ave
Registrant City: Toronto
Registrant State/Province: ON
Registrant Postal Code: M6K 3M1
Registrant Country: CA
Registrant Phone: +1.4165385457
Registrant Phone Ext:
Registrant Fax:
Registrant Fax Ext:
Registrant Email:
Registry Admin ID:
Admin Name: Contact Privacy Inc. Customer 0128129599

http://whois.domaintools.com/bitstamp.net

No, you misread the date format for the date the domain name registration was last updated. You can see below it's 01 October, not the 10 January. My source is https://who.is/whois/bitstamp.net

http://s11.postimg.org/a1zqarhxv/bitstampwhois2.png

The raw data is below

Raw Registrar Data
Domain Name: BITSTAMP.NET
Registry Domain ID: 1665186950_DOMAIN_NET-VRSN
Registrar WHOIS Server: whois.tucows.com
Registrar URL: http://tucowsdomains.com
Updated Date: 2014-10-01T17:45:23Z
Creation Date: 2011-07-04T12:09:15Z
Registrar Registration Expiration Date: 2024-07-04T12:09:15Z
Registrar: TUCOWS, INC.
Registrar IANA ID: 69
Registrar Abuse Contact Email: Email Masking Image@tucows.com
Registrar Abuse Contact Phone: +1.4165350123
Reseller: Domenca d.o.o.
Reseller: Email Masking Image@domenca.com
Reseller: +386 4 5835 444
Reseller: http://www.domenca.com
Domain Status: ok
Registry Registrant ID:
Registrant Name: Contact Privacy Inc. Customer 0128129599
Registrant Organization: Contact Privacy Inc. Customer 0128129599
Registrant Street: 96 Mowat Ave
Registrant City: Toronto
Registrant State/Province: ON
Registrant Postal Code: M6K 3M1
Registrant Country: CA
Registrant Phone: +1.4165385457
Registrant Phone Ext:
Registrant Fax:
Registrant Fax Ext:
Registrant Email: Email Masking Image@contactprivacy.com


Title: Re: Bitstamp issues statement and temporarily suspends service
Post by: singular on January 09, 2015, 08:15:48 PM
many people forget that Bitstamp "reserve" it's the client's Bitcoin.

Pretty much this. People forget customer's money is NOT a Bitstamp asset. They have to cover up the losses from their income, which is based on trading fees.

I may add...and not only on trading fees. You cannot make millions from 0.03%. This is like free so they have other source of making money from this biz; maybe the price difference... :)

Fees are from 0.4 to 1% at bitstamp (buyer and seller pay from 0.2-0.5%), they generate majority of the profits, check volume and you will see, so they can cover loss with that.

let's not forget that they reported a profit of about 800k USD in 2013....

even we double it because Bitstamp may report fake numbers in order to avoid possible taxes....it's 2 mil USD per year net profit roughly.

we can say they need 2 years to recover the loss (IF they will have the same amount of clients; clients who will run away ones the Bitstamp will open the withdrawals).

in the mean time, they have to open their pockets and hoping that everything will be as in 2014.... very hard to believe that,



Dunno what they reported, but calculate by yourself, accounting tricks exists in this world, also they moved business from slovenian company to uk company in 2013 :)


Title: Re: Bitstamp issues statement and temporarily suspends service
Post by: Poppy on January 09, 2015, 11:31:38 PM

Some new details on the story:
http://www.coindesk.com/analysis-bitstamp-hacker-stolen-additional-1-75-million/ (http://www.coindesk.com/analysis-bitstamp-hacker-stolen-additional-1-75-million/)

Quote
Analysis: Bitstamp Hacker Almost Stole Additional $1.75 Million

Bitstamp narrowly avoided losing an additional $1.75m in bitcoin during its recent hack, according to a blockchain analysis by an independent researcher.

In the final hours of a $5.1m heist that took place at the exchange five days ago, the $1.75m in bitcoin was quickly moved to an address thought to be used for cold storage by Bitstamp, analyst Danno Ferrin has found.
...

Talk about some serious pay day.

You think a hack like this can happen again? if so, I`m sure on buying bitcoin from bitstamp...


Title: Re: Bitstamp issues statement and temporarily suspends service
Post by: Quinn on January 10, 2015, 01:22:25 AM
If bitstamp goes down, the prices will fall so hard on bitcoin.

I hope there were more stronger exchanges..


Title: Re: Bitstamp issues statement and temporarily suspends service
Post by: dmwardjr on January 10, 2015, 09:29:37 AM
BITSTAMP IS TRADING NOW