The domains I want are listed on
GoDaddy Auctions, otherwise I would use Namecheap.
GoDaddy requires you to have a funding method (credit card) linked to your PayPal account to make payments for some reason.
BitSimple is pretty neat though, I might use it when I need PayPal $ for other stuff.
I probably will end up spending a couple hundred bucks. Will shoot you a PM right now.