Don't get down about this Basorexia. Very very cool that you took the initiative to create something like this without the other person knowing. I'd say more often than not the person would be all over this.. personalized collectibles are your niche.. keep rolling with it!
(Most Collectibles board members are more open to sending their addresses out than the majority of the rest of the forum.. it is a slippery slope when you try to do this for someone outside of the Collectibles board.. privacy/opsec)