Certainly you need to change your wallet address. You can't interchange BCH and BTC addresses.
Actually I'm quite sure you can have the same address for BCH and BTC as long as you add the private key to the wallet. Otherwise no one would have been able to get their BCH from the initial Bitcoin Cash split ( or Airdrop or whatever it is called ).
If it is a limitation of zpool that I can not change it that would be another matter. If so I guess I will just stick with this address until a BCH payout happens and create a new address at that time.