@edgie13
You may want to try change http:// to stratum+tcp://
I don't mine at that pool so can't be 100% sure what their settings are.
Also use 32bit version only even on 64bit PC to use stratum.
My batch looks like this:
C:\bfgminer-3.7.0-win32\bfgminer --http-port 8330 -Q 45 -s 50 -E 60 -S noauto -o stratum+tcp://stratum.mining.eligius.st:3334 -O 1EbapZX1t9CZmQaYh7i3MZFEmzaDkCN2dR -o stratum+tcp://stratum.bitcoin.cz:3333 -u USER -p PASS