Last night the program switched to zecminer as the most profitable, but when the program ran, it reduced the intensity, thereby dropping the revenue by an order of magnitude. (I noticed GPU temp was only 44C). I verified this by running zecminer by hand. When it starts, it says the graphics card doesn't have enough memory, so it reduces intensity to 4, rendering it pretty much a waste of time.
OK so I got curious and went to the trouble of setting up the older system again. Apparently the default intensity when zecminer runs is 6, on a scale of 0-9. It gives the error msg that there is not enough GPU memory on both systems, and drops to 4. At which setting performance is awful.
But, on my previous system, I see that I had the intensity explicitly set to 3. Setting it to 3 on both systems cranked up the speed to max, as far as I can tell.
This makes no sense to me, but it's what's working right now.
On a side note, for some reason Nicehash is running CryptoNight on my previous system, and Equihash (Claymore's zecminer) on this system (exact same GPUs, as noted previously.) They have different speed CPU's, etc. so that might have something to do with it.