|
Why I am offended and offender post is not removed?
My defending answer to his post was removed, but his insults not.
WTF is this?
Why double standards?
|
|
|
|
~
Nonsense is when you score my knowledge without knowing what I actually know. Talking simple does not mean that someone is dumb.
You missed the point. How about I create a topic with the title "pbies is a fucking idiot!" Just because I like to use those words, in that particular order, does not mean Im trying to insult you. Thats basically your argument, right? No, not right. Your thinking is malfunctioning. Especially about someone's else knowledge. Don't be so frustrated little kid, there will come a day for you also. |
|
|
|
I have always been fascinated by how some folks can make big claims without knowing squat about the subject. OP, you bandy around terms like bsgs and kangaroo like they are some kind of magic that can crack any encryption just like that. Do you even know what these methods represent and what they are capable of doing?
If you are really interested in learning about this kind of stuff, I would suggest asking questions about things you dont understand before making such outlandish claims.
That are simplified words of other guys here in another topic. If you want to battle about what they are saying you are free to go. Nonsense is when you score my knowledge without knowing what I actually know. Talking simple does not mean that someone is dumb. |
|
|
|
I think there is still security in the BTC system that was created by Satoshi and user funds are still in the safe category if you refer to the question from @Freddie Boyer and the answer you provided above.
If you read the topic - this security has been breached recently by bsgs and kangaroo programs. There is no more security involved. Any transaction can be redirected currently, depends on luck hitting the pvk from pub key. |
|
|
|
You already started the shitstorm, so i will expect to see more of how you're going to compare seeing that bitcoin ends with the content of what you wrote down, i can only say more grease to your elbow, but know that bitcoin is not ending.
If you would be positively directed for the idea you would already know that. If anyone can obtain pubkey and then get pvk from it, he could immediately redirect the tx to himself. That's the problem here which you don't see. Brute-force method.
This is very interesting, where things that are secret will no longer be secret. I wonder what the scale will be if this is not anticipated immediately.
As well as anticipating funds to be safe.
I think there is not much possible to do in this case. Trying to guess the pvks is easy, there is only time that prevents us from seeing txs redirected by larger group of persons. |
|
|
|
you can do that with any transaction that is in mempool and has made public key public.
If I give you two numbers and ask you to add them together will you do it at the same speed with all numbers? For example does it take you the same amount of time to add 3 and 2 together as it takes you to add 334212132454779 + 675456421213132457964? And these numbers aren't even big! It's the same in Elliptic Curve Cryptography. If you can solve ECDLP in a short time when the key range is tiny, that doesn't mean you can do the same when the key range is ginormous like 2 256. That's what the puzzle keys people are finding are, small keys in a tiny range compared to the max range of 2 256. Well, for computers it is fast: 1. selecting second number is fast, it can be pool of 10^9 numbers which will be operated in less than a second 2. multiplying this second number with known one is one instruction for CPU, so still under one second 3. then comparing to known value is still one instruction for CPU 4. if we have hit (still under one second, two at most) we have private key, there are only miliseconds to broadcast new tx with balance coming right to us So we can do that for all mempool txs with multithreaded CPU below few seconds, where we have time of about 10 minutes when the tx will be a fact. |
|
|
|
|
So in other topics here, guys are saying, that if we have public key for puzzle 66 going public, then in few seconds we can track private key for that public key (bsgs, kangaroo) and take over the transaction making own one and moving the amount to our address.
Now think for a moment: you can do that with any transaction that is in mempool and has made public key public. It is only time matter when there will be massive take over of transactions.
PS. Let the shitstorm begin!
|
|
|
|
|
If you guys are saying that pubkey is enough to take over any puzzle tx,
then it can be done with any tx that is in mempool.
|
|
|
|
Hi, I have a question for you pls. Does it means that a miner could hack the bitcoins from who really worked out the puzzles? Because once he signed the transaction, the miners knows the public key and if they know this is for the puzzles, they can utilize your method to find corresponding private key and hacked the funds.
For what all guys are saying here - seems like each and every random transaction should be possible to be stolen just knowing the public key. At any time when it is still in mempool. Not only puzzle addresses. |
|
|
|
Puzzle: 1 Zeros: 0 Ones: 1 Percent 0: 0.00% Percent 1: 100.00% Decimal: 1 | Binary: 1
Puzzle: 2 Zeros: 0 Ones: 2 Percent 0: 0.00% Percent 1: 100.00% Decimal: 3 | Binary: 11
Puzzle: 3 Zeros: 0 Ones: 3 Percent 0: 0.00% Percent 1: 100.00% Decimal: 7 | Binary: 111
Puzzle: 4 Zeros: 3 Ones: 1 Percent 0: 75.00% Percent 1: 25.00% Decimal: 8 | Binary: 1000
Puzzle: 5 Zeros: 2 Ones: 3 Percent 0: 40.00% Percent 1: 60.00% Decimal: 21 | Binary: 10101
Puzzle: 6 Zeros: 3 Ones: 3 Percent 0: 50.00% Percent 1: 50.00% Decimal: 49 | Binary: 110001
Puzzle: 7 Zeros: 4 Ones: 3 Percent 0: 57.14% Percent 1: 42.86% Decimal: 76 | Binary: 1001100
Puzzle: 8 Zeros: 5 Ones: 3 Percent 0: 62.50% Percent 1: 37.50% Decimal: 224 | Binary: 11100000
Puzzle: 9 Zeros: 3 Ones: 6 Percent 0: 33.33% Percent 1: 66.67% Decimal: 467 | Binary: 111010011
Puzzle: 10 Zeros: 8 Ones: 2 Percent 0: 80.00% Percent 1: 20.00% Decimal: 514 | Binary: 1000000010
Puzzle: 11 Zeros: 7 Ones: 4 Percent 0: 63.64% Percent 1: 36.36% Decimal: 1155 | Binary: 10010000011
Puzzle: 12 Zeros: 4 Ones: 8 Percent 0: 33.33% Percent 1: 66.67% Decimal: 2683 | Binary: 101001111011
Puzzle: 13 Zeros: 9 Ones: 4 Percent 0: 69.23% Percent 1: 30.77% Decimal: 5216 | Binary: 1010001100000
Puzzle: 14 Zeros: 9 Ones: 5 Percent 0: 64.29% Percent 1: 35.71% Decimal: 10544 | Binary: 10100100110000
Puzzle: 15 Zeros: 6 Ones: 9 Percent 0: 40.00% Percent 1: 60.00% Decimal: 26867 | Binary: 110100011110011
Puzzle: 16 Zeros: 8 Ones: 8 Percent 0: 50.00% Percent 1: 50.00% Decimal: 51510 | Binary: 1100100100110110
Puzzle: 17 Zeros: 6 Ones: 11 Percent 0: 35.29% Percent 1: 64.71% Decimal: 95823 | Binary: 10111011001001111
Puzzle: 18 Zeros: 12 Ones: 6 Percent 0: 66.67% Percent 1: 33.33% Decimal: 198669 | Binary: 110000100000001101
Puzzle: 19 Zeros: 7 Ones: 12 Percent 0: 36.84% Percent 1: 63.16% Decimal: 357535 | Binary: 1010111010010011111
Puzzle: 20 Zeros: 10 Ones: 10 Percent 0: 50.00% Percent 1: 50.00% Decimal: 863317 | Binary: 11010010110001010101
Puzzle: 21 Zeros: 10 Ones: 11 Percent 0: 47.62% Percent 1: 52.38% Decimal: 1811764 | Binary: 110111010010100110100
Puzzle: 22 Zeros: 10 Ones: 12 Percent 0: 45.45% Percent 1: 54.55% Decimal: 3007503 | Binary: 1011011110010000001111
Puzzle: 23 Zeros: 11 Ones: 12 Percent 0: 47.83% Percent 1: 52.17% Decimal: 5598802 | Binary: 10101010110111001010010
Puzzle: 24 Zeros: 15 Ones: 9 Percent 0: 62.50% Percent 1: 37.50% Decimal: 14428676 | Binary: 110111000010101000000100
Puzzle: 25 Zeros: 8 Ones: 17 Percent 0: 32.00% Percent 1: 68.00% Decimal: 33185509 | Binary: 1111110100101111011100101
Puzzle: 26 Zeros: 15 Ones: 11 Percent 0: 57.69% Percent 1: 42.31% Decimal: 54538862 | Binary: 11010000000011001001101110
Puzzle: 27 Zeros: 13 Ones: 14 Percent 0: 48.15% Percent 1: 51.85% Decimal: 111949941 | Binary: 110101011000011100001110101
Puzzle: 28 Zeros: 14 Ones: 14 Percent 0: 50.00% Percent 1: 50.00% Decimal: 227634408 | Binary: 1101100100010110110011101000
Puzzle: 29 Zeros: 13 Ones: 16 Percent 0: 44.83% Percent 1: 55.17% Decimal: 400708894 | Binary: 10111111000100101010100011110
Puzzle: 30 Zeros: 14 Ones: 16 Percent 0: 46.67% Percent 1: 53.33% Decimal: 1033162084 | Binary: 111101100101001100110101100100
Puzzle: 31 Zeros: 10 Ones: 21 Percent 0: 32.26% Percent 1: 67.74% Decimal: 2102388551 | Binary: 1111101010011111110011101000111
Puzzle: 32 Zeros: 17 Ones: 15 Percent 0: 53.12% Percent 1: 46.88% Decimal: 3093472814 | Binary: 10111000011000101010011000101110
Puzzle: 33 Zeros: 17 Ones: 16 Percent 0: 51.52% Percent 1: 48.48% Decimal: 7137437912 | Binary: 110101001011011001010100011011000
Puzzle: 34 Zeros: 18 Ones: 16 Percent 0: 52.94% Percent 1: 47.06% Decimal: 14133072157 | Binary: 1101001010011001011001000100011101
Puzzle: 35 Zeros: 20 Ones: 15 Percent 0: 57.14% Percent 1: 42.86% Decimal: 20112871792 | Binary: 10010101110110100100001000101110000
Puzzle: 36 Zeros: 19 Ones: 17 Percent 0: 52.78% Percent 1: 47.22% Decimal: 42387769980 | Binary: 100111011110100000100000101001111100
Puzzle: 37 Zeros: 15 Ones: 22 Percent 0: 40.54% Percent 1: 59.46% Decimal: 100251560595 | Binary: 1011101010111011101010110101010010011
Puzzle: 38 Zeros: 21 Ones: 17 Percent 0: 55.26% Percent 1: 44.74% Decimal: 146971536592 | Binary: 10001000111000001011111010110011010000
Puzzle: 39 Zeros: 19 Ones: 20 Percent 0: 48.72% Percent 1: 51.28% Decimal: 323724968937 | Binary: 100101101011111100000110000001111101001
Puzzle: 40 Zeros: 18 Ones: 22 Percent 0: 45.00% Percent 1: 55.00% Decimal: 1003651412950 | Binary: 1110100110101110010010010011001111010110
Puzzle: 41 Zeros: 20 Ones: 21 Percent 0: 48.78% Percent 1: 51.22% Decimal: 1458252205147 | Binary: 10101001110000110100110101100110001011011
Puzzle: 42 Zeros: 23 Ones: 19 Percent 0: 54.76% Percent 1: 45.24% Decimal: 2895374552463 | Binary: 101010001000100001110001011000110110001111
Puzzle: 43 Zeros: 19 Ones: 24 Percent 0: 44.19% Percent 1: 55.81% Decimal: 7409811047825 | Binary: 1101011110100111011001001111100010110010001
Puzzle: 44 Zeros: 22 Ones: 22 Percent 0: 50.00% Percent 1: 50.00% Decimal: 15404761757071 | Binary: 11100000001010110011010110100011010110001111
Puzzle: 45 Zeros: 26 Ones: 19 Percent 0: 57.78% Percent 1: 42.22% Decimal: 19996463086597 | Binary: 100100010111111001010000101000011110000000101
Puzzle: 46 Zeros: 27 Ones: 19 Percent 0: 58.70% Percent 1: 41.30% Decimal: 51408670348612 | Binary: 1011101100000110000011100010001101010101000100
Puzzle: 47 Zeros: 23 Ones: 24 Percent 0: 48.94% Percent 1: 51.06% Decimal: 119666659114170 | Binary: 11011001101011000010000101101010011110010111010
Puzzle: 48 Zeros: 17 Ones: 31 Percent 0: 35.42% Percent 1: 64.58% Decimal: 191206974700443 | Binary: 101011011110011011010111110011100011101110011011
Puzzle: 49 Zeros: 24 Ones: 25 Percent 0: 48.98% Percent 1: 51.02% Decimal: 409118905032525 | Binary: 1011101000001011101101011000000010101111101001101
Puzzle: 50 Zeros: 26 Ones: 24 Percent 0: 52.00% Percent 1: 48.00% Decimal: 611140496167764 | Binary: 10001010111101010000111100001011101001001101010100
Puzzle: 51 Zeros: 32 Ones: 19 Percent 0: 62.75% Percent 1: 37.25% Decimal: 2058769515153876 | Binary: 111010100000111000010100001101000000000100111010100
Puzzle: 52 Zeros: 22 Ones: 30 Percent 0: 42.31% Percent 1: 57.69% Decimal: 4216495639600700 | Binary: 1110111110101110000101100100110010111001111000111100
Puzzle: 53 Zeros: 29 Ones: 24 Percent 0: 54.72% Percent 1: 45.28% Decimal: 6763683971478124 | Binary: 11000000001111000100011100100011111100011001001101100
Puzzle: 54 Zeros: 22 Ones: 32 Percent 0: 40.74% Percent 1: 59.26% Decimal: 9974455244496707 | Binary: 100011011011111011011011010101101011010001111101000011
Puzzle: 55 Zeros: 24 Ones: 31 Percent 0: 43.64% Percent 1: 56.36% Decimal: 30045390491869460 | Binary: 1101010101111100001111110011011011001111110000100010100
Puzzle: 56 Zeros: 22 Ones: 34 Percent 0: 39.29% Percent 1: 60.71% Decimal: 44218742292676575 | Binary: 10011101000110001011011000111010110001001111111111011111
Puzzle: 57 Zeros: 28 Ones: 29 Percent 0: 49.12% Percent 1: 50.88% Decimal: 138245758910846492 | Binary: 111101011001001011100100100000111100101011101011000011100
Puzzle: 58 Zeros: 33 Ones: 25 Percent 0: 56.90% Percent 1: 43.10% Decimal: 199976667976342049 | Binary: 1011000110011101011011100001010010000110001001101000100001
Puzzle: 59 Zeros: 26 Ones: 33 Percent 0: 44.07% Percent 1: 55.93% Decimal: 525070384258266191 | Binary: 11101001001011011001011101110000111110010101011010001001111
Puzzle: 60 Zeros: 28 Ones: 32 Percent 0: 46.67% Percent 1: 53.33% Decimal: 1135041350219496382 | Binary: 111111000000011110100001100000100101001101100111101110111110
Puzzle: 61 Zeros: 32 Ones: 29 Percent 0: 52.46% Percent 1: 47.54% Decimal: 1425787542618654982 | Binary: 1001111001001011010100011011101000010111101100100100100000110
Puzzle: 62 Zeros: 28 Ones: 34 Percent 0: 45.16% Percent 1: 54.84% Decimal: 3908372542507822062 | Binary: 11011000111101010101000001111010110110000100011010101111101110
Puzzle: 63 Zeros: 27 Ones: 36 Percent 0: 42.86% Percent 1: 57.14% Decimal: 8993229949524469768 | Binary: 111110011001110010111101111110110101100110011110110100000001000
Puzzle: 64 Zeros: 34 Ones: 30 Percent 0: 53.12% Percent 1: 46.88% Decimal: 17799667357578236628 | Binary: 1111011100000101000111110010011110110000100100010001001011010100
Puzzle: 65 Zeros: 36 Ones: 29 Percent 0: 55.38% Percent 1: 44.62% Decimal: 30568377312064202855 | Binary: 11010100000111000101100010011010100000101101100100110100001100111
### 00000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000001
00000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000011
00000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000111
00000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000001000
00000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000010101
00000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000110001
00000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000001001100
00000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000011100000
00000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000111010011
00000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000001000000010
00000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000010010000011
00000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000101001111011
00000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000001010001100000
00000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000010100100110000
00000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000110100011110011
00000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000001100100100110110
00000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000010111011001001111
00000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000110000100000001101
00000000000000000000000000000000000000000000001010111010010011111
00000000000000000000000000000000000000000000011010010110001010101
00000000000000000000000000000000000000000000110111010010100110100
00000000000000000000000000000000000000000001011011110010000001111
00000000000000000000000000000000000000000010101010110111001010010
00000000000000000000000000000000000000000110111000010101000000100
00000000000000000000000000000000000000001111110100101111011100101
00000000000000000000000000000000000000011010000000011001001101110
00000000000000000000000000000000000000110101011000011100001110101
00000000000000000000000000000000000001101100100010110110011101000
00000000000000000000000000000000000010111111000100101010100011110
00000000000000000000000000000000000111101100101001100110101100100
00000000000000000000000000000000001111101010011111110011101000111
00000000000000000000000000000000010111000011000101010011000101110
00000000000000000000000000000000110101001011011001010100011011000
00000000000000000000000000000001101001010011001011001000100011101
00000000000000000000000000000010010101110110100100001000101110000
00000000000000000000000000000100111011110100000100000101001111100
00000000000000000000000000001011101010111011101010110101010010011
00000000000000000000000000010001000111000001011111010110011010000
00000000000000000000000000100101101011111100000110000001111101001
00000000000000000000000001110100110101110010010010011001111010110
00000000000000000000000010101001110000110100110101100110001011011
00000000000000000000000101010001000100001110001011000110110001111
00000000000000000000001101011110100111011001001111100010110010001
00000000000000000000011100000001010110011010110100011010110001111
00000000000000000000100100010111111001010000101000011110000000101
00000000000000000001011101100000110000011100010001101010101000100
00000000000000000011011001101011000010000101101010011110010111010
00000000000000000101011011110011011010111110011100011101110011011
00000000000000001011101000001011101101011000000010101111101001101
00000000000000010001010111101010000111100001011101001001101010100
00000000000000111010100000111000010100001101000000000100111010100
00000000000001110111110101110000101100100110010111001111000111100
00000000000011000000001111000100011100100011111100011001001101100
00000000000100011011011111011011011010101101011010001111101000011
00000000001101010101111100001111110011011011001111110000100010100
00000000010011101000110001011011000111010110001001111111111011111
00000000111101011001001011100100100000111100101011101011000011100
00000001011000110011101011011100001010010000110001001101000100001
00000011101001001011011001011101110000111110010101011010001001111
00000111111000000011110100001100000100101001101100111101110111110
00001001111001001011010100011011101000010111101100100100100000110
00011011000111101010101000001111010110110000100011010101111101110
00111110011001110010111101111110110101100110011110110100000001000
01111011100000101000111110010011110110000100100010001001011010100
11010100000111000101100010011010100000101101100100110100001100111
|
|
|
|
I tried JLP's Kangaroo on puzzle 65. It found the privat key in 28 seconds !
Can you share the exact command? |
|
|
|
...
Every transaction is replaceable if you have knowledge of the private key.
...
So anyone could do millions any time. Good luck with that thinking. |
|
|
|
Why win the lottery twice? This is precisely the problem we are dealing with, this is ONLY for low bit puzzles like 66.
A bot that is sniffing mempool transactions (transactions that have not yet been placed on the blockchain and are stored in volatile memory) gets the public key and in minutes the private key with kangaroo, then initiates a transaction with a commission larger, which has a better chance of obtaining confirmations than the "original" transaction
That is the problem with miners which do not acknowledge that RBF is off for a tx. If tx is with RBF off it should be treated as last and valid only. |
|
|
|
...
Really? That’s your reply?
No it can’t be done to any address. #66 will be solved within seconds of public key being broadcast, because its range is known. That’s why this is different versus just any old address.
Ah, ok, so when space is 1,4615016373309029182036848327163e+48 it can't be done, but when the space is 36893488147419103232 these are seconds. Nice joke. |
|
|
|
...
Stop spreading bs.
better you stop spreading bullshit. You may mark the TX with RBF or not, it doesn't change anything. The transaction can always be replaced independently if the TX has been signaled RBF or not. Believe it or not, saatoshi_falling is right about what he said. Anyone could do that with current any address with balance and known pubkey. |
|
|
|
I have python script for making SIGHASH_SINGLE transaction. It is using: from bitcoin.core import * from bitcoin.core.script import * from bitcoin.wallet import * from bitcoin.core.scripteval import VerifyScript, SCRIPT_VERIFY_P2SH For now it is on testnet, I have balance. My question is at which stage of getting ready the transaction the both inputs are going into one variable? target_scriptPubKey = destination_address.to_scriptPubKey()
txins= []
txin1 = CTxIn(COutPoint(lx(txid1), vout1))
txin2 = CTxIn(COutPoint(lx(txid2), vout2))
txins=[txin1,txin2]
txout = CTxOut(amount_less_fee, target_scriptPubKey)
tx = CMutableTransaction(txins, [txout])
txin_index = 0
redeem_script1 = address1.to_redeemScript()
redeem_script2 = address2.to_redeemScript()
sighash1 = SignatureHash(redeem_script1, tx, txin_index, SIGHASH_SINGLE, amount=amount1, sigversion=SIGVERSION_WITNESS_V0)
sighash2 = SignatureHash(redeem_script2, tx, txin_index, SIGHASH_SINGLE, amount=amount2, sigversion=SIGVERSION_WITNESS_V0)
signature1 = seckey1.sign(sighash1) + bytes([SIGHASH_SINGLE])
signature2 = seckey2.sign(sighash2) + bytes([SIGHASH_SINGLE])
witness1 = [signature1, public_key1]
witness2 = [signature2, public_key2]
witness1next = CScript(witness1)
witness2next = CScript(witness2)
ctxinwitnesses1 = [CTxInWitness(CScriptWitness(witness1))]
ctxinwitnesses2 = [CTxInWitness(CScriptWitness(witness2))]
tx.wit = CTxWitness(ctxinwitnesses1)
VerifyScript(witness1next, scriptPubKey1, tx, 0, (SCRIPT_VERIFY_P2SH,))
print(b2x(tx.serialize()))
|
|
|
|
|
It is enough to mark the tx as without RBF and the winner gets it all!
Stop spreading bs.
|
|
|
|
Maybe disabling RBF would be a start, and using a high fee.
Yep, that's the solution. It is one-time try only. |
|
|
|
Hello everyone!
I have a simple question about the power of gpu cards and the time to crack the puzzle 66
What is the actual cracking speed of Rtx 4090(Doesn't matter if bitcrack kangaroo or vanity) the faster one will be the better.
I want to calculate if i get 30x Rtx4090 How many days or months do i need to crack p66?
One RTX 4090 on Linux gets 3 GH/s, that is ~3000 MH/s. I am talking here about BitCrack. If you have 12x RTX 4090 (as some machines on vast.ai) you can make linear multiply by 12. That is ~36 GH/s. Time taken to whole its space is months or years. If you want to go through all possible private keys in the puzzle 66 range. Even miners which have several 4090 will not switch from mining to cracking puzzle 66. It is higher cost. |
|
|
|
|
Show Posts
