Not only was it peeled just a little, you can tell is was peeled off almost completely.

Also, part of the pub address is missing with only the first four characters showing...   12CY
From what I can tell, the pkey was torn away from it as well.  So, even if it was one of the 12CY coins that haven't been redeemed, there is no chance to get to the bitcoin from the missing part of the label.

My guess is that it is:  12CYkmtUESk1cnPfHJNpa4MZzYXfqVsjB6
- Which was redeemed in 2014

So, if you bought it a couple of years ago, it was already next to worthless when you bought it.

What's the back of the other one look like?

If the funds were still there and you weren't aware this coin was peeled prior, I would sweep them immediately since there is no reason to keep the funds on the coin.

In cases like this I would expect someone peeled, took a photo of the private key to import at a later time (replacing hologram quickly), and the funds are already gone.  Whether it was malicious or not I can't determine.