We had some luck with that eh?    If only it was always like that.

Nowhere to upload an image to at the moment but a screen copy as of 12:33pm, PST.  I did drop the Intensity down to 18 from 20 and that has seemed to matchup with the site a little better (as well as produce far fewer rejected).  

 cgminer version 3.7.2 - Started: [2014-03-27 00:01:32] - [0 days 07:31:33]
 Pool management GPU management Settings Display options Quit        
 (5s):2.753M (avg):2.772Mh/s | A:1165248  R:51456  HW:0  WU:2723.8/m  WUE:98.3%
 ST: 1  SS: 0  NB: 869  LW: 10746  GF: 1  RF: 0
 Connected to us-west.coinshift.com diff 1.02K with stratum as user 1Q697sCKUo1pp3GXGxPbJN6GJPJz97R1LE
 Coinshift  Diff: 5.42K  Started: [07:32:03]  Best share: 3.12M
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
 GPU 0:  69.0C 2923RPM | 457.4K/461.9Kh/s | R:5.5% HW:0 WU: 449.8/m I:18
 GPU 1:  73.0C 4325RPM | 458.8K/462.1Kh/s | R:2.1% HW:0 WU: 431.7/m I:18
 GPU 2:  72.0C 2990RPM | 457.9K/462.1Kh/s | R:6.0% HW:0 WU: 442.5/m I:18
 GPU 3:  70.0C 2800RPM | 458.7K/462.1Kh/s | R:3.8% HW:0 WU: 432.2/m I:18
 GPU 4:  61.0C 2865RPM | 458.2K/462.1Kh/s | R:2.9% HW:0 WU: 497.9/m I:18
 GPU 5:  51.0C 2902RPM | 457.9K/462.2Kh/s | R:5.0% HW:0 WU: 469.8/m I:18
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
 [07:28:22] Accepted 0316666f Diff 21.2K/1024 GPU 4 at Coinshift
 [07:28:41] Accepted 3ac657e9 Diff 1.11K/1024 GPU 3 at Coinshift
 [07:28:57] Accepted 136579d4 Diff 3.38K/1024 GPU 1 at Coinshift
 [07:29:21] Accepted 252e909b Diff 1.76K/1024 GPU 3 at Coinshift
 [07:30:46] Accepted 0451cf3d Diff 15.2K/1024 GPU 3 at Coinshift
 [07:30:59] Accepted 1a6606db Diff 2.48K/1024 GPU 3 at Coinshift
 [07:31:02] Accepted 1b67253d Diff 2.39K/1024 GPU 4 at Coinshift
 [07:31:02] Accepted 3793b251 Diff 1.18K/1024 GPU 4 at Coinshift
 [07:31:08] Accepted 1b74023b Diff 2.39K/1024 GPU 0 at Coinshift
 [07:31:10] Accepted 16fce4ca Diff 2.85K/1024 GPU 5 at Coinshift
 [07:31:12] Accepted 15f39765 Diff 2.98K/1024 GPU 5 at Coinshift
 [07:31:25] Accepted 254595ba Diff 1.76K/1024 GPU 5 at Coinshift
 [07:31:43] Accepted 01f7101f Diff 33.4K/1024 GPU 4 at Coinshift
 [07:31:47] Accepted 2a1d6620 Diff 1.56K/1024 GPU 0 at Coinshift
 [07:32:15] Accepted 0652f0da Diff 10.4K/1024 GPU 2 at Coinshift
 [07:32:18] Accepted 3b800ef8 Diff 1.1K/1024 GPU 4 at Coinshift
 [07:32:44] Accepted 1579bf53 Diff 3.05K/1024 GPU 2 at Coinshift

Phzi - Pool hashrate as of this moment is 3091.675 Mh/s.  Website is 2301.8 Kh/s with a rejected of 54.8 Kh/s.

Been running cgminer and my avg hashing rate is 2.833Mh/s but combined accepted/rejected hashrate per your site seems to be hovering between 2350 and 2500Mh/s.  I'm fairly new to mining but having tried out Middlecoin, Cleverming and WafflePool for a couple days each, they all virtually nailed it.  Any suggestions as to why I'm coming in below and/or what to do about it?