Mt. Gox is
not a scam. I can't help but think threads like this are deliberate attempts to undercut confidence in the bitcoin and legitimate bitcoin websites.
Nefanon, I don't think that's what's going on here at all. If someone's funds are being held without apparent cause I think they have reason to be concerned no matter how reputable the exchange is. I've read all over the forums that mtgox has requested ID from people in several instances, sometimes in accordance to their TOS - sometimes not. I've read they've been vulnerable to attacks and I can see why people are leery of sending them their information. Another reason people might be reticent to send their ID is because they do not want their real identity linked to their Bitcoin balances in case there is ever any government snooping at the exchange.