The reset options button should not affect your wallet like that, although someone in the past has mentioned that it has.
However, as long as you did not delete your wallet, all of your Bitcoin should be safe. Try starting the wallet with the -rescan option. Right click the shortcut to start Bitcoin Core and select properties. In the box labeled "target", add -rescan to the end of whatever is already in there. Make sure that there is a space between what is there and what you add. Then click OK and double click the shortcut to start Bitcoin Core. It will rescan and you should see your Bitcoin in your wallet. Rescanning can take a while. Once it is done, you can go back to the shortcut's properties and delete the -rescan.
Also, you should upgrade to the latest version of Bitcoin Core. AFAIK, the issue with needing to reindex on a hard shutdown or crash was only with older versions of the software.
Alas, the above rescan option has been to no avail.
I've upgraded to the latest version of Bitcoin Core and tried again, but still no joy
.
Any other tips you could kindly offer?