Bitcoin Forum
May 13, 2024, 08:18:55 AM *
News: Latest Bitcoin Core release: 27.0 [Torrent]
 
  Home Help Search Login Register More  
  Show Posts
Pages: [1]
1  Economy / Exchanges / Simultaneous buy/sell trades in Poloniex market data? on: April 04, 2016, 11:25:15 AM
Hi guys,

I was recently looking at the market data feed from Poloniex and found a few weird examples which I couldn't find an explanation for -- would appreciate if anyone could shed some light on this or throw some ideas.

Poloniex send a bunch of messages in each packet with a sequence number attached. The messages in one packet normally refer to one matching event (e.g. a trade, the book updates it causes and potentially the triggered stop-orders, I think). There's three message types: remove, modify (new price points count as modify as well) and trade.

As an example, for buy trades, the packet would look like this:

- trade: buy <rate> <amount>
- trade: buy <rate> <amount>
- trade: buy <rate> <amount>
- remove: ask <rate>
- remove: ask <rate>
- modify: ask <rate> <amount>

However, I found a few cases where's there's two simulatenous buy/sell trades in one event -- I'm trying to understand how could this be possible if the top of the book doesn't even move? If these were different trade events, they would be assigned different sequence number; if this is one event, how come it has both buy and sell legs? Also note the size of the small buy trade is roughly proportional to the size of the big sell trade every time (circa 0.00595%). Here's the data:

Code:
                                              type  side        rate        amount
seq     timestamp                  pair     

5136384 2016-04-02 19:51:33.768925 BTC_ETH  modify   bid  0.02763399   20.95993648
                                   BTC_ETH  modify   ask  0.02763400    0.02002996
                                   BTC_ETH   trade  sell  0.02763399    0.02003116
                                   BTC_ETH   trade   buy  0.02763400    0.00000120  // <-- wtf?
5136393 2016-04-02 19:51:35.787860 BTC_ETH  modify   bid  0.02763399   20.93990412
                                   BTC_ETH  modify   ask  0.02763400    0.02002876
                                   BTC_ETH   trade  sell  0.02763399    0.02003236
                                   BTC_ETH   trade   buy  0.02763400    0.00000120  // <-- wtf?
5136398 2016-04-02 19:51:36.870590 BTC_ETH  modify   bid  0.02763399   21.93990412
                                   BTC_ETH  modify   ask  0.02763400    0.01996921
                                   BTC_ETH   trade  sell  0.02763399    1.00000000
                                   BTC_ETH   trade   buy  0.02763400    0.00005955  // <-- wtf?
5136410 2016-04-02 19:51:42.086652 BTC_ETH  modify   bid  0.02763399   19.91993491
                                   BTC_ETH  modify   ask  0.02763400    0.01996802
                                   BTC_ETH   trade  sell  0.02763399    0.01996921
                                   BTC_ETH   trade   buy  0.02763400    0.00000119  // <-- wtf?

TL;DR: can there be both buy and sell trades in one market event if the top of book didn't move?
Pages: [1]
Powered by MySQL Powered by PHP Powered by SMF 1.1.19 | SMF © 2006-2009, Simple Machines Valid XHTML 1.0! Valid CSS!