DesignA remarkably simple and responsive interface, I can't stress enough how much I appreciate that it doesn't choke under it's own weight like some 2.0 sites do, and doesn't insult my intelligence. It could maybe be more intuitive in layout, but it walks you through pretty well already.
Everything else in the design is a matter of taste. It vaguely reminds me of the local cheque-cashing stores, which might be fitting. You could stylize the input forms with some css 3.0 without having to go full on jquery-ui.
Sign UpRegistration went so quick I don't remember doing it. I register in too many places I think. May be too easy, I might suggest a confirmation email. At least that helps old people like me remember the names of sites like this.
Login Settings page lets you update all account info including login name, primary/secondary email, password, etc. The option to not send any emails is pretty slick, though I haven't seen any yet.
There is a complete social profile system, which is completely voluntary. That's appreciated.
DepositRates low, sent meager 0.15 to given deposit address to test the "Unexpected Deposit Order" approach, which proved to have a bug, but Subcoin resolved it quickly, hopefully fixing the issue.
Deposit with order worked flawlessly, it used the same deposit address that I had in my address book already, and began showing confirmation status immediately. I look forward to seeing this working automatically.
Add MethodWhen you go to make a withdrawal, it kindly suggests that you need to add a
way to make a withdrawal. Suddenly it clicks, just how easy it will to be to make repeated withdrawals in the future! That's quite a feature, in fact.
Some suggestions:
- Perhaps mention that multiple methods can be added for each network. This becomes obvious only after you've added one.
- Clarify that "Your PIN" is your Subcoin PIN, not a Dwolla PIN.
- As discussed, clarify that Dwolla ID (###-###-####) is needed, not account email.
WithdrawalEasily created two withdraw orders, both for randomly solicited Dwolla accounts (can't get one outside of US). It might be good to mention the minimum withdrawal of $10, as I had thought I could send less.
Dwolla ReceivedIndependant confirmation:
https://bitcointalk.org/index.php?topic=258690.msg2758515#msg2758515This experiment has been a success! I look forward to eventually being among the first to try the Western Union option.
At this point I'm confident enough to advocate for the site. In fact, I've already added a link in my sig.
Thanks for the hard work you've put into filling this need, and for your generosity and responsiveness with the community.