The private key did not work for some reason, and when I would check addresses there was no BCH showing on it either.
However, this is what ended up working:
1 - Sent all coins to another wallet (thanks LoyceV), this is the safe thing to do
2 - Downloaded Bitcoin ABC on another PC
3 - Loaded it until it was up to date
4 - Swapped wallet with old bitcoin wallet that is now empty, but had coins in at time of fork
5 - If you sent your coins out, it will show 0. Go into transactions. Right click and select Abandon Transaction for all post-fork transactions.
And then your BCC is right there. This should work for anyone that was having issues with the Coinomi method. Make sure you have enough harddrive space when doing this files are very large.