Thanks for the suggestion. I tried both and neither worked. I eventually hooked up a dedicated power supply to the 2 Nvidia cards and it worked. Power issue! I thought for sure 600W would drive 2 of those cards and the MB/hard drive/CPU.
Well 600W might be enough power for your rig, but not every 600W PSU can deliver all the power these GPUs need. Even if it's a high quality PSU its 12V line still might be divided into multiple rails, and that could result in instability when mining with both cards (not always possible to connect 2 cards + the rest of the system while keeping both GPUs well supplied). And if it's a cheap old PSU, then there's a good chance it can't really supply 600W at all (or it can, but the voltage will drop from 12V to 11V or something).