Proof-of-Stake coins: Sentiment Vs Price Action

[jonald_fyookball]

There has been quite a lot of discussion
here in the Bitcoin forum in the last
few months about Proof-of-Stake coins.

My personal opinion about the general
sentiment here is that many people
have felt that there is too great
an energy cost to Proof of Work,
or that Proof of Stake is superior.

However, that sentiment seems to
be shifting, as people are starting
to realize there is no clear way to
ensure distributed consensus
with Proof of Stake... at least none
as robust as Bitcoin is doing with
Proof-of-Work.

Also, interesting that Gavin Andressen
mentioned recently he doesn't see energy
consumption as a problem and it will balance itself
out over time.

I took a look at some charts today on
Cryptsy.  These are charts VS the Bitcoin price.

(mods, please don't move to altcoin section,
this is about Bitcoin PoW vs PoS)

I am wondering, do you think the price
fluctuations reflect this sentiment?

Take a look at Peercoin vs Bicoin.  It
had a nice run up from November 2013
till January 2014, but since then
has faded and reversed direction.

NXT price history on cryptsy only goes
back to March... But it is increasing
in the last 30-60 days.  Perhaps the
jury is still out on NXT.

Thoughts?

[bluemeanie1]

NXT also has the largest volume on Bter(by far) of all the alts.

-bm

[LeChatNoir]

However, that sentiment seems to
be shifting, as people are starting
to realize there is no clear way to
ensure distributed consensus
with Proof of Stake... at least none
as robust as Bitcoin is doing with
Proof-of-Work.

NXT supporters claim this has been solved by transparent forging. I don't know if that is true.

[jonald_fyookball]

However, that sentiment seems to
be shifting, as people are starting
to realize there is no clear way to
ensure distributed consensus
with Proof of Stake... at least none
as robust as Bitcoin is doing with
Proof-of-Work.

NXT supporters claim this has been solved by transparent forging. I don't know if that is true.

I don't want this to turn into another PoW vs PoS thread... needless to say,
I think those claims haven't been universally accepted, at least for now.

[Zer0Sum]

It's all about the $$$...
And people are making a lot more $$$ with Alts.

Any decent Alt Index or basket of 10 quality, Gen 2.0 Alts...
Started outperforming BTC early this year... and will do so for the foreseeable future.

Alts spiked 50% versus stodgy BTC in the past week, baby.

Isn't this debate over?

[jonald_fyookball]

It's all about the $$$...
And people are making a lot more $$$ with Alts.

Any decent Alt Index or basket of 10 quality, Gen 2.0 Alts...
Started outperforming BTC early this year... and will do so for the foreseeable future.

Alts spiked 50% versus stodgy BTC in the past week, baby.

Isn't this debate over?

Yeah right... Most alts follow the pump and dump pattern and then die a slow death.
The only alts that are doing well right now are NXT and darkcoin.