You know, if he wants to give away 100 btc, I think we should let him.

For what it's worth - while the site appears to be broken now - the site was working better than most which use coindice, and withdrawals worked when the site had enough to pay them. People were a little bit harsh before he actually deserved it. However, given the admin's handling of the bug bounty and other bug reports, I wouldn't put too much trust in him or his site now if it even comes back. Also, any site which offers a bonus on deposits with no terms attached generally can't be trusted - if it could, it would go bust pretty quickly.