Do you agree with idea "Bitcoin bank" ?

[amiryaqot]

I don't understand the idea of bitcoin bank who will hold the funds which is totally against the spirit of bitcoin, everybody love bitcoin because of freedom so that I'm against this idea, very hard to understand why would we give our coins to 3rd party without any security about our funds, investment in bitcoin is better than this idea.

[1713556949]

1713556949

[1713556949]

1713556949

[1713556949]

1713556949

[1713556949]

1713556949

[1713556949]

1713556949

[crairezx20]

I don't understand the idea of bitcoin bank who will hold the funds which is totally against the spirit of bitcoin, everybody love bitcoin because of freedom so that I'm against this idea, very hard to understand why would we give our coins to 3rd party without any security about our funds, investment in bitcoin is better than this idea.

You have the point and i think we have already use the wallet as our bank.. and i think we dont need bitcoin bank except for ATM or any bitcoin machine that can withdraw and deposit bitcoin instantly.. will be a good idea to spread worldwide than bitcoin banks..

We are using it anonymously so if there is bitcoin bank i think they need our identity in order to be member of that bank..

[R3ffun]

Recently, i often see discussion about Bitcoin Bank. More and more people come here and ask about bitcoin bank & surprisingly i see few user agree with this idea.
So, i would like to find out the percentage of user who agreed with this idea.

Honestly, i think this idea is stupid and worst idea that i've seen in my life. What do you think?
p.s. we don't talk about bitcoin debit card.

i don't think so , bank local already good function .. so for what bitcoin bank ?

[GregH37]

I don't understand the idea of bitcoin bank who will hold the funds which is totally against the spirit of bitcoin, everybody love bitcoin because of freedom so that I'm against this idea, very hard to understand why would we give our coins to 3rd party without any security about our funds, investment in bitcoin is better than this idea.

You have the point and i think we have already use the wallet as our bank.. and i think we dont need bitcoin bank except for ATM or any bitcoin machine that can withdraw and deposit bitcoin instantly.. will be a good idea to spread worldwide than bitcoin banks..

We are using it anonymously so if there is bitcoin bank i think they need our identity in order to be member of that bank..

The difference is that you may ‘get a loan’ or ‘get interest’ with banks as well which our bitcoin wallets can’t provide. Bitcoin Bank is against the basic concepts of bitcoin but that is what people want the “bank” to be I assume. When bitcoin hits main stream of adoptions, people may start forgetting to demand for bitcoin banks.

[richardsNY]

I don't understand the idea of bitcoin bank who will hold the funds which is totally against the spirit of bitcoin, everybody love bitcoin because of freedom so that I'm against this idea, very hard to understand why would we give our coins to 3rd party without any security about our funds, investment in bitcoin is better than this idea.

You have the point and i think we have already use the wallet as our bank.. and i think we dont need bitcoin bank except for ATM or any bitcoin machine that can withdraw and deposit bitcoin instantly.. will be a good idea to spread worldwide than bitcoin banks..

We are using it anonymously so if there is bitcoin bank i think they need our identity in order to be member of that bank..

The difference is that you may ‘get a loan’ or ‘get interest’ with banks as well which our bitcoin wallets can’t provide. Bitcoin Bank is against the basic concepts of bitcoin but that is what people want the “bank” to be I assume. When bitcoin hits main stream of adoptions, people may start forgetting to demand for bitcoin banks.

People getting a financial gain such as interest over the coins they save there is the only reason. I can't think of anything else that people may find so interesting, that they throw away their full control over their coins. You said loans, but there are several other ways of how you can get a Bitcoin related loan. Think about certain Bitcoin lending sites, the community that you can ask for a loan, etc. No need for a service that is saying to be a "Bitcoin bank".

[Mirconome]

I don't understand the idea of bitcoin bank who will hold the funds which is totally against the spirit of bitcoin, everybody love bitcoin because of freedom so that I'm against this idea, very hard to understand why would we give our coins to 3rd party without any security about our funds, investment in bitcoin is better than this idea.

You have the point and i think we have already use the wallet as our bank.. and i think we dont need bitcoin bank except for ATM or any bitcoin machine that can withdraw and deposit bitcoin instantly.. will be a good idea to spread worldwide than bitcoin banks..

We are using it anonymously so if there is bitcoin bank i think they need our identity in order to be member of that bank..

The difference is that you may ‘get a loan’ or ‘get interest’ with banks as well which our bitcoin wallets can’t provide. Bitcoin Bank is against the basic concepts of bitcoin but that is what people want the “bank” to be I assume. When bitcoin hits main stream of adoptions, people may start forgetting to demand for bitcoin banks.

People getting a financial gain such as interest over the coins they save there is the only reason. I can't think of anything else that people may find so interesting, that they throw away their full control over their coins. You said loans, but there are several other ways of how you can get a Bitcoin related loan. Think about certain Bitcoin lending sites, the community that you can ask for a loan, etc. No need for a service that is saying to be a "Bitcoin bank".

I do not understand the essence of bitcoin bank. Although there are already some banks in bitcoin information. Just the very foundation of decentralized bitcoin tells a different story. Therefore, it is not that clear.

[lilit]

If a bunch of people with computers moschny represent bitcoin management system, the bitcoin bank but in fact will be the same. Just what is the difference between these banks and bitcoin bank.

[agamasrori]

If a bunch of people with computers moschny represent bitcoin management system, the bitcoin bank but in fact will be the same. Just what is the difference between these banks and bitcoin bank.

Yes, it will the same. Bitcoin was created to avoid centralization and bank monopolize so why must we create another centralization. I really dissagree with bitcoin bank idea.

[saiha]

If a bunch of people with computers moschny represent bitcoin management system, the bitcoin bank but in fact will be the same. Just what is the difference between these banks and bitcoin bank.

Yes, it will the same. Bitcoin was created to avoid centralization and bank monopolize so why must we create another centralization. I really dissagree with bitcoin bank idea.

I have too views for this, first is positive for this bitcoin bank idea. If banks will adopt bitcoin, then that will make the demand of bitcoin higher which can lead to price increase.

Negative, in a way first with its regulation, we are going to be taxed if we will use banks service associated to bitcoin.

And we are not anonymous anymore because they will require us our identities.

[mbuk81]

No I don't most people won't agree either as no one person or company should control bitcoins as it was not invented to be and would make bitcoin like any other currency which no one what's I believe and so would not  make it special which it as not one country on earth can control or run it the people do.

[Zadicar]

If a bunch of people with computers moschny represent bitcoin management system, the bitcoin bank but in fact will be the same. Just what is the difference between these banks and bitcoin bank.

Yes, it will the same. Bitcoin was created to avoid centralization and bank monopolize so why must we create another centralization. I really dissagree with bitcoin bank idea.

I have too views for this, first is positive for this bitcoin bank idea. If banks will adopt bitcoin, then that will make the demand of bitcoin higher which can lead to price increase.

Negative, in a way first with its regulation, we are going to be taxed if we will use banks service associated to bitcoin.

And we are not anonymous anymore because they will require us our identities.

These are the two possible effects that will surely happen when theres  a bitcoin bank and i would rather choose not to have it because it will expose of our identity especially when do hold huge amounts of bitcoin. I dont like to be taxed by the government and id like to have full control of my money and i wont entrust it to bitcoin banks.

[1Referee]

Just what is the difference between these banks and bitcoin bank.

Essentially, there is no difference if you strictly look at the fact that it's not you, but a different entity that is in control of your money/coins that you have stored there. But if you look at regulations, support from governments, etc, then something calling itself a Bitcoin bank is by far nothing compared to a real bank.

If you want to have some sort of a clue as to what can be seen as a Bitcoin bank, then the following examples are very close;

- Exchanges offering some sort of a wallet/payment service where you can also earn interest over you coins.
- Blockchain.info
- Xapo
- BitPay
- Coinsbank (previously known as BIT-X) This comes very close to the first mentioned option.

And surely there are more, but these are very common in the industry.

[frankmb]

Bitcoin made me my own bank, when storing btc on other sites/wallet providers it doesn't give any interest and not all of them gives the private keys. I just keep my btc safe with me and will not trust a 3rd party provider with to much of my coins.

[rajasumi2]

Not totally .tbh i do not agree with bitcoin bank at all .when i can secure all my wallets in ur cold storage then why go to a bank and let the whole world know about the whole balance i have .its better to keep in a wallet which is better and see how it s growing .kudoos

[saiha]

If a bunch of people with computers moschny represent bitcoin management system, the bitcoin bank but in fact will be the same. Just what is the difference between these banks and bitcoin bank.

Yes, it will the same. Bitcoin was created to avoid centralization and bank monopolize so why must we create another centralization. I really dissagree with bitcoin bank idea.

I have too views for this, first is positive for this bitcoin bank idea. If banks will adopt bitcoin, then that will make the demand of bitcoin higher which can lead to price increase.

Negative, in a way first with its regulation, we are going to be taxed if we will use banks service associated to bitcoin.

And we are not anonymous anymore because they will require us our identities.

These are the two possible effects that will surely happen when theres  a bitcoin bank and i would rather choose not to have it because it will expose of our identity especially when do hold huge amounts of bitcoin. I dont like to be taxed by the government and id like to have full control of my money and i wont entrust it to bitcoin banks.

I hate that we will be taxed too because that is the main reason why we are into bitcoins just to avoid the taxation of the government.

Identity requirements by the banks are required because that is implemented by the law but still we are in bitcoin which doesn't those things just to be able to use it.

[Zadicar]

If a bunch of people with computers moschny represent bitcoin management system, the bitcoin bank but in fact will be the same. Just what is the difference between these banks and bitcoin bank.

Yes, it will the same. Bitcoin was created to avoid centralization and bank monopolize so why must we create another centralization. I really dissagree with bitcoin bank idea.

I have too views for this, first is positive for this bitcoin bank idea. If banks will adopt bitcoin, then that will make the demand of bitcoin higher which can lead to price increase.

Negative, in a way first with its regulation, we are going to be taxed if we will use banks service associated to bitcoin.

And we are not anonymous anymore because they will require us our identities.

These are the two possible effects that will surely happen when theres  a bitcoin bank and i would rather choose not to have it because it will expose of our identity especially when do hold huge amounts of bitcoin. I dont like to be taxed by the government and id like to have full control of my money and i wont entrust it to bitcoin banks.

I hate that we will be taxed too because that is the main reason why we are into bitcoins just to avoid the taxation of the government.

Identity requirements by the banks are required because that is implemented by the law but still we are in bitcoin which doesn't those things just to be able to use it.

This is why im here on bitcoin world because i like its anonymous features on which you could able to transact without any trace.Having tax really pisses me off as we all know government do impose high taxes on our income and assets.

[saiha]

If a bunch of people with computers moschny represent bitcoin management system, the bitcoin bank but in fact will be the same. Just what is the difference between these banks and bitcoin bank.

Yes, it will the same. Bitcoin was created to avoid centralization and bank monopolize so why must we create another centralization. I really dissagree with bitcoin bank idea.

I have too views for this, first is positive for this bitcoin bank idea. If banks will adopt bitcoin, then that will make the demand of bitcoin higher which can lead to price increase.

Negative, in a way first with its regulation, we are going to be taxed if we will use banks service associated to bitcoin.

And we are not anonymous anymore because they will require us our identities.

These are the two possible effects that will surely happen when theres  a bitcoin bank and i would rather choose not to have it because it will expose of our identity especially when do hold huge amounts of bitcoin. I dont like to be taxed by the government and id like to have full control of my money and i wont entrust it to bitcoin banks.

I hate that we will be taxed too because that is the main reason why we are into bitcoins just to avoid the taxation of the government.

Identity requirements by the banks are required because that is implemented by the law but still we are in bitcoin which doesn't those things just to be able to use it.

This is why im here on bitcoin world because i like its anonymous features on which you could able to transact without any trace.Having tax really pisses me off as we all know government do impose high taxes on our income and assets.

Most of us are pissed off with the taxation of government and if that is going to happen in bitcoins for sure many will just hold their bitcoins.

Since there is a tax, there are some bitcoin users that wants to hold their bitcoin forever and will just wait for a one time selling of bitcoin.

In able to save the taxation of government to our bitcoins.

[Labumi]

If a bunch of people with computers moschny represent bitcoin management system, the bitcoin bank but in fact will be the same. Just what is the difference between these banks and bitcoin bank.

Yes, it will the same. Bitcoin was created to avoid centralization and bank monopolize so why must we create another centralization. I really dissagree with bitcoin bank idea.

I have too views for this, first is positive for this bitcoin bank idea. If banks will adopt bitcoin, then that will make the demand of bitcoin higher which can lead to price increase.

Negative, in a way first with its regulation, we are going to be taxed if we will use banks service associated to bitcoin.

And we are not anonymous anymore because they will require us our identities.

These are the two possible effects that will surely happen when theres  a bitcoin bank and i would rather choose not to have it because it will expose of our identity especially when do hold huge amounts of bitcoin. I dont like to be taxed by the government and id like to have full control of my money and i wont entrust it to bitcoin banks.

I hate that we will be taxed too because that is the main reason why we are into bitcoins just to avoid the taxation of the government.

Identity requirements by the banks are required because that is implemented by the law but still we are in bitcoin which doesn't those things just to be able to use it.

This is why im here on bitcoin world because i like its anonymous features on which you could able to transact without any trace.Having tax really pisses me off as we all know government do impose high taxes on our income and assets.

Most of us are pissed off with the taxation of government and if that is going to happen in bitcoins for sure many will just hold their bitcoins.

Since there is a tax, there are some bitcoin users that wants to hold their bitcoin forever and will just wait for a one time selling of bitcoin.

In able to save the taxation of government to our bitcoins.

Not just your friends, but everyone would be upset about the fact the tax administration does not provide any benefit to the majority of citizens. So, I am indeed happy that the government withdraw the tax for all citizens so that the interests and public facilities can be built. Yet it is not enough efeisien to provide assistance in public facilities, because in fact only a few groups of parts that can be enjoyed .. And you are one of those who have thought or strategy might be seen can never be done .sebab your way is something that is not right or just going to make our economy weaker

[Blitzboy]

If a bunch of people with computers moschny represent bitcoin management system, the bitcoin bank but in fact will be the same. Just what is the difference between these banks and bitcoin bank.

Yes, it will the same. Bitcoin was created to avoid centralization and bank monopolize so why must we create another centralization. I really dissagree with bitcoin bank idea.

Me too, I don't find the idea of having bitcoin bank promising, banks will just create another problem for bitcoin and its users. The main purpose of bitcoin is to give people freedom of money as it doesn't require paying tax and it isn't limited to any country, which means that it can be used internationally. And one thing for sure that bitcoin banks will make bitcoin no longer bitcoin like we know today.

[iqlimasyadiqa]

Bitcoin made me my own bank, when storing btc on other sites/wallet providers it doesn't give any interest and not all of them gives the private keys. I just keep my btc safe with me and will not trust a 3rd party provider with to much of my coins.

I agree with you . that bitcoin gives us an exceptional service. we have full access without any deletions. we are free of any embarrassing, we can get anything with bitcoin. This is a remarkable thing. bitcoin bank will make us powerful.