Who is stronger the government or the president?

[Okurkabinladin]

Sorry not knowing this kind of stuff, its just i wanted to know who's the strong one of them because some of my friend told me that the government is strong because they can decide to impeach the president and also i thought that president is more stronger than the government for that the president is more likely  has a bigger rank of his country.. so i need your opinion on this one and teach me

Your question could possibly be more vague 

In coutries such as Russia or Turkey, president is effectively head of the government aswell, in other euro countries (s)he is merely a figurehead for ceremonial occasions. United States and France fall somewhere inbetween those two extremes.

To be sure, you would have to actually read constituion of said country, as constitution clearly specifies who holds what powers in executive branch.

I disagree with you. The reading of the Constitution will do nothing. In Russia or Ukraine, for example, Parliament is an independent branch of government, but in fact it is not. Especially in Russia. It is a dictatorial country disguised as a democracy.

I wonder how do you define "dictatorial" country, that label is awfully popular today.
If you mean that either Ukraine or Russia is ruled by one dictator without limits, then that is blatantly false.

Russia has quite peculiar power elites, that struggle against each other in the Moscow and Petrograd. Not unlike power elites do the same in Washington. In both countries, president has to expend quite alot of energy on mediating interests of different cliques.

Ukraine is even more complicated as politicians blend with oligarchs and western agents, who keep pumping free money in the country.

Atleast in the first case however, rule of law is formally followed, when power balance requires it, the law is changed. So, take your time and read it 

LOL. Is Russia ruled by law? What wars elite? What are you talking about? Without the approval of Putin's Russia, nothing is done. All the opposition was killed. What is this if not a dictatorship?

How old are you? You know, Russia was around before you were born. It was around before Putin was born also. Heresy, I know, since Putin is Russia and Russia is Putin according to your favourite television news network.

Modern russian politics is not that different from early Roman empire, or before that Macedon - that is if can take post-communist era as a precedent. Ruler appoints successor, which then has to gain popular approval. Laws are made, amended or eliminated to reflect shifting power balance between different groups in Kremlin.

I dont think you are going to understand, since your perception of politics started and ended with work of Tolkien.

[1713484515]

1713484515

[1713484515]

1713484515

[1713484515]

1713484515

[1713484515]

1713484515

[Lieldoryn]

Sorry not knowing this kind of stuff, its just i wanted to know who's the strong one of them because some of my friend told me that the government is strong because they can decide to impeach the president and also i thought that president is more stronger than the government for that the president is more likely  has a bigger rank of his country.. so i need your opinion on this one and teach me

Your question could possibly be more vague 

In coutries such as Russia or Turkey, president is effectively head of the government aswell, in other euro countries (s)he is merely a figurehead for ceremonial occasions. United States and France fall somewhere inbetween those two extremes.

To be sure, you would have to actually read constituion of said country, as constitution clearly specifies who holds what powers in executive branch.

I disagree with you. The reading of the Constitution will do nothing. In Russia or Ukraine, for example, Parliament is an independent branch of government, but in fact it is not. Especially in Russia. It is a dictatorial country disguised as a democracy.

I wonder how do you define "dictatorial" country, that label is awfully popular today.
If you mean that either Ukraine or Russia is ruled by one dictator without limits, then that is blatantly false.

Russia has quite peculiar power elites, that struggle against each other in the Moscow and Petrograd. Not unlike power elites do the same in Washington. In both countries, president has to expend quite alot of energy on mediating interests of different cliques.

Ukraine is even more complicated as politicians blend with oligarchs and western agents, who keep pumping free money in the country.

Atleast in the first case however, rule of law is formally followed, when power balance requires it, the law is changed. So, take your time and read it 

LOL. Is Russia ruled by law? What wars elite? What are you talking about? Without the approval of Putin's Russia, nothing is done. All the opposition was killed. What is this if not a dictatorship?

How old are you? You know, Russia was around before you were born. It was around before Putin was born also. Heresy, I know, since Putin is Russia and Russia is Putin according to your favourite television news network.

Modern russian politics is not that different from early Roman empire, or before that Macedon - that is if can take post-communist era as a precedent. Ruler appoints successor, which then has to gain popular approval. Laws are made, amended or eliminated to reflect shifting power balance between different groups in Kremlin.

I dont think you are going to understand, since your perception of politics started and ended with work of Tolkien.

To compare the age of the country with the person's age is not correct. Russia is a country with an authoritarian ruler. Putin does not allow democratic elections to take place. The Russians don't want to change anything. Their ability to resist was suppressed in the days of Stalin.

[LTU_btc]

It depends mainly on country. In some countries like Belarus, Russia, Azerbaijan, Kazakhstan all power is on president hands. But there was one paradox: when Russian president was Medvedev and prime minister Putin, all power unofficially was in hands of Putin, was only puppet. In mostly European countries main job of presidents is foreign politics, but still, they have veto right to not accept new laws made by parliament (laws are offered by government). In some countries like Germany president almost don't have power.

[ustradebitcoin]

i think the president , the president control the army, means he can do anything

us president
dr president
ht president
vn president

they can do anything cause they control the army.

you can see that in Venezuela and most countrie in latin america the power is on President hands.

[BADecker]

Sorry not knowing this kind of stuff, its just i wanted to know who's the strong one of them because some of my friend told me that the government is strong because they can decide to impeach the president and also i thought that president is more stronger than the government for that the president is more likely  has a bigger rank of his country.. so i need your opinion on this one and teach me

Your question could possibly be more vague 

In coutries such as Russia or Turkey, president is effectively head of the government aswell, in other euro countries (s)he is merely a figurehead for ceremonial occasions. United States and France fall somewhere inbetween those two extremes.

To be sure, you would have to actually read constituion of said country, as constitution clearly specifies who holds what powers in executive branch.

I disagree with you. The reading of the Constitution will do nothing. In Russia or Ukraine, for example, Parliament is an independent branch of government, but in fact it is not. Especially in Russia. It is a dictatorial country disguised as a democracy.

I wonder how do you define "dictatorial" country, that label is awfully popular today.
If you mean that either Ukraine or Russia is ruled by one dictator without limits, then that is blatantly false.

Russia has quite peculiar power elites, that struggle against each other in the Moscow and Petrograd. Not unlike power elites do the same in Washington. In both countries, president has to expend quite alot of energy on mediating interests of different cliques.

Ukraine is even more complicated as politicians blend with oligarchs and western agents, who keep pumping free money in the country.

Atleast in the first case however, rule of law is formally followed, when power balance requires it, the law is changed. So, take your time and read it 

LOL. Is Russia ruled by law? What wars elite? What are you talking about? Without the approval of Putin's Russia, nothing is done. All the opposition was killed. What is this if not a dictatorship?

How old are you? You know, Russia was around before you were born. It was around before Putin was born also. Heresy, I know, since Putin is Russia and Russia is Putin according to your favourite television news network.

Modern russian politics is not that different from early Roman empire, or before that Macedon - that is if can take post-communist era as a precedent. Ruler appoints successor, which then has to gain popular approval. Laws are made, amended or eliminated to reflect shifting power balance between different groups in Kremlin.

I dont think you are going to understand, since your perception of politics started and ended with work of Tolkien.

To compare the age of the country with the person's age is not correct. Russia is a country with an authoritarian ruler. Putin does not allow democratic elections to take place. The Russians don't want to change anything. Their ability to resist was suppressed in the days of Stalin.

But. Consider that the rulers of Russia are people. They need air to breathe, water to drink, food to eat, etc.  This means that they follow many of the natural laws of people in the things that they do. It also means that they have to have a following to get things done... because they are not strong enough alone to do much more than any other people.

The point is the following. Their military is part of their following. Why does each individual soldier remain a soldier to do what Russian leaders say? Simply because of fear that they will be executed by their fellow soldiers at the command of the leader(s).

In other words, most all military people suffer from Stockholm Syndrome, just like the Muslims regarding Islam. If the Russian leaders are shrewd enough, they can gradually drag more and more of their people into this syndrome through the military. It's like that all over.

[chixka000]

Now i have to tell you the reality of the politics. Either president or government bodies may be much weaker than private groups. Your president might be a puppet nor your government

[grewak8700]

The majority of the country's President is always a subject to government. For me, the country's Prime Minister is stronger than the President.

[diegz]

Now i have to tell you the reality of the politics. Either president or government bodies may be much weaker than private groups. Your president might be a puppet nor your government

It depends, not all the time the president is greater than the government and vice versa.

Sometimes the governments power is divided into three, no one should be greater than each other.

There are type of government where the President is on power on the whole government and there are also type where the President is just a representative and not the sole ruler.

[adidas]

The president for me is the strongest entity. It is because he is general commander of the army so he can order them anytime he see fits. Of course there is the senate which can try to obstacle the president but history has shown that the president once decides for a war he doesn't care much about the senate.

[AleSergio]

Depends on a country, in some countries presidents are just some people, who do nothing and parlament does all the work. We cant say exactly if president is stronger or not, because we have different systems everywhere.

[The_prodigy]

In my own understanding US has the most powerful president who has lots of co-countries but president will never be strong when don't have goverments supporting him presidents leads co-leader not to be selfish but to ask what is going to be better for his country men US has lots of investment and investors who invest on gold and other resources

[FlightyPouch]

The man man that holds the power of the executive is really a powerful one, well he is the President, highest rank in a Democratic country. But you can't say that the government is more powerful than the president, if you didn't know, the branches of government are , legislative, executive and the judiciary. The president is also known as the executive chief, the president is also in the government, so when you are asking whose more powerful, it is the government because the president is also included in the government officials.

[kodes88]

every country led by the president to mean the president is No. 1. Just like the royal, king / queen is definitely number 1. However govermen and the president must always unidirectional. Both should have the same thought. But I think the president has the greater right in every decision, even decisions must be based on the approval of the president, there should be a signature of the president.

[gracia0023]

President is the most powerful position in a government. He the chief executive. In some country there are president who are controlled by group of people trying to monopolize the country. Those people are the ones whose desire was to get the riches of the nation. Thus, making the president a puppet.

But, if only the president has his own power and decision over the country, he will be able to build a great nation together with the goverment. Because a president will never be a president without a goverment.

[evilgreed]

In my opinion it depends upon the country where you were living may the Government or the President both of them are powerful enough to run a nation.

[TravelMug]

Its all about the President, not the Congress or the Senate. The President is the Commander in Chief, the Leader of his nation. Although they are all co-equal with the Legislative or Judicial branch, for check and balance, but for me the President is the most powerful among the three. 

[JavaLove]

In the United States, the president acts as head of the executive branch, but not necessarily head of state. It's clear to almost anyone that the overall government is much more powerful than the president. This was done on purpose in order to prevent a tyrannical individual from completely obliterating the country.

The President really has no powers. All laws he introduces must be passed through both houses of congress and then he must sign it. Additionally he has a cabinet that he must listen to.

You might say he has the power of executive orders. While this is true as we have seen with the new administration along with the former administration, the senate and house of reps can vote to repeal an order while judges in the judicial branch can also determine whether a new law/order is illegal or should be repealed.

Therefore, the President should be defined as having the last say rather than having all the power. Yes, the only minuscule power the President has is by using executive order but in the whole of everything, there is not much power for him.

[jems]

i choose government because government give power to President  even President lead the country and the government   has more power in President because they can control our country like tax

[fuckitall]

nO DOUGHT IT'S MR. PRESIDENT

[WarThunder]

i choose government because government give power to President  even President lead the country and the government   has more power in President because they can control our country like tax

I support the parliamentary presidential form of government. But all powers must be prescribed by laws. And the government is the president's choice and authorized by the parliament.