What are you think about my gambling related idea?

[boy130]

Prediction:

I know that there are a lot of people who have not technical knowledge enough to test how is provably fair working in his online casino by himself (most of popular bitcoin gambling sites have too complicated provably fair schemes especially in slots etc.). And main thing is not to check hashes like think most of people BUT to understand how then is result calculating basis on hashes. I remember one gambling site with true working provably fair but it had not any relation with results getting So it was fake provably fair which just generating hashes for every game and nothing more. Also it is very boring to check your results time to time (as casinos can manipulate with your results easily if you will trust their own checkers).

Additionally You need to have some math and logic skills to calculate house edge for every game yourself. As when casino says "we have 1% house edge" in most of times it is just words.

My idea:

I am going to create a fully independent topic (and maybe youtube channel) when I will post my own reviews on how is provably fair really working in most of popular casinos + how much is their real house edge.

I have some skills in web development (also gambling related) and I have a diploma of computer science. So I can do that. I will do it of course for free but maybe in future I will create donation btc address that do not spend my own assets on testing.

If you liked or disliked my idea then post here your opinion.

Thanks 

[1714691392]

1714691392

[1714691392]

1714691392

[1714691392]

1714691392

[piloder]

Even though I have voted I don't need it, many newbie may find your reviews/guides helpful. Posting videos on youtube would be nice, also it will be quite easier for newbies to understand the logic behind probably fair games/casino if it is presented in the form of visual guide. Hope you will come up with some nice guides/reviews.

[Bitcoinsummoner]

This idea can be help a lot for those people who don't have any programming skills or even how to know if the site are really provably fair..
Hoping that you can test every well-known site like a game from crypto-games and dice game in yolodice..
And i think if you found how to know if the site is actually generating house edge automatically the 1% house edge is just a words like you said..
Hoping your idea will help a lot for newbies and other gamblers who gamble in the other parts.. of any casino..

[potatopower]

Well about the websites not being provably fair for all the newbies I would just recommend to stay out from the websites that don't have too big of a reputation and all their problems will be solved. There's no need to check every single bet to see if it's provably fair or not. Though I would be curious to see how you will deny the house edges of some websites because it is usually true. Can't say don't create it, if you really want to do it and believe in it then do it, I'll be curious to check it out when it is up.

[BitFinnese]

Your Idea will definitely needed by newbie and good as reference in comparing Casino online sites.  This will help us validate if the site is actually using a provably fair game software and if they are actually stating the right info about their house edge.  And since you are giving effort to this idea, I think it is fine to add a BTC donation address right  from the start.

[Heartilly]

Prediction:

I know that there are a lot of people who have not technical knowledge enough to test how is provably fair working in his online casino by himself (most of popular bitcoin gambling sites have too complicated provably fair schemes especially in slots etc.). And main thing is not to check hashes like think most of people BUT to understand how then is result calculating basis on hashes. I remember one gambling site with true working provably fair but it had not any relation with results getting So it was fake provably fair which just generating hashes for every game and nothing more. Also it is very boring to check your results time to time (as casinos can manipulate with your results easily if you will trust their own checkers).

Additionally You need to have some math and logic skills to calculate house edge for every game yourself. As when casino says "we have 1% house edge" in most of times it is just words.

My idea:

I am going to create a fully independent topic (and maybe youtube channel) when I will post my own reviews on how is provably fair really working in most of popular casinos + how much is their real house edge.

I have some skills in web development (also gambling related) and I have a diploma of computer science. So I can do that. I will do it of course for free but maybe in future I will create donation btc address that do not spend my own assets on testing.

If you liked or disliked my idea then post here your opinion.

Thanks 

No need to tell us if it's good idea or not. A good output must be shown before it was being asked.

Just showed what you got since it will be useful for non technical and lack of knowledge about that users like me. Im curious about the hidden thing behind "we have a 1% house edge" or even at 0.5. Let's see if you cracked something undoubtful in their system. Thanks in advanced.

[shield132]

I doubt casino lies when they say that they have 1% housr edge because this isn't really such thing to lie. But what's about provably fair, I can agree you. Also there was tagged one owner because of fake provably fair system. Slots and etc things are out of provably fair, they are programmed for profit, not for fair decisions.
P.S idea is good..

[audaciousbeing]

I think its really a good idea to the community and for those who are lazy or does not have the technical expertise to verify all the claims of the gambling site as it relates to the above two issues mentioned. However, how do we trust your service in that there are already several review sites and they tend to give the kind of assurance you are given but they have been found to write things that favor the gambling site in other to increase their revenue. How are we sure you won't be bought for the review by the time this site is getting the attention of enough population of the community.

[actmyname]

I doubt casino lies when they say that they have 1% housr edge because this isn't really such thing to lie. But what's about provably fair, I can agree you. Also there was tagged one owner because of fake provably fair system. Slots and etc things are out of provably fair, they are programmed for profit, not for fair decisions.
P.S idea is good..

Slots can be 'provably fair' but it's a little different. In dice, you control the odds, the amount you wager and also the direction of your range (low or high). This makes it so that even if the casino tries to manipulate the results, any bet can be won. In slots, I would expect a hashed server seed + nonces. That way, it's one static server seed so results are essentially randomized (otherwise casino may just simply return losing outcomes given a static client seed) and you can check afterward. I'm not entirely certain on how the slot outcomes are expressed: if there is a certain combination/icon given a range or if it's simply based on 'amount won' and a visual representation is made. I do understand however that the visual aspect of slots is just that - the real results are mostly irrelevant to what you see on the screen before the final image.

Feel free to correct me if you found any mistakes and I will revise it in response. (PM would be preferred)


By the way @OP, doesn't DiceBot have an automatic provably fair verifier?

[SuperLed]

Go for it and use affiliate links so you will earn some coins while doing a good job. I doubt you'll receive any donations.

[adaseb]

I think you are a bit too late, there is a website already out that does this

https://dicesites.com/provably-fair

If you know the basics you can easily verify any of your bets on any gambling sites such the idea is the same.

[bajing]

I think your idea is very good, it will help people who do not understand how to prove the casino is fair or not. But there is little that I fear if you do it only once after the casino is believed they will be cheating will probably be better if you are willing to check it periodically.

[AmoreJaz]

Your idea is very sound. and there would be three different prospective that could come forth from it.
first would be the user base... they would certainly love it as it will show a better view and understanding of their possible gambling gains or loses.
the site owners that are honest and willing to have a better user experience would enjoy your idea also
but the casino owners that are dishonest will certainly get upset and get pretty foul with you for this. so please be prepared.
all summed up 2 of the 3 would still be a positive for you so IMHO go for it and thank you for offering such insight.

[iram3130]

Yes, the idea is good but I have seen this already got implemented and many of us using it. But still it is a good thing to make your own and we can cross reference the results.
Take it as a challenge and experience. Will look forward to it.

[ultrloa]

You should do some proper analyzation on each site you want to filtered so that you will not earn some bad reputation if your though's about how fair the site will be wrong and this kind of job/assumption well be more hassle to you and goodluck if you want to implement your ideas onhere.

[FrueGreads]

I would say go for it. I never really tried to know how provably fair works, I think I just trust on it. But yes, I just look at the logo and kind of trust the site. I don't bet much, so if a casino is well rated I kind of trust it. But your work could be a great addition for users to get more informed about this subject, and avoid being scamed, so I say go for it.

[eternalgloom]

I would focus on the Youtube channel, since there are already other websites that offer the same information.
You'll also reach more people who wouldn't look into this otherwise.

For this project, I would also try to make it purely donation based or have some other form of income without resorting to using affiliate links from the forums or getting funded by casino's to do a promotion.
A service like this needs to be completely independant andit can't look like you're biased.

[KennyR]

Each gambling house has its own house edge calculations. So far in my view what you have planned is simply a complication. Even the site you think as provably fair has got flaws. Rather than focussing on the calculations of different gambling sites try to develop a provably fair Casino and implement through a new site. You might gain popularity in a short if it works fine.

[Patatas]

I am going to create a fully independent topic (and maybe youtube channel) when I will post my own reviews on how is provably fair really working in most of popular casinos + how much is their real house edge.

Did you tried googling "Provably Fair in Bitcoin Gambling" ? You will not want to continue with your after that.Market is saturated and yes you can make a lot of money if you're YouTube channel blows up.
The explanation given by Nlnico on dicesites is more than enough to know how to calculate provably fair mechanism for dice games.

Hoping that you can test every well-known site like a game from crypto-games 

We would love some free promotion

[BitRoulette.win]

It is a interesting "to do" project!
My vote goes for "Yes".
You can start the review with (my) a provably fair gambling website: BitRoulette.win

[Luxo42]

boy130, are u programmer? U should create a scripts checking fairness. I have a few own such. So, any gambler can use them to be sure in casino.

[luvwindy]

I think it already exist. It's all the same idea but a slightly different execution. Vote "Yes"

[boy130]

I am happy that there are a lot of people who like my idea. One thing which I want to say for those who saying 'there are a lot of provably fair explanations already': I am not going just repeat how is the provably fair working but to test myself every popular casino. Also there are a lot of games like slots, roulette etc. which are not can be tested easily like dice. They have too complicated way for result getting which should be checked! 

[neochiny]

I am happy that there are a lot of people who like my idea. One thing which I want to say for those who saying 'there are a lot of provably fair explanations already': I am not going just repeat how is the provably fair working but to test myself every popular casino. Also there are a lot of games like slots, roulette etc. which are not can be tested easily like dice. They have too complicated way for result getting which should be checked! 

Go for it then.
Just make sure you have enough evidence for when/if you declare a site as a scam, fake provably fair, or fake House Edge.
After all, it'd be your word against theirs. Credibility and all that.
So just be 100% sure with whatever you say and write. You better be able to back up any claims you have. ^^
Good luck.

[darthmaul]

IDEA is always good thing when it is innovative. You seems to be serious about this project. If you break the chain of house edge and slots algorithm then that would be amazing. That will be your real provably fair game. Lol. Because these online casino are really shity due to their odds and on top of that the algorithm makes the house win always it is not provable fair game. It is just to attract more and more people to their sites and gamble our money. Thats not fair. You should try your project and we are sure you will succeed in that one.

[marlboroza]

Do you think gambling sites have some kind of hidden code inside provably fair system?
I don't think they need it, IMHO 1% house edge is already enough to give them good advantage over players.
Good luck with your idea.

[Amadues]

Probably not good idea If players feel cheated after every gambling game session,there are some ways to prove fairness of  "probably fair". As it stated above largest casino companies dont need to cheat players which will cause negative feedback about casino.Specially for online casinos there are so many alternatives,cheating issue will destroy their reputation.The only thing casinos need is "house edge". In every turnover casinos take their peace of cake. You need something different and non-discovered idea if you want to audit the "probably fair".