ChuckOne (OP)
Sr. Member
  

Activity: 364
Merit: 250
☕ NXT-4BTE-8Y4K-CDS2-6TB82
|
 |
May 23, 2014, 09:51:16 PM |
|
It took satoshi 20 years to solve the problem of decentralized concensus and NXT devs solving the problem by overnight patches and rushed work without much discussion...
Jealous?  Trollolololo... Okay, back to topic, please.  Not jealous... I am interested in a decentralized PoS solution ... just not seeing that happening. Maybe I dont have the vision but it looks to me impossible. Explain why EC is not a solution.
|
|
|
|
|
ChuckOne (OP)
Sr. Member
  

Activity: 364
Merit: 250
☕ NXT-4BTE-8Y4K-CDS2-6TB82
|
 |
May 23, 2014, 09:53:00 PM |
|
just came to my mind the old web-of-trust ...Key signing party  I see we need some distraction after a long day of discussing PoS features.  Anybody else? You have 10 minutes to troll. After that, discussion continues.
|
|
|
|
|
jonald_fyookball
Legendary

Activity: 1302
Merit: 1047
Core dev leaves me neg feedback #abuse #political
|
 |
May 23, 2014, 10:03:59 PM |
|
The concept of economic clustering is quite simple. Words "economic majority" say enough to explain how it works. From technical point of view it means that if someone decides to rewrite the history of the blockchain he won't be able to include transactions of those who don't take part in the attack, because every transaction contains the id of one of the recent blocks. When Alice sends money to Bob in exchange for something she'll get what she wants only if Bob validates the transaction. And this can happen only if they are both on the same branch. And that solves the nothing at stake problem how? Bob can validate the transaction and still be victim of a double spend.
|
|
|
|
ChuckOne (OP)
Sr. Member
  

Activity: 364
Merit: 250
☕ NXT-4BTE-8Y4K-CDS2-6TB82
|
 |
May 25, 2014, 09:05:21 PM |
|
N@S = forging better blockchains at no cost
Under EC, this alleged better blockchains are completely decoupled from the main chain as transactions do not recognize them.
|
|
|
|
|
jonald_fyookball
Legendary

Activity: 1302
Merit: 1047
Core dev leaves me neg feedback #abuse #political
|
 |
May 25, 2014, 09:21:30 PM |
|
N@S = forging better blockchains at no cost
Under EC, this alleged better blockchains are completely decoupled from the main chain as transactions do not recognize them.
How ? You didn't really explain anything in this post. Of course the "alleged better blockchains" are unrecognized by the main chain. Bitcoin does the same thing by having a rule (longest chain wins) to force consensus and everything else is rejected. But to attack in Bitcoin, you have to do proof of work in real time to try to get ahead. In proof of stake, you can just use resources that were owned in the paste at some possible point of attack, which is the nothing-at-stake problem.
|
|
|
|
ChuckOne (OP)
Sr. Member
  

Activity: 364
Merit: 250
☕ NXT-4BTE-8Y4K-CDS2-6TB82
|
 |
May 25, 2014, 09:34:32 PM |
|
Nice to see that serious discussion still goes on after placing this topic somewhere else. +1 for you.
Sorry, for being too unspecific.
The point is blockchain hopping is not possible anymore. People vouch for the blockchain (which is hopefully a single one) they want their transactions to be publish on. Nobody else can re-use their transactions to increase their economic value.
That makes big-accounts-from-the-past attacks impossible. Re-orgs would not occur as the economic majority stays on the same branch which their economic past is based on. Nobody want and could see their transactions lost.
Maybe, CfB can give you a better explanation. We will see.
|
|
|
|
|
jonald_fyookball
Legendary

Activity: 1302
Merit: 1047
Core dev leaves me neg feedback #abuse #political
|
 |
May 25, 2014, 09:51:21 PM |
|
the obvious question would be, how do they know which one they want it to be on?
|
|
|
|
|
mczarnek
|
 |
May 26, 2014, 03:03:31 PM |
|
the obvious question would be, how do they know which one they want it to be on?
As they forge, they are forging along a fork using the regular PoS algorithm. Say this one resolves itself within 10 or 20 or even 120 blocks, you can always point to the block X blocks back as proof that you are on a certain fork. Economic Clustering is just a way of committing to a specific fork. You can't later go back and rewrite the blockchain with a different fork because the majority has chosen one chain.
|
|
|
|
jonald_fyookball
Legendary

Activity: 1302
Merit: 1047
Core dev leaves me neg feedback #abuse #political
|
 |
May 26, 2014, 03:37:36 PM |
|
the obvious question would be, how do they know which one they want it to be on?
As they forge, they are forging along a fork using the regular PoS algorithm. Say this one resolves itself within 10 or 20 or even 120 blocks, you can always point to the block X blocks back as proof that you are on a certain fork. Economic Clustering is just a way of committing to a specific fork. You can't later go back and rewrite the blockchain with a different fork because the majority has chosen one chain. ...imo, not saying anything new. chains are chains and new blocks link back to previous blocks.
|
|
|
|
ChuckOne (OP)
Sr. Member
  

Activity: 364
Merit: 250
☕ NXT-4BTE-8Y4K-CDS2-6TB82
|
 |
May 27, 2014, 08:17:25 PM |
|
True. So, I do not understand the problem of yours.
PoS is secure up to a certain point; basically most of the time.
When PoS fails, EC helps accounts to keep track where they are and not accidentally swapping to a bad chain until the situation is resolved.
Maybe, you could describe your problem in terms of a specific attack vector?
|
|
|
|
|
jonald_fyookball
Legendary

Activity: 1302
Merit: 1047
Core dev leaves me neg feedback #abuse #political
|
 |
May 27, 2014, 08:49:27 PM |
|
We were taking about nothing at stake problem.
Anyway, at this point it feels like the debate has become redundant. It has been discussed in other threads so let's just wait and see what transpires when the "secret sauce" code is Released.
If you really believe in nxt, feel free to load Up the boat. I imagine that you will be rewarded Accordingly for backing the right horse.
|
|
|
|
ChuckOne (OP)
Sr. Member
  

Activity: 364
Merit: 250
☕ NXT-4BTE-8Y4K-CDS2-6TB82
|
 |
May 27, 2014, 09:15:28 PM |
|
Not sure how much secret sauce there is in this post. We will see. source https://nxtforum.org/general-discussion/on-economic-clusters-and-the-longest-chain/msg28204/#msg28204How is that defined mathematically so that a forger could automatically tell the legitimate network of the economic cluster from the attacker's network? Or when a new guy joins Nxt, for the first time, he has to identify the legitimate network through identifying the economic cluster by, e.g., asking a friend?
If T c/T >> K o, then it's legit branch T c - number of transactions belonging to cluster participants T - total number of transactions (must be within the normal range, defined statistically for the whole cluster) K o - ratio of transactions resent coz of orphaned blocks (defined statistically for the whole cluster) Asking a friend is better for a newbie coz it lower entry barrier (no need to understand what economic cluster is)
|
|
|
|
|
ChuckOne (OP)
Sr. Member
  

Activity: 364
Merit: 250
☕ NXT-4BTE-8Y4K-CDS2-6TB82
|
 |
May 28, 2014, 10:56:29 PM |
|
We were taking about nothing at stake problem.
I fear nothing@stake is too vague. We would need a more precise description. However, everybody else is welcome to join the discussion and find a way to break EC, i.e describe exactly under which the set of situations/circumstances EC will definitely fail.
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
ChuckOne (OP)
Sr. Member
  

Activity: 364
Merit: 250
☕ NXT-4BTE-8Y4K-CDS2-6TB82
|
 |
May 30, 2014, 09:57:45 AM |
|
Thank you. Reading.
|
|
|
|
|
ChuckOne (OP)
Sr. Member
  

Activity: 364
Merit: 250
☕ NXT-4BTE-8Y4K-CDS2-6TB82
|
 |
May 30, 2014, 07:27:32 PM |
|
I am glad the idea of Transparent Forging and Economic Clusters are roughly understood and internalized. I keep you posted on any new bit I could find on nxtforum.org. In the meantime, review Economic Clusters and try to describe specific attack vectors. Anybody is welcome to contribute. 
|
|
|
|
|
|