ricksta


June 27, 2011, 07:20:50 PM 

So with all these discussion on if mining is profitable or not, I decided to do a quit analysis.
Assuming each day, you will make 4% less bitcoin due to difficulty increase. You have a 1GH rig. That will yeild 0.66BTC daily.
Assume you need 500W of power for 1GH rig. for the simplicity of this calculation, lets assume your electricity is free.
So now we have a simple geometric series problem, assume you will run your rig forever.
where Present Value = (Today's income/(1+DifficultyIncrease))/(11/(1+DifficultyIncrease))
Today's income is 0.66BTC, DifficultyIncrease is 4%
So the total income you will make from a 1GH rig is 16.5BTC. At today's exchange rate, that is $280
Which is well below the cost of a 1GH machine(about $1000), which makes your investment a negative present value of $720 if you paid $1000 today for a 1TH rig.
If you have a hard time seeing how the calculation come about,
Here is a simplified version: Day Income 0 0.66 1 0.6336 2 0.608256 3 0.58392576 4 0.56056873 5 0.53814598 6 0.516620141 7 0.495955336 8 0.476117122 9 0.457072437 10 0.43878954 11 0.421237958 12 0.40438844 13 0.388212902 14 0.372684386 15 0.357777011 16 0.34346593 17 0.329727293 18 0.316538201 19 0.303876673 20 0.291721606 21 0.280052742 22 0.268850632 23 0.258096607 24 0.247772743 25 0.237861833 26 0.22834736 27 0.219213465 28 0.210444927 29 0.20202713 30 0.193946045 31 0.186188203 ........
If keep going until infinity, the sum is 16.5
Now if you factor in electricity cost, the present value will be even worse.
Now for those of you wondering, what if the price of bitcoin go up? So how high does it take for you to break even? So if present value of $1000 rig is 16.5 btc, that means the exchange rate should be 1000/16.5 = $60 to break even.
in another words, don't sell until btc is at $60, or you will never make your money back!
Personally, I think I bought into bitcoin too late to make any money, but I like the concept and I like to be a part of it just because.
Feel free to tare this analysis apart, it is a very simple analysis.





Advertised sites are not endorsed by the Bitcoin Forum. They may be unsafe, untrustworthy, or illegal in your jurisdiction. Advertise here.


mmortal03
Legendary
Offline
Activity: 1425


June 27, 2011, 07:31:20 PM 

Instead of 4% increase per day, shouldn't you use the percent increase per length of average difficulty period?




Synaesthesia


June 27, 2011, 07:35:59 PM 

Well the difficulty won't increase indefinitely ... it's unpredictable actually.

I deal in Bitcoins: 1ANtpQH5UKKYrd9619VSSibL76uzjZGH1D



SlipperySlope


June 27, 2011, 08:05:25 PM 

I also believe that a more accurate model would be to apply the difficulty increase over an average duration  not daily. The log charts at http://bitcoin.sipa.be/speedever.png are especially helpful in visualizing the steady, yet stepwise, increases. Leaving aside speculation on when ASIC technology supersedes today's GPU technology, I assume that the difficulty will level off when a substantial number of miners quit due to high power and air conditioning charges due to their mining rigs. Worldwide, there is a large disparity in what miners pay for power. For example, in Austin, Texas, USA, I pay about .13 USD per KWh. My rigs are located in the crawl space under my house and operate without air conditioning. They draw a total of 850 watts from the power socket. That costs me about 2.63 USD daily. I suppose that sometime in the next few months I'll be mining coins paying about 4 USD per day, and that difficulty will level off until the technology changes or BTC prices dramatically increase.




ZombieDeity


June 27, 2011, 08:14:16 PM 

I hope this is as wrong as it sounds. I just started mining with a 2 Gh/s rig yesterday.




AngelusWebDesign


June 27, 2011, 08:25:27 PM 

Good luck; that's all I can say.
I hope your rig didn't cost you much.




BombaUcigasa
Legendary
Offline
Activity: 1428


June 27, 2011, 08:26:47 PM 

Next difficulty jump will be around 10% for 12 days. How did you calculate 4% per day?
You can never correctly estimate the real difficulty or bitcoin price in the future!




bcpokey


June 27, 2011, 08:51:54 PM 

There should just be a bot for the forums that comes in to another thread with one of these "Future bitcoin mining" predictions, and just says "you assume you know the future therefore your analysis is wrong" and then closes the thread.
Yeah I have fascist leanings, sue me.
Anyway, a geometric series and a stepwise function will not at all yield the same thing, hence why you were wrong from the start. Additionally looking at merely the very first step in the more accurate stepwise function your progression falls apart. Rather than .404 on day 12 we are looking more like .63
A model is only as useful as it is accurate, and yours misses the boat completely.
But you were doomed from the start by tackling an intractable problem, so it's not totally your fault.
I will admit however that A) You should not build a 1$/Mhash machine and B) You should not expect to make much profit in the current price/difficulty regime. We will see where difficulty heads however.




mmortal03
Legendary
Offline
Activity: 1425


June 27, 2011, 09:41:28 PM 

Well the difficulty won't increase indefinitely ... it's unpredictable actually.
That's true, but you are actually making my point for me. It would be smart to assume, just as a rule of thumb, that it WILL increase indefinitely, however, assuming it will go up 4% daily doesn't seem to be the right way to conservatively estimate this. It's got to be more like a weekly step pattern (unless my knowledge of calculus is waning, and you CAN accurately estimate a comparable area under the curve with the daily 4% estimate you are plugging in).




BombaUcigasa
Legendary
Offline
Activity: 1428


June 27, 2011, 09:53:49 PM 

Well the difficulty won't increase indefinitely ... it's unpredictable actually.
That's true, but you are actually making my point for me. It would be smart to assume, just as a rule of thumb, that it WILL increase indefinitely, however, assuming it will go up 4% daily doesn't seem to be the right way to conservatively estimate this. It's got to be more like a weekly step pattern (unless my knowledge of calculus is waning, and you CAN accurately estimate a comparable area under the curve with the daily 4% estimate you are plugging in). EVEN if the difficulty and bitcoin numbers in the OP were exactly becoming reality, there is another variable that can't be predicted correctly in the future: BTC value. Thus the OP conclusion that you're stupid to buy a 1000$ 1GH rig can't be verified at the moment, and could be or could not be true depending on how the price varies. I recommend that the OP checks the evolution charts from mtgox, the difficulty charts, the cycle graphs and the approximation functions and do a better calculation.




rearwheels


June 28, 2011, 05:02:47 AM 

Actually I don't mind reading about such modelling.
Of course he cannot be right (now). Why 4%? Why not 4.23567%?
4% increment to infinity vs X% difficulty increment every Y days.
It's just all hypothesis.
Everyone have their own view and parameters that they want to take into account in running their mining "business".

Monitor multiple pools  www.btcpoolwatch.com( forum) If it's useful, please consider donating: 18bvrJ9Kouxwv8g4tLUemsv1GuxgGk8Kn7 (Pls PM me so I can thank you.)



gmaxwell
Moderator
Legendary
Offline
Activity: 2128


June 28, 2011, 05:19:26 AM 

That's true, but you are actually making my point for me. It would be smart to assume, just as a rule of thumb, that it WILL increase indefinitely,
So I should start investing in heavy lifting spacecraft businesses because it would be smart to assume that in ten years, given your figures, we'll be at a factor 1.6e62 than now than now thus requiring us to construct a dyson sphere in order to power bitcoin mining? Every exponential is a logistic in disguise. I may not have much of a clue what the future hashrate will be— but I can easily predict a few things: It won't require us to capture the complete energy output of the sun, so any continued exponential projection is wrong beyond short time frames, and it won't become significantly unprofitable against power consumption for the most efficient operators. I can speculate about what efficient means in the future, but without knowing the exchange rate isn't useful. And anything thoughts about the future exchange rate will just be guesses.




nebiki


June 28, 2011, 06:37:46 AM 

Every exponential is a logistic in disguise.
quite true. in fact, i expect the bound to be near what we're currently at. the "most efficient operator" is probably somewhere around 20cents/kwh (incl. maintenance cost and a minimum of profit to motivate him to keep his business going).

1DWttUPMiDL1ou64SoUriZ29bxdoChjPns



rograz


June 28, 2011, 10:49:39 AM 

What mainly has been driving difficulty (during the past months) is prices increase of BTC and not the other way around like some ppl seem to believe (and hoping, wishing their BTC should be worth 100USD etc). Add 23 weeks for difficulty lag and you start seeing where the 4060% increases we have seen for some jumps are coming from, if price stagnates or starts declining long term we'll go back to much smaller jumps in the 1030% area until ppl start dropping out due to low profits.




ZombieDeity


July 05, 2011, 02:32:49 PM 

No, no, guys... OP is right! The sky is falling! Quick, everyone sell me your rigs for next to nothing before they become literally worth nothing tomorrow!!!1!




mmcgehee
Newbie
Offline
Activity: 9


July 24, 2014, 11:25:18 PM 

This is very on target discussion, but the data is old:
"in another words, don't sell until btc is at $60, or you will never make your money back!" Hello??!? It's over $600 now
And of course, difficulty continues to creep up. So few, can hold their nerves calm, and calculate what's best. Present value of an annuity is the right way to calculate, but do you calculate using dollars, or bit coins?




goose20
Legendary
Offline
Activity: 1144


July 25, 2014, 01:53:03 PM 

This is very on target discussion, but the data is old:
"in another words, don't sell until btc is at $60, or you will never make your money back!" Hello??!? It's over $600 now
And of course, difficulty continues to creep up. So few, can hold their nerves calm, and calculate what's best. Present value of an annuity is the right way to calculate, but do you calculate using dollars, or bit coins?
Unfortunately fiat aint going to die off as quickly as we'd like  so you be calculating using dollars still.




