Merit "trading" - buying and selling Bitcointalk merit

[fabianji]

Very interesting to see the reactions to the newly introduced concept of merit as an additional indicator of account maturity and quality beyond just pure number of posts / activity. While this was introduced to increase post quality it has of course created a counter movement and a market place for "trading" merit - for money.
So this is just a reminder for everyone that the introduction of merit is a GOOD thing because it will help improve the quality of this forum for everybody.

"Trading" merit will undermine this and render it eventually useless.

Keep contributing!

[1713486976]

1713486976

[1713486976]

1713486976

[1713486976]

1713486976

[1713486976]

1713486976

[rat03gopoh]

Indirectly "sMerit" is given to the person who plays a role behind an account. If it is sold then the account changes character because of owner change. And it will be different sMerit to get, the new owner can get faster sMerit because more qualified or otherwise never again get sMerit.

[BillCoin]

Merit was made to determine one's post quality.
If someone buys and sells merit it means that he abuses the system.
I can guess that Merit trading is forbidden and those who try to trade Merit will probably get their thread to be deleted.

Merit also very helpful as it gives users the option to thank other users for their posts.
An ability that wasn't available before.

[just_Alice]

Very interesting to see the reactions to the newly introduced concept of merit as an additional indicator of account maturity and quality beyond just pure number of posts / activity. While this was introduced to increase post quality it has of course created a counter movement and a market place for "trading" merit - for money.
So this is just a reminder for everyone that the introduction of merit is a GOOD thing because it will help improve the quality of this forum for everybody.

"Trading" merit will undermine this and render it eventually useless.

Keep contributing!

I agree that merit is a good thing, due to reduction of low quality posts. And trading isn't an issue, because everything is checked and controlled by forum moderators (hopefully) and they'll cut off such actions. But there are some other problems: people give merits quite seldom, if we compare to "likes" on fb, and it would be great if people truly gave merits for what they like. But the thing is - lost of people barely even read others posts, or even if they do they don't feel like meriting someone due to rivalry. But I like the conception and I hope that it will go off well.

[fabianji]

Very interesting to see the reactions to the newly introduced concept of merit as an additional indicator of account maturity and quality beyond just pure number of posts / activity. While this was introduced to increase post quality it has of course created a counter movement and a market place for "trading" merit - for money.
So this is just a reminder for everyone that the introduction of merit is a GOOD thing because it will help improve the quality of this forum for everybody.

"Trading" merit will undermine this and render it eventually useless.

Keep contributing!

I agree that merit is a good thing, due to reduction of low quality posts. And trading isn't an issue, because everything is checked and controlled by forum moderators (hopefully) and they'll cut off such actions. But there are some other problems: people give merits quite seldom, if we compare to "likes" on fb, and it would be great if people truly gave merits for what they like. But the thing is - lost of people barely even read others posts, or even if they do they don't feel like meriting someone due to rivalry. But I like the conception and I hope that it will go off well.

Yes I definitely see the point of rivalry and there is of course the element of scarcity - because as you said Facebook likes are a limitless commodity so people usually give them freely. But even there sometimes people don't give a like because of jealousy. So it is similar in a way.

[rickz026]

can you discuss to me what is merit all about? thankyou

[Tyrantt]

can you discuss to me what is merit all about? thankyou

Read- https://bitcointalk.org/index.php?topic=2818350.0


There have already been some bans considering the merit trading, but just ask yourself is it actually worth it? If someone was to buy ~50 merit points, he might get 1-2 lower ranks but he'd still need to buy that same merit 3-4 times to get to some higher rank. For example you'd need to buy 5 times 50 merit, to get to Senior member, 5 times from different users or 1 time from one person (or multiple) every month and if that doesn't get suspicious, I don't know what will.

if you're buying merit, you'll sure to get banned sooner or later, it's just a matter of time.

[fabianji]

can you discuss to me what is merit all about? thankyou

Read- https://bitcointalk.org/index.php?topic=2818350.0


There have already been some bans considering the merit trading, but just ask yourself is it actually worth it? If someone was to buy ~50 merit points, he might get 1-2 lower ranks but he'd still need to buy that same merit 3-4 times to get to some higher rank. For example you'd need to buy 5 times 50 merit, to get to Senior member, 5 times from different users or 1 time from one person (or multiple) every month and if that doesn't get suspicious, I don't know what will.

if you're buying merit, you'll sure to get banned sooner or later, it's just a matter of time.

Accounts (farmed or hand grown - some even hacked) are sold pretty openly...

[ralle14]

can you discuss to me what is merit all about? thankyou

Read- https://bitcointalk.org/index.php?topic=2818350.0


There have already been some bans considering the merit trading, but just ask yourself is it actually worth it? If someone was to buy ~50 merit points, he might get 1-2 lower ranks but he'd still need to buy that same merit 3-4 times to get to some higher rank. For example you'd need to buy 5 times 50 merit, to get to Senior member, 5 times from different users or 1 time from one person (or multiple) every month and if that doesn't get suspicious, I don't know what will.

if you're buying merit, you'll sure to get banned sooner or later, it's just a matter of time.

Accounts (farmed or hand grown - some even hacked) are sold pretty openly...

We already know that, once they're caught they should receive negative trust for their action making the account useless. The merit page helps us track people who abuse the merit system. Checking their history of merits sent could easily determine which users are abusing the system. If you see one you could always put up a thread in the meta section so DT members could put a stop to those users.

[copypaper5]

selling and buying merit I think it's a cheat action.
because at the core of our knowledge level is really well established and our posts are more qualified and can be understood by moderators.

[richardsNY]

selling and buying merit I think it's a cheat action.
because at the core of our knowledge level is really well established and our posts are more qualified and can be understood by moderators.

People can cheat as much as they want to buy Merit and get their account to rank up quickly, but the main point of importance is that they in most cases can't avoid being tagged with red due to obvious and continuous Merit rewards for posts that don't deserve any. On top of that, most of the higher tier campaign managers know how to look through accounts who potentially have been buying Merit, or got awarded Merit from alt accounts. Currently it's still the very early stage, where everything needs to adjust and be correctly distributed, but the most important thing is that at least something is being done. It's already noticeable that the overall quality has been upped by a notch -- the more people are forced to deliver quality posts, the more they are forced to gain at least some knowledge regarding everything Bitcoin is about.

[Zadicar]

Merit was made to determine one's post quality.
If someone buys and sells merit it means that he abuses the system.
I can guess that Merit trading is forbidden and those who try to trade Merit will probably get their thread to be deleted.

Merit also very helpful as it gives users the option to thank other users for their posts.
An ability that wasn't available before.

It can really be treated or act on different way which merits can be used also as a show of appreciation among other user not only on post quality for sure. Abusing the system is the thing that cant really be avoided because there are people who do really make some advantage for the sake of leveling up but well theres no worries since theres always an eye for these kind of trading behavior. They would really be tagged as long they are caught on abusing this new system.

[trader34]

Very interesting to see the reactions to the newly introduced concept of merit as an additional indicator of account maturity and quality beyond just pure number of posts / activity. While this was introduced to increase post quality it has of course created a counter movement and a market place for "trading" merit - for money.
So this is just a reminder for everyone that the introduction of merit is a GOOD thing because it will help improve the quality of this forum for everybody.

"Trading" merit will undermine this and render it eventually useless.

Keep contributing!

I agree that merit is a good thing, due to reduction of low quality posts. And trading isn't an issue, because everything is checked and controlled by forum moderators (hopefully) and they'll cut off such actions. But there are some other problems: people give merits quite seldom, if we compare to "likes" on fb, and it would be great if people truly gave merits for what they like. But the thing is - lost of people barely even read others posts, or even if they do they don't feel like meriting someone due to rivalry. But I like the conception and I hope that it will go off well.

I see your point and I agree. But I think people with time will start to see the merit system as something usual and will get used to sending merits to posts which deserve it.

Maybe trading merits can be an issue in the near future, but I think the advantage of the merit system can be much bigger in the long run. So I agree with the idea (even if my rank now is low and for me it would have been much easier ranking up in the old way!) 

[taserz]

I was curious how long it would take to be abused.

[Cobalt9317]

I see your point and I agree. But I think people with time will start to see the merit system as something usual and will get used to sending merits to posts which deserve it.

Maybe trading merits can be an issue in the near future, but I think the advantage of the merit system can be much bigger in the long run. So I agree with the idea (even if my rank now is low and for me it would have been much easier ranking up in the old way!) 

That is highly likely to happen being new member acting in old way will benefit oneself in the merit system because only the old member can give you sMerits, thus if you leave a constructive post/comment to some topic they might notice that you are genuine and didn't want to shitpost your way up there.

[Barbut]

Merit was made to determine one's post quality.
If someone buys and sells merit it means that he abuses the system.
I can guess that Merit trading is forbidden and those who try to trade Merit will probably get their thread to be deleted.

Merit also very helpful as it gives users the option to thank other users for their posts.
An ability that wasn't available before.

Like with many other things invented with good reasons this one will be a subject of many speculations and manipulations. In my opinion many of us are giving the best we can, who is that judge to say that we have enough quality to get merit? Until now I didn't give and I didn't get any merits, I don't have enough merits to reward many great comments, and in same time I think many of my comments pass unnoticed here, who will reward me? My English is far from perfect, I'm trying to elaborate my thoughts in the best possible way, but does that means anything to anyone?
People will trade with merits, here or somewhere else, doesn't matter. When everyone is allowed to be a judge of comment quality I doubt in fair system.

[carlfebz2]

Merit was made to determine one's post quality.
If someone buys and sells merit it means that he abuses the system.
I can guess that Merit trading is forbidden and those who try to trade Merit will probably get their thread to be deleted.

Merit also very helpful as it gives users the option to thank other users for their posts.
An ability that wasn't available before.

Like with many other things invented with good reasons this one will be a subject of many speculations and manipulations. In my opinion many of us are giving the best we can, who is that judge to say that we have enough quality to get merit? Until now I didn't give and I didn't get any merits, I don't have enough merits to reward many great comments, and in same time I think many of my comments pass unnoticed here, who will reward me? My English is far from perfect, I'm trying to elaborate my thoughts in the best possible way, but does that means anything to anyone?
People will trade with merits, here or somewhere else, doesn't matter. When everyone is allowed to be a judge of comment quality I doubt in fair system.

Even myself I don't really bother or thinking up too much on how to earn smerits from other people as long you are doing fine on what you post as long it is not spam and having really a contribution then it should be fine but we cant really accept the situation on where there are post of ours which aren't considered by some people that haven't given any merit which isn't really a surprising thing. Abusing the system is possible because people would really make things that will really benefit them even post are not worth it to get merits but yet they are still getting more than on those deserving ones.

[fabianji]

selling and buying merit I think it's a cheat action.
because at the core of our knowledge level is really well established and our posts are more qualified and can be understood by moderators.

People can cheat as much as they want to buy Merit and get their account to rank up quickly, but the main point of importance is that they in most cases can't avoid being tagged with red due to obvious and continuous Merit rewards for posts that don't deserve any. On top of that, most of the higher tier campaign managers know how to look through accounts who potentially have been buying Merit, or got awarded Merit from alt accounts. Currently it's still the very early stage, where everything needs to adjust and be correctly distributed, but the most important thing is that at least something is being done. It's already noticeable that the overall quality has been upped by a notch -- the more people are forced to deliver quality posts, the more they are forced to gain at least some knowledge regarding everything Bitcoin is about.

Yes I agree that there is less meaningless noise and low quality posts which is great. The only concern is that more junior ranks have either no or very little merit and so they are very limited in where they can give merit. This limits the circle of members to be able to merit posts to the more senior members of this community.
It would be nice to also enable the less senior members of the community to contribute to post meriting.

[milewilda]

Very interesting to see the reactions to the newly introduced concept of merit as an additional indicator of account maturity and quality beyond just pure number of posts / activity. While this was introduced to increase post quality it has of course created a counter movement and a market place for "trading" merit - for money.
So this is just a reminder for everyone that the introduction of merit is a GOOD thing because it will help improve the quality of this forum for everybody.

"Trading" merit will undermine this and render it eventually useless.

Keep contributing!

This new way merit system created by theymos is really genius.It might get some critics to some people but generally this thing completely stopped account farming or selling accounts because those things are useless with this new merit system.Account wont be easily rank up because of merit requirement but its not the main thing why this is being created but for the sole purpose of post quality,you cant easily level up if you dont contribute anything worthy to this community.

[BettingTips]

Very interesting to see the reactions to the newly introduced concept of merit as an additional indicator of account maturity and quality beyond just pure number of posts / activity. While this was introduced to increase post quality it has of course created a counter movement and a market place for "trading" merit - for money.
So this is just a reminder for everyone that the introduction of merit is a GOOD thing because it will help improve the quality of this forum for everybody.

"Trading" merit will undermine this and render it eventually useless.

Keep contributing!

This new way merit system created by theymos is really genius.It might get some critics to some people but generally this thing completely stopped account farming or selling accounts because those things are useless with this new merit system.Account wont be easily rank up because of merit requirement but its not the main thing why this is being created but for the sole purpose of post quality,you cant easily level up if you dont contribute anything worthy to this community.

It's totally true ). The account sellers and spammer can't survive in this forum anymore. I think appearance of Merit point will make the number of member in this forum decreases a lot cause I think a lot of shitposter and account farmers will give up and get out of this forum. It'll make this forum become better and better . But there are some guys still trying to cheat merit system, they think they can overcoming all moderator, DT member and admin but they're wrong. LOL. Merit seller and cheater are being hunted very harshly.